Jump to content
Seriously No Politics ×

False Prophecies?


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I understand what he's saying but is seems like a severe twisting of the text to say the house in verse 5 is different from the temple in verse 4 that was to be built on the temple lot. If that is how the prophecy is to be understood that's fine but then it would seem to me someone could use the same hermanutic to make the bible/BoM say anything.

E.g. The structure in verse 4 would 1)be reared in this generation and 2) is called a temple. The structure in verse 5 would 1) be built within this generation and 2) is called the house of the lord, another name for a temple. Further verse 5 is introduced with a 'for' demonstrating a grammatical link to verse 4, if the house of the lord in verse 5 is different to the temple verse 4 would we not expect a indicator be given that there is a shift in the thinking? Instead we see a linking word.

As I read the Bible and the BoM and any other book I seek to understand the author as they intended to be understood. To interpret the verse in the way Zakuska has purposed would I think be inconsistent with how, certainly I, and I would imagine you and Zakuska read authors elsewhere.

There is a lot of that sort of stuff in the Bible. Prophecies that say one thing and then end up being fulfilled in another way. It is pretty obvious that you haven't read any of it yet. Either that, or you did not fully grasp what you read at the time. Let me offer an example. Jesus tells his twelve disciples the following:

And Jesus said unto them, Verily I say unto you, That ye which have followed me, in the regeneration when the Son of man shall sit in the throne of his glory, ye also shall sit upon twelve thrones, judging the twelve tribes of Israel. (Matthew 19:28)

Those who are with Jesus, following him as he was journeying, will set on twelve thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel. That seems the clear sense of the meaning of the passage. Now, what happened to Judas? He was one of the twelve who were following him at the time. Is this passage fulfilled to the letter? Will it be? Can it be?

Judas, you will recall, was replaced in his office and responsibilities by Matthias. I can offer more. I've got a whole list of them somewhere around here. (Just so you know, I used to be an atheist in my younger years).

Edited by MormonMason
Posted

I am well already fully convinced JS was a false prophet (for the two reasons I mentioned in my OP) and I have no doubt people here have heard about D&C 84.

And I am more fully convinced than ever before that Joseph Smith was a prophet. In your OP you mentioned two things, the first being that he taught a false God or false gospel. That is a matter of false interpretation or understanding on your part. And yes, I heard about D&C 84 ages ago.

I am however relatively new to Mormonism and so wanted to know how Mormons who believe JS was a true prophet do not see D&C 84 as a false prophecy.

I gave you the answer in my previous posts. Do you have any further questions about that?

So far the main response(e have been a couple of ok explainations) has been an attack against Biblical prophecies rather then an explaination of why the prophecy in question is actually true-I was expecting you guys to have a good explaination rather than just changing the subject.

Showing you how you misunderstand the Bible is not an attack on Bible prophecies. Your failure to grasp the situation is in part due to your failure to understand the Bible correctly

Posted

Actually I don’t think I am, can you show me a instance where the term “this generation” is used in biblical prophecies where it doesn’t mean something like “this generation alive today”?

Yes. Here are some quotes:

Matthew 24:

32 Now learn a parable of the fig tree; When his branch is yet tender, and putteth forth leaves, ye know that summer is nigh:

33 So likewise ye, when ye shall see all these things, know that it is near, even at the doors.

34 Verily I say unto you, This generation shall not pass, till all these things be fulfilled.

35 Heaven and earth shall pass away, but my words shall not pass away.

36 But of that day and hour knoweth no man, no, not the angels of heaven, but my Father only.

Mark 13:

28 Now learn a parable of the fig tree; When her branch is yet tender, and putteth forth leaves, ye know that summer is near:

29 So ye in like manner, when ye shall see these things come to pass, know that it is nigh, even at the doors.

30 Verily I say unto you, that this generation shall not pass, till all these things be done.

31 Heaven and earth shall pass away: but my words shall not pass away.

32 But of that day and that hour knoweth no man, no, not the angels which are in heaven, neither the Son, but the Father.

33 Take ye heed, watch and pray: for ye know not when the time is.

Luke 21:

29 And he spake to them a parable; Behold the fig tree, and all the trees;

30 When they now shoot forth, ye see and know of your own selves that summer is now nigh at hand.

31 So likewise ye, when ye see these things come to pass, know ye that the kingdom of God is nigh at hand.

32 Verily I say unto you, This generation shall not pass away, till all be fulfilled.

33 Heaven and earth shall pass away: but my words shall not pass away.

I have also found a couple of quotes from church leaders (apostles) from that generation that clearly understood the prophecy to refer to their generation:

There is nothing in those two quotes from two Apostles to suggest that they thought that was a prophecy unfulfilled. They correctly understood that the word generation in that scriptures refers to the generation in which they lived; but there is nothing in what they said that suggests that they thought it was a prophecy unfulfilled, which negates your point. They understood that it was not a prediction, but a commandment that could not kept at that time because of persecution, but that at some future date it would be fulfiled.

