Jump to content
Seriously No Politics ×

Reconciling Some Prophetic Statements


Recommended Posts

Posted

I was thinking last night about my attitude and how I view the prophets (the men who currently lead the Church and hold keys). When you go to law school, apart from being trained to be arrogant, you are also exposed to a variety of ways the judiciary branch interprets law. One of those ways is to interpret two or more laws that seem contradictory to be consistent if such an interpretation is possible. With that in mind I want to examine several quotes from leaders of the Church and see if any of you have a hard time reconciling them.

 

Wilford Woodruff:

 

 

 

The Lord will never permit me or any other man who stands as President of this Church to lead you astray. It is not in the programme. It is not in the mind of God. If I were to attempt that, the Lord would remove me out of my place, and so He will any other man who attempts to lead the children of men astray from the oracles of God and from their duty. 

 

Heber J. Grant

 

 

 

The Lord bless you, my boy, the Lord bless you; you have got a great responsibility. Always remember this is the Lord’s work and not man’s. The Lord is greater than any man. He knows whom He wants to lead His Church, and never makes any mistake.

 

Heber J. Grant

 

 

 

I know of nothing that I feel is of so great value in life as to be obedient to the counsel and advice of the Lord, and of His servants in this our day.

 

Marion G. Romney

 

 

 

I remember years ago when I was a Bishop I had President [Heber J.] Grant talk to our ward. After the meeting I drove him home. . . .Standing by me, he put his arm over my shoulder and said: “My boy, you always keep your eye on the President of the Church, and if he ever tells you to do anything, and it is wrong, and you do it, the Lord will bless you for it.” Then with a twinkle in his eye, he said, “But you don’t need to worry. The Lord will never let his mouthpiece lead the people astray.”

 

Dieter F. Uchtdorf

 

 

 

[T]here have been times when members or leaders in the church have simply made mistakes. There may have been things said or done that were not in harmony with our values, principles or doctrine.

 

So can these be reconciled? What say you?

Posted

I think the first statement by WW was in error... And then others just echoed him after that, and then Pres. Uchtdorf has now straightened it out.

This is kind of like the riddles where it's like "Person A never lies, Person B never tells the truth, etc." And the only one that fits is Pres. Uchtdorf's statement being correct. That makes it all work.

Not that you shouldn't be obedient, in general, or that our leaders aren't directed by The Lord, by and large, but the notion that our leaders should be followed, no matter what, doesn't sit right. JS didn't teach that, and expected people to question him and get their own confirmations by the Spirit. And of course, we know that JS erred in several things, as the D&C tells us. When's the last time we got a revelation on something erroneous a Church leader did? Guess they've all been perfect since JS, eh? :) But I do really appreciate Pres. Uchtdorf's statement... I think that puts things in a much better perspective going forward. We can have admiration for our prophets and apostles and heed their words and counsel, but they are men, after all, and children of God like we all are, and we can steer wrong by putting too much faith in the arm of flesh.

"Cursed is he that putteth his trust in man, or maketh flesh his arm, or shall hearken unto the precepts of men, save their precepts shall be given by the power of the Holy Ghost."

Inasmuch as our leaders give counsel that is given by the power of the HG, then that's great. But I wouldn't say that everything has been. It's up to us to verify things through our own connection with the HG, and not to blindly follow any man.

Posted (edited)

There's no need to reconcile. You go with the living prophet.

 

Besides, I view all five statements to be sincere, yet very personal opinions.

Edited by Senator
Posted (edited)

There's no need to reconcile. You go with the living prophet.

Only when he is "acting as such"  as D&C 1 says "they shall err and i shall be made known"  how is it made known..... "By the power of the Holy Ghost you may KNOW the truth of all things"

 

Christ has not commaded me to obey men who hold the office of Prophet, but rather to obey him "when" he is speaking through those who hold that office.

Edited by DBMormon
Posted

Not that you shouldn't be obedient, in general, or that our leaders aren't directed by The Lord, by and large, but the notion that our leaders should be followed, no matter what, doesn't sit right. JS didn't teach that, and expected people to question him and get their own confirmations by the Spirit.

 

Why does Joseph Smith get the final say on the matter even if you are right? Was he not just one of 16 men called of God?

