All Activity
- Past hour
-
The caricature: Mormons wishing to "get their own planet"?
Calm replied to theplains's topic in General Discussions
Stretching is good for the body, so why not good for the soul? Personally I am hoping it’s not much of a stretch, but I don’t have the skills to evaluate it to that level. -
I love the concept of eternal progression. I don’t like the idea of being in charge but working together for something meaningful…I feel I need that for joy as well. No desire for much power…just enough to be heard and understood and taken seriously, doubt I need to be a god for that to happen in the next life. I want more children…mine are easy personality wise even if one has major health issues. I need to know things are going to turn out well for my children, so being a god there might be essential. I want to make beautiful, fascinating, and interesting things. I want to learn how things work, what meaning and purpose there is and how people think and feel internally as well as understanding expression of it (don’t know if that requires mindreading or just awareness of who they are). I want a perfect body so I can do magnificent gymnastic moves, flips on trampolines (or whatever works) and rock climb mountains and climb very, very, very tall and twisted trees. If I could do all those things without being exalted, I would likely be fine with that…but who knows after an infinite time—if time exists—I might want something different. I figure the sense of family and love and rightness I look forward to will all come with oneness with God, so I wouldn’t need to be a god myself for that….unless that was the only way I could achieve that oneness.
- Yesterday
-
Years ago after having major struggles with one child I realized I do not want to have to look after children, some of whom are murderers and rapists for eternity. I love all my children and have joy in them, but no way I want to do that again with billions more. So no, I don't want to be a Godess/God if it means having more children.
-
You "know" this in the same way I "know" that you enjoy skinning puppies for fun and profit. Which is to say, you don't know that. This is a variant on the ad hominem fallacy. That is not what the ad hominem fallacy is. You really should look that up some time. It's a variant. It's sort of a hybrid between ad hominem and straw man. You impute motives and sentiments, then attack those motives and sentiments. Obergefell was a "massive societal shift." I assume you agree. Incremental movements. That's how it happened. The path was a mix of judicial privacy/equal-protection expansions, state experimentation, and cultural shifts: Privacy foundation (1960s–2003) Earlier cases (Griswold, Eisenstadt, Roe, Casey) established a constitutional liberty interest in intimate decisions. Lawrence v. Texas (2003) struck down sodomy laws, invalidating bans on private same-sex sexual conduct and signaling broader protection for consensual adult relationships under the Due Process Clause. State-level recognition (2000–2013): Vermont created civil unions (2000). Massachusetts’ high court legalized same-sex marriage in Goodridge (2003)—the first state to do so. Other states followed via courts or legislatures; some used ballot measures or statutes to ban it (e.g., California’s Prop 8). This created a patchwork that invited federal challenges. Federal DOMA challenge: The Defense of Marriage Act (1996) barred federal recognition of same-sex marriages. United States v. Windsor (2013) struck down the key provision on equal-protection and federalism grounds, requiring the federal government to recognize valid state same-sex marriages. Rapid public-opinion shift + litigation: Acceptance of same-sex marriage rose sharply in polls over 15–20 years. Coordinated litigation in multiple circuits produced conflicting rulings, setting up SCOTUS review. Obergefell (2015, a 5–4 decision) held that the 14th Amendment’s Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses require states to license and recognize same-sex marriages, treating the right to marry as fundamental and the sex-based restriction as unjustified. Dissenters (Roberts, Scalia, Alito, Thomas) warned that the reasoning could extend to other traditional limits on marriage, including number. So, can we extrapolate? If marriage can be redefined as to sex, why can't it be redefined as to number? Similar incremental patterns could appear, though they have not materialized at the same pace or scale: Privacy/liberty framing: Advocates could build on Lawrence and Obergefell to argue that the state lacks a compelling interest in restricting the number of consenting adults in a marital relationship, treating it as an intimate association or equal-protection issue (discrimination against non-dyadic relationships). Early steps might involve challenging cohabitation bans or securing limited recognition (benefits, hospital visitation, parenting rights) for polyamorous households rather than full marriage. That sure sounds like what is happening in West Hollywood. State experimentation: A progressive state court