Rain Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 I read about someone getting killed by a drunk driver and it brought to mind this question. I've never drunk before so I don't have any idea. Drinking impairs your thinking and driving. So why do we expect people to have someone ask for a ride if they have been drinking? When you are drinking then your brain is clear enough to know not to drive? Is there a point where someone wouldn't be capable of that choice?I'm not arguing that a drinker shouldn't be held accountable. I just don't understand the process enough to know how someone could make that choice while they are drinking if they have drunk enough to be a bad driver.
bluebell Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 I have wondered this so many times! There is no way for someone who is drunk, to be able to tell they are drunk. The only thing that makes sense is to make it illegal for people to drive after they've had any alcohol. Then the line would always be crystal clear for everyone. Of course, that would never fly because it would mean people wouldn't be able to drink socially at meals and such without always having a designated driver.
thesometimesaint Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 We've already tried legal prohibition. It didn't work all that well. So we're stuck with trying to control some of the negative impacts of drinking alcohol. If you are going to drink alcohol don't drive and if your going to drive don't drink alcohol. Call a taxi, select a designated driver before you go out drinking alcohol.
Calm Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 (edited) I like the technology of having a breath analyzer attached to the ignition...wouldn't be a bad idea for diabetics either (they are training dogs to tell their masters if they have high or low blood sugars based on the smell so I assume it is possible to use a variation on the technology, diabetics are supposed to test sugars before driving anyway...but not while driving, might as well be texting if trying to do that). I assume the same thing applies in most cases to drinking as it does to drugs....with experience you know how your body is going to react and you plan ahead on how much you will drink. And that level includes being able to refuse even if one wants another drink. Our culture has some areas that teach total indulgence though with alcohol so that isn't going to work for those who need it most. Edited April 30, 2015 by calmoriah 1
UtahTexan Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 Hog wash A person knows the risks of drinking. They know BEFORE they start drinking. There is ZERO excuse to drink and drive. As a former prosecutor, I cannot even begin to tell you the number of lives I have seen destroyed by drunk drivers. I cannot tell you how many dead bodies I have seen due to drunk drivers. NO EXCUSE. 2
bluebell Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 Hog wash A person knows the risks of drinking. They know BEFORE they start drinking. There is ZERO excuse to drink and drive. As a former prosecutor, I cannot even begin to tell you the number of lives I have seen destroyed by drunk drivers. I cannot tell you how many dead bodies I have seen due to drunk drivers. NO EXCUSE. They know that at a blood alcohol level of .07 they are law abiding citizens capable of driving home with full support of the government and society, and that at .08 they are driving drunk. What they don't know is when they have gone from .07 to .08 and that's a problem. This isn't about providing excuses. It's about recognizing the reality of the situation. There are people who drive so drunk that it's obvious. Then there are the people who were at a family BBQ with their kids and who had a few glasses of wine and then drove home in the car (with full approval of all their family members there) and were pulled over for speeding and were then arrested for DUI. It's the second group that I'm talking about.
UtahTexan Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 (edited) They know that at a blood alcohol level of .07 they are law abiding citizens capable of driving home with full support of the government and society, and that at .08 they are driving drunk. What they don't know is when they have gone from .07 to .08 and that's a problem. This isn't about providing excuses. It's about recognizing the reality of the situation. There are people who drive so drunk that it's obvious. Then there are the people who were at a family BBQ with their kids and who had a few glasses of wine and then drove home in the car (with full approval of all their family members there) and were pulled over for speeding and were then arrested for DUI. It's the second group that I'm talking about. I disagree. If you drink, you should not drive. Even one drink can slow your reaction time. But...if you think lives should be at risk...then you are right. Admittedly, I am not very objective. I was a victim of an alcoholic father and I have sen soooo much death, injury and destruction due to drunk drivers. It is one of the few crimes for which there is no excuse. If you drink. Do not drive. Easy. Edited April 29, 2015 by CountryBoy