 

To be honest I love Joseph Smith. But the appeal to him as if he is the end all, be all to any discussion never made any sense to me. In my mind his prophetic word is no better than any of the 15 that followed. In fact, President Monson's trumps him today.

Posted (edited)

Why does Joseph Smith get the final say on the matter even if you are right? Was he not just one of 16 men called of God?

 

To be honest I love Joseph Smith. But the appeal to him as if he is the end all, be all to any discussion never made any sense to me. In my mind his prophetic word is no better than any of the 15 that followed. In fact, President Monson's trumps him today.

 

Good point, but just to illustrate that our Church in this era didn't begin with the idea that the Prophet is infallible and should always be heeded blindly, without any chance that he could lead us astray.  Somewhere we got a different idea about that, presumably from WW's statement, and I think it's led to some "arm of the flesh" type of worship of our leaders, who, since JS, have also been fallible in some ways.

Edited by Grudunza
Posted

There's no need to reconcile. You go with the living prophet.

 

Besides, I view all five statements to be sincere, yet very personal opinions.

 

But what if the living prophet makes statements that are based on his personal biases and culture, as so many did about the priesthood ban?  And what if you felt, as guided by the Holy Ghost, that they were in error about those statements?  You would be right to have rejected those statements as false, and your conscience would be clear.  Were those statements accurate at the time, because the living prophet at the time said them?  I say no, they were always wrong.  And though there may have been some divinely guided purpose for the priesthood ban to begin with (though I don't personally believe that), I think that inasmuch as several of the leaders held firm to it when people like Pres. McKay were trying to overturn it, they did harm to the church as a whole in terms of reputation and membership, and to many individuals who were denied the blessings thereof.  Whether that constitutes "leading astray" may be debatable, but I think it counts to some degree.  

Posted (edited)

But what if the living prophet makes statements that are based on his personal biases and culture, as so many did about the priesthood ban?  And what if you felt, as guided by the Holy Ghost, that they were in error about those statements?  You would be right to have rejected those statements as false, and your conscience would be clear.  Were those statements accurate at the time, because the living prophet at the time said them?  I say no, they were always wrong.  And though there may have been some divinely guided purpose for the priesthood ban to begin with (though I don't personally believe that), I think that inasmuch as several of the leaders held firm to it when people like Pres. McKay were trying to overturn it, they did harm to the church as a whole in terms of reputation and membership, and to many individuals who were denied the blessings thereof.  Whether that constitutes "leading astray" may be debatable, but I think it counts to some degree.  

 

If you are looking for reasons to disagree or agree with a prophet you will find one. I think every single one of us here let's our political and social values cloud our judgment and we use it to justify our agreement or disagreement with the Lord's anointed. For example, when  a more conservative person reads statements made about socialism, communism and the dole they take those statements as evidence that a prophet is a Prophet. When a liberal person of our faith hears statements concerning same-sex marriage they say those statements are " based on his personal biases and culture," thus justifying their disobedience. Both views are qually wrong in my view.

 

And I offer it as my opinion, that when we pray and even if we believe the Spirit has told us something different (and I highly suspect anyone who claims such) than what the key holders have said, the advice to President Romeny from President Grant is very applicable. 

Edited by lvjd66
Posted

And I offer it as my opinion, that when we pray and even if we believe the Spirit has told us something different (and I highly suspect anyone who claims such) than what the key holders have said, the advice to President Romeny from President Grant is very applicable. 

 

I do agree with that, and there's a point when you can't be personally held accountable when you followed what you were expected to.  I would like to believe that a lot of the German army wouldn't really support what the Nazis were doing, if they knew the whole story.  And yet, they were expected and required to fight on that side.  

Posted

There is a logical and also spiritual way to easily reconcile these statements, but there is some emotional pain involved. That's all I have to say. The rest you will figure out over time.

Posted (edited)

There is a logical and also spiritual way to easily reconcile these statements, but there is some emotional pain involved. That's all I have to say. The rest you will figure out over time.

I think I know what you are getting at, and I agree with it if I am right.

Edited by lvjd66
Posted

Leading astray in this case means leading us to damnation. Joseph Fielding Smith being wrong about the moon landing did not lead anyone to sin themselves to hell.

