Jump to content
Seriously No Politics ×

All Activity

This stream auto-updates

  1. Today
  2. Okay. So you believe Thomas was really saying to Jesus, "You are the Lord of me, but you are not the God of me". As I mentioned before about the Greek, John 20:28 reads: καὶ ἀπεκρίθη Ὁ Θωμᾶς καὶ εἶπεν αὐτῷ ὁ κύριός μου καὶ ὁ θεός μου If you translate the Greek as literally as possible, you get: "The Lord of me and the God of me". Both "The Lord" and "the God" are being addressed to Christ. Jesus is much more than an agent or representative of God. He is God incarnate. Do you believe Jesus is God (Deity) in human flesh? How many true Gods are there? Even LDS scriptures point to there being one God. You are particular about the phrase "one God" or "the God", so let's see where it applies to Jesus. In Alma 11:26-19, a man named Amulek is explicitly asked, "Is there more than one God?" He answers "No". Alma 11:44 states that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are "one Eternal God". The very front of the Book of Mormon states that its purpose is to convince people that "Jesus is the Christ, the Eternal God". Then in 3 Nephi 11:14, Jesus explicitly declares Himself to be "the God of the whole earth". The Bible does not describe the trinity as 3 Gods. The Book of Mormon says God would come down and take on human flesh. "For behold, the time cometh, and is not far distant, that with power, the Lord Omnipotent who reigneth, who was, and is from all eternity to all eternity, shall come down from heaven among the children of men, and shall dwell in a tabernacle of clay" (Mosiah 3:5). "Have they not said that God himself should come down among the children of men, and take upon him the form of man, and go forth in mighty power upon the face of the earth?" (Mosiah 13:34). "And now Abinadi said unto them: I would that ye should understand that God himself shall come down among the children of men, and shall redeem his people. And because he dwelleth in flesh he shall be called the Son of God, and having subjected the flesh to the will of the Father, being the Father and the Son—The Father, because he was conceived by the power of God; and the Son, because of the flesh; thus becoming the Father and Son—And they are one God, yea, the very Eternal Father of heaven and of earth” (Mosiah 15:1-4). This is only one God, not two Gods. Is God of those verses above the true God? The doctrine of the trinity being one God is affirmed in other places too. "And the honor be to the Father, and to the Son, and to the Holy Ghost, which is one God. Amen" (Testimony of Three Witnesses). https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/scriptures/bofm/three?lang=eng "And now, behold, this is the doctrine of Christ, and the only and true doctrine of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, which is one God, without end. Amen" (2 Nephi 31:21) "Every thing shall be restored to its perfect frame, as it now is, or in the body, and shall be brought and be arraigned before the bar of Christ the Son, and God the Father, and the Holy Spirit, which is one Eternal God, to be judged according to their works, whether they be good or whether they be evil" (Alma 11:44). "And he hath brought to pass the redemption of the world, whereby he that is found guiltless before him at the judgment day hath it given unto him to dwell in the presence of God in his kingdom, to sing ceaseless praises with the choirs above, unto the Father, and unto the Son, and unto the Holy Ghost, which are one God, in a state of happiness which hath no end" (Mormon 7:7). The Book of Mormon's description of the Trinity is more in line with traditional Christianity. It even made its way into Doctrine and Covenants 20:28 ("Which Father, Son, and Holy Ghost are one God, infinite and eternal, without end. Amen"). In 1 John 5:20, speaking explicitly about Jesus Christ, John writes "And we know that the Son of God has come and has given us understanding, so that we may know him who is true; and we are in him who is true, in his Son Jesus Christ. He is the true God and eternal life". John already told us in chapter 1 verse 2 that Jesus is the 'life' who was manifested to them. So as Jesus is 'the eternal life' in verse 20, then the grammar forces us to accept that Jesus is also 'the true God' mentioned in that exact same breath. If John 17:3 excludes Jesus from being God, then 1 John 5:20 must exclude the Father from being God. Rather than excluding Jesus, John 17:3 contrasts the true, living Godhead (Father, Son, and Spirit) against the false idols of the Roman and pagan world. Then there's 1 John 1:2 ("...and we look to it and testify to it and proclaim to you the eternal life, which was with the Father and was made manifest to us"). The Father was not made manifest (fleshly visible) to them; Jesus was. Therefore, Jesus is explicitly defined as "the eternal life" at the start of the letter. When John closes the letter in 5:20 by saying, "He is the true God and eternal life," he is using a title he already pinned exclusively on Jesus. If you insist that the word "only" in John 17:3 strictly excludes Jesus from being the true God, then you must consistently apply that same rule of language to 1 John 5:20. There are other biblical passages too. "...waiting for our blessed hope, the appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior Jesus Christ" (Titus 2:13). "...and from their race, according to the flesh, is the Christ, who is God over all, blessed forever". Paul does not just call Jesus God; he calls him "God over all" (Romans 9:5). This leaves no room for Jesus to be a subordinate or secondary god in a hierarchy. "But of the Son he [God the Father] says, 'Your throne, O God, is forever and ever..." (Hebrews 1:8). Here, God the Father Himself explicitly calls Jesus "O God". If the Father calls the Son "God," it is a severe theological contradiction for someone to say Jesus is not the true God. If John 17:3 means Jesus cannot be the true God because the Father is, then how do we explain Jude 1:4, which calls Jesus 'our only Master and Lord'?" Jude 1:4 says Jesus is our only Lord. 1 Corinthians 8:6 says the Father is the one God, and Jesus is the one Lord. "If 'only true God' in John 17:3 excludes Jesus from being God, then 'only Lord' in Jude 1:4 must exclude the Father from being Lord. Does the Father cease to be Lord because Jesus is the 'only Lord'? Of course not. They share the same nature. 'Only' is used to contrast the true Godhead against false pagan idols, not to separate the Father from the Son. In LDS theology, the Father and Son are two separate Gods, which directly violates the singular "only true God" language of John 17:3. "Thou believest that there is one God; thou doest well: the devils also believe, and tremble" (James 2:19). As I mentioned before, the one true God can take on human flesh and still be considered one true God. You still haven't shown the existence of a heavenly mother from scripture. It doesn't mean one God was with another separate God. Who is the very God and Father of the person you believe is your heavenly mother? By the way, the Joseph Smith Translation (JST) introduces several significant interpretive and theological difficulties into John 1:1. "In the beginning was the gospel preached through the Son. And the gospel was the word, and the word was with the Son, and the Son was with God, and the Son was of God". Compare this with the original wording of John 1:1: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God". Notice how there is no indication of two Gods? There are several problems with Joseph Smith's revision. 1] The JST creates an apparent inconsistency concerning the identity of the Word. In JST John 1:1, the Word is identified with the gospel: "And the gospel was the word". However, in JST John 1:14, we read: "And the same word was made flesh". Then, in JST John 1:16, Joseph Smith explicitly identifies the Word with Jesus Christ: "For in the beginning was the Word, even the Son". Consequently, the reader is left with an interpretive difficulty. Is the Word the gospel, as verse 1 states, or is the Word the Son, as verse 16 explicitly states? If these are two different meanings of the Word, why does verse 14 say that the same Word was made flesh? If they are the same, how should we understand the identification of the gospel with the person of Jesus Christ? Joseph Smith's revision introduces a difficulty that is absent from John's original wording. 2] The JST removes John's explicit declaration of Christ's deity. Perhaps the most significant change is the replacement of: "And the Word was God" with: "And the Son was of God". These statements are not equivalent. John's original Greek explicitly identifies the Word as God (θεός). The Word is distinguished from the Father, with whom he exists, but is nevertheless identified as God. Joseph Smith removes this explicit identification and substitutes a statement that the Son was "of God". Whatever additional meaning someone might assign to that expression, it does not communicate the same proposition as John's original declaration. This is particularly significant because the surrounding verses continue to describe the Word/Son as the Creator of all things and the source of life. 3] The JST introduces unnecessary ambiguity into the passage. In verse 2, Joseph Smith retains the statement: "The same was in the beginning with God". But verse 1 has introduced several closely related subjects: the gospel, the Word, and the Son. The reader must now determine which of these is being referred to by "the same". Although the broader passage provides some clarification, the revision makes the opening of John's Gospel unnecessarily difficult to interpret. 