Jump to content
Seriously No Politics ×

Joseph Smith's Polyandry?


Recommended Posts

Posted
19 hours ago, Eek! said:

Thanks for posting the link.

Based on what I read at the link, it looks like Joseph's marriages to Sylvia Lyon and Sarah Ann Whitney fit the description of "polyandry" in that they were for "time and eternity" (rather than for eternity only) to a woman who was already civilly married, in the case of Sylvia, and to a woman who subsequently civilly married while Joseph was still alive, in the case of Sarah Ann. 

Am I missing something?  Correct me if I'm wrong, 

You are missing something.  In the case of Sarah Ann Whitney, it was a 'front marriage' as even Kingsbury himself admitted.  Without a marriage relationship, there is no polyandry.

In the case of Sylvia Sessions, you have the likelihood of a pioneer divorce, a common practice, which Sylvia also practiced with Ezekiel Clark later in life..

There remains no evidence for polyandry.

Posted
3 hours ago, rpn said:

The daughter doesn't write a direct quote.  And she wrote the affidavit in 1915: more than thirty years after her mother died in 1882 (if my math is correct).  We can't tell if she was paraphrasing her mother's statement or which part she may have changed.   But since Mother said that she was JS's daughter, referring to the sealing, we can as easily believe that, as we can that she was saying that JS had fathered the girl.   (Specially since that is how her sister Phoebe Clark, whom the Hales say was also there, understood it to be.)

This.

We don't know what the mother's state of mind was at the time. Perhaps she was drifting in and out of consciousness. Perhaps she was unaware that there were two daughters in the room, and perhaps it only occurred to her on the spur of the moment to bring it up with Josephine.

Too many variables here to form a hardened conclusion.

Posted
3 hours ago, Johnnie Cake said:

As soon as I wrote "begs the question"....I thought, oh boy, Scott's going to call me out for using the term in a "improper manner" but then I thought, well we are talking of a woman having sex with both of her husbands...which is an improper manner...so maybe it's improper use is justified...but you were too sharp Scott to let it slide.

thanks for keeping me honest 😜

At least you know I'm not singling you out to pick on you.

Longtime contributors to this board know that "begs the question" is a tripline for me.

Posted
2 hours ago, BCSpace said:

You are missing something.  In the case of Sarah Ann Whitney, it was a 'front marriage' as even Kingsbury himself admitted.  Without a marriage relationship, there is no polyandry.

In the case of Sylvia Sessions, you have the likelihood of a pioneer divorce, a common practice, which Sylvia also practiced with Ezekiel Clark later in life..

There remains no evidence for polyandry.

Were they not in Nauvoo at the time? which has the necessary requirements for divorce?  Would be interesting to see if divorces occurred in Nauvoo and how often.   And it was hardly a typical divorce if she got so quickly back with her husband or left him that she got confused over who the father might be.

Posted

Colour me impressed that people can keep track of who's who, who said what and when and then there's the DNA hhahahhahaha!

Posted
10 hours ago, BCSpace said:

You are missing something.  In the case of Sarah Ann Whitney, it was a 'front marriage' as even Kingsbury himself admitted.  Without a marriage relationship, there is no polyandry.

In the case of Sylvia Sessions, you have the likelihood of a pioneer divorce, a common practice, which Sylvia also practiced with Ezekiel Clark later in life..

There remains no evidence for polyandry.

Wouldn't a divorce have required another marriage ceremony when she got back with her 1st husband?  Yet none took place.  No its clear she was in a polyandry relationship with 2 men she deemed as husbands...having sexual relationships with both men in close proximity so that she couldn't even tell who the father of her child was.

Posted
19 minutes ago, Johnnie Cake said:

Wouldn't a divorce have required another marriage ceremony when she got back with her 1st husband?  Yet none took place.  No its clear she was in a polyandry relationship with 2 men she deemed as husbands...having sexual relationships with both men in close proximity so that she couldn't even tell who the father of her child was.

I'm not sure if it would require another marriage ceremony.  My ancestors (Mary Ann Darrow, Fredrick Walter Cox, Sr, and Edmund Richardson) didn't have another marriage when she left Cox to go back to Richardson.  They had their marriage sealed at that time, so maybe that could be seen as a remarriage.  I'm not even sure if they had a divorce or even if the marriage between Mary and Frederick was performed.

Posted
21 minutes ago, webbles said:

I'm not sure if it would require another marriage ceremony.  My ancestors (Mary Ann Darrow, Fredrick Walter Cox, Sr, and Edmund Richardson) didn't have another marriage when she left Cox to go back to Richardson.  They had their marriage sealed at that time, so maybe that could be seen as a remarriage.  I'm not even sure if they had a divorce or even if the marriage between Mary and Frederick was performed.

