Jump to content
Seriously No Politics Γ—

The Most Progressive Organization


Recommended Posts

Posted

I just received an email from John L. Sorenson that I thought I'd share. It seems to me that a number of folk here might enjoy the referenced blog posting.

I thought you might be somewhat interested in the forwarded item. Steve graduated from BYU in University Studies while I was chair of that department in the β€˜70s. He then married my secretary! They live in the Bay area. He has been a successful CEO of two sizable book publishing companies, the second one which he and his wife founded. It is now a big name in the area of management/entrepreneurship/organizational behavior, etc., publishing. (See his bio at the end.)

And an awfully nice guy.

The Most Progressive Organization on Earth

S t e v e n P i e r s a n t i

Posted

I just received an email from John L. Sorenson that I thought I'd share. It seems to me that a number of folk here might enjoy the referenced blog posting.

The Most Progressive Organization on Earth

S t e v e n P i e r s a n t i

He is from the Bay area? I couldn't tell. Lol.

Progressive in the classic sense. yeah. Progressive in the modern sense. Nope.

Interesting blog.

Posted (edited)
One purpose of this paper is to encourage progressives both inside and outside the LDS Church to focus on the many progressive dimensions of the Church instead of just on a few issues on which the Church is perceived to not be progressive. I believe that the LDS Church as an organizational model, distinctive LDS ideas and practices, and individual LDS members all have a great deal to contribute to advancing progressive ideas, practices, approaches, and institutions. I hope that this paper encourages progressives both inside and outside of the LDS Church to include LDS members, ideas, and practices in the rooms and at the tables where progressives gather.

I generally agree with the early definition of progressivism in the paper. It's certainly not political progressivism though it could be misunderstood for such. Specifically the word "egalitarianism" which does not exist in the Church in the politically progressive sense. The Law of Consecration illustrates this very well as everyone's wants and needs are considered equal in the sense that they are equally valid. This is a far cry from today's secular liberal progressive "distributive egalitarianism" a concept that has no place in the LDS Church.

Another purpose of this paper is to encourage a political balance that better reflects the progressive nature of the LDS Church than the current balance of political affiliations of LDS members in the United States, which is skewed to the conservative side. In my view, progressives both inside and outside the Church have substantially contributed toward pushing LDS Church members to the conservative side of the political spectrum by perpetuating and broadcasting the myth that the LDS Church is a conservative institution. If progressives both inside and outside the Church would instead recognize and tout the progressive dimensions of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the politics of a greater number of LDS members in the U.S. would move from conservative to progressive, thus yielding a political balance more consistent with the nature of the Church

The problem here is that whereas in the beginning of the paper he distinguishes between the Church's progressivism and today's political progressivism, at the end of the paper, he equates the two. God's economy of salvation is essentially a free market capitalist system based on merit (parable of the talents, laying up treasures in heaven, blessings predicated on obedience to laws etc.). God's temporal laws such as the Law of Consecration reject political progressivism by enshrining private property as the fundamental operative principle and utterly rejecting social collectivism.

President Lorenzo Snow emphasized the importance

of individual agency in moving forward the work

of consecration: β€œIn things that pertain to celestial

glory there can be no forced operations. We must

do according as the Spirit of the Lord operates upon

our understandings and feelings. We cannot be

crowded into matters, however great might be the

blessing attending such procedure. We cannot be

forced into living a celestial law; we must do this

ourselves, of our own free will. And whatever we

do in regard to the principles of the United Order,

we must do it because we desire to do it. Some of

us are practising in the spirit of the United Order,

doing more than the law of tithing requires.” (In

Journal of Discourses, 19:346.)

https://si.lds.org/b...-manual_eng.pdf

In short, Steven Piersanti has erroneously interpreted the Church's politically neutral stance as a license to accept philosophies that actually run counter to and undermine the values and principles taught by the LDS Church.

The Church is only Progressive in the same sense that LDS doctrine is Feminist. That is, modern political progressives and feminists will be severely disappointed with the Church and find themselves perpetually in conflict with it. Celestial Marriage is the ultimate goal of women and no one is shielded from agency and personal responsibility..

Edited by BCSpace
Posted

An interesting blog, though from my perspective, the auhtor is very selective in citing the issues that he considers to promote the "progressive" stance of the church.

Sure, downplay the power that men hold in the church, through their priesthood, by citing the fact that women are allowed to teach classes and serve as leaders over other women. Wow, they can teach and hold administrative roles, but they are powerless when it comes to the real powers such as those held by priesthood leaders in the home, bishops, SPs, GAs, etc.

Sure, promoting the idea of "equality of all people" and "tolerance" is easy if you fail to mention the political activeness of the church in opposing gay legislation today, the ERA in the 1970's, withholding the priesthood from blacks, etc.

And yes, touting the "giving" nature of the LDS church, particularly with regard to "donation of money" seems very progressive indeed. That is, until one does some digging to discover that the "giving" of 10% of your money to the church is not exactly voluntary, but is actually required to access the temple and thus the full blessings of the priesthood. If tithing were not a requirement in church to access the temple or be considered a member of the highest standing, how much do you think annual contributions to the LDS church would decrease?

An interesting blog indeed, but one must be wearing rose-colored glasses if one considers the LDS church the most progressive instituion of it's kind.

Posted (edited)

BCSpace:

As Californian I get tired of moocher states like Utah bad mouthing my state.

http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2012/jan/26/blog-posting/red-state-socialism-graphic-says-gop-leaning-state/

If the federal government didn't own so much of Utah's land, Utah would be able to forego federal dollars, the government owns significantly more Utah land than CA.

http://nationalatlas.gov/printable/printableViewer.htm?imgF=images/preview/fedlands/fedlands3.gif&imgW=588&imgH=450

BTW I am a Californian born and bred and would much rather live there than in Utah.