 

Are there some references on the 'leading us to damnation' interpretation? I agree that the moon landing thing is of little consequence. Does that mean that a prophet can teach us false doctrine (inter-racial marriage is "repugnant") but God will allow it to be taught if He considers it to be something that will not lead us to damnation? If God is able to intervene and stop "damnable doctrine" being taught, when has he done this? If he is able to do this, any thoughts on why he would also happy for false doctrine to be taught in His name by his living prophet?

Posted (edited)

If you are looking for reasons to disagree or agree with a prophet you will find one. I think every single one of us here let's our political and social values cloud our judgment and we use it to justify our agreement or disagreement with the Lord's anointed. For example, when  a more conservative person reads statements made about socialism, communism and the dole they take those statements as evidence that a prophet is a Prophet. When a liberal person of our faith hears statements concerning same-sex marriage they say those statements are " based on his personal biases and culture," thus justifying their disobedience. Both views are qually wrong in my view.

 

And I offer it as my opinion, that when we pray and even if we believe the Spirit has told us something different (and I highly suspect anyone who claims such) than what the key holders have said, the advice to President Romeny from President Grant is very applicable. 

 

So if I follow the advice the prophets have given to pray about their words and, in so doing, prayerfully reach a different conclusion to them, I should ignore it and follow their advice rather than my personally inspired answer?

 

Is that really the doctrine of the church?

Edited by canard78
Posted

So if I follow the advice of the prophets and prayerfully reach a different conclusion to them, I should ignore it and follow their advice rather than my personally inspired answer?

 

Is that really the doctrine of the church?

 

I offered it as my opinion, but I pulled it from President Grant's statement to President Romney. I don't think the Lord will treat it as a sin. Moreover, I think it will be counted as a sign of humility and the humble follower will be blessed for giving deference to the Lord's mouthpiece and key holder.

 

My opinion on this is in large part influenced by the fact that members of this board have claimed spiritual experiences to support their differing views of a variety of topics. I don't believe God is going to tell one of us that SSM is part of his plan and another that it isn't. One of us is wrong. I believe that we are all prejudiced by our opinions we hold on politics and social issues and so I distrust a lot of those alleged spiritual experiences (in some cases my own that disagree with what modern day prophets have said). The answer in my opinion is not to disregard those spiritual experiences but to follow the Prophets. The Lord will bless you.

Posted

Are there some references on the 'leading us to damnation' interpretation? I agree that the moon landing thing is of little consequence. Does that mean that a prophet can teach us false doctrine (inter-racial marriage is "repugnant") but God will allow it to be taught if He considers it to be something that will not lead us to damnation? If God is able to intervene and stop "damnable doctrine" being taught, when has he done this? If he is able to do this, any thoughts on why he would also happy for false doctrine to be taught in His name by his living prophet?

Yes, I reference myself as support. There are others but I do not remember them off-hand.

God can allow whatever He wants to be taught.

We would not know if God stopped doctrine from being taught because if He did the prophet died before he taught it.

God is not happy with falsehoods being taught but He is unwilling to turn prophets into automatons as they have to work out their salvation too. So instead He focuses on the important stuff like God existing, the necessity of ordinances, the nature of faith and repentance, and the like and makes sure those are right.

A fun side effect is that if people condemn the prophet for being wrong on peripheral issues then God, judging them by the standard they are using, is able to damn them for being wrong on peripheral issues.

Posted

So if I follow the advice the prophets have given to pray about their words and, in so doing, prayerfully reach a different conclusion to them, I should ignore it and follow their advice rather than my personally inspired answer?

 

Is that really the doctrine of the church?

I would go with what the Spirit tells you which is a little different then your prayerful conclusion. If you find the Spirit telling you to defy apostles and prophets I would be very careful to make sure it the Spirit.

Posted

lvjd66:

 

From reading your posts, I doubt that we are in agreement. But it would be nice if we were.

 

I just have a much more pessimistic view on these particular matters than most TBM's.

Posted

lvjd66:

 

From reading your posts, I doubt that we are in agreement. But it would be nice if we were.

 

I just have a much more pessimistic view on these particular matters than most TBM's.

 

You might be surprised. True, I am pretty orthodox in how I live my faith. I am probably a hardliner. But I understand that reconciling these quotes is going to cause a lot of pain to a lot of people. We are limited by our mortal existence. I love knowing there is a God who can and will make everything right in the end.

