Jump to content
Seriously No Politics ×

Joseph Smith's Polyandry?


Recommended Posts

Posted
22 minutes ago, Calm said:

There is a difference between teasing someone you are talking to and accusing a scientist who is not aware of the claim of possibly reporting false data.  Would you feel comfortable if Tacenda persistently accused you of intentionally reporting lies in your DN work?  It is the fact that Tacenda has continued to suggest the possibility of fudging that angers me.

I agree it is not cool to cast aspersions on someone's professional reputation without having a good reason or being able to substantiate it.

Apparently Tacenda feels duly chastened.

Posted
10 minutes ago, jkwilliams said:

For the record, I don't believe anyone is unbiased, including myself, so it would be silly to pretend otherwise.

Nor do I -- which is why I believe going "where the evidence leads" is such a subjective thing when the evidence could lead either way.

And thus we come back to the principle of belief being a matter of choice, not compulsion, in many instances.

(But we've been over that on the other thread.)

Posted
15 minutes ago, Scott Lloyd said:

Nor do I -- which is why I believe going "where the evidence leads" is such a subjective thing when the evidence could lead either way.

And thus we come back to the principle of belief being a matter of choice, not compulsion, in many instances.

(But we've been over that on the other thread.)

Well, you left out something important. I said "where I think the evidence leads." Big difference. 

Posted
3 hours ago, Calm said:

I am extremely disappointed in your continuing efforts to sully the reputation of not only a highly respected scientist, but a good man.  Do you even have a clue to how the work is done?  And making excuses for it by claiming you are "half kidding".  You should be ashamed of yourself.

Trust is easy when you struggle..Tacenda tries hard and I think your comment was uncalled for.  You should be ashamed of yourself.

Posted
2 hours ago, Jeanne said:

Trust is easy when you struggle..Tacenda tries hard and I think your comment was uncalled for.  You should be ashamed of yourself.

Tacenda accused a professional of lying and fudging results with nothing to back up the accusation.  That's a pretty serious thing.  She has since apologized (which isn't surprising because Tacenda is a good lady) but Cal wasn't being unreasonable to call her on it.

Posted
4 hours ago, Gray said:

If that's how you wish to portray these relationships. 

Not my portrayal but it is my comment on the portrayal by critics.

Posted
3 hours ago, Jeanne said:

Trust is easy when you struggle..Tacenda tries hard and I think your comment was uncalled for.  You should be ashamed of yourself.

Not so such accusations are no better coming from her position than from any other position.

Posted
2 hours ago, bluebell said:

Tacenda accused a professional of lying and fudging results with nothing to back up the accusation.  That's a pretty serious thing.  She has since apologized (which isn't surprising because Tacenda is a good lady) but Cal wasn't being unreasonable to call her on it.

I feel bad, because I hate when people do that to people I trust and believe in.  I won't mention who those people are or who those people they distrust's names are.  And Calm can call me on things, I'm use to it, she usually has a good reason. 

But need to say I didn't outright accuse in a serious tone, but may it was enough to do harm I guess.  But really how many people take me serious? ;) 

In my old age, my brain cells, judgement etc. is coming up empty, so you may see some crazy stuff coming out of my mouth.  Just warning y'all.  Still love this group, they give me more attention then my own family, haha.  And usually people will take anything if it means they get attention.

 

Posted
11 hours ago, bluebell said:

Tacenda accused a professional of lying and fudging results with nothing to back up the accusation.  That's a pretty serious thing.  She has since apologized (which isn't surprising because Tacenda is a good lady) but Cal wasn't being unreasonable to call her on it.

I didn't see it as an accusation but as an expression of distrust. Let's face it, a lot of former or no-longer-believing Mormons have lost a tremendous amount of trust in the church and its leaders, whether or not it is warranted. That's how I read Tacenda's comment, not as an attack or an accusation, but I get Calm's point. For me, trust is earned, and most LDS scholars I know have earned my trust, though a few have shown they cannot be trusted. Perhaps Dr. Perego hasn't earned Tacenda's trust yet.

Posted
1 hour ago, jkwilliams said:

I didn't see it as an accusation but as an expression of distrust. Let's face it, a lot of former or no-longer-believing Mormons have lost a tremendous amount of trust in the church and its leaders, whether or not it is warranted. That's how I read Tacenda's comment, not as an attack or an accusation, but I get Calm's point. For me, trust is earned, and most LDS scholars I know have earned my trust, though a few have shown they cannot be trusted. Perhaps Dr. Perego hasn't earned Tacenda's trust yet.

Coming from an academic background, you don't call into question someone's professional ethics unless you have a reason too.  Falsifying data is a serious accusation.