bluebell Posted April 29, 2015 Posted April 29, 2015 I disagree. If you drink, you should not drive. Even one drink can slow your reaction time. But...if you think lives should be at risk...then you are right. Admittedly, I am not very objective. I was a victim of an alcoholic father and I have sen soooo much death, injury and destruction due to drunk drivers. It is one of the few crimes for which there is no excuse. If you drink. Do not drive. Easy. Of course i agree that if you drink you shouldn't drive. But I'm talking about the law, not our opinions (as valid as i believe they are). My posts have nothing to do with what i think (though saying 'if you think lives should be a risk... was not a very kind or valid way to try to sum up my posts on the subject). The law says under certain specifications a person can drink and drive. The problem is that that we are asking people who we believe to be mentally impaired to judge when they are impaired. That doesn't make any sense. 2
rodheadlee Posted April 30, 2015 Posted April 30, 2015 Um, don't ask me how I know but it's not hard to tell when you've had too many to drive.They have drink charts for your weight, it all depends on the alcohol content, beer, wine, hard drinks all have a different content. Beer has anywhere from 1.2 to 12 % wine is 12%, hard drinks depend on what you drink,vodka, tequila, rum etc or mixed drinks. It also depends on what you have had to eat and the time between drinks. All numbers are from memory from a long time ago. 2 beers ok, 3 beers, not. I hated wine. 2 shots of rum or tequila ok, 3 shots not. I am so grateful i never hurt anyone in my past life, it's not hard to talk yourself into driving. 1
strappinglad Posted April 30, 2015 Posted April 30, 2015 Never had a drink but I have driven tired. I am told it is equivalent. We humans are stupid because we think that we are OK to drive even when we know we should stop. We must go just a bit further because it is important to get home etc. The person who is found drunk when driving needs to be given a prison sentence, but that would crowd the prisons .What I don't understand is the situation where a death has occurred because of a drunk driver and it is revealed the he has been charged numerous times before for the same offense. How does the justice system allow this absurdity? 1
Calm Posted April 30, 2015 Posted April 30, 2015 (edited) ". I am told it is equivalent"It is...depending on amount of sleep drivation of course. Over 24 hours without sleep is usually equivalent to have an over the limit blood alcohol count.Worse combination is both....drinking into the wee hours and then driving at the time your body is at its lowest point, usually around 3 AM..Saturday and Sunday from midnight to three are when the most fatal and highest rates during the week occur.http://www.cdc.gov/features/dsdrowsydriving/ Edited April 30, 2015 by calmoriah
Coreyb Posted April 30, 2015 Posted April 30, 2015 It's usually pretty easy to tell when you are drunk. 1
Calm Posted April 30, 2015 Posted April 30, 2015 (edited) It is certainly relatively easy to tell when I am high...most of the time I don't even have to stop and consider the matter (no, I do not take drugs recreationally...sometimes my sleep and movement disorder drugs just manage to unintentionally hit the sweet spot ). It can be fun for a couple of hours but is a real pain when I am trying to sleep.And I have never driven when there is the slightest chance of impairment. Don't ever plan on changing that choice. Can't imagine it would even occur to me to do so even when drugged.I am grateful I have been in only minor situations of pressure to do so and I have always been able to inform the person suggesting it that they were insane. I feel very troubled and bad for those who have sleep disorders and other issues and have to choose between putting food on the table and not driving. I have read accounts of having weekly micro sleeps in traffic because the doctors refuse to give them proper medication or they couldn't afford it...always driving wondering if that was the day they were going kill someone; my mother-in-law was made into a child again mentally and emotionally because my father in law fell asleep at the wheel one afternoon on a long strip of highway...never had another accident while I knew them; I know a mother with diabetes who suddenly came to her senses just before driving off the road with her kids in the car with her...for some unknown reason her blood sugars had just dropped without warning and 10 or 15 minutes had passed without her being aware of them.I cannot imagine putting oneself in that position and playing games with others' lives just for a night of fun. Edited April 30, 2015 by calmoriah
Raingirl Posted April 30, 2015 Posted April 30, 2015 You most certainly can tell if you are drunk. You most certainly can tell if you are too impaired to drive. You might choose denial. You won't know...gee....I am (technically) JUST under the legal limit and so I am good to go...but..whoopsie....that last sip put me over...I mean, that's just ridiculous. But, yeah... you know when you're drunk. 1
