Jump to content
Seriously No Politics ×

All Activity

This stream auto-updates

  1. Past hour
  2. You say: Is there really no way to make this work? And if not, what would I do? And is there really no one else here who has questions about the historicity of the Book of Mormon? The LDS will talk with you about the Book of Mormon. I see you haven't looked in since Saturday. If you ever see this, I would urge you to quit pretending to be a nincompoop. That guy you made up was pathetic. Come back, use a different name if you want, although we would forgive and forget the stupid charade if you want to admit it. This is Social Hall. It is more for personal issues than the more popular and sometimes doctrinal forum which is called General Discussions. The LDS, good folk that they are, assumed the best about ManyHobbies, and didn't question the hokey scenario. They were trying to help ManyHobbies. This is why you, who is not ManyHobbies, never managed to talk about the subject you came here to discuss! I am not LDS, and I don't know much about the Book of Mormon. I have read a few pages, and disbelieve because I have another religion. I am forthrightly Catholic here, but don't talk much about what is wrong with the LDS. Why? They have to like us before they can believe us. We have to at least like them and find areas of common ground which are plenty if we look. Its about love. We cannot evangelize those we don't love. I could sooner believe that you were a misguided young Catholic than a ridiculous fallen away Mormon! Tell them why you are a happy Catholic or Evangelical. I have an assumption about you, not ManyHobbies. I think you, not ManyHobbies, might have genuinely sincere motives to disabuse the LDS of what you and I both perceive to be an inaccurate view of us "Gentiles". Maybe you read about the spies Moses sent into Israel and justified not revealing who you really are. I would excuse that, even while thinking it was unwise. That makes you into someone who is better than a straight out liar. Be yourself if you come back. The LDS and others were trying to help ManyHobbies. I have a genuine concern for you. God bless you. Rory
  3. Today
  4. Everything? If so, then the Bible contradicts itself. "To him that overcometh will I give to eat of the hidden manna, and will give him a white stone, and in the stone a new name written, which no man knoweth saving he that receiveth it." (Revelation 2:17)
  5. There is no such distinction made for ontological equality in Revelation 3:21 because none is necessary, because the Bible already teaches that we are all the same "kind" of being as God elsewhere (Acts 17:28-29, where it teaches we are all the very génos of God).
  6. You got a point there.
  7. It appears you really like "the lifestyle" so much that you have considered lying to the Latter-day Saint faculty, staff, and students at BYU. Where is your integrity? Be a man and live "the lifestyle". Does "the lifestyle" include lying? I have more respect for a truth telling drunk than for lying so that you aren't pressured to drink. Maybe I am cynical but I say the truth. I have wondered if you are lying to us. There are no possible consequences here. Why should we believe someone who entertains lying where there could be great consequences?
  8. As a matter of fact, it’s been the doctrine of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints since 1832 that the inheritors of the Telestial Kingdom of glory will be blessed to enjoy the immediate personal presence of the Lord Jesus Christ. 76 These are they who receive of his glory, but not of his fulness. 77 These are they who receive of the presence of the Son, but not of the fulness of the Father. (Doctrine and Covenants 76)
  9. I strongly disagree. Jesus has a very strong secrecy theme in Mark. Jesus silences the demons from uttering His secret identity (Mark 1:34; 3:11–12), tells people who are healed not to tell anyone about it (Mark 1:44–45; 7:35–37), speaks in parables in public so that people won’t understand what he's teaching (Mark 4:11–12), so even to the degree that His own disciples do not understand who he is (Mark 4:41). You are misapplying Matthew 10:27, as it is out of context, Matthew 10:26-28 is about courage in the face of persecution. It was the custom of the Jews to whisper in the ear of their disciples what they were to pronounce aloud to others. Their houses were low and flat-roofed, they sometimes preached from there. He's saying be bold about the gospel "And fear not them that kill the body" for indeed their teaching will at length cost them their lives. If Matthew 10:27 meant "share every single private thing with the public," then Jesus directly violated His own rule later in Matthew 17:9 "Tell no one the vision..." And before that he said in Matthew 7:6, “Give not that which is holy unto the dogs, neither cast ye your pearls before swine, lest they trample them under their feet, and turn again and rend you.” As Early Christian writers understood it to mean there were unpublished secret teachings and sacred rites (Disciplina