or legislature, such as California, could create a limited form of recognition (civil unions or domestic partnerships for groups), generating the same patchwork that preceded Obergefell. Litigation could then force broader issues under full faith and credit or equal protection. Cultural and advocacy shifts: Media normalization, academic arguments framing monogamy as arbitrary or oppressive, and organized advocacy (analogous to earlier same-sex marriage groups) could shift elite and then broader opinion. Some religious or cultural communities already practice forms of plural marriage; selective enforcement challenges (as in certain Sister Wives-related cases against anti-bigamy laws) test the boundaries. Frankly, I think redefining marriage as to number, though not advisable, is nevertheless far more rational that redefining marriage as to sex. Judicial incrementalism: Lower-court rulings expanding “intimate association” or striking sex- or number-based restrictions could accumulate, eventually reaching the Supreme Court. The Obergefell majority’s emphasis on evolving understandings of liberty and dignity supplies a ready template. And the dissents explicitly flagged this possibility. Differences: There are some key differences right now. Public support for same-sex marriage rose dramatically; support for polygamy remains low in U.S. polling. We'll see if that happens. Legal and practical complexities (child custody, inheritance, tax/benefits allocation, divorce among multiple parties) are greater. Historical justifications for the two-person limit often center on biological complementarity, child-rearing stability, and gender dynamics rather than solely animus—arguments that carry different weight for many courts and voters. Since Obergefell, there has been modest litigation and discussion around polygamy/cohabitation but no equivalent wave of state legalizations or federal recognition. Critics of the “slippery slope” view, such as yourself, may note that democratic majorities and distinct policy interests can still halt further expansion. Proponents of further change (such as the lawyer in the article in the OOP) will likely treat number limits as the next arbitrary restriction to fall under the same logic. "Also requires that the change be somehow damaging or dangerous which you also haven’t shown." That sure sounds like Downplaying: "Okay, it might be happening a little bit, but it’s no big deal." Thanks, -Smac
-
It solves one of the deepest philosophical problems with any concept of eternal life: the problem of infinite boredom. Human retirement works because life is finite. Stretch a passive, self-focused vacation out to ten trillion years, and eventually, you’ve skied every mountain, read every book, and seen every sunset a million times. Without meaningful stakes, growth, or purpose, "eternal relaxation" starts to look less like paradise. Eternal progression, having a grand, ongoing project of creation and mentorship actually solves the problem of cosmic stagnation. We only dread the idea of helping a billion people, even finding their keys, because, right now, our bandwidth is strictly bottlenecked. Managing one household's lost keys and emergencies is exhausting. If you possess true omniscience and unlimited capacity, locating a set of keys doesn't require searching, stress, or taking time away from anything else. It’s less like working a call center and more like breathing, a natural byproduct of what you are. You draw satisfaction of effortlessly helping a friend or a kid solve a frustrating problem when you happen to have the exact right tool or answer? Now scale that up. When helping someone costs you zero energy and brings them genuine relief or joy and still enjoy personal hobbies. The ultimate sandbox where you have the power to create worlds and the effortless grace to help someone find their keys.
-
I believe the Universe to be infinite. I believe the number of intelligences to be infinite. Thus the Plan of Happiness will NEVER end. A GOD is necessary for administering the process of inviting intelligences to become spirit children of Heavenly Parents. This is the beginning step of an Eternal Round. The number of Eternal Rounds is infinite. Why keep this process going? Generation after Generations? Overwhelming LOVE is the overarching motivator. Unending JOY! Jesus (Jehovah) felt tremendous JOY as He carried out the Atonement in the Garden of Gethsemane.
-
Back when I believed it was possible I wanted the power of a God to throw a massive party in an exploding star, surf around an entire planet on one wave, and ride dinosaurs. I have no interest in using that kind of power to create harrowing gauntlets for my children to encourage violence, rape, slavery, and all that cruelty.
-
That is not what the ad hominem fallacy is. You really should look that up some time. A bunch of analogies that still require evidence of some massive societal shift. Also requires that the change be somehow damaging or dangerous which you also haven’t shown so really the whole things is actually just your usual paranoid hysterics.