Yirgacheffe Posted April 30, 2015 Posted April 30, 2015 Never had a drink but I have driven tired. I am told it is equivalent. We humans are stupid because we think that we are OK to drive even when we know we should stop. We must go just a bit further because it is important to get home etc. The person who is found drunk when driving needs to be given a prison sentence, but that would crowd the prisons .What I don't understand is the situation where a death has occurred because of a drunk driver and it is revealed the he has been charged numerous times before for the same offense. How does the justice system allow this absurdity?I've seen the same thing about cell phone use while driving. I've been the victim of cell phone drivers poor observation and driving more times than I care to think about since most of the worst instances I've had a car full of kids with me. 3
Garden Girl Posted April 30, 2015 Posted April 30, 2015 Never had a drink but I have driven tired. I am told it is equivalent. I had to give up being an ordinance worker in the Portland temple every Friday, a 180 mile round trip from my home here on the coast... but I had reached the point where I never knew if I would be okay on the way home... sometimes I was fine... other times no... sleep problems have plagued me for the last few years, and some days I was particularly tired after my shift when I embarked on the drive home, to the point that several times I woke just in time as I crossed the center line on our 2-way highways... I always felt that I was given help when I'd wake suddenly. I was fortunate I didn't kill someone, or myself... So I resigned as a worker... something I truly regretted having to do, but the alternative was too serious to continue... GG 1
sjdawg Posted April 30, 2015 Posted April 30, 2015 I read about someone getting killed by a drunk driver and it brought to mind this question. I've never drunk before so I don't have any idea. Drinking impairs your thinking and driving. So why do we expect people to have someone ask for a ride if they have been drinking? When you are drinking then your brain is clear enough to know not to drive? Is there a point where someone wouldn't be capable of that choice?I'm not arguing that a drinker shouldn't be held accountable. I just don't understand the process enough to know how someone could make that choice while they are drinking if they have drunk enough to be a bad driver.I occasionally go out for a few drinks with friends. When I do I make transportation plans in advance. I will often pre-schedule a taxi to pick me up at a certain time in the evening. Making the arrangements in advance eliminates (or reduces) my opportunities to exercise poor judgement later in the evening. I think some people can drink too much but still feel capable of driving. I don't want to be one of those statistics. 3
Rain Posted May 1, 2015 Author Posted May 1, 2015 The problem is that that we are asking people who we believe to be mentally impaired to judge when they are impaired. That doesn't make any sense.Yes, that's what I am asking. Having not drunk, I wondered if someone is capable of that judgement.
Rain Posted May 1, 2015 Author Posted May 1, 2015 ". I am told it is equivalent"It is...depending on amount of sleep drivation of course. Over 24 hours without sleep is usually equivalent to have an over the limit blood alcohol count.Worse combination is both....drinking into the wee hours and then driving at the time your body is at its lowest point, usually around 3 AM..Saturday and Sunday from midnight to three are when the most fatal and highest rates during the week occur.http://www.cdc.gov/features/dsdrowsydriving/Thanks for keeping me awake last night! DH got up for an early morning meeting yesterday and worked long into the night and wee hours of morning.
Rain Posted May 1, 2015 Author Posted May 1, 2015 Thanks for those of you answering if you can tell. The thought occurred to me the other night and it just really made me wonder about the whole experience. SJDAWG - Do you ever find yourself thinking you would have been ok without prior arrangements? Did you change your mind the next morning?
sjdawg Posted May 3, 2015 Posted May 3, 2015 (edited) Thanks for those of you answering if you can tell. The thought occurred to me the other night and it just really made me wonder about the whole experience.SJDAWG - Do you ever find yourself thinking you would have been ok without prior arrangements? Did you change your mind the next morning?There are many times I think I would have been ok without prior arrangements. However I still like the idea of prior arrangements because 1. It always gives me a reason to make a graceful exit. I don't like staying out too late so with my taxi there waiting I always have a good reason to leave. and 2. I don't think it is as simple as some people believe to judge if you are impaired or not. Sure you can tell if you are drop dead drunk but in that instance you may not be equipped to make good decisions. However, when driving a fraction of a second can make a big impact and that level of impairment is much more difficult to judge. 1 drink may slow my reflexes in an emergency situation but I wouldn't have felt impaired or drunk at the pub. I have never regretted making prior arrangements but I know lots of stories of people who have regretted driving. Even if I would have been fine driving (and most times I think I would have been) it isn't worth the price of a cab ride to find out. Those few dollars would seem pretty insignificant if I ever ended up hurting someone. Edited May 3, 2015 by sjdawg
Recommended Posts