Popular Post canard78 Posted May 18, 2014 Popular Post Posted May 18, 2014 (edited) Given parts of the endowment that is done today is different to the original in 1800s I would suggest it was never designed as a documentary. Elder Packer talks about the endowment in the context of parables (though he doesn't outright say that it is only a parable). Similarly the temple prep lesson describe the characters and scenes as symbolic (though it also doesn't say it is only a symbolic).If you will go to the temple and remember that the teaching is symbolic, you will never go in the proper spirit without coming away with your vision extended, feeling a little more exalted, with your knowledge increased as to things that are spiritual. The teaching plan is superb. It is inspired. The Lord Himself, the Master Teacher, taught His disciples constantly in parables—a verbal way to represent symbolically things that might otherwise be difficult to understand.Boyd K. Packerhttps://www.lds.org/ensign/2010/10/the-holy-temple?lang=engIn a symbolic way, the teachings and rituals of the temple take us on an upward journey toward eternal life, ending with a symbolic entrance into the presence of God. The characters depicted, the physical setting, the clothing worn, the signs given, and all the events covered in the temple are symbolic. When they are understood, they will help each person recognize truth and grow spiritually.http://www.lds.org/manual/endowed-from-on-high-temple-preparation-seminar-teachers-manual/lesson-5-learning-from-the-lord-through-symbols?lang=eng Edited May 18, 2014 by canard78 6
Popular Post canard78 Posted May 18, 2014 Popular Post Posted May 18, 2014 I find this quote also interesting, particularly in the context of a changing endowment. "Bro[ther] Joseph [smith] turned to me [brigham Young] and said: “Brother Brigham this is not arranged right, but we have done the best we could under the circumstances in which we are placed, and I wish you to take this mat[t]er in hand and organize and systematize all these ceremonies with the signs, tokens, penalties and key words.” I did so and each time I got something more; so that when we went through the Temple at Nauvoo, I understood and knew how to place them there. We had our ceremonies pretty correct."http://www.dialoguejournal.com/wp-content/uploads/sbi/articles/Dialogue_V20N04_35.pdfI love the endowment experience. I think it really opened and "flowered" for me when I stopped worrying about why and when the story happened and instead focused on what I could learn from the story and ceremony. I personally prefer to lean much closer to "parable" than historical. I don't need to understand an historically fallen Adam to know that I fall every day. 8
changed Posted May 18, 2014 Posted May 18, 2014 I think it is a mixture, that there really were two people who came to a world that had grown void, and brought in a new age - or a new era. I think Adam and Eve were real, that they came from a perfect heavenly sphere, that they voluntarily took upon themselves death and pain in order to raise up a family. 1
BlueDreams Posted May 18, 2014 Posted May 18, 2014 I put both. Some of the very basic details I think really happened. I think the vast majority of it is purely symbolic though. The varying accounts of adam and eve give this strong sense of flexibility in viewing the garden narrative. with luv,BD 2
CV75 Posted May 19, 2014 Posted May 19, 2014 Both, by far, far more symbolic than historical (by general modern standards, at least). 1
USU78 Posted May 19, 2014 Posted May 19, 2014 Just because something has mythic qualities does not mean it didn't happen. Consider Salt Lake County, if you would: What is at its head . . . and what is at its foot? Hint: The Capitol and the State Prison. 1
JLHPROF Posted May 19, 2014 Posted May 19, 2014 You really should add a 3rd option - it's a symbolic representation of actual events. The temple representation is more close to what actually happened than the Genesis account. But there is still symbolism. IE Was the apple actually an apple? Or does it just represent the mortal elements Adam & Eve took in to become mortal. So yeah, a there really should be a 3rd choice - symbolic representation of actual events. 1
canard78 Posted May 20, 2014 Posted May 20, 2014 You really should add a 3rd option - it's a symbolic representation of actual events. The temple representation is more close to what actually happened than the Genesis account. But there is still symbolism. IE Was the apple actually an apple? Or does it just represent the mortal elements Adam & Eve took in to become mortal.So yeah, a there really should be a 3rd choice - symbolic representation of actual events.I know it might be your opinion, not an absolute statement, but do you have any LDS sources that say the endowment version is more historically accurate than genesis. Not saying there are none, just interested to know if there are.
JLHPROF Posted May 21, 2014 Posted May 21, 2014 I know it might be your opinion, not an absolute statement, but do you have any LDS sources that say the endowment version is more historically accurate than genesis.Not saying there are none, just interested to know if there are. I'm afraid I really don't have time to look up anything "historical" and frankly I'm not sure there is any.But I think it falls into the "as it is translated correctly" scenario. OT texts that have been passed down and retranslated again and again since about 3000 BC vs. the scene portrayed in an ordinance revealed by revelation to a latter-day prophet.Just as we expect more accuracy in the BOM than in the Bible, it makes sense that we would expect more accuracy in the revelation of the temple story than in the OT text. But I suppose that isn't proof, just a bit of applied Mormonism. If there are significant difference, then I think further light and knowledge should take precedence.
