All Activity
- Today
-
A non-LDS perspective is found here: https://truthstodiefor.com/did-constantine-or-the-church-invent-the-trinity/ I found the following mentioned in a FairLDS article. A few highlights: Thus the New Testament itself is far from any doctrine of the Trinity or of a triune God who is three co-equal Persons of One Nature. There is no formal doctrine of the Trinity in the New Testament writers, if this means an explicit teaching that in one God there are three co-equal divine persons ... The Biblical witness to God, as we have seen, did not contain any formal or formulated doctrine of the Trinity, any explicit teaching that in one God there are three co-equal divine persons. The Church had to wait for more than three hundred years for a final synthesis, for not until the Council of Constantinople [AD 381] was the formula of one God existing in three coequal Persons formally ratified. It looks like the main focus here is on whether the Trinity is three coequal Persons instead of looking at another aspect of the Godhead. The Book of Mormon doesn't really get into whether the Trinity is made up of three coequal Persons, though it does teach that it consists of one God instead of three. "And now, behold, this is the doctrine of Christ, and the only true doctrine of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, which is one God, without end. Amen" (2 Nephi 31:21). "... dwell in the presence of God in his kingdom, to sing ceaseless praises with the choirs above, unto the Father, and unto the Son, and unto the Holy Ghost, which are one God ... " (Mormon 7:7). "... and be arraigned before the bar of Christ the Son, and God the Father, and the Holy Spirit, which is one Eternal God ... " (Alma 11:44). Amulek earlier recounted how an angel told him there was only one God (Alma 11:26-31). One aspect of it would later be redefined by Joseph Smith. "I have always declared God to be a distinct personage, Jesus Christ a separate and distinct personage from God the Father, and that the Holy Ghost was a distinct personage and a Spirit: and these three constitute three distinct personages and three Gods". But I cannot find any teachings prior to 1844 to support his "I have always declared ... these three constitute ... three Gods" statement. And this is despite a supposed revelation dated around 1829-1830: "Which Father, Son, and Holy Ghost are one God, infinite and eternal, without end. Amen" (Doctrine and Covenants 20:28). According to Church History Topics, all seven lectures (the Lectures on Faith) "were published together later that year in the first edition of the Doctrine and Covenants, the lectures constituting the "doctrine," and Joseph Smith's revelations, the "covenants". Lecture 5 taught the Holy Spirit was not regarded as a personage in the Godhead. Q3. How many personages are there in the Godhead? Two: the Father and the Son. (5:1) Q4: How do you prove that there are two personages in the Godhead? By the Scriptures. The Holy Spirit is identified as the mind of the Father and the Son, rather than being identified as a third personage alongside them. All seven lectures (the doctrine portion) were removed later. It should also be noted that the Book of Mormon itself, to borrow a phrase from the FairLDS article, is far from any doctrine of humans becoming coequal with God in the LDS sense of becoming gods equal in power, might, and dominion (Doctrine and Covenants 76:95).
-
The caricature: Mormons wishing to "get their own planet"?
theplains replied to theplains's topic in General Discussions
Sounds like visitation rights, but not dwelling with him in his kingdom. -
None of this had anything to do with New Testament Christians and the Jerusalem temple. They weren't even married in it.
-
This is how I see it too, and the role is "in God", and having God's name put upon us. I think the modern definition of "God" as an ontologically distinct being is what totally messes with people's thinking on this topic.
-
"And I knew such a man, (whether in the body, or out of the body, I cannot tell: God knoweth) How that he was caught up into paradise, and heard unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter." (2 Corinthians 12:3–4) The bottom line: There are things that believers are given that are to be kept sacred (or secret), and the Bible shows this to be true.
-
It was obviously enjoyable for me.. Thanks for catching my attention….
-
Seems like I was way under thinking it. Then again, would the number also depend on what part of the year one was born, what part of the year one died , and which year in the leap year rotation you were born? My number assumed exactly 100 years and yet if one lives to be 100, there is plenty of variance in the number of days involved. Sorry for the derail.
