Scott Lloyd Posted November 9, 2021 Posted November 9, 2021 14 minutes ago, bluebell said: Our ward is doing something similar. The appointments are kept on a google doc sheet and one of the clerks emails the person an invitation to the event so they have an email reminder of when their appointment is. Our bishop also offered zoom options. It's a testament to how much many of us hate zoom that so many people are still choosing to do the in-person option, including my family. We don't get reports of our tithing anymore though. We are asked to look it up ourselves on line and told that we will be provided with a paper copy only if we request one. I'm sure no one is more happy when tithing settlement is over than the bishop and those who have to help with the process. Hmm. I might suggest our ward do something like that regarding the donor reports, although I don’t mind printing out or emailing them for the attendees. I rather enjoyed doing it last year, although I admittedly might enjoy it less if I did not have the discretionary time that comes with being retired 😉 . 1
Rain Posted November 9, 2021 Posted November 9, 2021 7 minutes ago, The Nehor said: While this is true in my experience Bishops probably don’t look through donations to check on people who stop paying. I have access to that information and I only checked once at the Bishop’s request to get information about someone being considered for a calling. I thought about offering to monitor who was paying for abnormalities to report on once a month in Bishopric but decided I wasn’t really comfortable doing it. While the intention would be to help someone who may have lost a job or had a faith crisis it is kind of creepy. While the Bishop does have access to that information odds are he is completely ignorant about it. Most likely the first time he would have concerns based on abnormalities in tithing payment (absent a spiritual prompting) is when he does Tithing Settlement with the person or has to check off their status if they did not attend. I'm glad you decided against that. When my husband lost his job some years ago we were just fine. We had a savings and food storage. He had a number of opportunities to get a job. During that time I ended up doing a really short survey for $1. I hated paying the 1 dime tithing on that, but only because we knew it would make us stand out. 2
Scott Lloyd Posted November 9, 2021 Posted November 9, 2021 As a point of information, I’m quoting from the Church’s handbook this direction regarding tithing settlement: ”All members should attend tithing settlement to make sure their contribution records are correct and to declare to the bishop their status as tithe payers. If possible, all members of a family should attend tithing settlement. “In addition to reviewing records of members’ tithing, fast offerings, and other donations, during tithing settlement the bishop can discuss the principle of tithing with them, encourage them to give a generous fast offering, and discuss other relevant matters. At the time of tithing settlement, a clerk or a member of the bishopric could also review the Individual Ordinance Summary with members (see 33.6).” To the extent that most of what we do in the Church is optional, I suppose it could be said that tithing settlement attendance is optional. But from this passage in the handbook, it appears that it’s not something we should be cavalier about.
Rain Posted November 9, 2021 Posted November 9, 2021 6 minutes ago, Scott Lloyd said: As a point of information, I’m quoting from the Church’s handbook this direction regarding tithing settlement: ”All members should attend tithing settlement to make sure their contribution records are correct and to declare to the bishop their status as tithe payers. If possible, all members of a family should attend tithing settlement. “In addition to reviewing records of members’ tithing, fast offerings, and other donations, during tithing settlement the bishop can discuss the principle of tithing with them, encourage them to give a generous fast offering, and discuss other relevant matters. At the time of tithing settlement, a clerk or a member of the bishopric could also review the Individual Ordinance Summary with members (see 33.6).” To the extent that most of what we do in the Church is optional, I suppose it could be said that tithing settlement attendance is optional. But from this passage in the handbook, it appears that it’s not something we should be cavalier about. Oh, I wasn't cavalier about it. I searched to find what I could on the church website and scriptures about it. When not really finding anything that inspired me I posted here to see if I was missing anything. Then I talked to my husband and others. Then I talked with the Lord. I feel right with the Lord about not going. I also know that there are others who do not feel cavalier about it for good reason. And others who feel they really need to go. I feel comfortable that we can all be in a different place and feel right with our choices on this matter. 4
Scott Lloyd Posted November 9, 2021 Posted November 9, 2021 4 minutes ago, Rain said: Oh, I wasn't cavalier about it. I searched to find what I could on the church website and scriptures about it. When not really finding anything that inspired me I posted here to see if I was missing anything. Then I talked to my husband and others. Then I talked with the Lord. I feel right with the Lord about not going. I also know that there are others who do not feel cavalier about it for good reason. And others who feel they really need to go. I feel comfortable that we can all be in a different place and feel right with our choices on this matter. You’re entitled to your choice, of course. But the handbook does say “all members,” hence my comment about whether it is optional.
bsjkki Posted November 9, 2021 Author Posted November 9, 2021 ‘should’ vs ‘must’ The statement provides for individual circumstances. 3
Scott Lloyd Posted November 9, 2021 Posted November 9, 2021 22 minutes ago, bsjkki said: ‘should’ vs ‘must’ The statement provides for individual circumstances. It’s not my place to second-guess any individual’s decision, and I don’t mean to come across as doing so. But my reading of the handbook is that such “individual circumstances” ought to be the infrequent exception and not in any way routine.