The natural and simple face value reading of D&C 84:1-5 would suggest that Smith was making a prophecy that the temple would be constructed within the generation that was alive at the time of his prophecy. The two above quotes show that even after moving west the LDS apostles who were part of that generation seen the promise as a promise made to their specific generation that God was yet going to fulfil before they died.

Is there any evidence that other members of the generation that received the prophecy did not actually think it applied to them?

Everybody understood that it applied to them, or their generation, except that it was not a prophecy. It was a comamndment. That commandment will be kept, or fulfilled, at a future date.

Posted (edited)

It seems that someone who claims to speak a prophecy in the name of the Lord, yet the prophecy does not come to pass was to be put to death; that would likely qualify such a prophet as a false prophet.

Prophecy 1:

D&C 84:1-5

1 A revelation of Jesus Christ unto his servant Joseph Smith, Jun., and six elders, as they united their hearts and lifted their voices on high.

2 Yea, the word of the Lord concerning his church, established in the last days for the restoration of his people, as he has spoken by the mouth of his prophets, and for the gathering of his saints to stand upon Mount Zion, which shall be the city of New Jerusalem.

3 Which city shall be built, beginning at the temple lot, which is appointed by the finger of the Lord, in the western boundaries of the State of Missouri, and dedicated by the hand of Joseph Smith, Jun., and others with whom the Lord was well pleased.

4 Verily this is the word of the Lord, that the city New Jerusalem shall be built by the gathering of the saints, beginning at this place, even the place of the temple, which temple shall be reared in this generation.

5 For verily this generation shall not all pass away until an house shall be built unto the Lord, and a cloud shall rest upon it, which cloud shall be even the glory of the Lord, which shall fill the house.

This revelation that Joseph gave seems to claim;

1) it is from Jesus.

2) a temple lot had been set aside for the building of a temple.

3) a temple would be built within the generation of the hearers of the prophecy.

4) a city would be built around the city.

As far as I know no temple was built on this lot, to date a temple has yet to be built on this lot and the LDS church does not own the plot of land. How do you see this prophecy as being fulfilled or was this prophecy never fulfilled?

First off, let's determine WHERE this revelation was received.

Answer: Kirtland, Ohio

Why is this important?

Answer: Because in verse 4 it says, "Verily this is the word of the Lord, that the city New Jerusalem shall be built by the gathering of the saints, beginning at THIS PLACE, even the place of the temple, which temple shall be reared in this generation."

"THIS PLACE" is referring to Kirtland, Ohio.

Did you know that a temple WAS built by that generation in Kirtland, Ohio?

Did you know that "the gathering of the saints" began in Kirtland, Ohio?

This prophecy was fulfilled. And perfectly so.

Edited by Vance
Posted

Are you interested enough to read the essay on Biblical Keys for Discerning True and False Prophets? Would it be helpful to consider Joseph Smith in light of the 27 other tests? And do you happen to have any other candidates that look better in relation to the full set of tests than does Joseph Smith?

Or say Duane Crowther's book on the Prophecies of Joseph Smith, showing over a hundred fulfilled prophecies? Do they count?

Does it matter than even within the Bible, (as I noted in a linked section) the Deut. 18 test is the most qualified test in practice, and the one most subject to abuse, even within the Bible.

  • Prophets can be misunderstood (for example, John 3:18-22)
  • Prophecy may have its fulfillment contested, either through misinformation, or cunningly devised fables. (Matthew 28:12-13)
  • Prophecy may be distant fulfillment. (For example, 2 Peter 3:9)
  • Prophecy may be of conditional fulfillment (Jeremiah 18:8-10)
  • Prophets may speak their own opinion. (2 Corinthians 8:8)
  • Prophets may even speak presumptuously on occasion. (2 Samuel 7:14)
  • Prophets may disagree among themselves on some matters. (Acts 15:39)
  • A prophet's words may be recorded imperfectly. (Compare Acts 9:7 and Acts 22:9)
  • Finally, even prophets may misinterpret prophecy. (It is clear that much of the New Testament presumes an immanent return in glory, necessitating eventual warnings not to expect such.)
  • (Overall, see Isaiah 55:11)

And regarding the 1832 Kirtland revelation recorded as D&C 84:

When I look at LDS history, I notice several cites were build by the gathering of saints. And it happens that the Saints did build a temple in Kirtland just a few years later, and the manifestations in the Kirtland temple were witnessed by many. It seems to me that the "this place" phrase can just as easily refer to the Kirtland location where the revelation was received, where the Saints were in fact gathering, and where they actually did built a temple where the glory of the Lord filled the house. What builds the City New Jerusalem is the gathering of the Saints, where ever they happen to be. That's a possible interpretation I think.

And of course there is the issue of conditional prophesy, or other times, of God asking people to do something that they don't get around to doing. Or even changing circumstances and changed expediencies.

Joseph Smith once remarked "a man would command his son to dig potatoes and saddle his horse, but before he had done either he would tell him to do something else. This is all considered right; but as soon as the Lord gives a commandment and revokes that decree and commands something else, then the Prophet is considered fallen."17

I have a theory that one of reasons critics are drawn to the Deuteronomy test is that the difficulties in interpreting various situations gives the critic more control over the outcome than the use of any other test. And one of the reasons that the other Biblical tests are generally neglected is that they tend to remove that control.

