ttribe Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 2 minutes ago, Mystery Meat said: I don't get the need to talk about issues with the church openly and with other people. I have my issues, questions and concerns as do most other people. But for some, negativity/drama truly is like oxygen. Couldn't survive without it. And yet, you come to a website and do exactly that. 2
stemelbow Posted April 28, 2016 Author Posted April 28, 2016 1 minute ago, Mystery Meat said: I don't get the need to talk about issues with the church openly and with other people. I have my issues, questions and concerns as do most other people. But for some, negativity/drama truly is like oxygen. Couldn't survive without it. I don't think my wife would like it if someone dismissed her perspectives as nothing but negativity/drama. It's odd you don't get other people's desires to discuss the Church openly when we often do that here. I realize many aren't open about their feelings about the Church, mostly because their instinct is to defend and protect, but in a way that can be seen as discussing openly. Their true instinct and feeling is revealed. 2
Mystery Meat Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 Just now, ttribe said: And yet, you come to a website and do exactly that. No I don't. I don't come here to talk negatively about the church. I come to defend the Church and its leaders against unscrupulous attacks, half-truths, and to offer a faithful perspective.
ttribe Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 1 minute ago, Mystery Meat said: No I don't. I don't come here to talk negatively about the church. I come to defend the Church and its leaders against unscrupulous attacks, half-truths, and to offer a faithful perspective. Okay.
Mystery Meat Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 2 minutes ago, stemelbow said: I don't think my wife would like it if someone dismissed her perspectives as nothing but negativity/drama. It's odd you don't get other people's desires to discuss the Church openly when we often do that here. I realize many aren't open about their feelings about the Church, mostly because their instinct is to defend and protect, but in a way that can be seen as discussing openly. Their true instinct and feeling is revealed. CFR that I have ever come here to discuss the Church negatively.
Mystery Meat Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 Just now, ttribe said: Okay. I am glad we agree.
stemelbow Posted April 28, 2016 Author Posted April 28, 2016 5 minutes ago, Mystery Meat said: No I don't. I don't come here to talk negatively about the church. I come to defend the Church and its leaders against unscrupulous attacks, half-truths, and to offer a faithful perspective. Why is openly discussing the Church thought to be negatively talking about the Church, as if such talking is unfairly done? That's an odd mindset to me. 3
ttribe Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 3 minutes ago, Mystery Meat said: CFR that I have ever come here to discuss the Church negatively. Relax. The part I bolded in my previous response says nothing about discussing the Church "negatively." It says " talk about issues with the church openly and with other people." That's a pretty broad statement. Perhaps you can now recognize how both me and stem might have interpreted your statement less strictly than you intended. And, good grief, this CFR thing gets more abuse on this board than just about anything else.
stemelbow Posted April 28, 2016 Author Posted April 28, 2016 6 minutes ago, Mystery Meat said: CFR that I have ever come here to discuss the Church negatively. CFR that I said anything about you coming here to discuss the Church negatively. I thought your initial statement was suggesting you don't get why people want to discuss the Church openly. I think you meant that to be negatively, but I can't quite tell. 1
Mystery Meat Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 (edited) 7 minutes ago, stemelbow said: CFR that I said anything about you coming here to discuss the Church negatively. I thought your initial statement was suggesting you don't get why people want to discuss the Church openly. I think you meant that to be negatively, but I can't quite tell. That's fair, and I apologize for the miscommunication. Based on how you described the group in which your wife will be participating it doesn't sound like it is going to be a place where much positivity will be shared. Instead it seems like a place where perceived negative aspects of the church are discussed, obsessed over, and focused on. I think such a need is impossible for me to understand or relate to. I also think it is a terrible atmosphere to build a testimony or strengthen faith and continued exposure won't lead anywhere good. Edited April 28, 2016 by Mystery Meat
stemelbow Posted April 28, 2016 Author Posted April 28, 2016 2 minutes ago, Mystery Meat said: That's fair, and I apologize for the miscommunication. Based on how you described the group in which your wife will be participating it doesn't sound like it is going to be a place where much positivity will be shared. Instead it seems like a place where perceived negative aspects of the church are discussed, obsessed over, and focused on. I think such a need is impossible for me to understand or relate to. I also think it is a terrible atmosphere to build a testimony or strengthen faith and continued exposure won't lead anywhere good. that's odd, openly discussing issues, feelings and thoughts seem to suggest negativity to you. I imagine tons of positivity is discussed. They laugh and have fun, or at least it sounds like they do. Sure they seem to discuss issues they have with the Church, but that doesn't necessarily mean negative atmosphere. 1
ttribe Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 4 minutes ago, stemelbow said: that's odd, openly discussing issues, feelings and thoughts seem to suggest negativity to you. I imagine tons of positivity is discussed. They laugh and have fun, or at least it sounds like they do. Sure they seem to discuss issues they have with the Church, but that doesn't necessarily mean negative atmosphere. Given what you know of the dynamics on this board, the kind of responses you are getting can't be surprising; are they? 1
Mystery Meat Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 5 minutes ago, stemelbow said: that's odd, openly discussing issues, feelings and thoughts seem to suggest negativity to you. I imagine tons of positivity is discussed. They laugh and have fun, or at least it sounds like they do. Sure they seem to discuss issues they have with the Church, but that doesn't necessarily mean negative atmosphere. If so, then more power to them. But based on what you have described I am skeptical that when it comes to their discussions about the Church that it will be an uplifting experience. Other components of their meetings may in fact be.