Beyond that, Mormons who have left the faith or lost their testimonies often speak of how wrong it is for members to question their ethics and integrity just because they've come to a different conclusion than they have. Given that, it's sometimes odd how quick some in that group are to question the ethics and integrity of those they disagree with. 

Posted
5 minutes ago, bluebell said:

Coming from an academic background, you don't call into question someone's professional ethics unless you have a reason too.  Falsifying data is a serious accusation.

Beyond that, Mormons who have left the faith or lost their testimonies often speak of how wrong it is for members to question their ethics and integrity just because they've come to a different conclusion than they have. Given that, it's sometimes odd how quick some in that group are to question the ethics and integrity of those they disagree with. 

I know. I am not justifying her reaction, but I think I understand where she is coming from. That's all. As I said, only a few Mormon scholars have earned my distrust, with good reason. My integrity and ethics are questioned all the time (see the thread about the detained missionaries), and it no longer bothers me. I figure I've probably given people plenty of reasons to doubt my integrity. Dr. Perego has not, IMO.

Posted

I may be confused but it sounds like people are arguing that it's not polyandry because the sealings to women who were already married were likely not consummated?  That feels like a difficult position to maintain knowing we mostly can't know the bedroom activities of people from 170 years ago.  Its been a while but are there examples of polyandry after the Nauvoo period?

Posted
2 minutes ago, jkwilliams said:

I know. I am not justifying her reaction, but I think I understand where she is coming from. That's all. As I said, only a few Mormon scholars have earned my distrust, with good reason. My integrity and ethics are questioned all the time (see the thread about the detained missionaries), and it no longer bothers me. I figure I've probably given people plenty of reasons to doubt my integrity. Dr. Perego has not, IMO.

 

9 minutes ago, bluebell said:

Coming from an academic background, you don't call into question someone's professional ethics unless you have a reason too.  Falsifying data is a serious accusation.

Beyond that, Mormons who have left the faith or lost their testimonies often speak of how wrong it is for members to question their ethics and integrity just because they've come to a different conclusion than they have. Given that, it's sometimes odd how quick some in that group are to question the ethics and integrity of those they disagree with. 

I thought long and hard about why I wouldn't even trust science.  I think I have been invested in the situation that Josephine is Joseph's daughter so much that it is somewhat like those on the board that no matter what they hear negative about the church they won't believe the church is in the wrong.  Compare that to me and no matter how right the evidence, I struggled to believe it.

My nephews are descendants of Josephine, and their cousin is who I've been in contact with.  She's the one that was very sure that she was the daughter, and even went so far as posting about it on FB awhile back, I FB messenged her two days ago about the final results, and it was the first she'd heard about it.  I linked her up with Ugo's Go Fund Me page that has discussion about it.  

So I have a history of believing it to be true, and being excited to talk to my nephews about their being related to the Joseph Smith.  Phew, glad that conversation didn't take place now.

I know the things I've said here don't excuse my behavior, and don't be mad, but I'd like to see the proof or results for myself, just for fun.

Big thanks to JK and Jeanne for sticking your necks out to help me feel a little better or soften the blows.  Now I hope the thread can get back on track.  

Posted
24 minutes ago, Tacenda said:

 

I thought long and hard about why I wouldn't even trust science.  I think I have been invested in the situation that Josephine is Joseph's daughter so much that it is somewhat like those on the board that no matter what they hear negative about the church they won't believe the church is in the wrong.  Compare that to me and no matter how right the evidence, I struggled to believe it.

My nephews are descendants of Josephine, and their cousin is who I've been in contact with.  She's the one that was very sure that she was the daughter, and even went so far as posting about it on FB awhile back, I FB messenged her two days ago about the final results, and it was the first she'd heard about it.  I linked her up with Ugo's Go Fund Me page that has discussion about it.  

So I have a history of believing it to be true, and being excited to talk to my nephews about their being related to the Joseph Smith.  Phew, glad that conversation didn't take place now.

I know the things I've said here don't excuse my behavior, and don't be mad, but I'd like to see the proof or results for myself, just for fun.

Big thanks to JK and Jeanne for sticking your necks out to help me feel a little better or soften the blows.  Now I hope the thread can get back on track.  

It is hard to let go of things we are deeply invested in. BTW, Josephine Lyon married William Fisher, who was a prominent Pony Express rider and my great-grandfather's oldest brother. 

Posted
1 minute ago, thesometimesaint said:

Not really. All it takes is once.

Yes, but the odds decrease pretty quickly the fewer times it happens. 

Posted
8 minutes ago, jkwilliams said:

Yes, but the odds decrease pretty quickly the fewer times it happens. 