-
I haven't started a thread in years, but after reading the thread about the godhead, I honestly wonder what the motivation is to want to become a God. Maybe it is just me, but I have no interest in becoming a god. I don't even want to be a king or president of some country or have everyone worship me. I don't want to be looking for everyone's keys or determining the outcome of a football game, even the Super Bowl. I never want to be making a decision on whether a child should live or die. Nor am I interested in having billions of children, or multiple wives. Heck, I don't even want one. Don't want to be in charge of a planet. I don't like meetings or "councils". I mean, what in the job description of godhood appeals to you. I think when I was involved in the Church, the idea of being a god sounded pretty cool. All that power i guess and an awesome throne. But it is the responsibility that would be overwhelming. I guess the emphasis was on all the glory and not the actual job description. Or maybe I never took the time to ask myself why being a god was such a worthwhile goal. I love being retired. Waking up and deciding what I want to do for the day, or do nothing. I enjoyed my career, but I enjoy the freedom that retirement gives me way more. I love going skiing for the day, sailing the ocean visiting other lands and meeting people from different cultures, creating art in glass and ceramics, going to museums to see what others have created, watching a good movie, having friends over to play games or enjoy a meal together, and a hundred other activities that bring me joy and contentment. Maybe I am just weird to not want to be a god. Maybe I lack that lust for power over freedom to do what I enjoy doing. So I want to understand what all this effort members put in to this goal makes it so appealing? I am really curious to understand why someone wants to be a god for all eternity. Think of this as a job interview. Tell me why you want to be a god.
-
It is a stupid progression I agree, but it happens nonetheless. Rather frequently, in fact. Quite a strawman, that. Nothing in this thread amounts to "hysterics." You "know" this in the same way I "know" that you enjoy skinning puppies for fun and profit. Which is to say, you don't know that. This is a variant on the ad hominem fallacy. Downplaying: "Okay, it might be happening a little bit, but it’s no big deal." There are all sorts of matters which do not have a "direct impact" on you, but you weigh in on them all the time. I do the same. I think that's quite okay. A slippery slope argument is not automatically a logical fallacy, though it becomes one when used incorrectly. A slippery slope argument is valid and sound if there is actual, verifiable proof or a high probability that each step in the chain genuinely leads to the next. Here, we have precedent: marriage was radically redefined as to sex, so why can't it be redefined as to number? Further, the proponent of the city ordinance is saying "this law is just the beginning"? Beginning of what? What "future" do you think she is referencing? What "was out of reach"? It's a reasoned assessment. Well, it's an analogy. Thin edge / end of the wedge: A small or seemingly minor change that opens the door to a much larger, more severe, and undesirable consequence down the road. Give them an inch and they'll take a mile: A classic proverb meaning that if you grant a tiny favor or compromise, the person will keep pushing for complete control or excess. Foot in the door: Originally a positive sales tactic, it is often used metaphorically when a minor initial acceptance creates an opening for a complete encroachment or obligation. Tip of the iceberg: Used when a small, visible problem or concession is only the very beginning of a massive, hidden issue. The boiling frog: The idea that if a frog is put in cool water and it is heated very slowly, it will not notice the danger until it is cooked—describing fatal incremental change. Do you think any of these are more apt? Thanks, -Smac
-
Good to see you, hope all is well. I ran out of patience for contemporary combative nonsense, years ago I dropped out of pretty much anything and everything in the Mainland that has to do with the dominant culture. My physical and mental health is intact because of it. It's spread everywhere, I can see on Reddit how people in Japan and E.Asia are also fed up and are actually doing something, not all of it good unfortunately. Social Hall is pretty much the only place I'll post anymore, it's still civil. That is such a blessing, I'm happy this board has managed to keep it while so many other places have lost it. Take care Rory!
-
It is a stupid progression and it is an excuse to fly into hysterics about everything because everything is now some kind of existential threat. It is a worldview of perpetual paranoia. I know you don’t like living in a pluralistic society but if you choose to live in one you have to put up with other people doing weird things. Since it has no direct impact on you you should just get over it. The slippery slope fallacy is a falllacy for a reason. It is not a default assumption. Also I hate the camel’s nose in the tent. It is about a guy with a sapient camel who leaves the poor thing out in a sandstorm and when it wants protection from the storm the human is supposed to leave it to suffer because he doesn’t want to share and is worried that somehow offering some relief to the suffering camel might end in him booted out of the tent. It is an analogy that endorses selfishness.