4] The JST changes the relationship between the Word and life. In the original text, John writes: "In him was life; and the life was the light of men". The personal Word is directly identified as the one in whom life exists. The JST instead reads: "In him was the gospel, and the gospel was the life, and the life was the light of men". This introduces another conceptual change. The gospel is now identified with the life that was in the Word. Why does Joseph Smith introduce this additional identification when John's original wording directly identifies the Word as the source of life? 5] The textual evidence does not support Joseph Smith's revision. There is no known Greek manuscript evidence supporting the alternative wording introduced by the JST. The surviving manuscript evidence consistently supports the traditional reading that the Word was God. Consequently, Joseph Smith's revision cannot be established through the available textual evidence. Its authority depends entirely upon accepting his claim that he received a revelation restoring the original meaning of the passage. Why should we accept Joseph Smith's alteration of one of the clearest biblical declarations of Christ's deity when his revision introduces interpretive difficulties that are not present in the original text? I would emphasize something else. The original John 1:1 does not merely say that Jesus existed before creation. It makes two distinct assertions: A] The Word was with God - distinguishing the Word from the Father. B] The Word was God - identifying the Word as divine (Deity). This is important because historic Christian theology does not teach that Jesus is the Father. It teaches that the Son is distinct from the Father while sharing the divine nature. The original wording establishes precisely that distinction. And John 1:3 reinforces the point: "All things were made by him; and without him was not any thing made that was made". If absolutely everything that came into existence was made through the Word, the Word cannot himself belong to the category of created things. That is an especially strong argument against attempts to portray Jesus (the pre-incarnate God) as a procreated being. Even while possessing full divinity, Jesus voluntarily placed himself under the authority of the Father to accomplish the plan of salvation. This is known as functional subordination—meaning he is equal in nature and essence, but subordinate in his role and mission. I already provided this in part one of my response. Other leaders besides Joseph Smith taught that God the Father had a Father. If you believe any of those quotes I provided are false, then please mention that LDS leader. And, it would be help if you can identify the God and Father of the person you believe is your heavenly mother. Becoming [future tense] "partakers of the divine nature" means that people do not have a divine nature right now. I don't believe God shares His unique, divine glory with anyone else. Think of it like the moon and the sun: The moon reflects the sun's light entirely, but the moon never becomes a sun. Jesus, however, doesn't just reflect the light—he is the light (Hebrews 1:3). It sounds like your premise is that if believers can be "one" with God, share His "glory," inherit His "divine nature," and sit on His "throne," then the relationship between the Father and Jesus is no different than the relationship between God and exalted humans. Sharing in relationship, reflection, and inheritance is completely different than sharing in God's unique, uncreated identity and glory. When Jesus prays that believers are "one," he is praying for relational unity and purpose among the church, not ontological unity (oneness of being). Christians become "one" in mind, heart, and mission. The glory Jesus gives to the disciples in John 17:22 is the glory of the indwelling Holy Spirit and divine grace, which allows us to reflect God. But notice the massive distinction: in John 17:5, Jesus asks for the glory he had before the world existed. Believers did not exist before the world, nor do we possess uncreated glory. Jesus has a unique glory as the Creator; we have a derived glory as the redeemed. Peter (2 Peter 1:4) is talking about moral transformation, not ontological progression into godhood. He is saying that through Christ, believers escape their sinful human nature and partake in God's holy, righteous nature (holiness, love, goodness). Here's a simple analogy: If you jump into a swimming pool, you are "partaking of the water nature"—you get wet. But you do not become water. Partaking in God's holy nature means we are filled with his Spirit to act like him, not that we evolve into a new deity. Jesus says, "The one who conquers, I will grant him to sit with me on my throne, as I also conquered and sat down with my Father on his throne". I think Latter-day Saints use this to say we get our own divine throne and ruler status over our own universes. In the ancient world, sitting on a king's throne didn't mean you became the king or co-equal in majesty. It was a high honor indicating intimate fellowship, authority, and co-reigning under the king's supreme sovereignty. In the Book of Revelation, we see the 24 elders and Christian martyrs sitting on thrones, but they are not Gods (Revelation 4:4; 20:4). Jesus is the uncreated Creator of all things (John 1:3, Colossians 1:16). He didn't progress to earn his throne; he has always been God. We, on the other hand, are created beings. A kind earthly father might let his toddler sit on his lap in the driver's seat of his car, grip the steering wheel, and share in the 'glory' of driving. But the toddler didn't build the car, he doesn't own the car, and he isn't a licensed driver. He is just sharing in his father's joy. That is what God does for us. He shares his joy, his inheritance, and his presence with us—but he never steps off his throne as the one and only true God to let us become independent gods of our own. In LDS theology, Jesus is viewed as the elder spirit brother—someone who was begotten by Heavenly Mother and progressed to godhood, just like we are trying to do. But look at what Paul says in Colossians 1. He says Jesus created all things in heaven and earth, visible and invisible, including all 'thrones and dominions.' Since Jesus created absolutely everything in heaven, that means he created the angels, he created the universe, he created Satan, and he created us. He cannot be our 'brother' in a literal, sibling sense, because a sibling doesn't create his own brothers. He is our Creator. There is a massive difference between the one who builds the house, and the people who get to live in it. But in LDS theology, Jesus did not create your heavenly mother, Satan, the Father of Heavenly Father, the world Heavenly Father grew up on, or all the other beings who became Gods before the LDS Jesus achieved his godhood. The so-called mischaracterization of LDS belief breaks down when you consider previous LDS leaders teaching of God the Father having a Father. The sons of that Grandfather God (including Heavenly Father of our Earth) are subject to their own Father God. I hope you can state which of those previously quoted teachings you believe are false. Maybe you have Mosiah 5:7 in mind? ("And now, because of the covenant which ye have made ye shall be called the children of Christ, his sons, and his daughters; for behold, this day he hath spiritually begotten you"). I think in this case, "spiritually begotten" means undergoing a spiritual rebirth and adoption into the family of Jesus Christ by making and keeping sacred covenants; not being literal spirit offspring. Origen provided the initial raw vocabulary, but because his ideas left room for ambiguity, later Church Fathers and Ecumenical Councils spent centuries tightening the definitions to safeguard monotheism. Origen was condemned for other teachings too. Example: the pre-existence of souls, that the Word of God became a cherub for cherubim and a seraph for seraphim; that the resurrection body will be spherical (an accusation that refused to die), etc. https://firstthings.com/orthodox-origen/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origenist_crises https://thewestminsterstandard.org/the-anathemas-of-the-second-council-of-constantinople/ During the first Origenist crisis around 400 AD, the church father Jerome produced a literal Latin translation of On First Principles to expose what he viewed as Origen's errors. His Letter to Avitus cataloged these exact speculative points and served as a major sourcebook for Emperor Justinian over a century later. https://catholicstand.com/origen-and-the-problem-of-posthumous-condemnation/ It seems you consider Origen more truthful on some of what he taught instead of what past LDS leaders taught (as I quote often but you refrain from labelling them as false). Origen had his errors; the LDS leaders had their errors too. You use the future tense ("will also be") whereas the passage in John 17 uses a combination of past, present, and future tense ("the glory which thou gavest me I have given them"). Traditional Christianity views the given glory as the presence of the Holy Spirit and the privilege of mimicking God's love on earth. Don't conflate John 10:30 with John 17:21. No one ever stoned the disciples for being "one in us"; a charge of blasphemy. It seems you believe Jesus is not truly God, but only a person who carries that title. God, a person, not a title, became flesh ("And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory" (1 Timothy 3:16). The early Church Fathers taught that humans could become gods through participation in God's divine nature, receiving immortality, incorruptibility, and likeness to God through Jesus Christ. They did not thereby teach Joseph Smith's doctrine that God the Father was once a mortal man who progressed to godhood, or that humans could eventually become Gods in the LDS sense. