Jump to content
Seriously No Politics ×

All Activity

This stream auto-updates

  1. Past hour
  2. I think so. He appears to be a honest man who speaks precisely and accurately about what scripture contains as opposed to what people want to read into them. I see no reason he can’t be a believing, faithful LDS accepting everything that he says because I know very, very well one can do that since I am devout and yet accept Dan’s comments as accurate scholarship. My personal beliefs depend on my personal interaction with God, not the interpretations of academic scholarship, even if my personal beliefs came in part due to my interaction with scripture in seeking greater understanding of it. Ancient understanding of God as academics have explored it has expanded my understanding of God, but has not limited it.
  3. I acknowledge this. How do you think Dan's bishop should treat these public statements? Dan McClellan: "Just because I had never called Jesus a failed prophet doesn't mean I'm not perfectly happy to say the Jesus of the Gospels is a false prophet, which I am perfectly happy to say." Dan McClellan: "To the degree that faith is evidence of things hoped for and not seen, you should not expect the data to support what you have faith in. And they don't. The data point pretty firmly in the opposite direction of a historical Book of Mormon. That is why I talk about the Book of Mormon as something that is, the data indicate is a product of the nineteenth century. ... That's what I would argue the data indicate." Dan McClellan: Religion “is not something that exists outside of discourse.” It is “like McDonald’s”—something we agree to treat as real, but that “does not exist in the world. It exists only in our discourse and in our imagination.” Humans tell campfire stories about “unseen agents” (deceased kin, imagined creatures, etc.), then build narratives around them because of our capacity for imagination. “So religion is something that only exists in our imagination.” Dan McClellan: He points to hardcore atheists who still light candles, say prayers, and observe Jewish rituals. “That’s what all religion is.” When pressed on whether Mormonism is therefore just a social club, he answers: “Yes, it is a social club. It can be nothing other than a social club… fundamentally that is what created religion at the roots of human evolution.” Dan McClellan: Terms like atheist, agnostic, theist, or Latter-day Saint are “social identities” that do not map one-to-one onto internal beliefs. Even when someone insists they “deeply believe” something, “those beliefs are generated within contexts and for rhetorical reasons, not because we deeply hold those beliefs.” Dan McClellan: “I'm probably doing something right if I’m offering reasons for {Latter-day Saints} to remain faithful and reasons for {Latter-day Saints} to feel justified in not remaining faithful.” Do the above public statements I quoted also "speak for themselves?" Understood. I would very much like to see Dan be an example of someone who is well-trained and well-learned in scholarly/intellectual pursuits, and who also is a faithful and devoted Latter-day Saint. I have had many such examples in my life: my father; Daniel C. Peterson, John W. Welch, Richard L. Bushman, Hugh Nibley, William Hamblin, John Tvedtnes, Don Bradley, Brant Gardner, Louis Midgley, and many others. I have difficulty putting Dan in that category. Thanks, -Smac
  4. Today
  5. Massivve societal shift??? Yes, massive. Are you saying it was not? If so, please explain. I'd like to hear what you have to say. And others have ample grounds to disagree with that characterization. Regardless, Obergefell was, in my view, a "massive societal shift." I would be quite surprised if you disagree with that statement. You beg the question here. Big time. That is a logical fallacy. While a question isn't strictly a logical fallacy on its own, using it to imply "if it doesn't affect you personally, your point doesn't matter" is a flawed argument. A form of ad hominem and/or red herring, I think. Elective abortion hasn't affected my marriage, but I can still be opposed to it and publicly articulate the reasons why. Medical interventions on children to cut off healthy body parts, chemically sterilize them, and like "trans" procedures hasn't affected my marriage, but I can still be opposed to such things and publicly articulate the reasons why. The sexualization and grooming of children hasn't affected my marriage, but I can still be opposed to such things and publicly articulate the reasons why. If I present an argument, I hope you would address it rather than personalize the discussion via "why doe you care"-style questions. Thanks, -Smac
  6. I want to keep this brief because I’m on my phone. I’ve really disliked the response from followers of Huff’s work who say it’s “a nothing burger” and “it’s not big deal.” Most of these people still believe that it was one paper years ago or do believe, like @ttribe said, that the ends justify the means. It’s hard for me to forgive Wes because of his whole response to the accusations. He tried to hide it, then tried to say it was a mistake made years ago. Only when other non-LDS people came out and called him out for it did he finally come clean. I also understand it was when his daughter was (and I believe still is) going through a major health scare. (Prayers to her). So he likely didn’t want to also deal with this on top of that. However we don’t get to choose when that bill comes due for our actions. I hope he moves forward, but I also hope that he gets the academic discipline he deserves. Most of my ire comes from me being in a masters program currently. If I plagiarize, I’m finished. Do not pass go. Do not collect 200. I would never forgive myself and I wouldn’t expect others who work with me to forgive me as easily especially since I’m an English teacher. I literally have lessons on how to avoid plagiarism. It’s tedious sometimes, I know, but it is so necessary. I don’t like how people want to push that aside simply because Wes is a warrior for the gospel. I especially don’t like it when people said that it was no big deal. That everyone is doing it. It makes a mockery of the people out there that are honest about their work and are going through so many hoops to avoid such accusations. Finally, Dan does deserve an apology from Wes. The first thing that Wes did was try to turn this on Dan by questioning motives. Dan held his ground and brought receipts. I know part of research and human experience is to really think about where you get your information, but to immediately go after Dan by poisoning that well was a jerk move. All in all, this was something that really hit home for me, and the reactions to it have bothered me all week.