-
The caricature: Mormons wishing to "get their own planet"?
The Nehor replied to theplains's topic in General Discussions
That is a stretch there on Acts 17. -
The caricature: Mormons wishing to "get their own planet"?
The Nehor replied to theplains's topic in General Discussions
I think you meant terrestrial there. -
Why does life make it so hard to trust God?
bluebell replied to bluebell's topic in General Discussions
I saw this quote from CS Lewis that resonated with me. He said— “We are not necessarily doubting that God will do the best for us; we are wondering how painful the best will turn out to be.” Yeah. Basically that. -
Why does life make it so hard to trust God?
manol replied to bluebell's topic in General Discussions
Damn. Pardon my French, but Damn. I admire you, my friend. You've been given every excuse (well, maybe not every excuse but close enough) to turn against God and you've decided that none of them are good enough. One of the highly unorthodox ideas my cafeteria-style approach has selected (from NDE accounts) goes something like this: Our lives are not actually only for ourselves; our lives are actually for everyone. I have no idea how such might be the case, but just in case there's something to it: Thank you. Gotta run now. I feel another bout of French coming on. -
I see you don't view it the way I do and I'm ok with that. Are you saying it does bring comfort to you and if so, what comforts you about it?
-
Why does life make it so hard to trust God?
Kenngo1969 replied to bluebell's topic in General Discussions
I suppose it's a matter of perspective, but I don't think, considering the whole body of "on the record" conversations we have between God and Joseph Smith, that God was chewing Joseph out. I'm sure that, long since, any disagreements that God and Joseph may have had have been hashed out quite thoroughly. -
I can't imagine how discouraging that must be for you, especially as it goes on and on. I appreciate you saying you are not downplaying anyone's experiences. I am not doing that either, I'm just trying to understand. People often use that experience of Joseph's when others were going through a hard time. I never liked it because I felt like God was chewing out Joseph for not handling his difficult times like his perfect, Godly, Son, but I recognize it brings comfort to some. Are you one who finds comfort in it? What brings comfort in it to you? Again, not trying to catch you, I figure it must mean something to you, and I want to understand better.
-
Why does life make it so hard to trust God?
Kenngo1969 replied to bluebell's topic in General Discussions
I'm not dismissing or downplaying anyone's genuine feelings to the contrary here. That is not ... not ... NOT ... my purpose. (I did mention that it is not my purpose, right? I think I did.) Joseph Smith felt forsaken: "O, God, where art Thou, and where is the pavilion that covereth Thy hiding place?" Doctrine and Covenants 121:1. Joseph Smith wasn't perfect, and I think he'd be the first to admit that. Christ felt forsaken: "My God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken me?" Mark 17:46. Christ is perfect, yet consider everything He went through. Through two failed hip reconstructions that, in some ways, set me back permanently, and decades of soul-crushing, pulverizing, self-doubt when the dog of clinical depression alternated between nipping at my heels and threatening to devour me whole, at times, I felt forsaken. Still, I don't know how certain aspects of my life are going to play out. Will any employer ever realize ... however grudgingly ... "Yeah, this guy could be an asset to us"? For that matter, will anyone ever hire me for anything other than ... answering ... the ... damn ... phone? ("But, Ken! You don't understand! We all have a cosmic mission, a reason why we were put on this planet ... and that is yours!") What about my obscene [useless???] overeducation and underemployment? The only answer I've ever received about my most prominent educational misadventure (and believe me: it was a massive misadventure) is, "Yes, Ken, you were exactly where I wanted you during those (in my case, five) years of your life." Meanwhile, the government, in its infinite wisdom, said, "Nope! Sorry! We're not going to trouble ourselves enough to help you find a [suitable] job, but ... Good news! Under our rules, now you are Totally and Permanently Disabled! Your [massive] student loans (at least I wasn't "smart" enough to try to get into, say, Hah-vahd! ) are forgiven!" Lord, if that isn't the sort of decision that only a government could make! And, in the immortal words of the Everly Brothers and, later, of Linda Ronstadt (who, no offense, Gentlemen, did it better), "When will I be loved?!" (Whoever you are, wherever you are, whenever we should chance to meet ... but, don't worry, I'm not holding my breath! 