Arcani) that were never written in public scripture and were strictly reserved for the initiated. “Nothing is more difficult, my brethren, than to reason concerning the truth in the presence of a mixed multitude of people. For that which is may not be spoken to all as it is, on account of those who hear wickedly and treacherously; yet it is not proper to deceive, on account of those who desire to hear the truth sincerely. What, then, shall he do who has to address a mixed multitude? Shall he conceal what is true? How, then, shall he instruct those who are worthy? But if he set forth pure truth to those who do not desire to obtain salvation, he does injury to Him by whom he has been sent, and from whom he has received commandment not to throw the pearls of His words before swine and dogs, who, striving against them with arguments and sophisms, roll them in the mud of carnal understanding, and by their barkings and base answers break and weary the preachers of God’s word. Wherefore I also, for the most part, by using a certain circumlocution, endeavour to avoid publishing the chief knowledge concerning the Supreme Divinity to unworthy ears." (Clementine Recognitions 3:1) Clement of Alexandria (200 AD) explicitly wrote that Jesus "did not disclose to the many what did not belong to the many" and that "secret things are entrusted to speech, not to writing" (Stromata 1.1). Origen (248 AD) openly defended Christianity’s distinction between public teachings and "deeper mysteries" reserved for the mature (Against Celsus 1.7, 3.60). And Basil the Great (300 AD) stated plainly that the Apostles passed down sacred rites and words "in a mystery" that were "guarded in silence" because "the uninitiated are not permitted to look upon them" (On the Holy Spirit 27.66). Early Christians didn't invent these ideas, they inherited it straight from Jesus, Paul, and the Hebrew Temple. Hebrews 5 proves higher truths were actively withheld and not "publicly available." Look at what the author of Hebrews actually does, he lists the public basics as repentance, faith, baptisms, laying on of hands, resurrection, and judgment (Hebrews 6:1–2) and explicitly stops explaining what is beyond these as his readers were not ready to receive it (Hebrews 5:11). If that knowledge were meant to be openly available to everyone, he would have written it all right there in the letter. I'm not invoking any pagan ideas here, God Himself instituted these things in the Jerusalem Temple. The Temple was built on progressive circles and boundaries (Outer Court, Holy Place, Holy of Holies) with ordinances performed strictly out of public view by an ordained priesthood. Numbers 4 as prime biblical evidence that the sacred things of the Temple were strictly concealed even from the wider Levitical workforce, let alone the general public. Veiling the sacred objects (Numbers 4:5–15) and a strict prohibition on looking (Numbers 4:20) full of esoteric temple rites later suppressed or obscured by Second Temple reformers (Numbers 6:22–27). Ancient Israel had an exoteric (public) religion governed by the Law of Moses and the Deuteronomists, and an esoteric (secret) religion preserved by the high priesthood in the Holy of Holies. Its rituals were never written down in detail for the public because they were transmitted orally from priest to priest. Jesus and the earliest Christians saw themselves as restoring this lost, secret First Temple priesthood. When Jesus speaks of the "mysteries of the kingdom" (Mark 4:11), He is operating squarely within the temple tradition. "Sacred, not secret" is an LDS slogan too, but not a biblical concept. Throughout Scripture, what is truly sacred (set apart) is guarded from the unprepared, not out of elitism, but because holy things require preparation and readiness to receive. We also know Masonry was influenced by the Royal Society and transformed the Masonry Guilds into Speculative Freemasonry, infusing the guilds with older Solomonic temple lore and Christian symbolism. The claim therefore is it has a common ancestor, Solomon’s Temple and Early Christianity. Freemasonry itself traces its ritual legends directly to Solomon’s Temple and early Christian liturgy preserved very similar symbolic gestures, washings, anointings, sacred vestments, and handclasps (dexiosis, the sacred right-hand clasp of fellowship and resurrection Galatians 2:9). The LDS version strips away Masonic legends and center the entire Endowment on Christ, the Creation, the Fall, and the Atonement. Sacred garments, ritual washings and anointings, new names, sacred handclasps, and dramatic reenactments of creation and ascension into God's presence predate modern Freemasonry by millennia. In all the ancient Near Eastern royal resurrection dramas of the kings, from Egypt to Mesopotamia, and especially Israel, and by extension Christianity. Exodus 28–29 is the Israelite priestly garments and consecration, in the Dead Sea Scrolls and in early Christian baptismal and temple-style liturgies (such as those described by Cyril of Jerusalem in the 4th century).
