Jump to content
Seriously No Politics ×

Telestial Kingdom -- Infinite Boredom?


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Here is an excerpt from Star Trek Voyager, describing the daily life of those who exist in eternity

Quinn then takes everyone to the Continuum...

...which appears as an endless road in the desert. Janeway is incredulous that this is the Continuum, and Quinn explains that this is simply a representation of the Continuum created so she could comprehend it. He then leads everyone to a small, run-down building by the side of the road.

In the building are several people each doing various things. Some are reading newspapers and magazines (called 'The Old' and 'The New), another man is playing a pinball machine named "Galaxy" and a couple play croquet with balls that appear to be miniature planets. Quinn explains that the road represents the universe, and that it goes around in a large circle before ending up right back at the building. Quinn has traveled the road many, many times and has done everything he can in the building. Played the games, sat on the porch, been the dog and even took the place of the scarecrow once before. When Janeway asks why, he tells her that it was simply because he hadn't done it before. Janeway states that the people in the building don't seem to be suffering, and Quinn states that they don't dare feel sad because if they did then at least that would be some progress.

Quinn then tells Janeway that when he was a respected philosopher he celebrated the purity the Q had reached and at the beginning of their era the Continuum was full of discussion on the discoveries and the issues that arose in the universe, but now everyone is silent because there is nothing left to say. Everything has already been said, and no-one has spoken to each other for ten millennia as a result.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Death_Wish_%28episode%29

 

Edited by cdowis
Posted

I've posted that video here before.  But it's not analogous with the Telestial Kingdom.

These are Gods with all knowledge and experience.  No, that scene perfectly describes the existence of the Heavenly Father described by Elder McConkie.  The God who can never learn anything new but only progresses in number of worlds created for all eternity.

A wretched being, just like Quinn in that story.

Posted

Proof that eye can not see nor heart understand all that God has in store for those who love him.

At least that story shows some of the things we can all imagine doing at some time or another.

Posted
1 hour ago, cdowis said:

Here is an excerpt from Star Trek Voyager, describing the daily life of those who exist in eternity

Quinn then takes everyone to the Continuum...

...which appears as an endless road in the desert. Janeway is incredulous that this is the Continuum, and Quinn explains that this is simply a representation of the Continuum created so she could comprehend it. He then leads everyone to a small, run-down building by the side of the road.

In the building are several people each doing various things. Some are reading newspapers and magazines (called 'The Old' and 'The New), another man is playing a pinball machine named "Galaxy" and a couple play croquet with balls that appear to be miniature planets. Quinn explains that the road represents the universe, and that it goes around in a large circle before ending up right back at the building. Quinn has traveled the road many, many times and has done everything he can in the building. Played the games, sat on the porch, been the dog and even took the place of the scarecrow once before. When Janeway asks why, he tells her that it was simply because he hadn't done it before. Janeway states that the people in the building don't seem to be suffering, and Quinn states that they don't dare feel sad because if they did then at least that would be some progress.

Quinn then tells Janeway that when he was a respected philosopher he celebrated the purity the Q had reached and at the beginning of their era the Continuum was full of discussion on the discoveries and the issues that arose in the universe, but now everyone is silent because there is nothing left to say. Everything has already been said, and no-one has spoken to each other for ten millennia as a result.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Death_Wish_%28episode%29

 

As the prophet Joseph Smith taught, all of us have already been alive forever. Even so, I don't find my life boring in the least. I therefore believe it"s not likely life will ever be boring for anyone, including the saved in the telestial kingdom. Forever is a long, long time. Yet I have all sorts of interesting things on my 'to do list' for today.

Posted

I think having children forever is the main thing that will make my eternal life interesting, including experiencing all of that with my wife, because even though at some point it may feel like we have already done everything there is for us to enjoy it will seem like we are experiencing it all for the first time through the eyes and minds of our children.

Plus there are some things that are nice to keep doing and enjoying more than only a few times.

Posted (edited)
23 minutes ago, Ahab said:

I think having children forever is the main thing that will make my eternal life interesting, including experiencing all of that with my wife,

Those in the Telestial Kingdom do not have wives or husbands.  Just people.

You would be sharing the same space as Hitler, etc.  Now that may be interesting for the first few thousand years.  He can go into great detail all the things that he caused to happen.  And then you would move on to the next person.   After a few billion years, it may get abit repetitive.

Then you can play the scarecrow.

Edited by cdowis
Posted

While I can't speak for others, I currently have tremendous joy in living the Gospel of Christ even being single. I hike, spend time researching and investing in different projects, look to furthering my education, enjoy serving in my calling, and am looking at buying a home. While there are pangs of longing at times for a spouse, those are outweighed by the joys of Gospel living. In the Resurrection those concerns that might weigh someone down are largely consumed in the Atonement.  I can't imagine what that joy must feel like in a resurrected state, even with the sorrow of eternal separation.

With regards to Hitler. The scriptures make it clear that there is a spectrum of glory and association in the Telestial Kingdom. I have no clue where he'll be at though, so I'm not going to invoke Godwin's Law.