😆 ... Love You, Dear!) At this point, my "pitch" would have to be, "Will you take care of me, in my advancing age and my ever increasing decrepitude?" 🤣 (Who wouldn't jump at that opportunity!) The pieces that haven't yet fallen into place? I've given up my hammer and chisel trying to make them fit! Does it all make sense now, in a way that it hasn't before? Yes and no. Maybe, to the extent that is so, it is so only because I have given up my hammer and chisel. Maybe it all makes sense now, to the extent that is so, only because I have given up so much of the excess baggage in which, so often, I have carried [what eventually, in the long run, the verrrrry long run, indeed, in the eternities, will turn out to be] trivial things. Oh. And as for trusting God? "Will ye also go away? Lord, to whom shall we go? Thou hast the words of eternal life." See John 6:66-70. "Lord, be it unto me according to Thy word." Luke 1:38. -
You say: Is there really no way to make this work? And if not, what would I do? And is there really no one else here who has questions about the historicity of the Book of Mormon? The LDS will talk with you about the Book of Mormon (BOM). I see you haven't looked in since Saturday. If you ever see this, I would urge you to quit pretending to be a nincompoop. That guy you made up was pathetic. Come back, use a different name if you want, although we would forgive and forget the stupid charade if you want to admit it. This is Social Hall. It is more for personal issues than the more popular and sometimes doctrinal forum which is called General Discussions. The LDS, good folk that they are, and other caring parties who probably doubt the BOM, assumed the best about ManyHobbies, and didn't question the hokey scenario. They were trying to help ManyHobbies. This is why you, who is not ManyHobbies, never managed to talk about the subject you came here to discuss! I am not LDS, and I don't know much about the Book of Mormon. I have read a few pages, and disbelieve because I have another religion. I am forthrightly Catholic here, but don't talk much about what is wrong with the LDS. Why? They have to like us before they can believe us. We have to at least like them and find areas of common ground which are aplenty if we look. Its about love. We cannot evangelize those we don't love. I could sooner believe that you were a misguided young Catholic than a ridiculous fallen away Mormon! Tell them why you are a happy Catholic or Evangelical. I have an assumption about you, not ManyHobbies. I think you, not ManyHobbies, might have genuinely sincere motives to disabuse the LDS of what you and I both perceive to be an inaccurate view of us "Gentiles". Maybe you read about the spies Moses sent into the Promised Land and justified not revealing who you really are. I would excuse that, even while thinking it was unwise. That makes you into someone who is much better than a straight out liar. I wouldn't accuse you of sin. Be yourself if you come back. The LDS and others were trying to help ManyHobbies. I have a genuine concern for You. God bless you. Rory
-
Everything? If so, then the Bible contradicts itself. "To him that overcometh will I give to eat of the hidden manna, and will give him a white stone, and in the stone a new name written, which no man knoweth saving he that receiveth it." (Revelation 2:17)
-
The caricature: Mormons wishing to "get their own planet"?
InCognitus replied to theplains's topic in General Discussions
There is no such distinction made for ontological equality in Revelation 3:21 because none is necessary, because the Bible already teaches that we are all the same "kind" of being as God elsewhere (Acts 17:28-29, where it teaches we are all the very génos of God). -
You got a point there.
-
It appears you really like "the lifestyle" so much that you have considered lying to the Latter-day Saint faculty, staff, and students at BYU. Where is your integrity? Be a man and live "the lifestyle". Does "the lifestyle" include lying? I have more respect for a truth telling drunk than for lying so that you aren't pressured to drink. Maybe I am cynical but I say the truth. I have wondered if you are lying to us. There are no possible consequences here. Why should we believe someone who entertains lying where there could be great consequences?