smac97 Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 (edited) On 4/28/2016 at 9:31 AM, stemelbow said: Interesting perspective. I personally can't see discussing doctrines and history of the Church as the same as discussing a person and in so doing harping on someone's weakness. I was not speaking of something as innocuous as merely "discussing doctrines and history of the Church." You seem to be painting a much more critical picture: "My wife has started meeting with some other ladies (how sexist of them) to talk about different things about life including their issues with the Church." "As a result she has reported some pretty harsh things being said about the Church by some, but it seems everyone's taking it just fine." "She opposes the idea, much like myself, that we should for some reason shut people out who are assertive or proselytizing in their efforts against the Church, or at least shut them out when they do so." "She kind wants out of the Church." "Of course she has some negative ideas about the Church." "I think it's possible in the near future she may find herself out of the church." "She's pretty bored with Church generally, and finds the environment a little inhospitable for her." Continuing with my perspective, here's how the above statements would turn out: "My wife has started meeting with some other ladies (how sexist of them) to talk about different things about life including their issues with their husbands." "As a result she has reported some pretty harsh things being said about their husbands by some, but it seems everyone's taking it just fine." "She opposes the idea, much like myself, that we should for some reason shut people out who are assertive or proselytizing in their efforts against their husbands, or at least shut them out when they do so." "She kind wants out of the her marriage to me." "Of course she has some negative ideas about me." "I think it's possible in the near future she may find herself out of our marriage." "She's pretty bored with our marriage generally, and finds the environment a little inhospitable for her." If I was having difficulties with my wife, and if my wife proposed to meet regularly with other women who having problems with their husbands, and if these meetings became a venue for these women to complaint about and criticize and find fault with their husbands, then I would be very distressed and concerned. I would feel this way because my marriage is important to me. I believe it has eternal significance. I have made covenants pertaining to my marriage. I owe my wife and our marriage my allegiance. I work hard to maintain my marital relationship. So a hypothetical group gripefest which, I think, is designed to foster and encourage faultfinding and complaining (I haven't seen you mention anything about the women in this group praying together, reading scriptures, studying out of "the best books," or any other efforts to foster faith and perseverance in their relationships with the Church). Such a hypothetical group would appear to be designed to damage or destroy marital relationships, not strengthen and build them up. For me, this does not look like even a judgment call. It's not a "reasonable minds can disagree" about the most likely outcome of these meetings. I think that most likely outcome is pretty darn obvious. Quote The Church's teachings and ideas promoted through church should be open to discuss. Of course we should be discussing the Church's teachings. But we should do so with faith and hope. By searching the scriptures, by seeking inspiration through study and prayer and temple worship and humility and patience. None of us are percipient witnesses to the form and content of the meetings you are describing, but what you are describing seems pretty bleak. We all know the things we can do to study and grow in faith in and knowledge and understanding of the Restored Gospel. From what you are describing, those things aren't being done. Quote But instead we treat her like she needs to be protected from the market place of ideas lest, if we allowed open thought and discussion, someone tries to damage her. That seems fearful. Nope. I strongly encourage Latter-day Saints to adhere to the Lord's admonition in D&C 109:7: "And as all have not faith, seek ye diligently and teach one another words of wisdom; yea, seek ye out of the best books words of wisdom, seek learning even by study and also by faith." I have not, and do no, advocate "fear." I advocate faith and study and the Spirit as alternatives to faultfinding and resentment and doubt. Thanks, -Smac Edited April 28, 2016 by smac97 2