2BizE Posted November 9, 2021 Posted November 9, 2021 I have transitioned away from tithing settlement. I think it is a relic of the past and of little value. Other charities I donate money to do not hold a meeting to question me about whether or not I’ve given enough money to them. They are simply grateful. The only way I know if to get this old structure to disappear is to no longer support it. Tithing is discussed during temple recommend interviews anyway.
2BizE Posted November 9, 2021 Posted November 9, 2021 2 hours ago, Rain said: Oh, I wasn't cavalier about it. I searched to find what I could on the church website and scriptures about it. When not really finding anything that inspired me I posted here to see if I was missing anything. Then I talked to my husband and others. Then I talked with the Lord. I feel right with the Lord about not going. I also know that there are others who do not feel cavalier about it for good reason. And others who feel they really need to go. I feel comfortable that we can all be in a different place and feel right with our choices on this matter. I really like how you purposefully analyzed your desires and chose an option that was most meaningful for you.
JustAnAustralian Posted November 9, 2021 Posted November 9, 2021 14 minutes ago, 2BizE said: Other charities I donate money to do not hold a meeting to question me about whether or not I’ve given enough money to them. And as a counter example, a charity I donate to regularly calls and asks me to up my donation, and when I say no, they suggest upping it by a smaller amount. 1
Scott Lloyd Posted November 9, 2021 Posted November 9, 2021 I submit that purportedly faithful members who regard tithing as just a “donation to charity” are viewing it wrong. It is a commandment from God. One Church leader I recall characterized it as “discharging a debt to the Lord.” 4
Calm Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 44 minutes ago, JustAnAustralian said: And as a counter example, a charity I donate to regularly calls and asks me to up my donation, and when I say no, they suggest upping it by a smaller amount. I donated almost 20 years ago to one charity and then I heard the people calling weren’t volunteers, but a company that gets paid to fundraiser. I now tell everyone I don’t give to phone requests. I told the first group to take me off their list multiple times. Hasn’t worked yet. Twice a year they try again. 1
Popular Post Calm Posted November 10, 2021 Popular Post Posted November 10, 2021 31 minutes ago, Scott Lloyd said: I submit that purportedly faithful members who regard tithing as just a “donation to charity” are viewing it wrong. It is a commandment from God. One Church leader I recall characterized it as “discharging a debt to the Lord.” Or as paying for a service, measuring how much they give in comparison to how much they get from the Church. Those are strange approaches to me. I can see viewing fast offerings, mission funds, etc. as donations, but tithing is in another class. Though understandable there is some confusion over the charity perception when we get to deduct it from our taxes because legally it is a donation and the Church works hard to keep it so (how they handle mission funding, for example). 5
Scott Lloyd Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 (edited) 1 hour ago, Calm said: Or as paying for a service, measuring how much they give in comparison to how much they get from the Church. Those are strange approaches to me. I can see viewing fast offerings, mission funds, etc. as donations, but tithing is in another class. Though understandable there is some confusion over the charity perception when we get to deduct it from our taxes because legally it is a donation and the Church works hard to keep it so (how they handle mission funding, for example). In a sense (legal, governmental, non-ecclesiastical), it IS a charity. That’s why I used the modifier “just” when I said faithful Church members should not regard it as “just a donation to charity.” Edited November 10, 2021 by Scott Lloyd
Rain Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 5 hours ago, Scott Lloyd said: You’re entitled to your choice, of course. But the handbook does say “all members,” hence my comment about whether it is optional. It doesn't just say "all members". It says "All members should attend tithing settlement to make sure their contribution records are correct and to declare to the bishop their status as tithe payers." Since I 1. make sure the records are correct and 2. already declared my status to the bishop by email then I feel fine about not attending. 2
Rain Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 2 hours ago, 2BizE said: I really like how you purposefully analyzed your desires and chose an option that was most meaningful for you. Thank you.
Scott Lloyd Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 1 hour ago, Rain said: It doesn't just say "all members". It says "All members should attend tithing settlement to make sure their contribution records are correct and to declare to the bishop their status as tithe payers." Since I 1. make sure the records are correct and 2. already declared my status to the bishop by email then I feel fine about not attending. As I said, I’m not interested in second-guessing your individual choice; it’s none of my business. But I read the handbook entry as saying that tithing settlement is the designated means for “all members” to ensure the correctness of their tithing records and declare their status as tithe payers. The phrasing is pretty clear. Maybe someday the procedure will change, but for now, it says what it says.