  10. Dwell with Jesus. Do you see the terrestrials living with Him? I believe Paul is describing the complete, mature presence and moral character of God within a human life, rather than absorbing God's infinite, divine essence. Revelation 3:21 distinguishes between delegated authority (sharing in Christ's victory and governance) and ontological equality (becoming the same divine species as God). Sitting on a king's throne symbolizes co-regency and honor granted by grace, not a transformation into the king's actual nature. The 24 Elders are also on thrones but they are not Gods. There is doubt about Athanasius even being the author. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Athanasian_Creed See “Did Constantine Or the Church Invent the Trinity? What History Shows” https://truthstodiefor.com/did-constantine-or-the-church-invent-the-trinity/ There is doubt about Athanasius even being the author. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Athanasian_Creed Many modern Christians, including some Anglicans, Methodists, and Reformed believers, question whether eternal salvation truly depends on understanding and affirming dense, technical definitions of the Trinity rather than simple trust in Jesus Christ. Consequently, many churches have dropped it from public worship. But at least it affirms one God, not three in the Godhead as is found in LDS theology.
  11. Yesterday
  12. It is good to see you, Ol' Timer! It seems to me that some of the more prolific and combative among us have been dropping off. Some of them seemed as old as me or older. Maybe they just got tired of it too? I am 70 years old now and writing anything serious is wearying and unsatisfying lately. I will undoubtedly lurk about like you. Say howdy to old customers when they pop in. Let a few people know I am still alive. Stick to Social Hall. Let's agree not to be total strangers around here! Take care, Poptart. Regards, Rory
  13. Masonry influenced the LDS Church with its special oaths, handshakes, and garments. Much of this is now public knowledge.
  14. Jesus instructed His disciples to broadcast everything He told them in private: "What I tell you in the dark, say in the light, and what you hear whispered, proclaim on the housetops" (Matthew 10:27). Private explanations to the Twelve were for the purpose of clarification and training so they could later preach those exact truths publicly, not so they could hoard esoteric knowledge. While pagan cults used teleios to mean "initiated," in standard Greek and the Septuagint (the Greek Old Testament), it simply means "mature," "full-grown," or "complete." The difference between an "outsider" and an "insider" in Mark 4 is not secret knowledge, but faith and receptivity to Jesus. Likewise, the difference between a "babe" and the "mature" in Hebrews 5 is not secret initiation, but spiritual diligence and growth in understanding the publicly available Word of God. The Christian faith is sacred, not secret.
  15. Last week
  16. It hasn't been easy, had a few friends go back to their home country despite being US citizens. Irony, their standard of living went up by quite a bit. I see myself following in their footsteps in a few years, me and mine have never been treated well by the greater mainland culture. I don't see it improving either, is what it is..
  17. I'm glad to see you. I've been worried about you.
  18. I still wander in here from time to time, mostly to lurk. I gave up on engaging most English speaking places a while ago now, Covid was it for me, besides having to use ublock/privacy apps it's just too much. I've had a presence here for a while, looking at it now this board looks quite sane. I'm actually quite pleased, compared to a lot of other places there's still civility here and a shared reality.