-
This…it just ends up leading to some crazy set up when plopped down into eternity/the fullness of universe. Not very functional here and gets worse the more involved over time and space. The majority of scripture was not written in a culture where the nuclear family was the primary relationship for an individual. More like a family network.
-
Why assume it would be like now that? Even now lots of work gets delegated and scripture seems to indicate God works that way. It’s the socializing that is a problem in my view. The rules of mortality can’t be meaningful in eternity because even given infinite time how can God meaningfully dwell with the over 50 billion inhabiting the Celestial Kingdom (estimate is around 117 billion human have lived on earth, pre puberty mortality rate was likely around 50% for most of history), assuming our bodies take up the same amount of space. While the perfected earth has more than enough room if one allows for 50 sq feet per person with communal areas for eating, so one could say God dwells with us if we talking about living on the same planet, but “dwell” implies some interaction. And if we had only 50 billion in the CK, they all could have one on one personal time with the Father for about 1 second every 16 centuries or so. (using chat and half asleep so could be off). So either time doesn’t function like it appears to us or we won’t function in time…or dwelling is primarily symbolic if talking about sharing location.
-
So what about those who receive lesser rewards? They won't be gods creating worlds. Will their eternal lives be infinite boredom?
-
I should be precise…depending on counting the extra days in leap years. And now I am thinking this has more than just two answers as I certainly didn’t consider leap seconds or hours, just days. They are changing how we track time though…dropping leap seconds for leap hours for one thing. Remembered this today and thought some might be interested in it, hence this post. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/scientists-vote-to-end-leap-seconds-redefining-how-the-world-keeps-time/ So the last 100 years allegedly (because I am cheating and using chat this time) were 3,155,760,027 seconds with 27 leap seconds (only added since 1972) and 1 extra leap day in 2000 because the end of the 20th century year is divisible by 400. For the next 100 years, it will be 3,155,673,600 as there is no leap day in 2100. Apparently 1999 was the end of the 1900s though. Someone needs to get these things synchronized. It’s as bad as DST (Devil’s Saving Time)
-
A form of Hebraism new to me: Seidel's Law. Kevin Christiansen brought this up way back in 2016 (https://www.mormondialogue.org/topic/67765-the-state-of-the-evidence/page/27/#findComment-1209651202). It is the idea of an inverted quotation. Shows up in the OT, NT, dead sea scrolls, other ancient literature, and numerous times in the Book of Mormon. Fun stuff. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpHr20T_EQU
-
2
-
Why do you want to be a god?
california boy replied to california boy's topic in General Discussions
Now working together for something meaningful seems like a much better job description. But it seems like being a god is pretty much a full time commitment. Never being able to take a break for eternity seems like something that would just be exhausting. For me, I can connect and find joy and happiness in connecting on a one on one basis. Getting to know people and learning about their lives and what motivates them is more what brings me happiness. Being responsible for billions of people even if their are your children seems so unfulfilling to me. For one thing, too many tragic failures that you also have to deal with for eternity. -
Why do you want to be a god?
california boy replied to california boy's topic in General Discussions
Oh I agree that just pursuing skiing and reading every book would become pretty boring quickly. And if there was a position for a part time god, I would be more interested. But being a god forever seems eventually to be just as repetitive. I do get a lot of joy and satisfaction of helping others. But there is also all the tragedy and suffering that you have to deal with for eternity as well. It seems more exhausting than fulfilling. More like an eternal "groundhog" day. Is any day any different than the last when you are a god? -
Why do you want to be a god?