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/harvard-theological-review/article/you-are-gods-deification-in-the-naassene-writer-and-clement-of-alexandria/C80F703545F874BFF70612BFC1D92021 https://www.ect.org/en/article/deification They taught humans are deified and given thrones strictly "by grace" as an adoptive gift, never by their own natural essence or substance. Even when elevated to the status of "gods and sons" who judge and co-reign with Christ, human beings remain ontologically distinct creatures. Sitting on thrones does not turn humans into independent deities; rather, it allows them to participate in the divine life in a creaturely mode. Your argument assumes that when the Church Fathers used the word "gods" (theoi or dii), they meant independent, self-existent, divine beings—the way a modern reader or a pagan might define a god. This is historically inaccurate. Humans remain dependent upon God and worship him. LDS theology describes exalted beings as Gods of their own created worlds and spirit children in the future. For example, you don't worship the Father of Heavenly Father (a Grandfather God) – he is not your God. As the 1997 Gospel Principles said, until it was modified in the current version, "They will have their righteous family members with them and will be able to have spirit children also. These spirit children will have the same relationship to them as we do to our Heavenly Father. They will be an eternal family". As we worship the Heavenly Father (of Earth), these other LDS spirit children will worship their own Father God. The most important distinction is that participating in God's divine nature is not the same thing as becoming another God of the same ontological category as the Father. In LDS theology, Jesus becomes ranked as a God after he attains some pinnacle of intelligence (Religion 430-431 – Doctrines of the Gospel Student Manual). Neither he nor the Holy Ghost are Gods prior to them being born to a heavenly mother. Maybe you view only Heavenly Father as God by nature (your frequent use of "only true God") and Jesus and the Holy Ghost as Gods by title. By the way, which God do you believe your heavenly mother worships? Deification is a huge topic, with varying degrees of interpretation. We could go on and on about it. https://www.ect.org/en/article/deification The Bible describes the awful fate of those who don't overcome (those who don't become gods [in the LDS sense of] sitting on God's throne as you mentioned): "He that overcometh shall inherit all things; and I will be his God, and he shall be my son. But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone: which is the second death" (Revelation 21:7-8). In both Old and New Testament times, marriages were never performed in the temple, tabernacle, or synagogue. It wasn't until the Catholic Church's Council of Trent in 1563 AD—and subsequent Protestant Reformation laws—that Western religious and state institutions legally mandated that weddings be officiated by clergy inside a church building to keep legal, centralized records. According to the following FAIRLDS article, there will be no wedding ceremonies after the resurrection. In the New Testament gospels, Jesus never uses the word "sealing" nor does he explicitly draw a distinction between "sealing" and "marriage". The LDS Church interprets the binding in Matthew 16:19 as "sealing" though. https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/temples/what-happens-in-a-temple-sealing?lang=eng https://newsroom.churchofjesuschrist.org/article/temple-marriage But there is absolutely no record in the New Testament or any ancient historical text indicating that Peter or other apostles ever performed a marriage or sealed a couple inside the temple of Jerusalem. The second death is for those who are not in the first resurrection (Revelation 20:6-7). However, according to the seminary manual, those who inherit the telestial kingdom are not in the first resurrection but they don't experience the second death (Doctrine and Covenants 76:37-38). Joseph Smith taught both things during his lifetime – God is eternal and God is not God from all eternity. From previous conversations, it seems you interpret "God is not God from all eternity" in the sense of him becoming God when he became our heavenly parent or started creating worlds, but this is not in agreement with previous LDS teachings. "The progression of our Father in heaven to godhood, or exaltation, was strictly in accordance with eternal principles" (Achieving a Celestial Marriage Student Manual). "His work and His glory, He told us, is to bring to pass the immortality and eternal life of man. He has already achieved godhood. Now His only objective is to help us to enable us to return to Him and be like Him and live His kind of life eternally" (But If Not ..., Elder Dennis E. Simmons Of the Seventy, April 2004 General Conference). "Joseph Smith taught in the King Follett sermon that God was once a man and lived on an earth. [43] Other than the Prophet's statement in that particular address, this is all we know. When and how and in what manner he became God is unknown" (God and Man, Robert L. Millet, BYU). God executed judgment against the Egyptian gods. These were false deities. Isaiah is not saying that the pagan gods of Israel were real deities but that none of them could compare with the God of Israel in his power, glory, and majesty. Baal, Molech, and Chemosh are some of those gods in Psalms 86:8. I believe God exists as God eternally. There never is a time when Heavenly Father achieved his godhood (became God). Apparently there was no Godhead before Heavenly Father reached his exaltation if you believe He did not have his own Father (Grandfather) God. A previous LDS teaching even indicates only two personnages making up the Godhead: Q3. How many personages are there in the Godhead? Two: the Father and the Son. (5:1) https://lecturesonfaith.com/5/ And prior to the LDS Jesus being ranked as a God in his pre-mortal life, he wasn't even part of this Godhead. So you believe the Father is God by nature but the Son is God by title? The context of "being one" in John 10 and 17 is not the same. I explained this before. But the LDS Jesus is not an additional God when he was born to a heavenly mother. He becomes ranked as an additional God when he later attains some level of intelligence (Religion 430-431 – Doctrines of the Gospel Student Manual). The "oneness" Jesus claims in John 10 involves an exercise of divine omnipotence that human disciples could never mimic in John 17 But do you believe disciples become Gods by nature or by title? I believe this is sons of God by adoption. But in LDS theology, "sons of God" are classified as the joint-heirs; only exalted beings (Romans 8:14-17). Elder Dallin H. Oaks of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles explained, "We are all heirs of our heavenly parents. ‘We are the children of God,' the Apostle Paul taught, ‘and if children, then heirs; heirs of God, and joint-heirs with Christ' (Romans 8:16–17). This means, as we are told in the New Testament, that we are ‘heirs … of eternal life' (Titus 3:7) and that if we come to the Father, we are to ‘inherit all things' (Revelation 21:7)—all that He has—a concept our mortal minds can hardly grasp. But at least we can understand that achieving this ultimate destiny in eternity is possible only if we follow our Savior, Jesus Christ, who taught that ‘no man cometh unto the Father, but by me' (John 14:6)" (Ensign, May 2013, "Followers of Christ"). The important condition: "If children, then heirs …". All children are heirs. There is no child who is not also the heir. Origen provided the initial raw vocabulary, but because his ideas left room for ambiguity, later Church Fathers and Ecumenical Councils spent centuries tightening the definitions to safeguard monotheism. It became "The Church confesses is that God is three Persons (hypostasis) in one Essence (ousia)". https://christianity.stackexchange.com/questions/78627/why-were-ousia-and-hypostasis-synonymous-in-the-nicene-creed In LDS theology, it is three Gods. It really sounds like you don't believe that Jesus is God incarnate (truly God in human flesh), but rather just an agent with a title of God. God, a person, not a title, became flesh ("And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory" (1 Timothy 3:16). I've posted a new thread "Did Constantine Or the Church Invent the Trinity? What History Shows" to address this. https://truthstodiefor.com/did-constantine-or-the-church-invent-the-trinity/ The Book of Mormon and the testimony of the Three Witnesses agree more about the trinity than latter LDS teachings. The Latter-day Saints evolved into polytheism - the existence of a plurality of Gods. It seems you believe Jesus is only God by title, not by nature. You keep making a big thing about "the God" and God as if "the God" is a reference to Heavenly Father and Jesus is not "the God". But the Book of Mormon is full of "the God": 1] "The God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob" "For the fulness of mine intent is that I may persuade men to come unto the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, and be saved" (1 Nephi 6:4). "But behold, I will show unto you a God of miracles, even the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob..". (Mormon 9:11). See also Mosiah 7:19, Alma 29:11, and 3 Nephi 4:30. 2] "The God of Israel" "And the God of Israel yonder cometh... to be crucified by wicked men..". (1 Nephi 19:10). "When the resurrected Jesus appears in the Americas, He uses this exact title to introduce Himself: "Arise and come forth unto me... that ye may know that I am the God of Israel, and the God of the whole earth, and have been slain for the sins of the world" (3 Nephi 11:14). 3] "The God of Nature" "...many of the kings of the isles of the sea shall be wrought upon by the Spirit of God, to exclaim: The God of nature suffers" (1 Nephi 19:12). 4] Others The God of the whole earth (3 Nephi 11:14, 3 Nephi 22:5). The God of glory / The God of heaven (Alma 60:32, Ether 2:8). The God of my / our righteousness (2 Nephi 4:35). 