Johnnie Cake Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 In which he declared his unbelief and stated he believed Joseph Smith was a fraud. Someone in his stake turned him in and when his SP asked him to delete the FB post...he refused. While I respect the church's right to set its boundaries and to be able to say who can and can't be a member of their organization...it seems to me that those boundaries are shrinking and becoming more compact and restrictive. An individuals right to personal expression seems to be taking a back seat to the churches right to control its own message. I'm curious how the illustrious members of this board view this development. Is the churches skin too thin? Do you support this action? Should personal expression be controlled to the point of losing ones membership. I should state that this individual was in good standing in all other areas...with the exception of his "thoughts" 1
Popular Post thesometimesaint Posted April 1, 2016 Popular Post Posted April 1, 2016 If a member denies the basic Truth Claims of the Church they have excommunicated themselves. The Church is simply accepting their excommunication. 11
Jeanne Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 My friend just posted her thoughts on the essays and was exed. I am hoping members will quit turning people in and just perhaps have a good conversation first. There shouldn't be a "thought police" any where in the church (IMO). Good luck with this...duh..it may just depend on local ward authorities on how anything plays out anymore.
Johnnie Cake Posted April 1, 2016 Author Posted April 1, 2016 1 minute ago, Jeanne said: My friend just posted her thoughts on the essays and was exed. I am hoping members will quit turning people in and just perhaps have a good conversation first. There shouldn't be a "thought police" any where in the church (IMO). Good luck with this...duh..it may just depend on local ward authorities on how anything plays out anymore. Wow...this is worse... may I ask where this took place?
Popular Post JLHPROF Posted April 1, 2016 Popular Post Posted April 1, 2016 I agree with Sometimesaint. Expressing that the very origin of the Church is fraudulent and doing so publicly, and refusing to cease doing so, seems like a pretty good reason for excommunication to me. He wasn't disagreeing with a point of doctrine, but with the very foundation of the Church. Can you be a Christian and not believe Christ died for your sins? Can you be a Muslim and not follow Mohammed? Can you be a Buddhist and not believe Buddha reached Nirvana? Can you be a Mormon and not believe Joseph Smith restored the Book of Mormon, Christ's Church, and priesthood authority? This guy excommunicated himself. 7
Jeanne Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 1 minute ago, Johnnie Cake said: Wow...this is worse... may I ask where this took place? Here in Utah..Cache County. I wrote more about this on the "peepstone" thread.
Popular Post strappinglad Posted April 1, 2016 Popular Post Posted April 1, 2016 Horse feathers ! He declared his unbelief to the world. Don't think that facebook is just a private message board. He called Joseph a fraud. Fine, and I suspect there was more said between him and the SP over that interview. Why he would want to remain a member of a fraudulent organization I don't know ,but why the SP had to sever the ties with the Church ,I fully understand. Had the former member stood in testimony meeting and declared the same attitude, a similar fate would likely have befallen him. 7
Popular Post halconero Posted April 1, 2016 Popular Post Posted April 1, 2016 He then went on r/exmormon throughout the whole process and repeatedly expressed his contempt for the leadership involved, recorded the whole thing secretly, and kept talking about how he stood up for himself and what he said throughout the whole thing. Yeah, I was following the same thread. Don't ask me why I'm on that subreddit. Probably a morbid curiosity which ebbs and flows. 14
Popular Post strappinglad Posted April 1, 2016 Popular Post Posted April 1, 2016 Stake authorities do not issue drive by excommunications. Interviews are held , beliefs are discussed, attitudes are demonstrated, If I declare on facebook or some other public space, like a billboard, that I am committing some deviation from doctrine and or practice, I should expect to be asked to visit with the Bishop. The results from that interview could be anything from stern council to excommunication. 8
Popular Post Storm Rider Posted April 1, 2016 Popular Post Posted April 1, 2016 25 minutes ago, Johnnie Cake said: In which he declared his unbelief and stated he believed Joseph Smith was a fraud. Someone in his stake turned him in and when his SP asked him to delete the FB post...he refused. While I respect the church's right to set its boundaries and to be able to say who can and can't be a member of their organization...it seems to me that those boundaries are shrinking and becoming more compact and restrictive. An individuals right to personal expression seems to be taking a back seat to the churches right to control its own message. I'm curious how the illustrious members of this board view this development. Is the churches skin too thin? Do you support this action? Should personal expression be controlled to the point of losing ones membership. I should state that this individual was in good standing in all other areas...with the exception of his "thoughts" I am scratching my head on this. There are consequences to free speech in the Church and there should be. You get to say anything want and believe anything you want - that is free speech and freedom of religion. However, if you want to go public as a member and deny the truthfulness of the restoration of the gospel.....why are you a member? Why would anyone want to be a member of something they strongly believe is fraudulent? You lost me on this. No, this is not about his thoughts. If I think about things I don't proclaim it to the world. When I think I am thinking, questioning. If it a serious thought I will ASK someone their thoughts. I don't just start bearing witness to the world about what is something that is not just a thought. If you want a conversation, then talk to your home teacher, visiting teacher, bishop, stake president, sunday school teacher, relief society president, priesthood leader, etc. However, when you resort to public displays then you have moved beyond having a conversation into providing testimony to the truth of something else, something other than the gospel of Jesus Christ. With as many churches in the world why stay in a church that one views as fraudulent and wrong? 5
CV75 Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 32 minutes ago, Johnnie Cake said: In which he declared his unbelief and stated he believed Joseph Smith was a fraud. Someone in his stake turned him in and when his SP asked him to delete the FB post...he refused. While I respect the church's right to set its boundaries and to be able to say who can and can't be a member of their organization...it seems to me that those boundaries are shrinking and becoming more compact and restrictive. An individuals right to personal expression seems to be taking a back seat to the churches right to control its own message. I'm curious how the illustrious members of this board view this development. Is the churches skin too thin? Do you support this action? Should personal expression be controlled to the point of losing ones membership. I should state that this individual was in good standing in all other areas...with the exception of his "thoughts" Do you have a link?