Garden Girl Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 12 minutes ago, Mystery Meat said: That's fair, and I apologize for the miscommunication. Based on how you described the group in which your wife will be participating it doesn't sound like it is going to be a place where much positivity will be shared. Instead it seems like a place where perceived negative aspects of the church are discussed, obsessed over, and focused on. I think such a need is impossible for me to understand or relate to. I also think it is a terrible atmosphere to build a testimony or strengthen faith and continued exposure won't lead anywhere good. I tend to think that this will be the ultimate result, considering the group consists of exLDS and less active (and active but questioning members such as your wife) vs active and believing LDS... that is if there are more in number of the ex-less-questioning than the believing... and that would not normally strengthen a wavering member. GG
Jeanne Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 2 hours ago, stemelbow said: I see I didn't say enough about my take. And I admit that priesthood holder comment was tongue in cheek. I guess one of the ladies had her husband try and force her to not talk openly and not talk to ex-LDS by alluding to his priesthood power. I wouldn't have any desire to coerce my wife to stop something. Here's my take: I like it. As a result she has reported some pretty harsh things being said about the Church by some, but it seems everyone's taking it just fine. She opposes the idea, much like myself, that we should for some reason shut people out who are assertive or proselytizing in their efforts against the Church, or at least shut them out when they do so. She wants to hear and reason with people. Anyway, she's in a place that is different from me in a sense. She kind wants out of the Church. I want in. I could see her leaving, but the pull to stay is really strong. I want the best for her and for her to be happy. I encourage her to make her own path. If she leaves, she leaves. She might be stronger in the long run because of it. After all, we're supposed to kind of let the process of making weak things become strong to us, no? I don't fear truth and letting people run their course, on their own terms. But in light of the recent suggestion to disconnect from proselytizing and assertive comments opposing the Church, I figure I'd explore further how that would work. You are wonderful. You want her to be happy and that is so important. If she communicates with you, you are so far ahead of a lot of marriages! She doesn't need your permission but loves it like a friend. To let her come to conclusions on her own is more of a blessing than you may realize. IMO, I think you will both end up on the same page because you are important to eachother.
CA Steve Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 So how is this informal get together of women discussing Church issues significantly different from what goes on here on this board every day? 2
stemelbow Posted April 28, 2016 Author Posted April 28, 2016 20 minutes ago, Mystery Meat said: If so, then more power to them. But based on what you have described I am skeptical that when it comes to their discussions about the Church that it will be an uplifting experience. Other components of their meetings may in fact be. I disagree that discussing the issues or problems these ladies have with the Church is unproductive and not uplifting. The Church is not perfect and we should be wise enough to consider, reconsider and even analyze the church and it's many teachings, practices, cultural impacts, traditions and the like. I think people are more resilient than the Church leaders often give us credit for. I think truth is more important than whether the Church is behaving properly. 3
Jeanne Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 2 hours ago, Bobbieaware said: What is the motivation of these ex-LDS women, and somewhat disaffected LDS women (you euphemistically call them 'less participating'), want to "chat" about with active members? Perhaps be persuaded to come back into full fellowship with the Church? I doubt it. What is your wife's motivation to participate in this group? To help those who have lost --or are loosing -- their faith to come back to the fold? If so, one might be persuaded to not be against it. But if she's going there to join in on the negativity of these former and wavering members -- negativity that will almost surely come to pass -- I"d say she should run swiftly in the other direction. Attempting to reclaim lost sheep is good, but being ambivalent or indifferent about reclaiming the Lord's lost sheep is not so good. Some just want the affiliation and friendship believe it or not. An ex LDS woman doesn't just decide she knows it all...that she doesn't see misunderstanding from her point of view..nor does she want to take away what is important to others. For me, I just want women to understand that I am really the same. That I haven't turned into some huge monster that hates. And I remember also the women who really needed to talk..and some ex LDS are there just to listen and understand themselves better. You knowsome of us ex people can help people remain don't you??? After all, these women have minds of their own and may want to ask questions that will help them remain. I know I am not stating all this well, but women sometimes need a place of their own.