  7. There's another source that I missed posting for new book I discussed above, for the chapter on 2 Nephi 25:23 by Dan McClellan. In this video posted on Aug 20, 2026, Dan comes out in defense of the Book of Mormon's reading and references his prior paper on that topic: Also, I've been wanting to respond further to the assertions about Dan's beliefs and membership in the church. Dan has said in many of his videos that he is an "active" member of the church. In the Mormon Stories podcast video, Dan indicated that he has never turned down a calling in the church in his life, and that has been a priority of his, to serve where he is asked to serve, in whatever capacity he is asked to serve. In one of his videos this year (I forget which one), he indicated that he currently holds a calling in the church as a primary teacher (if I remember correctly). What bishop in his right mind would call Dan to be a primary teacher if Dan didn't believe the things that the church teaches? And regarding his Joe Rogan interview, Dan has been attacked by several people, but this one is amusing, especially his thumbnail pitch, “You can lead a dogmatist to data but you can’t make him think”: But the main reason I am posting this here is because the podcaster that Dan is responding to accuses him of two things right at the beginning of this video, and Dan's responses are relevant to this thread topic: Accusation: "This guy was uh basically a Mormon who turned atheist." Dan's response: "This is incorrect. I am still very much an active member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. And as I have repeatedly and consistently pointed out all over social media, I am not an atheist" Accusation: "This guy is not a Christian." Dan's response: "I am a Christian as I have pointed out many times and neither you nor anyone you know nor any person or group that exists today or has ever existed apart from maybe Jesus is in charge of who is and is not Christian. Really all you're saying is he's not a Christian that I agree with or that I like, which means absolutely nothing." I think those two responses speak for themselves. I have more I want to say sometime, but my time has been limited.
  8. Attribution? 😉
  9. Putting these women back into open society, potentially if not certainly, puts them back in close touch with their kids. Not acceptable as far as I am concerned.
  10. I am not much into punishment by society in general, I think we would do better if we emphasized rehabilitation and more natural consequences (if they steal property, they get restricted to a certain extent until they replace it). The victims are the ones, imo, who should be determining punishment, if they want it or not. If they want it, then a judge should get involved. I don’t know the children’s opinions in this case, did it get shared in the book (I don’t think they should be walking around free at this point even if the kids are okay with that; extensive community service and strict house arrest if they aren’t a danger to others seems appropriate)? Judges and doctors should be deciding what conditions are appropriate, imo. Incarceration to keep others safe, that’s a valid approach as well, but I don’t think a generic approach is that useful. I would prefer house arrest for punishment more for nonviolent with restrictions tailored to the crime and circumstances and enforceability. Why screw someone up and make them a bigger problem for society while they are ‘paying their dues’? I think it would be better to allow many to continue working while taking a portion of pay for victim compensation and restricting after hours liberties. It is not going to happen here even if they are managing to close prisons in one country (Netherlands) at least because of lower need for them.
  11. Would they? The great Jewish commentaries very, but orbit the very same ideas of a precreation "council of the righteous" (Ruth Rabbah 2:3a), composed of "the souls of the righteous with whom He took counsel before creating the world." (Genesis Rabbah 8:7). Rabbinic and later midrashic lore often treats the souls of the righteous as comprised of figures like Adam, Enoch, Noah, Abraham, and Moses (Midrash Kee Tov). Sure, Rabbis could be asserting foreknowledge, that God foresaw them. But it could literally be a council of human souls or premortal "blueprints" are actually there and seem to be occupying the place the council of holy ones should be in, deliberating in the heavenly court.
  12. Yesterday
  13. You don’t know what you are talking about. You don’t know how ENM or polyamory works. You don’t understand that the slippery slope is a fallacy and not an inflexible law. What is there to discuss? You need your moral panic where you punch down on the weirdos and marginalized of society so you invent a new danger to the moral fabric of the nation over a local law letting someone visit their romantic partner while they are in a hospital.