5] Title page "And also to the convincing of the Jew and Gentile that Jesus is the Christ, the Eternal God". According to a church teaching, Heavenly Father called a Grand Council to present his plan for our progression in the pre-mortal life. Name some of the works of these gods prior to the council. Thomas, in a literal rendering of the Greek said to Jesus "The Lord of me and the God of me". If Jesus is the Lord of Thomas (my Lord), then Jesus is the God of Thomas (my God). Both titles—"My Lord" (Ho kurios mou) and "My God" (Ho theos mou)—are grammatically forced onto the exact same singular individual: Jesus. If Thomas was mistakenly addressing God the Father while looking at Jesus, or if he was separating the titles between two beings, then Jesus's immediate response in the very next verse makes no sense ("Jesus saith unto him, Thomas, because thou hast seen me, thou hast believed: blessed are they that have not seen, and yet have believed"). Jesus completely accepts the titles. He does not correct Thomas by saying, "Do not call me your God, I am just the image of the Father" We find a similar teaching in Romans 9:5 and 10:12. "To them belong the patriarchs, and from their race, according to the flesh, is the Christ, who is God over all, blessed forever. Amen" (ESV). "For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek; for the same Lord is Lord of all, bestowing his riches on all who call on him" (ESV). Christ is Lord of all and God over all. The entire climax of John's gospel builds up to Thomas's confession. John starts his gospel by saying "the Word was God" (John 1:1) and caps it off in chapter 20 with Thomas finally realizing it: "My Lord and my God". Earlier, Jesus said to Mary "I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God". There is no contradiction with John 20:28. Traditional Trinitarian theology actually requires Jesus to have a God in his human nature, while also showing that Jesus carefully separates his relationship with the Father from Mary's. When Jesus took on human flesh (John 1:14), he voluntarily submitted himself to the Father as a faithful human being. Because he is genuinely human, the Father is truly "his God". Saying Jesus calls the Father "my God" does not disprove Jesus's divinity unless you assume Jesus stopped being human after the resurrection. Since Jesus rose in a physical human body, he continues to relate to the Father as the perfect human mediator. Look closely at the exact wording in John 20:17. Jesus does not say, "I am ascending to our Father and our God". Instead, Jesus splits the phrase in two: "my Father and your Father, my God and your God". Throughout the Gospels, Jesus never includes himself with the disciples when calling God "our Father" (the Lord's Prayer was a model for them to pray). He purposefully chooses not to say "I ascend unto our Father," maintaining the theological boundary between his unique, divine status as the Only Begotten Son and humanity's status as children of God. In the Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5–7), Jesus uses the title "Father" about 17 times. He uses "Your Father" (or "Thy Father") 16 times. At the very end of the sermon, he switches to "My Father". The Book of Mormon also borrows this differentiation of "our Father" vs. "my Father". The exact phrase "our Father" is found only once, in 3 Nephi 13:9. If I am not mistaken, the linguistic separation is maintained in the Pearl of Great Price and Doctrines and Covenants. If you argue that calling the Father "my God" means Jesus cannot be God himself, then look at Hebrews 1:8–9, which uses both concepts in a single breath. God calls Jesus "God". In verse 8, God the Father speaks directly to the Son and says, "Your throne, O God, is forever and ever". God also has a God. Immediately afterward, in verse 9, the Father says to the Son, "Therefore God, your God, has anointed you with the oil of gladness". Ah. I see. You believe Jesus is truly God because he was given a title. Therefore, the LDS Jesus is not God before he is given that title; so he is not God from all eternity. LDS doctrine shows he was ranked as a God when he reached some level of intelligence. God, the being, not a title, became flesh ("And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory" (1 Timothy 3:16). The presence of an angel in Revelation does not overwrite Christ's personal, divine identity, nor does the text allow the angel to steal Christ's unique titles. The Book of Revelation explicitly shifts between the narrative voice of the angel, the voice of John, and the direct, unmediated voice of the resurrected Jesus Christ. Look at Revelation 1:17–18. John falls at his feet as dead, and the speaker says: "Fear not; I am the first and the last: I am he that liveth, and was dead; and, behold, I am alive for evermore, Amen; and have the keys of hell and of death". An angel cannot say this. When John tries to worship the angel, the angel says "See thou do it not: for I am thy fellowservant... worship God" (Revelation 22:9). If the angel was acting as a flawless conduit of Jesus's personal divine identity, and if "bearing the image" allowed him to accept divine titles or representation, he would not have refused worship. Contrast this directly with John 20:28 (which you brought up earlier). When Thomas calls Jesus "My Lord and my God," Jesus accepts the worship and praises Thomas's faith. If Jesus was just an "agent" or "image" of the Father in the same way the angel is an agent of Jesus, Jesus would have been forced to say, "See thou do it not, I am thy fellow servant, don't call me your God" The fact that Jesus accepts what Thomas said while the angel rejects it proves Jesus is God, and the angel is merely a creature. You quote Revelation 22:16 ("I Jesus have sent mine angel..".) to prove the angel is talking. But look at what happens in the text. The moment the angel delivers the message, Jesus himself breaks into the text in the first person to close the book. In verse 12, the speaker says, "And, behold, I come quickly; and my reward is with me, to give every man according to his work". In verse 13, he declares, "I am Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the end, the first and the last". Then in verse 16, he clarifies, "I Jesus have sent mine angel..". If the angel is still the one speaking in verse 16, then the angel is saying, "I [the angel] have sent mine angel". That makes no linguistic sense. The sentence structure demands that Jesus has taken over the dialogue to stamp his personal authority on the final warnings of the book. The Book of Revelation utilizes an angel as a guide, but the theology of the book relies entirely on the supreme, uncompromised deity of Jesus Christ. An angel can carry a message, but an angel cannot claim to be the "Alpha and Omega," cannot accept worship, and cannot claim to have been dead and made alive. If you claim Jesus isn't the one speaking in Revelation because an angel was involved, you have to apply that same rule to your own scriptures. The Doctrine and Covenants is supposedly filled with Jesus speaking in the first person, yet LDS theology says angels were heavily involved in the Restoration. If the presence of an angel erases Jesus's direct voice in the Bible, it erases it in the D&C too. If you believe Jesus is truly speaking to Joseph Smith in the D&C, you must accept He is truly speaking to John in Revelation. In the Book of Mormon, angels never claim to be God, they never speak as if they are Jesus Christ in the first person, and they actively correct anyone who confuses them with God. In Isaiah 44:6, God declares, "I am the first and I am the last; apart from me there is no God". When Jesus says I am the first and the last in the Book of Revelation (1:17-18; 2:8; 22:13), he is claiming to be God. In Revelation 1:8, the Lord God says, "I am the Alpha and the Omega... who is, and who was, and who is to come, the Almighty". It appears again in Revelation 21:6 spoken by the one seated on the throne, and finally in Revelation 22:13, where Jesus applies it to himself alongside "the First and the Last, the Beginning and the End". This Lord God is Christ. Deuteronomy 4:35 - "the LORD he is God; there is none else beside him". Deuteronomy 6:4 - "The LORD our God is one LORD". Isaiah 45:5 - "I am the LORD, and there is none else, there is no God beside me". See also Romans 9:5 and 10:12. See "Did Constantine Or the Church Invent the Trinity? What History Shows" https://truthstodiefor.com/did-constantine-or-the-church-invent-the-trinity/ While the idea of three Gods in the Godhead is absent from canonical scripture, it comes directly from Joseph Smith ("I have always declared God to be a distinct personage, Jesus Christ a separate and distinct personage from God the Father, and that the Holy Ghost was a distinct personage and a Spirit: and these three constitute three distinct personages and three Gods"). Can you give me an authoritative source for what you just said? Apparently you know something Robert L. Millet doesn't. These three LDS teachings show God is an exalted man: 1] "The progression of our Father in heaven to godhood, or exaltation, was strictly in accordance with eternal principles" (Achieving a Celestial Marriage Student Manual). 2] "His work and His glory, He told us, is to bring to pass the immortality and eternal life of man. He has already achieved godhood. Now His only objective is to help us to enable us to return to Him and be like Him and live His kind of life eternally" (But If Not ..., Elder Dennis E. Simmons Of the Seventy, April 2004 General Conference). https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/general-conference/2004/04/but-if-not?lang=eng 3] "Joseph Smith taught in the King Follett sermon that God was once a man and lived on an earth. [43] Other than the Prophet's statement in that particular address, this is all we know. When and how and in what manner he became God is unknown" (God and Man, Robert L. Millet, BYU). https://rsc.byu.edu/no-weapon-shall-prosper/god-man But LDS leaders don't teach what you just said. See 1], 2], 3] just mentioned immediately above. By them, I understand that God, once a man, achieved his godhood. "When and how and in what manner he became God is unknown" (Robert L. Millet). God the Father "becoming" a God means he is not eternally God. I understand your point about God the Father being the most intelligent of all other eternal beings, but you need to caveat this with "only within his realm". You still haven't considered all the previous LDS teachings that God the Father had a Father and that he [Heavenly Father] achieved godhood. LDS theology has Jesus being ranked as a God when he reached some pinnacle of intelligence, not because he started creating worlds. The LDS Heavenly Mother does not become a God by having spirit children.