My post was directed at BC Spaces assertion that a possible undocumented divorce had taken place between Sylvia and Winsor. If a divorce had taken place I'm merely asking wouldn't a remarriage also have to have taken place?  The fact that none did...lessens the likelihood of BC Spaces's assertion.

Posted
43 minutes ago, Johnnie Cake said:

My post was directed at BC Spaces assertion that a possible undocumented divorce had taken place between Sylvia and Winsor. If a divorce had taken place I'm merely asking wouldn't a remarriage also have to have taken place?  The fact that none did...lessens the likelihood of BC Spaces's assertion.

Divorce from civil marriages were not seen as necessary.  I've provided evidences of this repeatedly.
And I'll say it again - as long as we attempt to view civil marriage the same way as priesthood marriage we will never truly understand how they practiced polygamy.

 

Posted
1 hour ago, JLHPROF said:

I've provided evidences of this repeatedly.

Fair enough I'm willing to be convinced.  Could you direct me to perhaps one of your past threads where this evidence is presented.  Thanks

Posted
13 hours ago, BCSpace said:

In the case of Sylvia Sessions, you have the likelihood of a pioneer divorce, a common practice, which Sylvia also practiced with Ezekiel Clark later in life.

What exactly is a "pioneer divorce"?   The first three pages of Google didn't help.  From the context of what happened between Sylvia and Ezekiel it sounds like she just left him, and in his mind he may have still considered her to be his wife because he continued to support her.  

Posted
23 minutes ago, Johnnie Cake said:

Fair enough I'm willing to be convinced.  Could you direct me to perhaps one of your past threads where this evidence is presented.  Thanks

  • Mormon Polygamy by Van Wagoner Pg 42 - Smith viewed as invalid those marriages not sealed by his blessing...Claiming sole responsibility for binding and unbinding marriages on earth and in heaven, he did not consider it necessary to obtain civil marriage licenses or divorce decrees.
  • Pg 46-47 - quoting John D. Lee - "About the same time the doctrine of 'sealing' was introduced...the saints were given to understand that their marriage relations with each other were not valid...If their marriage had not been productive of blessing and peace, and they felt it oppressive to remain together, they were at liberty to make their own choice, much as if they had not been married."
  • and quoting Increase McGee - "it is now the woman's privilege to choose whom she sees fit; if she likes the one she had been living with, she can keep him; if not, she is at liberty to ship him and take another;"
  • Eleanor J. McLean married Parley P. Pratt in polygamy while still married to Hector McLean, although she was separated from him. When asked if she had divorced McLean before she married Pratt, she answered: “No, the sectarian priests have no power from God to marry; and a so called marriage ceremony performed by them is no marriage at all; no divorce was needed… . Stephen Pratt, “The Last Days of Parley P. Pratt,” Brigham Young University Studies (1975): 20.
  • There was another way in which a woman could leave a man—if the woman preferred a man higher in authority and he is willing to take her and her husband gives her up. There is no bill of divorce required, in [this] case it is right in the sight of God. - Brigham Young ,Conference Reports, 8 Oct. 1861

And that's just the easiest ones to find.  And yes, there are historical examples of all of these.

As I've also said before we don't have to agree with them, but we have to understand the doctrinal viewpoint and principle they were operating under.
If we try to consider civil marriage as the same as priesthood marriage we will never understand the choices they made.

 

Posted
17 minutes ago, Eek! said:

What exactly is a "pioneer divorce"?   The first three pages of Google didn't help.  From the context of what happened between Sylvia and Ezekiel it sounds like she just left him, and in his mind he may have still considered her to be his wife because he continued to support her.  

http://josephsmithspolygamy.org/common-questions/sexual-polyandry/

  • Several factors could contribute to this decision including the difficulty in obtaining a legal divorce and the financial non-status of women in Jacksonian America.
    Many couples simply separated in what became known as a “pioneer” divorce, where one or both parties simply ignored their former marriage vows and moved on with their lives. Indeed when Sylvia decided to cease her relationship with Ezekiel Clark, her fourth husband contracted for time, in the mid-1850s, they took this route. Ezekiel later remarried without processing legal paperwork despite his position as a state legislator.

 

See also:
Eleanor J. McLean married Parley P. Pratt in polygamy while still married to Hector McLean, although she was separated from him. When asked if she had divorced McLean before she married Pratt, she answered: “No, the sectarian priests have no power from God to marry; and a so called marriage ceremony performed by them is no marriage at all; no divorce was needed… . Stephen Pratt, “The Last Days of Parley P. Pratt,” Brigham Young University Studies (1975): 20.