  19. I misspoke about King Herod sending them with gifts to find the baby Jesus. Thanks for better clarification Calm. I do remember now a story much like these scriptures I looked up. https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Matthew 2&version=KJV
  20. About 50 years ago when I was the ward finance clerk, before computers, the Bishop let my wife type out the Sunday donations forms(in triplicate) each week. She was a faster and better typist than me.
  21. And it’s pretty well established that legal protections increase family stability. Removes sources of conflict and anxiety for both adults and children. People are going to poly whether it is recognized or not, so for the best interest of the children involved, it seems logical to establish legal protections to maximize what stability there is. Gone are the days social stigma was enough to keep people in even in the most abusive marriages. Never was strong enough to keep men that faithful. Fear of poverty, losing rights to their children worked for women as long as they were treated as children themselves, property of either their father or husband. Want to promote so called traditional marriage (labeling it traditional just because there’s a man and woman involved doesn’t make sense to me since culture and technology has pretty much changed so much of the other characteristics)? Makes more sense to approach it by removing the biggest contributors to instability, especially financial stress. Provide counseling and education to lower divorce rates. Remove the need for any parent to be long absent from their home just so they can get a decent paying job or even if living together, not interacting with each other because needing to work long hours to survive. (There is also the imo foolish setup of school hours that works more as babysitting than maximizing learning.) Remove marriage penalties that lower rates of assistance or raises taxes if persons from lower income levels gets married. Let people be confident they will be able to afford a stable, safe home for their family, that they will have time off from work for pregnancy if necessary and paternity leave plus assurance they can get effective medical care for themselves and their children and that they will be able to feed and care for all their children no matter what happens and they will likely have more. If you want a parent in the home raising children, then make it possible to live on one income. Highly unlikely pointing at others, insisting those people must not be allowed to marry or anything similar to it and no way should the community help them with babies and children they shouldn’t have had in the first place (even if abortion was also removed as a choice) is somehow magically going to make other people want to cuddle up in male-female pairs with government approval and pop kids out. https://community.lawschool.cornell.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Sheff-et-al.-final.pdf https://vanierinstitute.ca/families-count-2024/polyamorous-families-have-broadened-family-law/ Create a family friendly, family supportive environment rather than a community where parents feel they are walking a tight rope. https://ideas.repec.org/a/spr/eurpop/v29y2013i4d10.1007_s10680-013-9295-4.html https://www.researchgate.net/publication/304020356_The_Influence_of_Family_Policies_on_Fertility_in_France_Lessons_from_the_Past_and_Prospects_for_the_Future https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6286255/
  22. So I was wrong…it wasn’t a writer taking liberty with the story to make it more dramatic. It is appropriate to the story, one of the many, apparently, misinterpretations by the Herdsmen children. Got this from Chat: In answer to “who is the king they think gave the presents”:
  23. Because that is a creative interpretation. The actual scriptures identify them as coming from the treasure chests of the magi, nothing about Herod giving gifts. Now Herod could have given them stuff they then added to their treasure chests or “their” could have meant in their stewardship. That Herod gave the chests for them to carry. But a more natural interpretation imo you don’t have to squint hard and pencil in words to read between the lines to see is they brought their own treasures to worship the child. I double-checked my memory. Matthew appears to be the only reference to that.