Meadowchik Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 1 hour ago, smac97 said: My wife is a wonderful person in virtually all respects. She is a joy to have in my life, and I am grateful for my relationship with her. She is not, however, utterly without flaw or defect. She has her foibles. But she is at her core a good and decent and beautiful person. If a stranger, or even perhaps some general-but-not-particularly-close acquaintance of mine, were to come to me and ask that I sit down and listen to him outline what he dislikes about my wife, what my wife's flaws were, etc., I would decline. That would not be due to my wife being perfect, but rather that it is not the place of some self-selected yahoo to presume to tell me what he dislikes about my wife (let alone presume to propose telling me such things on a regular basis). There would be no good faith in that. Even if some of the things this fellow had to say about my wife were true, I have no doubt that regular meetings with him would quickly devolve into a faultfinding gripefest, would be devoid of goodwill toward my wife or a desire to help her improve, and would not have the Spirit present. Now, if someone I knew and trusted very well came to me and, in a spirit of genuine love and concern and care for both me and my wife, advised me that he had observed a particular defect in my wife's character, or that he had information about some prior misconduct on her part, I would probably find that a bit weird and presumptuous. But if I had enough trust in the person and in his motives and competency, I would probably sit down and listen to what he had to say. But if this fellow proposed that he would like to make it a regular habit for him to come sit with me and regularly discuss and explore my wife's flaws and transgressions, well, I would not countenance that. I am not a moron. I know my wife well, far better than an outsider ever would or could. I would see no value in regularly meeting with such a person. Even if this person asked me to do it because regularly criticizing my wife would be a cathartic and helpful exercise for him, I would not do it. I think such a proposal would be profoundly unhealthy. Cancerous, even. If and when my wife develops some flaw or commits some transgression that merits discussion or correction, I would address it in the proper time and place and manner. I would meet with her. I would meet with those who have stewardship over her, people whom I trust and know have motives of concern and kindness and Christlike love for her. I would work with such persons to discern and discuss the truth of what has happened, to affect repentance if necessary, and to implement steps to ensure that the misconduct or flaw is not repeated in the future. Meeting with people who harbor malice toward my wife, and who desire to injure or destroy my relationship with her, could never be part of that process. I love my wife. She is good and decent and true. She is what she claims to be. I have a covenant relationship with her. I owe her my allegiance. I would not betray her faith and confidence by inviting and participating in discussions with people hell-bent on making me think ill of her, of harming or destroying my relationship with her. Now, having said all that, go back and re-read the foregoing paragraphs and replace the references to my wife with references to the Church. That's how I would feel about the proposal in the OP. Thanks, -Smac Interesting but church doesn't work in it, because it is ours, not yours alone. 1
Ahab Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 2 hours ago, stemelbow said: My wife has started meeting with some other ladies (how sexist of them) to talk about different things about life including their issues with the Church. They are a mix of active LDS, ex-LDS and less participating, shall we say. What is your take? should I fear the results of these meetings? Thanks for your thoughts. How is that any different than various types of people discussing things on this board? Do you think they would actively discourage men to join them in their discussions? You seem to be saying that only women are involved in those discussions, so I would wonder why it would be only women.