  3. Your argument from Acts 17:28–29 does not establish the LDS doctrine of literal spiritual offspring of a heavenly mother. First, the Greek word *genos* does not, by itself, establish biological or spiritual reproduction. It can refer to offspring, family, stock, lineage, or kind. Its precise meaning must be determined by its context. Simply pointing out that the word can mean offspring does not establish the specific theological claim you are making. Second, look at the context. In Acts 17:24–25, Paul identifies God as the Creator of the world and everything in it, emphasizing that God gives all humanity life, breath, and everything else. He then quotes the Greek poet Aratus in verse 28, using the expression "we are also his offspring". His argument is that humanity derives its existence from God and therefore God cannot be represented by lifeless idols. Nothing in this passage discusses premortal spirit children, heavenly procreation, or a heavenly mother producing spirit children. Third, the Bible frequently uses family language to describe humanity's relationship with God without implying literal reproduction. Romans 8:15–16, for example, explicitly describes believers becoming God's children through adoption. John 1:12 and Galatians 4:4–7 likewise describe becoming children of God through faith and redemption in Christ. Finally, your statement that God has not revealed what literal offspring means actually highlights the problem. If the nature of this alleged literal offspring relationship has not been revealed, how can you confidently claim that Acts 17 establishes the LDS doctrine of literal spiritual parentage through marriage? The passage does not explain such a process, nor does it establish that God has a heavenly wife or that human spirits were produced through divine procreation. The biblical teaching that God is our Father does not require the LDS interpretation. God is our Father as our Creator and Sustainer, and he makes believers his children through adoption in Christ. You are reading a much more specific LDS doctrine into a passage that simply does not teach it. Lacking many of the attributes of a mature God does not detract from LDS leaders teaching that man is a God in embryo, albeit an immature God. Early Church Fathers did not teach men and women are Gods in embryo. Take a look at Acts 14:12-15. When the people of Lystra attempt to identify Paul and Barnabas as gods, Paul doesn't suggest that they are gods in embryo, that they possess divine potential, or that they might eventually become mature Gods. Instead, he emphatically rejects their identification and directs them to the living God, the Creator of all things. "Men, why are you doing these things? We also are men, of like nature with you" (verse 15). Paul uses genos to establish humanity's relationship to God, not to establish that human beings share God's exact nature or can eventually become Gods. Several past LDS leaders taught God the Father had a Father (uppercase, F), using father (lowercase, f) in other instances. They have the same meaning, albeit appearing different from how you depict it. I'll address it further below. You would presume this Father (this Grandfather God) also had billions of sons and daughters; likely some who became Gods before one specific son achieved godhood and became the Heavenly Father of our Earth. Let me know which of these teachings you believe are false and leading people astray: Joseph Smith: "If Jesus Christ was the son of God, and John discovered that God the Father of Jesus Christ had a Father, you may suppose that he had a Father also. Where was there ever a son without a father? and where was there ever a father without first being a son? Whenever did a tree or anything spring into existence without a progenitor? And every thing comes in this way. Paul says that which is earthly is in the likeness of that which is Heavenly; hence if Jesus had a father, can we not believe that he had a father also? I despise the idea of being scared to death at such doctrine, for the bible is full of it. I want you all to pay particular attention to what I am saying. Jesus [HC 6:476] said that the Father wrought precisely in the same way as his Father had done before — as the Father had done before, he laid down his life and took it up same as his Father had done before; he did as he was sent, to lay down his life and take it up again, and then was committed unto him the Keys. I know it is good reasoning" (Joseph Smith Papers). The first part shows the Father (Heavenly Father) had a Father. The second part shows what the LDS Father did – he laid down his life as Jesus did. He (the Father) did as he was sent; by the Grandfather of Jesus. Source 1 "If Abraham reasoned thus—If Jesus Christ was the Son of God, and John discovered that God the Father of Jesus Christ had a Father, you may suppose that He had a Father also. Where was there ever a son without a father? And where was there ever a father without first being a son? Whenever did a tree or anything spring into existence without a progenitor? And everything comes in this way. Paul says that which is earthly is in the likeness of that which is heavenly, Hence if Jesus had a Father, can we not believe that He had a Father also? I despise the idea of being scared to death at such a doctrine, for the Bible is full of it. [5]" Source 2 Joseph Fielding Smith: "Evidently his Father passed through a period of mortality even as he passed through mortality, and as we all are doing. Our Father in heaven, according to the Prophet, had a Father, and since there has been a condition of this kind through all eternity, each Father had a Father, until we come to a stop where we cannot go further, because of our limited capacity to understand" (Joseph Fielding Smith, Doctrines of Salvation). Orson Pratt: "We were begotten by our Father in Heaven; the person of our Father in Heaven was begotten on a previous heavenly world by His Father; and again, He was begotten by a still more ancient Father; and so on, from generation to generation, . . . we wonder in our minds, how far back the genealogy extends, and how the first world was formed, and the first father was begotten" (The Seer). George Q. Cannon: "He came here, was born, had a father and mother like you have. Well, who was his father? Why God was His father; and who was God's father? Why God had a father like you and I have" (Gospel Truths, volume 1). Spencer W. Kimball: "We must be grafted into the true vine, and continue to partake of its fatness, and then we shall go back to our Father and God, who is connected with one who is still farther back; and this Father is connected with one still further back, and so on; and just so far as we respect our superiors and try to save our children, so shall we receive blessings from this time forth and forever, and shall become as numerous as the sands upon the seashore" (Journal of Discourses 5:5). A few questions come to mind: Was he begotten by that "father" and "mother" through sexual relations? Or was he born of his virgin "mother"? Who is the God and Father of that "woman" that begat the mortal body of the man who would later become the Heavenly Father of our Earth? Consider all the other people who lived on that world where the LDS Heavenly Father is said to have had a mortal experience. What is their literal spiritual parentage – whose offspring are? Joseph Smith said "The heads of the Gods appointed one God for us". You only mentioned Jesus. Maybe he is the God you believe the Gods appointed for us. But who are the heads [plural] of the Gods? Already addressed above. While the LDS Church officially affirms the doctrine of a heavenly mother, it has not identified a specific revelation, vision, or prophetic declaration in which God first revealed this doctrine to Joseph Smith or any another prophet. Thanks. I found something similar in the seminary manual. Yes. Apparently there will be a literal biological generation of spirit children in the LDS doctrine of eternal increase. I already addressed this above. But I think it's only the LDS Church that has introduced a heavenly mother to try to make sense of what Paul is saying. The prophets and apostles never taught that God was married and we are the spirit offspring of a heavenly mother. You never do say whether you believe your heavenly mother had a God and Father herself and was a saved sinner. Either she had a Father and God or she didn't? Which is it? Either she was a saved sinner or she was not. Which is it? Based on the LDS teachings that I mentioned earlier, it is reasonable to believe they [past LDS leaders] taught she had a God and Father – this would be the Grandfather God I keep referring to. Who is the God of the father and mother of that man who had an earthly experience and later became Heavenly Father of our Earth? I understand your point about getting a "higher exaltation" but you are not considering all the LDS teachings that God the Father, once a man, became a God. He obtained his exaltation. But you keep referring to how God became God in the sense of God only becoming a Father, another time where he becomes a God by creating worlds (I think you said both those things). I'll just provide a few. Let me know which of these are false and leading people astray: [1] "Through a continual course of progression, our Heavenly Father has received exaltation and glory; and He points us out the same path ... we shall eventually come in possession ... of everything that heart can desire" (Religion 430-431 - Doctrines of the Gospel Student Manual, chapter 33). [2] "Mormon prophets have continuously taught the sublime truth that God the Eternal Father was once a mortal man who passed through a school of earth life similar to that through which we are now passing. He became God-an exalted being-through obedience to the same eternal Gospel truths that we are given opportunity today to obey" (The Gospel Through the Ages, 