california boy replied to california boy's topic in General Discussions
I love all the joy you list. But as a god, you also have to deal with all the tragedy. I have seen people that seem to have everything and reasons for overwhelming love and joy but become crippled and fall into depression when something really tragic happens to those they love. Maybe if being a god was all helping others and bringing growth and progress to yourself and others, then yeah, certainly a brighter job description. Unfortunately there are two sides of that coin. How do you deal with that for ETERNITY? -
I should be precise…depending on counting the extra days in leap years. And now I am thinking this has more than just two answers as I certainly didn’t consider leap seconds or hours, just days. They are changing how we track time though…dropping leap seconds for leap hours for one thing. Remembered this today and thought some might be interested in it, hence this post. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/scientists-vote-to-end-leap-seconds-redefining-how-the-world-keeps-time/
-
In John 4:32, Jesus told His disciples, "I have food to eat that you know nothing about." Calling the reward "hidden manna" in Revelation echoes this idea that God sustains His people in ways the rest of the world cannot perceive. The promise of "I will give" can also imply a future application - referring to believers who stay faithful all the way to the end of their earthly lives. In this view, eating the hidden manna happens in the afterlife or the coming Kingdom of God.
-
I think my views of what it even means to be exalted have slowly shifted over the years. My current rendition doesn't really like the term "a god" because I don't see that as how God is to begin with. It's too individualistic or at best nuclear where God is inherently pluralistic and familial/communal in harmonic unity. Oddly it's contemplating the other degrees of glory rather than just the highest degree of the celestial kingdom that's shifted me most. I think all who are a part of the kingdoms of glory are manifestations and expressions of God. They have role and space in the ways of God. Just as the earth and everything around us are expressions of divinity without having to uninformly be the same and hold the same roles. I'm personally leaning to that actually not being all that Godly, to be completely singular/the same. Earth doesn't work that way and when we try to make it that way we screw it up and destroy diversity and perpetual growing capacity. Life shrinks under uniform control and dominance, God expands. And what we do have written about what God is notes that Their ways is not ours (here). I assume the direct parallels go as about as far as me trying to view the capacities of adulthood through how my baby engages with the world. There's some carry over...but anything beyond vague parallels are kinda laughable. So when I think about exhalation I don't think of being "a god" I think of having a specific role in God. And that role (though vaguely defined due to my temporal limitations) is that of creating more God. I don't know exactly what that means. I think parenting is a vague variation of it (though again, I really really don't think the nuclear variation we got going is some perfect model of. It's not even a great model for here half the time) but I don't think that's its only variation. I feel the powers of God as I manage a garden. Sometimes I feel it when I do my work as a therapist. Sometimes I feel it with my kids. I don't really feel it singularly and alone...even in my personal contemplions/meditations I'm engaging with the divine in one way or another*. I feel it in relation with another. In connectivity and helping those connections thrive. In finding meaning in my experiences that both help and are helped by others. That's what I want to continue in perpetuity. The act of participating in the divine and expansive work of the harmonious and diverse God. And I also don't think that divine work will be all on me and/or my husband to fulfill. Tied to the * above, I would note that I don't experience God just through the most direct manifestations of Jesus or our heavenly parents. I also experience it in those who've passed on. My grandmothers and daughters in particular. My prayers often feel more like inviting family counsel more so than just praying to a singular entity nowadays. So when I think of wanting exaltation, I want to be deeply and thoroughly integrated into the Divine. I want to be able to engage in the creative work of becoming. On my simplest days its wanting those bright experiences and glimpses of God that I have here to last forever. PS. Do I get the job? 😋😉 With luv, BD
-
-
Why would I want to be a god? I honestly think it's completely out of love for my Heavenly Father and his Son, Jesus Christ, and the love he shows us by providing a plan that allows us to grow and learn and partake of the same things that he enjoys. He is offering us everything he has. And I see it as a shared experience, a social construct as a "Zion people" who all have the same goals and desires and love for others. I have no desire for power or attention, but if our Heavenly Father loves us and trusts us enough to rule with him in serving others then I want to be a part of that.
-
The caricature: Mormons wishing to "get their own planet"?