  14. That is a very ad hoc retroactive change in meaning. If you were to tell it to the writer of the Psalm I think he would stare at you in abject confusion wondering what you are talking about.
  15. The council of gods, like Jesus, appear to be preincarnate human spirits who are supposed to eventually become mortal. Abraham 3:22-24; 4:1, Abraham, like Jesus, was among the gods before he was human. Jesus had to abandon his position to be mortal in order to super exalt himself beyond his premortal glory. A deliberate step down into mortal vulnerability and death. Philippians 2:5-11, Jesus "emptied himself [ekenosen]... humbled himself by becoming obedient to death... Therefore, God super-exalted him [hyperypsosen]" an exalted embodied human and this is above His previous status. These two versions of godhood are simply different. Thus, in Psalm 82, the flawed divine council is judged for failing to execute justice, with verse 7 declaring that they will "die like mortals" becoming mortals. And the new human sons of God are supposed to replace them in the council.
  16. Massivve societal shift??? Seems like most people feel allowing someone who is gay to marry is setting something right that was just based on prejudice. Sure there is a small minority that still thinks prejudices is enough to allow two people from having legal protections that marriage offer, but they and you are really on the minority side of things Specifically how has gay marriage affected your marriage or for that matter, anyone's marriage?
  17. Having read the daughter’s book, I agree it’s too soon.
  18. Has anyone seen the documentary currently streaming on HBO "Mama's Boy: A Story from Our Americas (2022)". It is the story of Dustin Lance Black (Oscar winning writer of the documentary "Milk") growing up in the south. His family The first part of the movie is about her mother contracting polio as a child and her determination to not let this handicap define her life. She marries and the family joined the church when Dustin Lance Black was young. His father ended up abandoning the family and his mother who despite her handicap was forced to figure out a way for the family to survive. Dustin Lance Black talks about how the Church stepped in and provided financial assistance by leaving money anonymously in their mailbox. Without that money, it was highly likely that the family would have been sent to foster care. The Church then successfully matches his mother up with the ward Boy Scout leader who had also been previously married and had two children that he never really had any relationship with. This man ended up being physically abusive to his mother and the children. His mother goes to the bishop and tells him how her and the children are being physically abused. The bishop blames it all on her. She is suppose to support the priesthood leader in her home and make it a place where he wouldn't want to beat the family up. At one point this second husband is going after his mother who is in crutches with a knife attempting to kill her. By chance, her oldest son ends up saving her. She goes to the police. It turns out that this man also abused his first wife, something the bishop KNEW ABOUT before her marriage to him, and still blamed her for the violence against her. The movie also talks about Dustin Lance Black's significant involvement in building bridges between the Church and the gay community. It is not a story centered around the Church. But it is a story that the Church plays a part of what the family goes through. At times, the Church deserves high praise for so many of the things it has done. But, there is also a very dark side of the Church when it has epic failures in blaming and abandoning those that they know are being harmed and abused. This is a heartbreaking film that could have had such a different ending if Church leaders did what was right and protect the vulnerable.
  19. That's a fair angle. Here's another: Do we as a society want to use the punitive and coercive force of law to turn religious leaders who receive religiously-motivated confessions of misconduct into de jure agents of the State? Wouldn't the people doing the confessing pretty quickly stop doing that? And another: Attorneys also have constitution-based rights and obligations to not disclose confidential information to law enforcement, so why is nobody applying an the-ends-justify-the-means analysis there? The increase in sexualization of children and other forms of depravity and licentiousness are doing great damage to society. Perhaps it's time for SCOTUS to weigh in. From Grok: I agree. In my view, the Church's perspective in appropriately nuanced. We see the value of the privilege, but it is not an absolute doctrinal requirement. Again, from Grok: Abuse Policy and Legal Reporting (Handbook 38.6.2) The Church’s policy is that abuse “cannot be tolerated in any form.” Leaders must take reports seriously and never disregard them. Key directives: Bishops and stake presidents must promptly call the Church’s abuse help line in every situation involving suspected or reported abuse (or child pornography). The help line connects them with legal and clinical professionals who advise on assisting victims, protecting others, and complying with local reporting laws. 38.6.2.7 Legal Issues Relating to Abuse: “Church leaders and members should fulfill all legal obligations to report abuse to civil authorities. … The Church’s policy is to obey the law.” Leaders are also instructed to urge members who have violated the law to report their own activities to authorities. Summary of the Church’s Approach Aspect Church Policy Confidentiality Strongly protected for confessions and counseling Help line Mandatory call in abuse situations for legal/clinical guidance Immediate reporting Required if life-threatening harm or serious injury is imminent Legal obligations Explicit policy to obey the law and fulfill mandatory reporting requirements Flexibility Unlike some traditions with an absolute “seal,” the Church prioritizes compliance with civil law while protecting confidentiality where the law permits it The relevant sections are General Handbook 32.4 (especially 32.4.4) and 38.6.2 (especially 38.6.2.1 and 38.6.2.7). I served as my ward's bishop for five years. I called the helpline several times. Notably, one of the times I called I was instructed to disclose the matter to law enforcement. Thanks, -Smac