Posted
1 hour ago, Bobbieaware said:

As the prophet Joseph Smith taught, all of us have already been alive forever. Even so, I don't find my life boring in the least. I therefore believe it"s not likely life will ever be boring for anyone, including the saved in the telestial kingdom. Forever is a long, long time. Yet I have all sorts of interesting things on my 'to do list' for today.

We are missing the point of eternity and immortality being combined.
How many billions of times can God say "Let there be light", send his son to die, redeem and exalt a world before there is nothing new to learn, to see, or to do.

How many times can you perform the same action before boredom and despair set in?  Over the course of billions and billions of years, eternities upon eternities, completing the same tasks over and over again, never learning or doing anything you haven't already done?

It's the very definition of damnation.

Posted
4 minutes ago, JLHPROF said:

We are missing the point of eternity and immortality being combined.
How many billions of times can God say "Let there be light", send his son to die, redeem and exalt a world before there is nothing new to learn, to see, or to do.

How many times can you perform the same action before boredom and despair set in?  Over the course of billions and billions of years, eternities upon eternities, completing the same tasks over and over again, never learning or doing anything you haven't already done?

It's the very definition of damnation.

You missed my point. The mere fact that I'm not at all bored, even though I have already existed for all eternity, is a strong indication to me that existence is never likely to become boring. I think you"re assuming too much based on a very limited fallen earthly perspective. It seems to me that after existing forever I am right smack dab in the very middle of the very nightmarish existence which you fear, yet it's not at all boring. Why? I wouldn't be at all surprised if one of the recurring processes of eternity is passing through progressive veils of forgetfulness that help keep our learning experiences forever fresh and new. I don't pretend to know for sure what to expect, but I believe the Book of Mormon when it says eternal life is a state of happiness that has no end. The Book of Mormon teaches us that before coming to earth Christ was the eternal God who knew all things, yet when he was born on this earth as a baby boy his learning process started all over again, as if he knew nothing. If life isn't boring for a God who knows all things, I'm not too worried about what lies ahead.

Posted
1 hour ago, JLHPROF said:

We are missing the point of eternity and immortality being combined.
How many billions of times can God say "Let there be light", send his son to die, redeem and exalt a world before there is nothing new to learn, to see, or to do.

How many times can you perform the same action before boredom and despair set in?  Over the course of billions and billions of years, eternities upon eternities, completing the same tasks over and over again, never learning or doing anything you haven't already done?

It's the very definition of damnation.

No, with damnation there is an end to a person's increase.  No one more... anything, or at least no more of the most important material possessions that matter the most.  No more children.  No more days or nights to spend with a husband or wife. No more planets to populate with offspring.  No more offspring.  No more!

I like looking forward to getting more things.  More eternal things of eternal significance.  The best kinds of things to be had.  And never being satisfied as if all that I have is enough. A insatiable appetite for more stuff, with a proper place for all of my stuff.

Posted

There's also the matter of what "eternal" even means for beings who might be outside of the time-flow, who look at it like we do the lay of the land before us. If all is before us, and we have no urgency in time, only places in it, how does the mind adapt to that? Can one get bored from continuing on through millenia when there are no millenia as we know it?

Posted
1 hour ago, Matthew J. Tandy said:

There's also the matter of what "eternal" even means for beings who might be outside of the time-flow, who look at it like we do the lay of the land before us. If all is before us, and we have no urgency in time, only places in it, how does the mind adapt to that? Can one get bored from continuing on through millenia when there are no millenia as we know it?

We will always have time, although we may not think much about it or pay much attention to it, at times.  

We will always be able to measure how long something took to accomplish, or how long something has to go before it is finished, if and when we want to, forever and ever.

Posted

Why do you think that God can't learn anything new?  Is He unable to compose a new song or tell a new story, or even hear a new story never before told by another?  

In the Voyager episode, the Q fixed their ennui problem by having children. :)

 

Posted

The idea that the omniscient are bored is a longrunning sci-fi concept but of course it comes entirely from a human point of view that boredom is a universal trait. I suspect the the Gods do not suffer from it. Roddenberry has always had a weird idea of how gods must operate. Most of his god-beings are irresponsible jerks. You have Q and the Squire of Gothos (proto-Q). You have the Metrons who are so civilized and above violence that when two battling starships come into their space they put the two captains on the planet and have them fight to the death and it appears we are supposed to think they are civilized. No wonder Roddenberry was an atheist. I'd hate gods like that too.

As to the Telestial it is a very enjoyable place.

Posted (edited)
13 hours ago, The Nehor said:

As to the Telestial it is a very enjoyable place.

I think it as a living in a resort hotel on a beach in Hawaii.  You have your own room to yourself, with a TV and you can go to the beach and enjoy yourself and associating with the other tourists.  BUT you are a tourist, a guest.  You don't have the family ties, and it is "enjoyable" but that's all there is to it.  Many of the people living there are not very pleasant, and their conversation is not what I could call stimulating.  Perhaps you get the occasional visitor from the outside.

You are comfortable, but there's always the TV, perhaps Gilligan's Island, if you get bored.  You can only dream, fantasize on what might have been.