1945). [3] "The doctrine that God was once a man and has progressed to become a God is unique to this Church" (Teachings of Brigham Young, chapter 4). [4] "The progression of our Father in heaven to godhood, or exaltation, was strictly in accordance with eternal principles" (Achieving a Celestial Marriage Student Manual). [5] "Joseph Smith taught in the King Follett sermon that God was once a man and lived on an earth. Other than the Prophet's statement in that particular address, this is all we know. When and how and in what manner he became God is unknown" (God and Man, Robert L. Millet, BYU). [6] "We believe in a God who is Himself progressive, whose majesty is intelligence; whose perfection consists in eternal advancement; the perpetual work of whose creation stands "finished, yet renewed forever;" [2]—a Being who has attained His exalted state by a path which now His children are permitted to follow; whose glory it is their heritage to share" (James E. Talmage, The Articles of Faith, Lecture 24, Article 13, "Practical Religion"). It's interesting that you would place President Joseph Field Smith into this camp of "some English speaking people". He said, "We must believe in God as the possessor of the fullness of all these characteristics and attributes. I say also that he is an infinite and eternal being, and as an unchangeable being, he possesses these perfected powers and attributes from everlasting to everlasting, which means from eternity to eternity" (Ensign, May 1971, "The Most Important Knowledge"). It seems you believe the President was in error. And error leads people astray. You point to attributes, whereas I refer to his eternal nature of existence as Deity. I see that the LDS Jesus has not existed from all eternity to all eternity as God. He became a God when he reached some pinnacle of intelligence, as taught in Religion 430-431 – Doctrines of the Gospel Student Manual. Even the LDS Heavenly Father became a god, obtained his exaltation, as earlier teachings show. So, this God did not have specific attributes eternally. Was he always a God? No. Was he always married? No. Was he at any time a married person without spirit offspring? Yes. That period when he had no spirit offspring ended with the birth of Christ as the first spirit child of his wife. Proverbs 8:22–25 describes Wisdom as existing before the earth, mountains, and depths. There are three important expressions in the original Hebrew: In verse 22, it is qanah (possessed, acquired, or created. In verse 23, it is nissakhti (established, appointed, or installed). In verses 24-25, it is cholalti (brought forth, given birth). The Hebrew word in verse 22, qanah, is particularly controversial. It can be translated as "possessed" (as in the KJV) or "created" (as in several modern translations). For example: - KJV: "The LORD possessed me". - NIV: "The LORD brought me forth". - ESV: "The LORD possessed me". The point is that wisdom is not something God acquired after creation. God's wisdom is fundamental to his identity and nature. Even if someone interprets the expression "brought forth" as indicating a beginning for Wisdom, that does not establish a beginning for God. The passage distinguishes between God and the poetic personification of Wisdom. It does not say that God himself came into existence or that he did not possess wisdom as one of his attributes. It seems that only exalted beings (those who become Gods) are the only ones really considered the sons of God. This would fit with the LDS Church's interpretation of Romans 8:14-17. When Heavenly Father was born into mortality on some other world, was he born through sexual relations between a man and woman? Was he the firstborn in the flesh or spirit in any way? "God hath fulfilled the same unto us their children, in that he hath raised up Jesus again; as it is also written in the second psalm, Thou art my Son, this day have I begotten thee". No connection with a heavenly mother. "…and Jacob the father of Joseph the husband of Mary, of whom Jesus was born, who is called Christ". Jesus did not have a biological grandparent since Joseph was not Christ's biological father. Calling Jacob Jesus' legal grandfather is an explanation of the genealogical relationship, not an explicit title used in the passage. The genealogy establishes Jesus' legal Davidic ancestry. So you believe Satan had agency before he became the spirit brother of Jesus? According to LDS teachings, the Fall was ordained to occur. Adam did what he had to do. "Adam did only what he had to do. He partook of that fruit for one good reason, and that was to open the door to bring you and me and everyone else into this world, for Adam and Eve could have remained in the Garden of Eden; they could have been there to this day, if Eve hadn't done something" (Ensign, Jan 2006) Others taught the Fall of Adam and Eve was not an unforeseen consequence of human disobedience but was deliberately incorporated into God's plan. Brigham Young explicitly stated that God had designed that Adam and Eve should fall. "Did [Adam and Eve] come out in direct opposition to God and to his government? No. But they transgressed a command of the Lord, and through that transgression sin came into the world. The Lord knew they would do this, and he had designed that they should". Bruce C. Hafen called it a deliberate part of the plan of salvation. "The Fall was not a disaster. It wasn't a mistake or an accident. It was a deliberate part of the plan of salvation ... Yet our Father's plan subjects us to temptation and misery in this fallen world as the price to comprehend authentic joy" (Ensign, May 2004, "The Atonement: All for All"). Also reproduced in the Book of Mormon Teacher Manual. Russell M. Nelson taught that the plan required the Fall. "The plan required the Creation, and that in turn required both the Fall and the Atonement. These are the three fundamental components of the plan. The creation of a paradisiacal planet came from God. Mortality and death came into the world through the Fall of Adam. Immortality and the possibility of eternal life were provided by the Atonement of Jesus Christ. The Creation, the Fall, and the Atonement were planned long before the actual work of the Creation began" (in Conference Report, Apr. 2000, 105; or Ensign, May 2000, 84)". Imagine that. Disobedience was required for the LDS Adam and Eve to begin the first step to their potential exaltation. Satan could have frustrated the entire plan by not doing anything. Or maybe we can't blame Satan either because he did what he had to do in order to carry out what the LDS God had intended and designed before creation. This raises some important theological questions: Question 1: If the Fall was deliberately designed and required by God's plan, why was disobedience to God's command the necessary means of accomplishing that plan? Question 2: Why did God make disobedience necessary to fulfill His plan? Saying that God anticipated their choice does not fully answer why he designed the circumstances in which disobedience was necessary. Question 3: Where does the Bible say Adam and Eve could not have children without disobeying God? Genesis never explicitly says that they were biologically incapable of having children before eating the fruit. Neither does it say animals could not reproduce. Question 4: Does calling it a transgression (some LDS leaders and the Book of Mormon call it sin) change the fact that God prohibited it? God prohibited the action. Adam and Eve did precisely what was prohibited. Calling it a necessary transgression does not change the fact that they disobeyed an explicit commandment. The difficulty I see with the LDS explanation is that it portrays disobedience to God's explicit command as a necessary component of his plan. God commanded Adam not to eat from the tree, yet LDS theology teaches that Adam needed to eat from it for humanity to exist, experience mortality, and progress. I understand the LDS distinction between God designing the circumstances and forcing Adam and Eve to make their choice. However, that still leaves an important question: Why would an all-wise and omnipotent God make the violation of his own commandment a necessary requirement for accomplishing his plan? Why could he not accomplish his purposes without requiring humanity's first parents to disobey him? Furthermore, where does the Bible explicitly teach that Adam and Eve were incapable of having children without first violating God's command? Answer: it does not. "Simply used" is an understatement. It's more like the above teachings that God designed and planned for disobedience to be the means for Adam and Eve to begin their journey of progression. Apparently, according to Gospel Principles, agency (the ability to choose between good and evil) also existed in some pre-mortal life.
  4. And lòoking shabby…
  5. Meanwhile, you’ve got me wondering if you’re one of those who believes in the putative God of perfect love and mercy who turns his back on majority of the human race and abandons them to the horrors of an endless hell of unimaginable agony and sorrow? If you are, you have to admit that living forever in a heavenly kingdom of glory in the presence of Jesus Christ is a merciful arrangement of salvation that’s light years ahead of the so-called “plan of salvation” of the God of the Creeds who behaves more like a bloodthirsty idolatrous god of Old Testament on steroids. I say this because while the devotees of Baal and Moloch had the ability to kill the bodies of their victims they lacked the wherewithal to be able to mercilessly and senselessly torture them forever. A textbook example of straining at a gnat while swallowing a camel.
  6. smelling not good
  7. It's relative, I guess. To one who doesn't want godhood may not seem like a tragedy, but a tragedy to those who do. Or the possibility the judgments are fixed and no retry if you change your mind after a few centuries of reflection.