Edited by calmoriah
Posted

An interesting blog, though from my perspective, the auhtor is very selective in citing the issues that he considers to promote the "progressive" stance of the church.

Sure, downplay the power that men hold in the church, through their priesthood, by citing the fact that women are allowed to teach classes and serve as leaders over other women.

And over men as well or did you not know there are female SS teachers and male Primary teachers?
Posted

Sure, downplay the power that men hold in the church, through their priesthood, by citing the fact that women are allowed to teach classes and serve as leaders over other women. Wow, they can teach and hold administrative roles, but they are powerless when it comes to the real powers such as those held by priesthood leaders in the home, bishops, SPs, GAs, etc.

So what is the difference between real power and these presumably fake powers women have?

Posted

The difference between Superman and Batman....honestly calling someone a superhero whose only 'powers' are tech based is just ridiculous, don't you think?

Posted

Calmoriah:

If the federal government didn't own so much of Utah's land, Utah would be able to forego federal dollars, the government owns significantly more Utah land than CA.

http://nationalatlas...gW=588&imgH=450

BTW I am a Californian born and bred and would much rather live there than in Utah.

The problem is that Utah didn't own it. It was always federal land to be disposed of as they see fit. From time to time federal lands do become open for sale or are given outright to a state, but anymore that isn't common. Further state and local governments profit from increased income from sales to tourism. None of which goes to the federal government. BLM lands the renters pay rent which is paid back to local and state governments. Overall Utah receive $1.07 for every dollar paid while California receives $0.97 for every dollar paid.

I'm a military brat, and also served in the military, so lived all over the US. I loved New Mexico, but it was a lot harder to make a decent living there. Plus my aged parents asked us to move back closer to them. Being close to the Grandkids I see what they meant. So we moved back to California, and will most likely stay here for the rest of our lives.

Posted

If you like progress I highly recommend ProgressQuest. It is an entirely non-interactive MMO where you have your character make progress by upgrading his gear and leveling up. It is like World of Warcraft without the tedium of having to play the boring thing.

Posted

So what is the difference between real power and these presumably fake powers women have?

I think the point was to say that women's power is limited as compared to men's when one considers the priesthood and the hierarchy. A woman has "power" of a man who is taking her sunday school class, but that is nothing like the "power" men with the priesthood have over women, since all major leadership positions, the positions with the authority of the priesthood, are held by men.

Obviously, as a Catholic, I have no problem with that. Men and women have been given different roles by God.

Overall, I think the article is rather silly. The author should be proud that he is a member of a patriarchal and conservative religion and not try to downplay it or spin it as something else. It comes off as being ashamed of what his religion is.

Honestly, it's the same feeling I have when I hear Mormons trying to distance themselves from the teaching that God was once a man, etc. I say stick to your guns. When you downplay something it shows a hesitancy/doubt that plays right into your critics hands.

Posted

The difference between Superman and Batman....honestly calling someone a superhero whose only 'powers' are tech based is just ridiculous, don't you think?

As a fan of Iron Man I disrespectfully disagree.

Posted

Calmoriah:

The problem is that Utah didn't own it. It was always federal land to be disposed of as they see fit.

Which is irrelevant to my point.
Posted

As a fan of Iron Man I disrespectfully disagree.

I am more impressed by the man who uses his brain rather than simply relying on powers he is born with or acquired accidentally....just saying "superhero" seems off as would calling tech stuff "supernatural".
Posted (edited)

So what is the difference between real power and these presumably fake powers women have?

You can't be serious.

In the LDS church, it is men who hold all the power in administering the sacred ordinances that are necessary for salvation (baptism, sacrament, marriage, etc, etc.). Likewise, it is men, exclusively, that have the power to determine other's worthiness (bishop interviews, courts of love, etc.). Furthermore, it is men, and exclusively men, that have the authority to serve in the highest roles of leadership (church president, area president, stake president, high counsleor, mission president, district president, ward bishop, etc.). Also, it is men, and solely men, who have the power to heal the sick, ordain others to positions of power, give blessings, etc.

Surely you cannot compare this to the very limited power that is held by women in the church.

Edited by Walden
Posted

You can't be serious.

I could if I wanted to.

In the LDS church, it is men who hold all the power in administering the sacred ordinances that are necessary for salvation (baptism, sacrament, marriage, etc, etc.). Likewise, it is men, exclusively, that have the power to determine other's worthiness (bishop interviews, courts of love, etc.). Furthermore, it is men, and exclusively men, that have the authority to serve in the highest roles of leadership (church president, area president, stake president, high counsleor, mission president, district president, ward bishop, etc.). Also, it is men, and solely men, who have the power to heal the sick, ordain others to positions of power, give blessings, etc.

All of which depends on God guiding said man and delegating power to him. So is your argument that the Priesthood is a fraud and that women should have equal access to this fraudulent power or that it is real and God is hoarding it because he is a misogynist or that it is real and women should have it and God knows it but those horrible prophets will not let the revelation flow and realize it or that you just want to complain and have not worked out a logical basis for it?

Surely you cannot compare this to the very limited power that is held by women in the church.

I disagree with your premise that women's power is "very limited" so I cannot state how I compare these two things. And don't call me Shirley.

Posted

According to the US constitution, the Federal Government is granted land only for very narrow purposes. This,however,has been ignored most notably west of the Mississippi to the point where the Feds hold vast tracts of land in the western states and Alaska. that is why they can use Utah as a military testing ground and can restrict access to massive areas in Nevada etc.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...