InCognitus replied to theplains's topic in General Discussions
We've discussed this before, and I honestly haven't been able to find any support for your claim that this is a "stretch" (I've looked and I keep researching this question). I Googled this just now (in incognito mode to avoid any prior preferences): How did the ancient greeks understand the word genos in phaenomena by aratus? This is the results I got: [Begin Quote] In the opening lines of Phaenomena, the ancient Greeks understood the word genos (γένος) to mean "offspring," "lineage," or "kind". Specifically, in line 5 of the poem, Aratus writes tou gar kai genos eimen ("For we are also his offspring"), referring to Zeus. To an ancient Greek audience, this carried three intertwined layers of meaning: Stoic Pantheism and Cosmic Kinship. Aratus was heavily influenced by Stoic philosophy, which viewed Zeus not merely as a mythological sky-god, but as the rational, divine principle (Logos) permeating the entire universe. Calling humanity Zeus's genos meant that humans share a direct, rational, and spiritual kinship with the cosmos itself, enabling them to read and understand the stars Zeus placed in the sky. Literal Descent and Lineage. Rooted in the verb gignomai ("to be born" or "to come into being"), genos naturally invoked traditional Greek ideas of genealogy and bloodline. In mythic terms, Zeus was literally "father of gods and men," making humanity his collective descendants or race. Shared Class or Nature. In broader Greek usage, genos also denoted a distinct biological species, tribe, or category of beings sharing a common nature. By using genos rather than a word strictly meaning "biological children" (like tekna or huioi), Aratus emphasized that humanity belongs to the same divine class of rational beings as Zeus, bridging the gap between mortal life and celestial order. (Note: This exact phrase became particularly famous because the Apostle Paul later quoted it during his speech at the Areopagus in Athens, recorded in Acts 17:28, to build common philosophical ground with his Greek listeners.) [End of quote] The AI response didn't really supply any relevant references for some of the specific things it said (I tried looking for more), but that's exactly what I got. It did reference this Oxford article on genos, which says: "The word genos was widely and variously used in Greek of all periods to denote ‘species’, ‘genus’, ‘sort’, ‘category’, ‘birth’, ‘kin’, ‘race’, ‘lineage’, ‘family’, ‘generation’, ‘posterity’, etc. Probably from its use to denote ‘(noble) lineage’, it came to be used in 4th‐cent. bc Athenian orators and inscriptions in a quasi‐precise sense to denote a set of families or individuals who identified themselves as a group by the use of a collective plural name. Some such names were geographical or occupational, but most were patronymic in form, implying the descent of their members from a fictive or real common male ancestor. About 60 such groups are known. Some 4th‐cent. evidence suggests that a genos could be a constituent part of a phratry, perhaps as its most prominent oikos (‘house’)." So how is it a "stretch" to say that Acts 17:28-29 is teaching that we are all the same "kind" of being as God? -
Depends on if you include leap years or not (correct if not)
-
I am reasonably sure that if you do not want to become a god , then no one will make you. 3,153,600,000 that is the number of seconds one has if one lives to be 100 years old. If , for a tenth of a second, one touches a hot stove just once in all that time, lesson learned. Even poorly talented old me would have figured out how to play a harp after 1000 years and want to try something new. ( Calm can correct my math if needed )
-
That's also what caught my attention. I'm still going through his data and setting up some of his libraries. The one that stands out is A true and remarkable account of the life and trance of Dr. George de Benneville, late of Germantown, which he puts at #3 behind Ilive's Jasher. Will explain the significance after I confirm he's got the same txt that I've gone through
-
It is nice that he created a repo to replicate everything. He links to it at https://github.com/lifehug/book-of-mormon-authorship/tree/master The shared phrases are interesting but it looks like they didn't really have that much impact on the attempt to attribute authorship. On the git readme, it says: The bottom half of the blog also goes into that. It doesn't seem like the Book of Mormon really matches any of the books, including the Book of Jasher. It is also interesting that his model puts the Book of Mormon language before the 1700 and earlier than the other imitation scriptures. That fits with what Skousen and Carmack have argued.