  20. Are throuples taking over reality TV? Inside the new wave of polyamory Looks like West Hollywood isn't the only move to normalize group marriage/relationships. Incremental steps. Riiight. Normalization. Incremental steps. Denial: "It’s not happening at all." Downplaying: "Okay, it might be happening a little bit, but it’s no big deal." Rationalization: "Yes, it’s happening, and actually, that’s a good thing." Moral/Social Shaming: "You're a bigot/idiot/conspiracy theorist for having a problem with it." Looks like we are moving from Step 2 to Step 3. So this has been going on for years on reality TV. West Hollywood, then, is taking an incremental step, but not the first one. Normalization via incremental steps. So she's not a member of the Church? Normalization. Yep. Normalization. Step 3: Rationalization: "Yes, it’s happening, and actually, that’s a good thing." I think these are efforts to change - increase - both of these percentages. Definitely Step 3. Thanks, -Smac
  21. As a layperson, I lack the expertise to tease apart 150 pages of legal documents. That said, the central "question" that I see in this case is the broader question of whether society should trust churches to determine what their theology etc. considers confidential. The saddest thing to me is that this issue of child abuse (though there are other issues as well) has caused so many people in society (believers and non-believers) to lose trust that churches are able to make good moral judgements in cases like these. I'm not sure what SCOTUS will do. I'm not sure they want to set a precedent of letting courts and legislatures interpret churches' "canon law" to determine what a church considers confidential. I also think that church with the most to lose is the Catholic church, which is theologically committed to the "seal of the confessional." Perhaps it wouldn't be as big of an impact as I think, because Confession as a Sacrament might have enough "ritual" to clearly delineate between "this action was a confession" and "that action was not a confession." Someone with more familiarity with the Catholic Sacrament of Confession would need to educate me. The LDS church won't lose much, because we are less formal about and less committed to keeping confessions absolutely confidential. In our view, confidentiality is mostly one of many "tools" for promoting good community -- avoid gossip, promote trust between members and leaders, etc. Disclosures that serve the purpose of promoting good community would be easily accepted, IMO. Some in the LDS "faith crisis" community prefer to describe their experience as a "trust crisis." I think that, whatever SCOTUS decides to do, we (and other churches) maybe should be talking about how we rebuild trust in the church's ability to "do the right thing."
  22. I think the general consensus is, it's way too soon. If they have taken all of the programming the Utah Department of Corrections recommends for someone in their position(s), they should take it again ... and again. Thoughts?
  23. Those beings are deities that rule over all the other nations and other deities that ruled over Israel before Yahweh/Jehovah became their only deity. Trying to retroactively meld these concepts with LDS concepts is a HUGE stretch and requires a lot of cherry picking. For example when Yahweh throws the other deities out of the divine council in one of the Psalms for their nations destroying his during the Babylonian captivity how does that fit into the LDS conception of divine beings?
  24. I admit to some disgust at Huff’s followers. While I understand the whole forgiveness thing this goes beyond forgiveness to just excusing it. They should be angry. This guy was cheating. Someone who plagiarizes on that scale is likely playing fast and loose with other facts. They should feel a sense of betrayal. And the repentance for this should involve getting out of the apologetics game since you aren’t trustworthy. They seem to see this as a faux paus and now he should carry on. This just convinces me that many of his followers don’t care about the quality of his scholarship or how truthful he is.They just want their pretty boy face of apologetics to keep telling them what they want to hear. Tell me lies Tell me sweet little lies Tell me lies, tell me, tell me lies Oh, no, no, you can't disguise You can't disguise, no, you can't disguise Tell me lies Tell me sweet little lies
  25. Yes and no, because the Great Commission requires initiating disciples, but not indiscriminate disclosure of every teaching to every person at the same time. Matthew 28:19–20 says three things, preach to make disciples in all nations, then initiate them by baptizing them, and then keep teaching them to observe every other thing Christ commanded. The goal isn't merely to announce the first principles of the gospel (milk) but continuing instruction after (meat). I believe the Great Commission requires us to make complete disciples of Christ, not necessarily to disclose sacred teachings indiscriminately. I see no contradiction between preaching the gospel in all nations and reserving certain sacred instruction for anyone first prepared to receive it, not necessarily giving every teaching to every person at the beginning of their conversion.
  26. Have only been loosely following this as posts appear on my Facebook feed, but it's fascinating seeing this seemingly appear out of nowhere given the recent Jason Arday fisaco.
  1. Load more activity
×
×
  • Create New...