  8. Yesterday
  9. I don’t believe that time and therefore interaction works the same way in the next life as this one. Don’t ask me to support the idea it’s like mortality since I think that’s highly unlikely, nonsense even. I think hierarchies are unlikely as well if there is an actual oneness. The idea that being born in the less than a blink moment that is mortality earlier than another of your ‘lineage’ will somehow give you eternal authority over another who has existed forever as well…at least if you are male…is irrational as well, imo. My guess is we will have other senses and ways of communication that essentially allow us to be in more than one place at once in terms of interacting with others. I don’t believe we can conceive what it will be like to exist at the level that God and his resurrected family do.
  10. What would be the tragedy of not wanting to be a god. What do you think the difference would be between becoming a god and choosing not to?
  11. 1 second every 16 centuries. Yeah that doesn't really interest me enough to build my whole life around. Now it makes me wonder how long judgement day is going to take. That's a long time to be waiting for your one second meeting with God. Can you tell me why you are so looking forward to all of this? Or is it all just abstract thinking because we really have no idea what being a god really entails.
  12. There might be an Eternal Progression loophole in whether people can move between kingdoms after mortality. Why would learning, evolving, and progressing ever stop even in a lesser kingdom? Under this view, lower kingdom’s could just be a slower, more tailored pace for those who weren’t interested in the heavy-duty track of godhood. If Doctrine and Covenants 76 says is correct that the glory of the lesser kingdoms are so overwhelming and wonderful that "surpasses all understanding," and that inhabitants will be genuinely happy. Or is ignorance bliss and they may not have the capacity for it. Happiness is about being in the place that matches your capacity and desires. If someone genuinely doesn't want the burden of godhood then being handed a universe maybe would feel like a punishment. The LDS paradigm is generally that heaven is custom-fit to what you actually want.
  13. If gods fix everything in the end, the only true tragedies are those who don't pursue greatness. For anyone who despises injustice, it might feel great to be able to put everything right. This make makes the concept of divine justice appealing, rather than a heavy burden.
  14. In Solomon’s Jerusalem Temple, the Upper Chambers (aliyyot) sat directly above the Holy of Holies and were overlaid with pure gold, signifying that they possessed the exact same level of supreme sanctity as the Holy of Holies itself (1 Chronicles 28:11; 2 Chronicles 3:9). In Hebrew tradition (such as Mishnah, Middot 4:5), these upper chambers were strictly off-limits except for the highest rites. Marriages of the royal order took place in "a special room on top of the temple building" (Raphael Patai, On Jewish Folklore, 123), often described as the "sacred hut" or "bridal chamber" (Aubrey R. Johnson, Sacred Kingship in Ancient Israel) The Temple of Herod in Jerusalem was under the control of the Sanhedrin. Christians did not have the clout to have free reign of that temple, they only obtain access by submitting to the Jewish priests there (Acts 24:18). During the day light hours, Christ utilized the Temple by teaching the masses outside the Temple, while during the night, Christ taught only to his inner circle of disciples on a mountain called the "Mount of Olives" (Luke 21:37-38) as was his "wont" or custom (Luke 22:39). For the next 700 years, the Christians that lived there called the Mount of Olives, "the sanctuary of the Lord, that is, the Temple" to be built in the future. Thus, Emperor Constantine’s mother built a "sacred church and temple on the very summit". On the Mountain of Olives was also a cave, "authentic history informs us that this very cave the savior imparted ineffable mysteries to his disciples" (Philip Schaft, Nicene and Post Nicene Fathers, Eusebias [1994], p531; Eusebius, Life of Constantine 3:43) Jesus initiated his disciples in aporrhetois mysteriis is literally "secret mysteries". In the first-century Greek New Testament, mysteries specifically denoted secret initiatory rites, and that early Christian writers like Clement, Origen, and Basil explicitly applied that exact meaning to Christian ordinances like baptism, anointing, and the eucharist, keeping them hidden from the uninitiated. Saul, with his new name of Paul, explicitly calls marriage a "great mystery" (Ephesians 5:31–32). To suggest the true Davidic King Jesus restored most but not all the Davidic enthronement rites would be so strange. Early Christian texts like The Gospel of Philip (in the Nag Hammadi library) explicitly lists five sacred mysteries of early Christianity. "The Lord did everything in a mystery: a baptism and a chrism [anointing] and a eucharist and a redemption and a bridal chamber." (Gospel of Philip 67:27–30) Historical evidence that the 2nd century Christians were already practicing a structured sequence of five temple-style initiatory ordinances. A sacred marriage as an old temple style ordinance existed in early Christian memory.
  15. Let's be clear about this, because many people confuse the idea of whether or not Jesus can rightfully be called "God" with "The Trinity". The core problem of the Trinity is not over the divinity of Jesus Christ, but with how Jesus and his Father are "one God". Now a quote from the article: First of all, it is clear from contemporary documents that Constantine DID "push the key word homoousious". He is the individual that is reported to have added the word to the Nicene Creed. The "Letter of Eusebius of Caesarea to his church regarding the Nicene Creed" attests to this act. A statement of faith was put forth by the council, and then Eusebius reports: "There was nothing to contradict in this statement of faith we put forward. In fact our most pious Emperor, before anyone else, testified that it was comprised of most orthodox statements. He even confessed that such were his own sentiments, and he advised all present to agree to it, and to subscribe and agree with its articles, with the insertion of the single word, 'of the same being as' [homoousios]. He gave his interpretation of this word, saying that '<the Son> was not ‘of the same being as’ according to what we experience in our bodies, as if the Son had come to be by a dividing or breaking off from the Father. For his nature could not be subjected to any bodily experiences, as it does not consist of matter, exists in a spiritual realm, has no body. Therefore such things must be thought of in divine, unspeakable concepts.' Such were the theological remarks of our most wise and most pious Emperor; but they were intent on adding the word 'of the same being as'." It's easy to see how most of those at the council agreed to the inclusion of the word (only 2 refused to sign), because even Latter-day Saints might agree with the way it was explained at the council. Eusebius goes on to explain their reasoning (in the letter linked above): "As this formula was being debated, we made sure to inquire in what sense they introduced 'from the essence of the Father,' and 'of the same being as the Father.' [homoousious] Through intense questioning and explaining, the meaning of the words was examined closely. They explained that the phrase 'of the same being as' indicated that the Son is truly from the Father, but he is not a part of him. We felt we could agree to this word when used in this sense, to teach, as it did, that the Son was from the Father, not however a part of his essence. On this account we agreed to the sense ourselves, without denying even the term 'of the same being as,' since maintaining peace was our goal, provided we did not depart from the orthodox understanding." But, as the article explains, there was a lot of disagreement in the years that followed over what exactly the word meant. The problem with "The Trinity" comes from the way that the word is interpreted NOW. This comes from the article: THE CLAIM WHAT IT WOULD HAVE TO MEAN IS IT TRUE? The church invented the belief Christians before AD 325 didn’t worship the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit as one God. The idea simply wasn’t there. Of course not. The written evidence runs from the first century onwards, as we shall see. The church invented the vocabulary Words such as “Trinity” and “of one substance” were developed later to protect a belief the church already held. Yes—and the church doesn’t hide this. It’s no secret. The words above that I put in red are absolutely false. That is clear from the discussion about the meaning of "homoousious" as described in the letter from Eusebius (above) that they were led to believe the word meant something other than what it says above in red. They were MISled into accepting this. And what follows is how homoousious is understood TODAY (not at the time it was introduced): In the book The Forgotten Trinity, in a chapter titled "What Is the Trinity?", under what is called a "Basic Definition," the author James White writes: "Within the one Being that is God, there exists eternally three coequal and coeternal persons, namely, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit" (The Forgotten Trinity - Recovering the Heart of Christian Belief, by James R. White (1998, Bethany House Publishers), p.26, emphasis added) On the next page, James paraphrases Hank Hanegraaff, of the Christian Research Institute, whom I have often heard repeat this statement of belief on his radio show ("The Bible Answerman"): "[W]hen speaking of the Trinity, we need to realize that we are talking about one what and three who's. The one what is the Being or essence of God, the three who's are the Father, Son, and Spirit. We dare not mix up the what's and who's regarding the Trinity" (ibid, p.27) In the book Why You Should Believe in the Trinity, Robert M. Bowman, Jr, states a similar belief: "Another aspect of God's oneness is the fact that there are no separations or divisions or partitions in God. The trinitarian doctrine holds that God is a single infinite being, transcending the bounds of space and time, having no body either material or spiritual (except the body that the Son assumed in becoming a man). Thus the trinitarian God has no parts. You cannot divide infinite being into components. The Athanasian Creed affirms that God is not divided by the three persons when it states that the trinitarian faith does not allow for "dividing the substance" (using "substance" to mean the essence or being of God). The three persons, consequently, are not three parts of God, but three personal distinctions within God, each of whom is fully God" (Why You Should Believe in the Trinity - An Answer to Jehovah's Witnesses, Robert M. Bowman, Jr., 1989 Baker Book House, pp.12-13) And from the Got Questions website article, What is the meaning of homoousious?: "The issue was settled at the Council of Nicaea. The bishops of the church discussed and debated the issue and finally decided by overwhelming majority that homoousious (“same substance”) best encapsulates the teaching of the New Testament on the nature of Jesus. The Nicene Creed was the result of this meeting and reads in part, 'We believe in one Lord, Jesus Christ, the only Son of God, eternally begotten of the Father, God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God, begotten, not made, of one Being with the Father.' That last phrase of one being is a translation of the Greek word homoousious. The word homoousious is not found in Scripture, but the Council felt this was the best word to describe orthodox biblical teaching concerning Christ." So did Constantine invent "The Trinity"? No. But he is directly responsible starting the controversy that messed up "the Godhead" by adding the word that modern Christians use to define God the Father and Jesus Christ as "one being" or "one substance", and this is a totally unbiblical concept. Why couldn't they just stick with the definition of how Jesus and his Father are "one" as Jesus provided for us in the Bible that was believed by the Christians prior to Nicaea?