oremites Posted May 21, 2014 Posted May 21, 2014 A different way to ask this might be: On a scale from 0 (entirely symbolic) to 100 (all events are depicted as they actually occurred), where does the temple ceremony fall? My answer is 15. Just my opinion, of course. I don't claim any special insight.
thesometimesaint Posted May 21, 2014 Posted May 21, 2014 I know it might be your opinion, not an absolute statement, but do you have any LDS sources that say the endowment version is more historically accurate than genesis.Not saying there are none, just interested to know if there are. You might be interested in Temple and Cosmos by Hugh Nibley. 1
Guest Posted May 21, 2014 Posted May 21, 2014 Just wanted to know how other feel.The film represents more than just the Garden, it is composite of events.
canard78 Posted May 21, 2014 Posted May 21, 2014 You might be interested in Temple and Cosmos by Hugh Nibley. I have it. I love it. It was part of the process of embracing the idea of a symbolic play. I may have missed the part where he says that the endowment version of the creation story is the most historically accurate.
Guest Posted May 21, 2014 Posted May 21, 2014 (edited) You might be interested in Temple and Cosmos by Hugh Nibley.I love his book, "Approaching Zion". Have not read Temple and Cosmos. I'll check it out. Edited May 22, 2014 by Pa Pa
halconero Posted May 22, 2014 Posted May 22, 2014 Fun fact: The Genesis account is the amalgamation of two different creation stories. In the first, creation occurs in 6 days, is performed by Elohim, involves the sexless organization of "man" who is then simultaneously split into the two sexes, and involves Hebrew cosmology. The second account involves the man being created before all other creatures (unlike the first account), and who comes before woman; the creator is Yahweh instead of Elohim, and the entire creative period occurs in just one day.Numerous groups have tried to reconcile these accounts and contradictions, the craziest one (according to Western Christian culture) is the Gnostic account of creation (evil Demiurge creates the world with the help of her/his sons Abel/Eloim and Cain/Yahweh). How do we reconcile it? By saying the first account was the spiritual creation, while the later was the physical creation, as outlined in the Moses Creation Myth.I think this opens up the symbolism, mystery, revelatory process, and ambiguity all at once if we realize that the 6 day creative period depicted in the Endowment was actually the spiritual creation. 1
Garden Girl Posted May 23, 2014 Posted May 23, 2014 I have it. I love it. It was part of the process of embracing the idea of a symbolic play. RE: Temple and Cosmos... Me too, Canard... me too. GG
thesometimesaint Posted May 23, 2014 Posted May 23, 2014 RE: Temple and Cosmos... Me too, Canard... me too. GG I've got his entire collected works. Love them all. I fully believe that if Church members read them we'd have a much better understanding of the Church, and how the Gospel plays out in our lives. 2
JLHPROF Posted May 23, 2014 Posted May 23, 2014 I've got his entire collected works. Love them all. I fully believe that if Church members read them we'd have a much better understanding of the Church, and how the Gospel plays out in our lives. Agreed. If only we could replace the Sunday School manuals...quick, someone call correlation.
Kenngo1969 Posted May 23, 2014 Posted May 23, 2014 Option (3): "I wasn't there ... at least, not that I remember ... so I dunno!"
Tacenda Posted May 24, 2014 Posted May 24, 2014 All these years I believed it happened like in the temple movie. It's kinda sad that I wasn't told in the beginning. What the heck is true in scripture? Sounds like a big scam, maybe our test is to not rely on it but our relationship with Him. Yes, I used that word again, haha. But we do need to be born again and no that doesn't mean baptism at 8! I'm off in tangent land but it bothers me that just like Santa isn't real, Easter Bunnies don't bring Easter baskets, and the Tooth Fairy doesn't exist, now the GoE doesn't? And some would even compare the story of Mormonism to being just as much the fairytale, what next? We're all gonna have to take our big boy and girl pills.
Popular Post halconero Posted May 24, 2014 Popular Post Posted May 24, 2014 All these years I believed it happened like in the temple movie. It's kinda sad that I wasn't told in the beginning. What the heck is true in scripture? Sounds like a big scam, maybe our test is to not rely on it but our relationship with Him. Yes, I used that word again, haha. But we do need to be born again and no that doesn't mean baptism at 8!I'm off in tangent land but it bothers me that just like Santa isn't real, Easter Bunnies don't bring Easter baskets, and the Tooth Fairy doesn't exist, now the GoE doesn't? And some would even compare the story of Mormonism to being just as much the fairytale, what next? We're all gonna have to take our big boy and girl pills. I'd say that the truths taught in scripture and by the drama in the endowment are beautiful. They teach a number of things. 1) As we are all Adams and all Eves we have our own personal fall. 2) The sacrifice of Jesus on our behalf is what redeems us 3) Satan's plans will be frustrated and combatted through Christ. 4) Prophets and Apostles function to point us to Christ. 5) Physical reminders can aid us in remembering the Atonement of Christ. Ordinances in the endowment are meant to remind us of the crucifixion of Christ 6) Women and Men aid each other in coming to Christ 5
Recommended Posts