  24. Decent work as a mainstream Protestant devotional analyzing Matthew 15:21–28. But for your purposes, this specific devotional could be a polemical subtext using a Protestant interpretation of grace and exclusivity to implicitly critique LDS theology or culture. As non-LDS in LDS spaces frequently share Protestant devotionals to contrast "Biblical Christianity" with what they view as LDS errors. (Not that you shouldn't tell us what you think is meaningful to you, just beware that I feel a certain "Trojan horse" approach to your style of apologetics, so forgive me if I sometimes falsely say so.) In Part 2, the author criticizes the disciples for acting like they were upgraded to "Jesus class" while looking down on outsiders, citing Ephesians 2:14 "destroyed the barrier, the dividing wall of hostility". Critics often argue that LDS temples, the priesthood, or the concept of there being the "one true church" creates an elitist "in-group" vs. "out-group" barrier that contradicts New Testament grace. It heavily emphasizes undeserved favor (grace) and states that the woman had no "rights and privileges" yet was accepted purely through her recognition of Jesus. Another critique of LDS theology is that Latter-day Saints rely on obedience, ordinances, and personal worthiness to "earn" salvation, rather than relying solely on Christ's grace. "Great faith is relying solely on Jesus and no one, nowhere, and nothing else" in Part 4, could be a subtle jab at LDS reliance on living prophets, temples, and an institutional church as ones and wheres. The story highlights an outsider bypassing religious gatekeepers (the disciples who wanted to send her away) and going straight to Jesus. Critics use this narrative framework to argue that individuals do not need an institutional priesthood to access Christ. Notice that the Canaanite woman in Matthew 15 received physical healing as an act of mercy available to outsiders described as "crumbs from the table". However, immediately following this in Matthew 16-18, Jesus shifts focus exclusively to His inner circle, the Keys of the Kingdom (Matt. 16:19), ascending the Mount of Transfiguration for an endowment with only three apostles and commanding strict secrecy (Matt. 17:1-9), and conferring binding priesthood authority upon the Twelve (Matt. 18:18). Protestant devotionals often flattens God’s mercy and grace as freely extended to all (like the Canaanite woman), ignoring instances of covenants, keys, and temple mysteries entrusted progressively to initiated stewards who are prepared to bear them. If the Canaanite woman highlights how freely Christ extends mercy to outsiders, that’s true. What it leaves out is what Jesus does after to establish strict priesthood boundaries, secret teachings, and temple-style initiation for His inner circle. Jesus did not teach everything openly to the public. He explicitly told His inner circle, "To you has been given the secret [musterion] of the kingdom of God, but for those outside everything is in parables" (Mark 4:11). Paul continues this exact framework, distinguishing between spiritual "babes" who only receive elementary principles (Hebrews 5:12–6:2) and the mature (teleios, "complete/initiated"). "We speak wisdom among them that are perfect [teleios]... we speak the wisdom of God in a mystery [musterion], even the hidden [apokekrymmenen] wisdom, which God ordained before the world unto our glory" (1 Corinthians 2:6-7). In the first-century world, musterion and teleios were standard terms for sacred initiation into guarded rites not preached to the general public. Found throughout scripture. Jesus' endowment in 2 Peter 1:16-18, Peter writes, "We were eyewitnesses of His majesty... when we were with Him on the holy mountain." The Greek word Peter chooses for "eyewitnesses" is epoptai, the technical term used in ancient sacred rites for initiates admitted to the highest grade. Grace and mercy are freely offered to everyone who comes to Christ, just like the Canaanite woman. But the New Testament makes it clear that priesthood keys and the higher mysteries of God belong to entrusted and faithful stewards.
  25. It is actually very popular amongst LDS. I don’t think it is reasonable. I really think if God felt strongly about it He should have just said so instead of doing a bit of childish winking and hinting about it.
  26. Not something I am familiar with either. I am presuming the movie may indicate, that has the Magi travelled through Jerusalem on the way to Bethel. Herod asked for the gifts to be given. Unless there is any basis for this, then it may have been added to the script. 🤔
  27. Sounds like a good movie! Does it say that in the bible? I've never heard that either.
  28. Dan just put out a short video promoting two books, and one of them is the Mormonism in Five Minutes book I posted about above. And he's doing a giveaway the Mormonism book in case anyone wants to try for it Here's the link to the video: Two new books & a giveaway! #maklelan3558
  29. No, I don’t. Thank you for your candor. I didn't ask if the construction/interpretation of the is popular, but rather if it is reasonable. Thanks, -Smac
  1. Load more activity
×
×
  • Create New...