Edited by cdowis
Posted
14 hours ago, SeekerB said:

Why do you think that God can't learn anything new?  Is He unable to compose a new song or tell a new story, or even hear a new story never before told by another? 

This is the whole point of this Star Trek scene, but some people cannot understand how accurate this silly bit of Sci-Fi is to theological principles.

The very idea that God knows everything that can ever be known and can never learn anything new is simply preposterous and illogical.
And IF it were true, it would make God one of the most miserable, pitiable beings.  It would make immortality a curse.
 

14 hours ago, The Nehor said:

The idea that the omniscient are bored is a longrunning sci-fi concept but of course it comes entirely from a human point of view that boredom is a universal trait. I suspect the the Gods do not suffer from it.


Reason would demand that they do.  Even if missing the mortal weakness for boredom, they would still be little more than automatons going through the same repetitive motions of creation, never expanding, never growing, never progressing.
Simply gaining more kingdoms and posterity seems a rather selfish reason for creating worlds forever without any change.
To stop progressing is to be dead, and God is most certainly NOT dead.

Posted (edited)
7 minutes ago, JLHPROF said:

This is the whole point of this Star Trek scene, but some people cannot understand how accurate this silly bit of Sci-Fi is to theological principles.

The very idea that God knows everything that can ever be known and can never learn anything new is simply preposterous and illogical.
And IF it were true, it would make God one of the most miserable, pitiable beings.  It would make immortality a curse.

And IF it were false, then it would be possible for God to learn something that completely invalidates the Plan of Salvation -- oops, and where would that leave us.  How can we trust or have faith in God if He is constantly learning and we don't know the result of His education.  Instead of being eternally in joy and peace, we would be hanging on a thread of fear and doubt on what may happen to us.

Now, for me, THAT is illogical and preposterous.

Edited by cdowis
Posted (edited)
11 minutes ago, cdowis said:

And IF it were false, then it would be possible for God to learn something that completely invalidates the Plan of Salvation -- oops, and where would that leave us.  How can we trust or have faith in God if He is constantly learning and we don't know the result of His education.  Instead of being eternally in joy and peace, we would be hanging on a thread of fear and doubt on what may happen to us.

Now, for me, THAT is illogical and preposterous.

No, not at all.  In order for "it would be possible for God to learn something that completely invalidates the Plan of Salvation" such a thing would have to exist.

The plan of salvation is not new.  The temple teaches us that it is eternal and has always been the same.  Since it has always existed in the same pattern how could God learn something to invalidate it.  It has already been validated throughout all creations.  It was validated by God utilizing the plan of salvation to become God.  He has experience that validates it.  There is nothing in existence that he could learn that would change that.
Simple reasoning.

God continues to learn.  President Young was right.  Elder McConkie was wrong.
 

Edited by JLHPROF
Posted
9 minutes ago, JLHPROF said:

No, not at all.  In order for "it would be possible for God to learn something that completely invalidates the Plan of Salvation" such a thing would have to exist.

The plan of salvation is not new.  The temple teaches us that it is eternal and has always been the same.  Since it has always existed in the same pattern how could God learn something to invalidate it.  It has already been validated throughout all creations.  It was validated by God utilizing the plan of salvation to become God.  He has experience that validates it.  There is nothing in existence that he could learn that would change that.
Simple reasoning.

God continues to learn.  President Young was right.  Elder McConkie was wrong.
 

What is important to me is that he knows enough to save me.

Posted

How about the idea that IF there are things that God (our Father) "learns" that he didn't already know before... IF that idea is true... that those things that he didn't know before are simply additional things that are in no way any different than what he already knows?

How does that idea sound to everybody?

Like,  for example, how maybe he didn't know me before he created me, even though he did already know every characteristic I could possibly have.  Because there are only so many ways for any person to be.  

To get more specific,  hair color, for example. 

Just when exactly did he know what color of hair I would have?  There are only so many possibilities,  right?  Even allowing for my hair changing to different colors over time or at different times. 

I lean toward the idea that he knows everything there is in all of existence right now, with the past AND future simply being more of the same kinds of things that he already knows right now.  The only difference really is that there will simply be MORE of what he already knows now in the future.  More planets that he has created, more of his children,  more people who eventually learn all that he knows, and more people who don't,  etc.

 

Posted (edited)
28 minutes ago, JLHPROF said:

God continues to learn.  President Young was right.  Elder McConkie was wrong.
 

I disagree.

IMO, sour "simple logic" is based on a flawed assumption.

Edited by cdowis
Posted

Love never gets boring.  

Creativity will not be lost - just look how creative we are with the limited knowledge, and thus limited tools and mediums of expression that we have!  Artistic expression through music, food, poetry, story, dance, and visual arts is limitless.  Who know what other mediums and instruments there will be available to us then to express ourselves?

Free agency will always exist, making relationships eternally interesting and challenging.  I am sure that animal life will abound (with its own free agency), and our relation to the natural world will be profoundly enhanced and interesting with potential abilities to communicate, cooperate, and coordinate with the natural world in meaningful ways.  If you think that human choirs are interesting, imagine the possibilities when you harmonize and create heavenly music in coordination with the natural world!  I think Disney was onto something there. 

  

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...