Posted (edited)
13 minutes ago, JLHPROF said:
  • Mormon Polygamy by Van Wagoner Pg 42 - Smith viewed as invalid those marriages not sealed by his blessing...Claiming sole responsibility for binding and unbinding marriages on earth and in heaven, he did not consider it necessary to obtain civil marriage licenses or divorce decrees.
  • Pg 46-47 - quoting John D. Lee - "About the same time the doctrine of 'sealing' was introduced...the saints were given to understand that their marriage relations with each other were not valid...If their marriage had not been productive of blessing and peace, and they felt it oppressive to remain together, they were at liberty to make their own choice, much as if they had not been married."
  • and quoting Increase McGee - "it is now the woman's privilege to choose whom she sees fit; if she likes the one she had been living with, she can keep him; if not, she is at liberty to ship him and take another;"
  • Eleanor J. McLean married Parley P. Pratt in polygamy while still married to Hector McLean, although she was separated from him. When asked if she had divorced McLean before she married Pratt, she answered: “No, the sectarian priests have no power from God to marry; and a so called marriage ceremony performed by them is no marriage at all; no divorce was needed… . Stephen Pratt, “The Last Days of Parley P. Pratt,” Brigham Young University Studies (1975): 20.
  • There was another way in which a woman could leave a man—if the woman preferred a man higher in authority and he is willing to take her and her husband gives her up. There is no bill of divorce required, in [this] case it is right in the sight of God. - Brigham Young ,Conference Reports, 8 Oct. 1861

And that's just the easiest ones to find.  And yes, there are historical examples of all of these.

As I've also said before we don't have to agree with them, but we have to understand the doctrinal viewpoint and principle they were operating under.
If we try to consider civil marriage as the same as priesthood marriage we will never understand the choices they made.

 

Interesting...thanks for the additional information... (1st impression...Nauvoo was one crazy town)

 

EDIT TO ADD:  In light of this Nauvoo dismissal of civil marriages and the recent DNA revelations, can you help me understand why Sylvia believed she could engage in marital relationships (sex) with both Winsor and Joseph at the same time.  If she truly held to the belief that she was divorced from Winsor and married to Joseph, wouldn't she have been committing adultery with one of her husbands?

Also kind of throws the 12th article of faith out the window...

Edited by Johnnie Cake
Posted
14 hours ago, Johnnie Cake said:

Help me understand one thing...Sylvia thought Joseph was the father of her daughter Josephine but was wrong, DNA shows that in fact Josephine's father was the other guy Sylvia had been sleeping with...her husband...so what exactly is wrong? I don't understand why critics have such a problem with this...

I think the main group who benefit from this new information is the group who deny Joseph Smith practiced plural marriage at all.

They have long claimed that the women who gave affidavits in the latter half of the 19th century in Utah in response to Joseph Smith III's missionary efforts were falsified in order to prove Joseph Smith III wrong.

I.e., the LDS Church wanted to prove that Joseph Smith did have plural wives whereas Joseph Smith III wanted to prove he did not.

Now that it appears Sylvia Sessions fibbed in her affidavit, might she not also have been fibbing about everything else?

And what does this do to the credibility of the other affidavits from alleged plural wives of Joseph Smith gathered under the same circumstances?

I expect Denver Snuffer may have something to say about this at Sunstone . . .

Posted
1 minute ago, consiglieri said:

I think the main group who benefit from this new information is the group who deny Joseph Smith practiced plural marriage at all.

They have long claimed that the women who gave affidavits in the latter half of the 19th century in Utah in response to Joseph Smith III's missionary efforts were falsified in order to prove Joseph Smith III wrong.

I.e., the LDS Church wanted to prove that Joseph Smith did have plural wives whereas Joseph Smith III wanted to prove he did not.

Now that it appears Sylvia Sessions fibbed in her affidavit, might she not also have been fibbing about everything else?

And what does this do to the credibility of the other affidavits from alleged plural wives of Joseph Smith gathered under the same circumstances?

I expect Denver Snuffer may have something to say about this at Sunstone . . .

I don't believe Sylvia Sessions gave an affidavit. 

Posted
5 minutes ago, jkwilliams said:

I don't believe Sylvia Sessions gave an affidavit. 

Ooops.  It was her daughter, Josephine, who gave the affidavit attesting to what her mom told her.

Good catch!

I still think this is a coup for the "Joseph Smith Fought Polygamy" crowd.

Posted
1 minute ago, consiglieri said:

Ooops.  It was her daughter, Josephine, who gave the affidavit attesting to what her mom told her.

Good catch!

I still think this is a coup for the "Joseph Smith Fought Polygamy" crowd.