CV75 Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 26 minutes ago, Jeanne said: My friend just posted her thoughts on the essays and was exed. I am hoping members will quit turning people in and just perhaps have a good conversation first. There shouldn't be a "thought police" any where in the church (IMO). Good luck with this...duh..it may just depend on local ward authorities on how anything plays out anymore. Maybe she shouldn't have friended the bishop...
ksfisher Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 4 minutes ago, halconero said: He then went on r/exmormon throughout the whole process and repeatedly expressed his contempt for the leadership involved, recorded the whole thing secretly, and kept talking about how he stood up for himself and what he said throughout the whole thing. In my experience (and this is only my experience) it is more the attitude of the person for whom the disciplinary council is being held that determines the outcome of the council than the specific sin. I've seen people who committed the same sin receive different outcomes from a disciplinary council. If a person expresses a willingness to change I've seen disciplinary councils be very merciful. If the person comes in with no intention of changing, then the conclusion seems obvious. 4
JLHPROF Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 This whole thing comes down to the "free" thing again. People seem to think that "free agency" means you can choose to do whatever you like. That doesn't exempt you from the consequences. And "free speech" means you can say whatever you like. That also doesn't exempt you from the consequences. The Church had every right to do what they did, and so they should. 1
JAHS Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 That person is probably Facebook friends with lot of member of his stake and ward. The stake president and Bishop are protecting their members. He was first asked to remove the post, which is correct procedure. He refused so the next step is disciplinary procedures.
Jeanne Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 11 minutes ago, CV75 said: Maybe she shouldn't have friended the bishop... And maybe friending him should have got him to read those essays!
cinepro Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 I too am mystified by people who hold the Church's leaders, doctrines and history in contempt, but then act surprised or offended when they face Church discipline for publicly expressing those ideas. Jeremy Runnels, the author of the CES letter, was answering questions over at Reddit and I asked him why he wanted to still be a member of the Church. I asked him why he still wanted to be a member, and this was his response: Although I do not identify as a Mormon in the traditional sense, I take pride in my pioneer blood. Many of my ancestors were converted in England, traveled across the plains, and helped establish the church in Salt Lake as well as in LDS colonies outside of Utah. My ancestors made incredible sacrifices to live the gospel. I don’t want to turn my back on my heritage or the beautiful and powerful experiences I have enjoyed as a member of the church. In that sense, I am a Mormon even though I do not believe fundamental doctrines and do not consider myself a member of the LDS church. For those same reasons, I have not removed my name from church records. In some ways, I am holding on to a piece of a previous life. Yet, on the other hand, I am disheartened by the Church’s treatment of those who struggle with certain aspects of Church theology. I am concerned by the whitewashing of Church history. I am hurt by the labels and assumptions my friends and family members have made about me because of my lack of belief. I am troubled by the Church’s lack of introspection and engagement with a wide variety of issues. For these, and many other reasons (some of which I have outlined to you previously), I think it may be worthwhile to respond to my Stake President’s inquiries and potentially attend a disciplinary council. In doing so, I am not fighting for my membership. I am trying to start a discussion and open a dialogue. https://www.reddit.com/r/exmormon/comments/45xw4g/update_to_facing_excommunication_fight_or_flight/ 4
RevTestament Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 50 minutes ago, Johnnie Cake said: In which he declared his unbelief and stated he believed Joseph Smith was a fraud. Someone in his stake turned him in and when his SP asked him to delete the FB post...he refused. While I respect the church's right to set its boundaries and to be able to say who can and can't be a member of their organization...it seems to me that those boundaries are shrinking and becoming more compact and restrictive. An individuals right to personal expression seems to be taking a back seat to the churches right to control its own message. I'm curious how the illustrious members of this board view this development. Is the churches skin too thin? Do you support this action? Should personal expression be controlled to the point of losing ones membership. I should state that this individual was in good standing in all other areas...with the exception of his "thoughts" What do you think Joseph Smith would have done with someone who claimed he was a fraud, and the church is not true? Yeah, he would give the dude the boot, and did several times. No different today. It is one thing to believe maybe some of Josephs statements are incorrect personal opinion, and are wrong, but quite another to believe Joseph was a fraud, that the restored priesthood is fraudulent, and all the additional scripture is fraudulent. Why force the issue? Why not just resign, if you dont believe the Church is true? See no problem with excommunicating him - like Jeremy Runnels. IF you don't believe in something, or stopped believing in it, don't join it, or don't try to stay a member. Most other members would view you as a fraudulent member imho. Is Donald Trump a fraudulent Republican?