Scott Lloyd Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 3 hours ago, Calm said: I donated almost 20 years ago to one charity and then I heard the people calling weren’t volunteers, but a company that gets paid to fundraiser. I now tell everyone I don’t give to phone requests. I told the first group to take me off their list multiple times. Hasn’t worked yet. Twice a year they try again. It takes a lot of brass to be a fundraiser. I’m glad we are no longer obliged to take on that role for BSA. 1
Calm Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 I really like how it was done in Canada and it worked pretty well. Every spring we would sell daffodils for a couple of bucks or so. Think it was for heart association. It was something to look forward to even, no one was making money besides the flower growers I am guessing, at least the ones selling them were unpaid volunteers. I had something to offer so it wasn’t just trying to convince them to trust the money was going to a good cause. Very win win. Especially if my 4 year old daughter went along. Sold them all out on those days.
Rain Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 2 hours ago, Scott Lloyd said: As I said, I’m not interested in second-guessing your individual choice; it’s none of my business. It doesn't feel like you are trying to second guess my choices. It feels like you are trying to say I'm wrong because you keep presenting the same evidence as if I didn't understand what it says. 2 hours ago, Scott Lloyd said: But I read the handbook entry as saying that tithing settlement is the designated means for “all members” to ensure the correctness of their tithing records and declare their status as tithe payers. The phrasing is pretty clear. Maybe someday the procedure will change, but for now, it says what it says. 2
Stargazer Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 On 11/9/2021 at 5:29 AM, kimpearson said: Any bishop has pretty much total access to ward members offerings 24/7 through the internet portal. If a bishop had true concerns about a members tithing status, he could see that long before tithing settlement. All your member information and your family membership information is available to you online. It could be set up for you to indicate your tithing status online. But as many have opined, there is this nostalgic feeling for enough members, that the tradition continues. My experience is that many of the younger generation are just emailing or texting their tithing status to the bishop. Yes, the bishop has total access to donation amounts. But there's no way he can reliably determine if someone is a full- or part-tither. And he needs to report. So he asks. Gives the member the opportunity to stand proud with a forthright "Full!" I know many members are annoyed with tithing settlement, but I love it! Of course, some people think I'm cracked, anyway, so maybe that's it. I also love giving talks, and I've now managed to weasel my way into being asked to speak with high council members on their once a month forays into the wards (my nephew is a HC member, so it wasn't hard). IMHO, it's fine to declare via email. But it's important for the bishop to be involved with his ward members as a minister, and for some members this is one of their few opportunities. And keep in mind that the declaration is an "Ananias and Sapphira" moment! 2
Stargazer Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 15 hours ago, The Nehor said: It is easier than it used to be before the data was all easily recorded online. I remember as a ward clerk in the early 2000s trying to distribute paper copies of everything. Ugh! The thing I am still driven nuts by is the person who brings all their donations in cash at Tithing Settlement day. Usually the donations from the day are already processed and it is almost always the last week and they worriedly ask if it will be processed in time because they need it to be for tax purposes so we get to do it again and I hate having that much cash in one place. There is a person like this in every ward I have been a clerk in. You should have been the finance clerk in my old ward when one brother, who had a rather hostile attitude towards federal reserve notes, decided to top up his tithing for the year at tithing settlement by bringing in a couple of gold coins to donate. This was about 25 years ago, and I only heard about it because he very proudly told me what he had done. I can only imagine what the bishop and finance clerk had to do to get this sorted out with headquarters. I don't think he did this on the 31st, though.
Stargazer Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 (edited) 10 hours ago, 2BizE said: I have transitioned away from tithing settlement. I think it is a relic of the past and of little value. Other charities I donate money to do not hold a meeting to question me about whether or not I’ve given enough money to them. They are simply grateful. The only way I know if to get this old structure to disappear is to no longer support it. The "other charities" do not have a Biblical mandate and divine authority connected with them. 10 hours ago, 2BizE said: Tithing is discussed during temple recommend interviews anyway. Yes, every other year, not annually, as mentioned in DC 119:4 - "...one-tenth of all their interest annually..." And there is the principle of personal responsibility when it comes to "return and report". The bishop has to report tithing faithfulness in his ward to SLC annually. How else is he to do it other than to ask? Of course, for most members he has to guess anyway, since most members avoid TS like the plague for one reason or another. Edited November 10, 2021 by Stargazer 2
MustardSeed Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 I have one opinion on tithing- Mind my own business.
Stargazer Posted November 10, 2021 Posted November 10, 2021 1 hour ago, MustardSeed said: I have one opinion on tithing- Mind my own business. Of course. So should we all. But when someone brings up their opinion on some aspect of it in a public forum, inviting comments, it becomes a matter for discussion. 1
Recommended Posts