FWIW

Kevin Christensen

Pittsburgh, PA

I posted my response above BEFORE I read your post.

Posted

Jonah is a good example of a conditional prophecy. Jonah prophesied to Nineveh that in forty days the city would be destroyed because of the wickedness of the people, period. He didn't say, "unless you repent". But when the people repented, the city was not destroyed. In fact, Jonah himself was disappointed and displeased that his prophecy was not fulfilled!

Jonah MISUNDERSTOOD his own prophecy??????

Oh, the horror of it all.

Posted (edited)
I didn't say...I said I'm only interested ...If I believe true prophets must meet this standard...

... isn't going to make me think you have a reasonable reason for thinking JS was a prophet.

There lies the problem. You state that this is the standard for a test of a true prophet. Then you say "I'm not trying to prove he's a false prophet". You don't understand your own question.

Further, you don't understand the idea of answering a question with a question. It is not to divert or deflect, but to provide a complete answer in a concise manner. You have been shown how Jesus himself as well as other prophets of the Bible have NOT passed this test. Yet you still believe they are true prophets. How can you believe that? If you can answer that, you have the same answer for how some believe this prophecy was not fulfilled yet believe Joseph is still a prophet.

The very fact that you feign intellectual analysis of this criterion and yet you fail to apply it to your own beliefs shows you are not being intellectually honest. That is what others were pointing out to you. If you are not intellectually honest, how can you hope to carry on a reasonable discussion with those who disagree with your views?

All the previous statements can be summarized thus:

Holmes: Here's my question.

Response: Here's the answer.

Holmes: Anyone? Anyone?

Response: Since you ignored that answer, here are some cases where you are not being consistent.

Holmes: So, you're saying he didn't pass the test. See, he's not a true prophet, just like I said. But I'm not trying to prove that.

Response: Do you realize these others also fail the test?

Holmes: So, because these true prophets failed, it's ok for JS to be a false prophet? I don't accept that answer. But that isn't what I'm trying to prove.

Response: No, we're saying you're applying it incorrectly or inconsistently. A test is only valid for comparisons if applied consistently.

Holmes: No, the test is fine because it proves JS is a false prophet. But that is not what I'm trying to prove.

Response: So, since all the Biblical prophets mentioned as well as Jesus himself failed that test, they were also false prophets?

Holmes: I don't apply it to Biblical prophets because we all know they were true prophets in spite of this test. But I've proven Joseph Smith is a false prophet since he failed this test. Even though that is not what I was trying to prove.

Response: Huh??? All Biblical prophets are true prophets even though they fail the test. But JS is a false prophet because he failed this test. Love that logic.

Holmes: I guess you just can't handle the idea that I've proven he's a false prophet.

Response: My give up. My give up.

Edited by Carborendum
Posted

There lies the problem. You state that this is the standard for a test of a true prophet. Then you say "I'm not trying to prove he's a false prophet". You don't understand your own question.

Further, you don't understand the idea of answering a question with a question. It is not to divert or deflect, but to provide a complete answer in a concise manner. You have been shown how Jesus himself as well as other prophets of the Bible have NOT passed this test. Yet you still believe they are true prophets. How can you believe that? If you can answer that, you have the same answer for how some believe this prophecy was not fulfilled yet believe Joseph is still a prophet.

The very fact that you feign intellectual analysis of this criterion and yet you fail to apply it to your own beliefs shows you are not being intellectually honest. That is what others were pointing out to you. If you are not intellectually honest, how can you hope to carry on a reasonable discussion with those who disagree with your views?

All the previous statements can be summarized thus:

Holmes: Here's my question.

Response: Here's the answer.

Holmes: Anyone? Anyone?

Response: Since you ignored that answer, here are some cases where you are not being consistent.

Holmes: So, you're saying he didn't pass the test. See, he's not a true prophet, just like I said. But I'm not trying to prove that.

Response: Do you realize these others also fail the test?

Holmes: So, because these true prophets failed, it's ok for JS to be a false prophet? I don't accept that answer. But that isn't what I'm trying to prove.

Response: No, we're saying you're applying it incorrectly or inconsistently. A test is only valid for comparisons if applied consistently.

Holmes: No, the test is fine because it proves JS is a false prophet. But that is not what I'm trying to prove.

Response: So, since all the Biblical prophets mentioned as well as Jesus himself failed that test, they were also false prophets?

Holmes: I don't apply it to Biblical prophets because we all know they were true prophets in spite of this test. But I've proven Joseph Smith is a false prophet since he failed this test. Even though that is not what I was trying to prove.

Response: Huh??? All Biblical prophets are true prophets even though they fail the test. But JS is a false prophet because he failed this test. Love that logic.

Holmes: I guess you just can't handle the idea that I've proven he's a false prophet.

Response: My give up. My give up.

An extraordinarily accurate assessment of the situation here. I figured out early in this thread that holmes is not interested in the answer to his own question because his cup is entirely full.

moving on...nothing to see here.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...