stemelbow Posted April 28, 2016 Author Posted April 28, 2016 15 minutes ago, smac97 said: I was not speaking of something as innocuous as merely "discussing doctrines and history of the Church." You seem to be painting a much more critical picture: "My wife has started meeting with some other ladies (how sexist of them) to talk about different things about life including their issues with the Church." "As a result she has reported some pretty harsh things being said about the Church by some, but it seems everyone's taking it just fine." "She opposes the idea, much like myself, that we should for some reason shut people out who are assertive or proselytizing in their efforts against the Church, or at least shut them out when they do so." "She kind wants out of the Church." "Of course she has some negative ideas about the Church." "I think it's possible in the near future she may find herself out of the church." "She's pretty bored with Church generally, and finds the environment a little inhospitable for her." Continuing with my perspective, here's how the above statements would turn out: "My wife has started meeting with some other ladies (how sexist of them) to talk about different things about life including their issues with their husbands." "As a result she has reported some pretty harsh things being said about their husbands by some, but it seems everyone's taking it just fine." "She opposes the idea, much like myself, that we should for some reason shut people out who are assertive or proselytizing in their efforts against their husbands, or at least shut them out when they do so." "She kind wants out of the her marriage to me." "Of course she has some negative ideas about me." "I think it's possible in the near future she may find herself out of our marriage." "She's pretty bored with our marriage generally, and finds the environment a little inhospitable for her." If I was having difficulties with my wife, and if my wife proposed to meet regularly with other women who having problems with their husbands, and if these meetings became a venue for these women to complaint about and criticize and find fault with their husbands, then I would be very distressed and concerned. I would feel this way because my marriage is important to me. I believe it has eternal significance. I have made covenants pertaining to my marriage. I owe my wife and our marriage my allegiance. I work hard to maintain my marital relationship. So a hypothetical group gripefest which, I think, is designed to foster and encourage faultfinding and complaining (I haven't seen you mention anything about the women in this group praying together, reading scriptures, studying out of "the best books," or any other efforts to foster faith and perseverance in their relationships with the Church). Such a hypothetical group would appear to be designed to damage or destroy marital relationships, not strengthen and build them up. For me, this does not look like even a judgment call. It's not a "reasonable minds can disagree" about the most likely outcome of these meetings. I think that most likely outcome is pretty darn obvious. Well I remain appreciative of your perspective even though I find your application to people or marriage to be way off course. The Church is not a relationship nor is it a frail person with whom we talk behind her back. it is a conglomeration of people, culture, tradition, teaching, history that is unique. To discuss it is to discuss ideas and feelings. It is not to hate people. it is not to fight or battle. Sure there will be, as in all cases when people discuss, negative things said about ideas and perhaps even people. While you see any notion of speaking openly about people's feelings regarding the Church to be a gripefest, designed to foster and encourage faultfinding and complaining, I see a healthy environment where ideas are shared, thoughts are encouraged, rather than beat down. But, I can see where you are coming from because your view is similar to many members views. But it feels to be bred by fear a desire to isolate and hide. 15 minutes ago, smac97 said: Of course we should be discussing the Church's teachings. But we should do so with faith and hope. By searching the scriptures, by seeking inspiration through study and prayer and temple worship and humility and patience. None of us are percipient witnesses to the form and content of the meetings you are describing, but what you are describing seems pretty bleak. We all know the things we can do to study and grow in faith in and knowledge and understanding of the Restored Gospel. From what you are describing, those things aren't being done. Nope. I strongly encourage Latter-day Saints to adhere to the Lord's admonition in D&C 109:7: "And as all have not faith, seek ye diligently and teach one another words of wisdom; yea, seek ye out of the best books words of wisdom, seek learning even by study and also by faith." I have not, and do no, advocate "fear." I advocate faith and study and the Spirit as alternatives to faultfinding and resentment and doubt. Thanks, -Smac I hear ya. Church is a splendid place for your type of discussion. It simply doesn't work for those of us who would rather go deeper.
smac97 Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 On 4/28/2016 at 10:35 AM, Meadowchik said: Interesting but church doesn't work in it, because it is ours, not yours alone. I do not understand this statement. I recognize that the Church is not mine alone. I never suggested otherwise. But my relationship with the Church is indeed mine alone, as my relationship with my wife is also mine alone. Thanks, -Smac
JulieM Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 2 hours ago, stemelbow said: My wife has started meeting with some other ladies (how sexist of them) to talk about different things about life including their issues with the Church. They are a mix of active LDS, ex-LDS and less participating, shall we say. What is your take? should I fear the results of these meetings? Thanks for your thoughts. I think it's great. She may even have some influence and insights for the exMo's I think it's completely understandable to want to discuss some things in an environment where she feels safe and can be open and honest. Many feel intimidated at church or have topics they don't dare bring up at church. 1
Johnnie Cake Posted April 28, 2016 Posted April 28, 2016 2 hours ago, stemelbow said: My wife has started meeting with some other ladies (how sexist of them) to talk about different things about life including their issues with the Church. They are a mix of active LDS, ex-LDS and less participating, shall we say. What is your take? should I fear the results of these meetings? Thanks for your thoughts. There were some ladies in our neighborhood doing this very thing...and the Bishop got wind of it and threatened church discipline if they didn't shut it down...nothing like the potential chill of male patriarchy sticking its nose into a woman's affairs to fan the flames of doubt.
Recommended Posts