  16. A non-LDS perspective is found here: https://truthstodiefor.com/did-constantine-or-the-church-invent-the-trinity/ I found the following mentioned in a FairLDS article. A few highlights: Thus the New Testament itself is far from any doctrine of the Trinity or of a triune God who is three co-equal Persons of One Nature. There is no formal doctrine of the Trinity in the New Testament writers, if this means an explicit teaching that in one God there are three co-equal divine persons ... The Biblical witness to God, as we have seen, did not contain any formal or formulated doctrine of the Trinity, any explicit teaching that in one God there are three co-equal divine persons. The Church had to wait for more than three hundred years for a final synthesis, for not until the Council of Constantinople [AD 381] was the formula of one God existing in three coequal Persons formally ratified. It looks like the main focus here is on whether the Trinity is three coequal Persons instead of looking at another aspect of the Godhead. The Book of Mormon doesn't really get into whether the Trinity is made up of three coequal Persons, though it does teach that it consists of one God instead of three. "And now, behold, this is the doctrine of Christ, and the only true doctrine of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, which is one God, without end. Amen" (2 Nephi 31:21). "... dwell in the presence of God in his kingdom, to sing ceaseless praises with the choirs above, unto the Father, and unto the Son, and unto the Holy Ghost, which are one God ... " (Mormon 7:7). "... and be arraigned before the bar of Christ the Son, and God the Father, and the Holy Spirit, which is one Eternal God ... " (Alma 11:44). Amulek earlier recounted how an angel told him there was only one God (Alma 11:26-31). One aspect of it would later be redefined by Joseph Smith. "I have always declared God to be a distinct personage, Jesus Christ a separate and distinct personage from God the Father, and that the Holy Ghost was a distinct personage and a Spirit: and these three constitute three distinct personages and three Gods". But I cannot find any teachings prior to 1844 to support his "I have always declared ... these three constitute ... three Gods" statement. And this is despite a supposed revelation dated around 1829-1830: "Which Father, Son, and Holy Ghost are one God, infinite and eternal, without end. Amen" (Doctrine and Covenants 20:28). According to Church History Topics, all seven lectures (the Lectures on Faith) "were published together later that year in the first edition of the Doctrine and Covenants, the lectures constituting the "doctrine," and Joseph Smith's revelations, the "covenants". Lecture 5 taught the Holy Spirit was not regarded as a personage in the Godhead. Q3. How many personages are there in the Godhead? Two: the Father and the Son. (5:1) Q4: How do you prove that there are two personages in the Godhead? By the Scriptures. The Holy Spirit is identified as the mind of the Father and the Son, rather than being identified as a third personage alongside them. All seven lectures (the doctrine portion) were removed later. It should also be noted that the Book of Mormon itself, to borrow a phrase from the FairLDS article, is far from any doctrine of humans becoming coequal with God in the LDS sense of becoming gods equal in power, might, and dominion (Doctrine and Covenants 76:95).
  17. Sounds like visitation rights, but not dwelling with him in his kingdom.
  18. None of this had anything to do with New Testament Christians and the Jerusalem temple. They weren't even married in it.
  19. This is how I see it too, and the role is "in God", and having God's name put upon us. I think the modern definition of "God" as an ontologically distinct being is what totally messes with people's thinking on this topic.
  20. "And I knew such a man, (whether in the body, or out of the body, I cannot tell: God knoweth) How that he was caught up into paradise, and heard unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter." (2 Corinthians 12:3–4) The bottom line: There are things that believers are given that are to be kept sacred (or secret), and the Bible shows this to be true.
  21. It was obviously enjoyable for me.. Thanks for catching my attention….
  22. Seems like I was way under thinking it. Then again, would the number also depend on what part of the year one was born, what part of the year one died , and which year in the leap year rotation you were born? My number assumed exactly 100 years and yet if one lives to be 100, there is plenty of variance in the number of days involved. Sorry for the derail.
  23. This…it just ends up leading to some crazy set up when plopped down into eternity/the fullness of universe. Not very functional here and gets worse the more involved over time and space. The majority of scripture was not written in a culture where the nuclear family was the primary relationship for an individual. More like an extended family network.
  24. Why assume it would be like now that? Even now lots of work gets delegated and scripture seems to indicate God works that way. It’s the socializing that is a problem in my view. The rules of mortality can’t be meaningful imo in eternity because even given infinite time how can God meaningfully dwell with the over 50 billion inhabiting the Celestial Kingdom (estimate is around 117 billion human have lived on earth, pre puberty mortality rate was likely around 50% for most of history), assuming our bodies take up the same amount of space. While the perfected earth has more than enough room if one allows for 50 sq feet per person with communal areas for eating, etc so that one could say God dwells with us if we are talking about living on the same planet, “dwell” implies some interaction. And if we had only 50 billion in the CK, they all could have one on one personal time with the Father for about 1 second every 16 centuries or so. (using chat and half asleep so could be off)….if mortality rules of existence apply (which I don’t think they do). So either time doesn’t function like it appears to us in mortality or we won’t function in time…or “dwelling with God” is primarily symbolic if talking about sharing location, which would be a shame imo.
  25. So what about those who receive lesser rewards? They won't be gods creating worlds. Will their eternal lives be infinite boredom?
  26. I should be precise…depending on counting the extra days in leap years. And now I am thinking this has more than just two answers as I certainly didn’t consider leap seconds or hours, just days. They are changing how we track time though…dropping leap seconds for leap hours for one thing. Remembered this today and thought some might be interested in it, hence this post. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/scientists-vote-to-end-leap-seconds-redefining-how-the-world-keeps-time/ So the last 100 years allegedly (because I am cheating and using chat this time) were 3,155,760,027 seconds with 27 leap seconds (only added since 1972) and 1 extra leap day in 2000 because the end of the 20th century year is divisible by 400. For the next 100 years, it will be 3,155,673,600 as there is no leap day in 2100. Apparently 1999 was the end of the 1900s though. Someone needs to get these things synchronized. It’s as bad as DST (Devil’s Saving Time)
  27. A form of Hebraism new to me: Seidel's Law. Kevin Christiansen brought this up way back in 2016 (https://www.mormondialogue.org/topic/67765-the-state-of-the-evidence/page/27/#findComment-1209651202). It is the idea of an inverted quotation. Shows up in the OT, NT, dead sea scrolls, other ancient literature, and numerous times in the Book of Mormon. Fun stuff. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpHr20T_EQU
  1. Load more activity
×
×
  • Create New...