Posted

I offered it as my opinion, but I pulled it from President Grant's statement to President Romney. I don't think the Lord will treat it as a sin. Moreover, I think it will be counted as a sign of humility and the humble follower will be blessed for giving deference to the Lord's mouthpiece and key holder.

 

My opinion on this is in large part influenced by the fact that members of this board have claimed spiritual experiences to support their differing views of a variety of topics. I don't believe God is going to tell one of us that SSM is part of his plan and another that it isn't. One of us is wrong. I believe that we are all prejudiced by our opinions we hold on politics and social issues and so I distrust a lot of those alleged spiritual experiences (in some cases my own that disagree with what modern day prophets have said). The answer in my opinion is not to disregard those spiritual experiences but to follow the Prophets. The Lord will bless you.

 

I wouldn't agree with Pres Grant's statement to Pres. Romney. I think that was a case of "personal opinion." I'm not aware of that message being repeated more than once or twice. It certainly hasn't become a core doctrine.

 

"One of us is wrong." So given both people reached that conclusion via the same method (spiritual witnesses/inspiration) how can we possibly ever know? Why can't both be right? Answers and truth are two different things. (Bukowski... where are you!). I could receive divine guidance to reach a conclusion and establish an answer that works for me, even though that isn't the reality. If it's useful, it's useful. 

 

Maybe SSM marriage (for example, or inter racial marriage, etc etc) really IS part of the lord's plan. Maybe he recognises that he can't teach that principle to some Mormons yet. Maybe he recognises that to do so would be the equivalent of throwing seeds on stony ground. Who knows... The best I can do is rely on the spiritual guidance I believe I receive. It means my answers are different to your answers. Both were received through spiritual processes. As a result, neither are any more than personal conclusions. Maybe both of us have the "right" answers if both of us find those answers useful. If, ultimately, an answer leads me to godliness, it's a good answer.

 

Have a look at D&C 19:6-7... God's happy for people to give answers that later change. Not because he wants to deceive, but because he wants to give answers in different times and places that will be useful and be "more express" to "work on the hearts of men." 

Posted

 

Maybe SSM marriage (for example, or inter racial marriage, etc etc) really IS part of the lord's plan. Maybe he recognises that he can't teach that principle to some Mormons yet. Maybe he recognises that to do so would be the equivalent of throwing seeds on stony ground. Who knows... The best I can do is rely on the spiritual guidance I believe I receive. It means my answers are different to your answers. Both were received through spiritual processes. As a result, neither are any more than personal conclusions. Maybe both of us have the "right" answers if both of us find those answers useful. If, ultimately, an answer leads me to godliness, it's a good answer.

 

 

I disagree here. If there was a person who wanted SSM to be part of the Lord's plan and would be ready to receive it, it would be me. It coincides with my politics first of all. Second of all, I have many friends and even a family member who I would love to support in this matter. I take no pleasure in being called a bigot. But its not the answer the Lord gave me.

Posted

I was thinking last night about my attitude and how I view the prophets (the men who currently lead the Church and hold keys). When you go to law school, apart from being trained to be arrogant, you are also exposed to a variety of ways the judiciary branch interprets law. One of those ways is to interpret two or more laws that seem contradictory to be consistent if such an interpretation is possible. With that in mind I want to examine several quotes from leaders of the Church and see if any of you have a hard time reconciling them.

 

Wilford Woodruff:

 

 

Heber J. Grant

 

 

Heber J. Grant

 

 

Marion G. Romney

 

 

Dieter F. Uchtdorf

 

 

So can these be reconciled? What say you?

 

I do not see anything to reconcile; they do not contradict each other. Just because the Lord may have to remove a Prophet from his position does not mean the Lord made a mistake. It is likely that said Prophet would be put in place to teach us something or in a way nobody else could have. At the end of the day, that is not a mistake by the Lord. That mistake/sin would fall on the head of the Prophet for dereliction of duty.

Posted

I do not see anything to reconcile; they do not contradict each other. Just because the Lord may have to remove a Prophet from his position does not mean the Lord made a mistake. It is likely that said Prophet would be put in place to teach us something or in a way nobody else could have. At the end of the day, that is not a mistake by the Lord. That mistake/sin would fall on the head of the Prophet for dereliction of duty.

 

So then what about the priesthood ban, the Adam-God theory, and other such teachings? Why was BY not "removed?"

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...