Popular Post Calm Posted April 1, 2016 Popular Post Posted April 1, 2016 39 minutes ago, halconero said: He then went on r/exmormon throughout the whole process and repeatedly expressed his contempt for the leadership involved, recorded the whole thing secretly, and kept talking about how he stood up for himself and what he said throughout the whole thing. What!?! There is more to the story?!? I am shocked!!! 11
thesometimesaint Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 As a long time participant on this MB I've noticed that the LDS question almost every statement by our leaders. So questioning isn't the determining factor. But publicly proclaiming the basic Truth Claims of the Church to be fraudulent is a one way ticket to a nice long talk with your Bishop. 1
Johnnie Cake Posted April 1, 2016 Author Posted April 1, 2016 52 minutes ago, halconero said: He then went on r/exmormon throughout the whole process and repeatedly expressed his contempt for the leadership involved, recorded the whole thing secretly, and kept talking about how he stood up for himself and what he said throughout the whole thing. Yeah, I was following the same thread. Don't ask me why I'm on that subreddit. Probably a morbid curiosity which ebbs and flows. Contempt? I don't recall him being disrespectful or expressing contempt
mfbukowski Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 1 hour ago, Johnnie Cake said: In which he declared his unbelief and stated he believed Joseph Smith was a fraud. Someone in his stake turned him in and when his SP asked him to delete the FB post...he refused. While I respect the church's right to set its boundaries and to be able to say who can and can't be a member of their organization...it seems to me that those boundaries are shrinking and becoming more compact and restrictive. An individuals right to personal expression seems to be taking a back seat to the churches right to control its own message. I'm curious how the illustrious members of this board view this development. Is the churches skin too thin? Do you support this action? Should personal expression be controlled to the point of losing ones membership. I should state that this individual was in good standing in all other areas...with the exception of his "thoughts" 1- Since the real reason for his excommunication is confidential, we only have his story. 2-The last sentence is self-contradictory. All we have is "thoughts". That's like saying "He died from nothing serious." 3
Johnnie Cake Posted April 1, 2016 Author Posted April 1, 2016 44 minutes ago, CV75 said: Do you have a link? Probably not linkable...from here
CA Steve Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 36 minutes ago, Storm Rider said: I am scratching my head on this. There are consequences to free speech in the Church and there should be. You get to say anything want and believe anything you want - that is free speech and freedom of religion. However, if you want to go public as a member and deny the truthfulness of the restoration of the gospel.....why are you a member? Why would anyone want to be a member of something they strongly believe is fraudulent? You lost me on this. No, this is not about his thoughts. If I think about things I don't proclaim it to the world. When I think I am thinking, questioning. If it a serious thought I will ASK someone their thoughts. I don't just start bearing witness to the world about what is something that is not just a thought. If you want a conversation, then talk to your home teacher, visiting teacher, bishop, stake president, sunday school teacher, relief society president, priesthood leader, etc. However, when you resort to public displays then you have moved beyond having a conversation into providing testimony to the truth of something else, something other than the gospel of Jesus Christ. With as many churches in the world why stay in a church that one views as fraudulent and wrong? Most of us view the leadership and general membership of the church as good people honestly trying to live their lives. What is so hard to understand about someone wanting to remain part of that organization and culture even if they believe it started out wrong? I am one who thinks the recent changes to the handbook regarding SSM and their children is wrong and I do not believe it was a revelation from God. If I voiced that opinion on my FB page should I be excommunicated?
VideoGameJunkie Posted April 1, 2016 Posted April 1, 2016 He said he wanted to resign but the only way his wife would accept him leaving the church is if he was excommunicated. He wanted to resign.
Recommended Posts