It definitely disproves Brian Hales's assertion that Sylvia was separated from her husband at the time. IMO, that she thought Josephine (alone out of all her children) was Joseph Smith's child, tends to support the assumption that there was sexual polyandry in her case. 

Posted (edited)
37 minutes ago, JLHPROF said:
  • Mormon Polygamy by Van Wagoner Pg 42 - Smith viewed as invalid those marriages not sealed by his blessing...Claiming sole responsibility for binding and unbinding marriages on earth and in heaven, he did not consider it necessary to obtain civil marriage licenses or divorce decrees.
  • Pg 46-47 - quoting John D. Lee - "About the same time the doctrine of 'sealing' was introduced...the saints were given to understand that their marriage relations with each other were not valid...If their marriage had not been productive of blessing and peace, and they felt it oppressive to remain together, they were at liberty to make their own choice, much as if they had not been married."
  • and quoting Increase McGee - "it is now the woman's privilege to choose whom she sees fit; if she likes the one she had been living with, she can keep him; if not, she is at liberty to ship him and take another;"
  • Eleanor J. McLean married Parley P. Pratt in polygamy while still married to Hector McLean, although she was separated from him. When asked if she had divorced McLean before she married Pratt, she answered: “No, the sectarian priests have no power from God to marry; and a so called marriage ceremony performed by them is no marriage at all; no divorce was needed… . Stephen Pratt, “The Last Days of Parley P. Pratt,” Brigham Young University Studies (1975): 20.
  • There was another way in which a woman could leave a man—if the woman preferred a man higher in authority and he is willing to take her and her husband gives her up. There is no bill of divorce required, in [this] case it is right in the sight of God. - Brigham Young ,Conference Reports, 8 Oct. 1861

And that's just the easiest ones to find.  And yes, there are historical examples of all of these.

As I've also said before we don't have to agree with them, but we have to understand the doctrinal viewpoint and principle they were operating under.
If we try to consider civil marriage as the same as priesthood marriage we will never understand the choices they made.

 

This is all very interesting..but it makes marriage vows such a sham unless it under the doctrine of sealing.  Kind of throws a different light on chastity at least to me.

Edited to add:  Too bad Emma wasn't more aware of how this all works before Joseph had her sealed.

Edited by Jeanne
Posted
16 minutes ago, Jeanne said:

This is all very interesting..but it makes marriage vows such a sham unless it under the doctrine of sealing.  Kind of throws a different light on chastity at least to me.

Edited to add:  Too bad Emma wasn't more aware of how this all works before Joseph had her sealed.

I doesn't make them a sham any more than consecration makes tithing a sham.
There are telestial vows, terriestrial vows, and celestial vows.  It all depends on us.  D&C 132 even outlines the different levels of vows.

As far as Emma is concerned, she had the same option to get a "pioneer divorce" from Joseph if she was unable to accept polygamy as anyone else did.  I don't doubt how hard polygamy was for the early members, but I refuse to treat them as victims.  Their agency was still intact.  They could walk away and many did.

Posted
2 hours ago, jkwilliams said:

It definitely disproves Brian Hales's assertion that Sylvia was separated from her husband at the time. IMO, that she thought Josephine (alone out of all her children) was Joseph Smith's child, tends to support the assumption that there was sexual polyandry in her case. 

Brilliant!!!

Posted
On 6/12/2016 at 1:56 PM, Jeanne said:

Well...she is definitely her mother's daughter!:)  On the off shoot here..but why didn't people smile back then???

Slow lenses and even slower film.

Posted
2 hours ago, jkwilliams said:

It definitely disproves Brian Hales's assertion that Sylvia was separated from her husband at the time. IMO, that she thought Josephine (alone out of all her children) was Joseph Smith's child, tends to support the assumption that there was sexual polyandry in her case. 

Yes. And I am distrustful of interpretations of the data from those who are not open to the possibility of polyandry. As of now, we have some very agenda driven conclusions from those who are determined to rule out anything but polygyny as being valid. Those who insist that polygamy is the Lord's favored marriage arrangement for all time have boxed themselves in if polyandry turns out to have been in JS's plans. 

Posted
On 6/12/2016 at 1:09 PM, ALarson said:

Thanks, Calm.  I value your opinion greatly.  I am really not familiar with Meg Stout other than reading some of her writings on this one topic and I'm not impressed with her theories.  

 

I read enough of her stuff on M* to be horrified.  She insisted that a letter or word in one of Eliza's poems had been altered which proved that it was actually written about a former lover.(She came up with the word she needed it to have said.) The problem is she came to this conclusion without viewing the original document and having no background whatsoever in analyzing handwriting if she had.  If I remember correctly, Stout apparently thinks the Nauvoo women were fooling around so much JS had to rescue them with polygamous marriages.   

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...