I'll bet dollars to donuts that the women in that time period were excellent at natural birth control given there was not birth control pills or condoms etc.  I researched a bit about the natural methods because I mentioned in a post earlier that they do exist.  The pull out method (awww, I didn't want to go here or say this phrase, that's how modest I tend to be about sex) is an excellent form of birth control for the most part.  So I'm betting that at the time, these women knew that polygamy was on the down low, and a child would not be good at the time.  

Posted (edited)
2 minutes ago, Tacenda said:

I'll bet dollars to donuts that the women in that time period were excellent at natural birth control given there was not birth control pills or condoms etc.  I researched a bit about the natural methods because I mentioned in a post earlier that they do exist.  The pull out method (awww, I didn't want to go here or say this phrase, that's how modest I tend to be about sex) is an excellent form of birth control for the most part.  So I'm betting that at the time, these women knew that polygamy was on the down low, and a child would not be good at the time.  

That's probably a safe bet. I hadn't thought of that, but it makes sense.

Edited by jkwilliams
Posted

The fact of the matter is that Joseph sealed himself to these married women for eternity and stole them for eternity from their earthly husbands, and some of the husbands were good LDS men serving a mission, who never had a chance since Joseph was the prophet. 

Posted
On ‎6‎/‎14‎/‎2016 at 8:46 AM, jkwilliams said:

Only if one assumes regular relations. 

I was watching an episode of Seinfeld last night where George was asking Susan about not knowing when her "cycles" are.

This put me in mind of the fact that having sex with a woman is less likely to result in conception depending on where the woman is in her "cycles."

If you have only one wife, you would have to have sex during the time of the month when she is not fertile.

If you had enough wives on differing cycles, you could probably manage to have sex any given night of the week so long as the wife you were having sex with was at the right place in her "cycle."

This practice would be unlikely to result in pregnancies.

On average, you would need around thirty wives to make this work.

How many wives did Joseph Smith have again . . . ?

Posted
2 minutes ago, consiglieri said:

I was watching an episode of Seinfeld last night where George was asking Susan about not knowing when her "cycles" are.

This put me in mind of the fact that having sex with a woman is less likely to result in conception depending on where the woman is in her "cycles."

If you have only one wife, you would have to have sex during the time of the month when she is not fertile.

If you had enough wives on differing cycles, you could probably manage to have sex any given night of the week so long as the wife you were having sex with was at the right place in her "cycle."

This practice would be unlikely to result in pregnancies.

On average, you would need around thirty wives to make this work.

How many wives did Joseph Smith have again . . . ?

Yes, the only person he was likely intimate with regularly was Emma, and she is the one who conceived. 

Posted (edited)
49 minutes ago, Tacenda said:

I'll bet dollars to donuts that the women in that time period were excellent at natural birth control given there was not birth control pills or condoms etc.  I researched a bit about the natural methods because I mentioned in a post earlier that they do exist.  The pull out method (awww, I didn't want to go here or say this phrase, that's how modest I tend to be about sex) is an excellent form of birth control for the most part.  So I'm betting that at the time, these women knew that polygamy was on the down low, and a child would not be good at the time.  

Some form of birth control has been used by women for thousands of years. Some more effective than others. But I find it odd that they bought into polygamy, and raising seed unto the Lord would simultaneously elect to use birth control.

You do what they called couples who use the "withdrawal" method? Mommy and daddy. ;)

Edited by thesometimesaint
Posted
1 minute ago, thesometimesaint said:

Some form of birth control has been used by women for thousands of years. Some more effective than others. But I find it odd that they bought into polygamy, and raising seed unto the Lord would simultaneously elect to use birth control.

You do what they called couples who use the "withdrawal" method? Mommy and daddy. ;)

My guess is that sexual intimacy between Joseph and his wives would have been infrequent, to say the least, so, even if the wives were all on the same cycle (and that is highly unlikely), the odds of successful pregnancy would be pretty low. Especially if they were taking preventive measures. As Tacenda said, it makes sense for them to do so, as a pregnancy would have raised a scandal. 

Of course, this is all just speculation. 

Posted

It didn't seem to have been much of a scandal for Hyrum and a few other close associates.

The women don't all have to be on the same cycle. In fact it is better if they are not. Having sex with your wives is no big deal for me. But I'm perfectly content with the one wife I've ever had. I have no desire for another.

I agree it is all just speculation.

Posted (edited)

Do we know an approxamite date for when Josephine was conceived? Is it possible that the conception happened around the time when Sylvia transitioned from Windsor to Joseph? That could explain why Sylvia was confused.

Edited by Rivers
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...