Calm Posted December 3, 2011 Posted December 3, 2011 (edited) The claim is true as stated - the counsel given was to avoid, among others, R-rated movies.Right, it is just not meaningfull for those who never knowingly encounter an r rated movie because their country labels movies a different way and they do not have access to US ratings. Edited December 3, 2011 by calmoriah
Calm Posted December 3, 2011 Posted December 3, 2011 Of course not.I would have been surprised if so, but the way you phrased that comment seemed to imply such a position.
Diggerdan60 Posted December 3, 2011 Posted December 3, 2011 (edited) There are no questions on the temple recommend interview regarding R-rated movies, so there is no prohibition against them like there is for the word of wisdom.However, the saints are to "live in the world, but not of the world". When we choose entertainment choices we would ideally not choose anything which would harm our ability to recieve spiritual promptings. This would include almost all movies PG-13 or greater, most PG movies and a majority of television shows.Personally this standard is too hard for me to live and as a weak person , who really enjoys movies, I picked the no R-rating rule for me because it is better than nothing. It is a standanrd I can live with. My weakness for entertainment would allow me to rationalize watching any R-rated movie that I wanted to see, therefore I simply say no R-rated movies for me personally. This is my personal standard and I do not think less of others who do not have this same standard. We all have weaknesses and vices and people who look down on others for not following an R-rated movie standard have some issues of there own to work out.Most stake presidents and general authorties I know on a personal enough level to discuss personal entertainment choices typically do not watch much Television let alone attend movies. I believe that if we strive to improve our spirituality our entertainment choices will be more and more limited. The waste of time alone is probably a good enough reason to avoid most of the entertainment we participate in, in our modern society. Edited December 3, 2011 by Diggerdan60
ERayR Posted December 3, 2011 Posted December 3, 2011 It all comes down to what you want to put into your mind. The ratings are an INDICATION that there MAY be something in it you don't want.
rpn Posted December 3, 2011 Posted December 3, 2011 The idea that secular authorities establish which movies are acceptable and which are not, is just plain ludicrous. In the 1970's when Pres Benson or whomever counseled against R rated movies, there was a whole lot clearer differences in the ratings in the US, and a lot fewer members of the church outside the US. Movies that then were R in America, might not snag PG-13 today. Further, fundamentally the counsel gave members an excuse not to exercise their agency, so long as it wasn't R rated. The current counsel, consisted with the handbook changes and current training, is to quit giving lists, and start teaching principles. And the principle is not allowing into your mind things that don't bring you closer to Him (see exact wording in the For the Strength of Youth pamphlet), no matter what their rating is. 2
WalkerW Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 Why, yes, I did read one of them. As, of course, you would have known had you read the thread.Glad to hear. But one is not all.So, in the whole thread, which you did not read, nobody else attempted the same thing, with the same rationalizations?Did I imply anywhere that others had not? I simply provided reading material, which you responded to with a snarky comment without (as you just admitted) having read all of them.And yet, it was the counsel given to the global church.You missed the point, which Calmoriah has already noted.When you publicly rationalize and attempt to justify disobeying counsel, is that obedience?Obedience to what or whom exactly? Is, as Card asks, no R-rated films a divine commandment from God Himself that requires strict obedience? (If so, you would think God would be able to communicate the same commandment in a way that crosses national and cultural boundaries)Perhaps that is what I disagree with.That's fine. I'm personally glad to see people publishing on this subject, even if they don't accept the common view that all R-movies are off limits. To me, this shows that they take the counsel seriously (possibly more seriously than those who don't give it a second thought and produce a superficial, self-aggrandizing interpretation of the counsel). 3
Log Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 (edited) In the interest of brevity, I shall dispense with the rest of your post. For the record, issuing preachments condemning my not bothering to read more than Card's self-justifying screed when you have not bothered to get up to speed on the conversation by reading the thread reeks of arrogance.Obedience to what or whom exactly? Is, as Card asks, no R-rated films a divine commandment from God Himself that requires strict obedience? (If so, you would think God would be able to communicate the same commandment in a way that crosses national and cultural boundaries)Obedience to the officially stated counsel of the duly authorized servants of God. Now, if, in your private life, you wish to justify yourself in doing things contrary to counsel, that's your privilege. When you publicly counsel others to jettison the counsel of the duly authorized and recognized servants of God, you are diminishing their authority in the eyes of others, and harming those who otherwise might, but for your bad example before them, begin to trust in the counsel of the prophets. I guess giving strict heed to the counsel and teachings of the messengers of the Father is out of vogue around here. Edited December 4, 2011 by Log
WalkerW Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 (edited) For the record, issuing preachments condemning my not bothering to read more than Card's self-justifying screed when you have not bothered to get up to speed on the conversation by reading the thread reeks of arrogance.In the interest of brevity, I shall dispense with the rest of your post. For the record, issuing preachments condemning my not reading the entire thread (something I acknowledged at the forefront--thus why I only provided links and not opinions in my first post), while feeling free to self-righteously opine on articles you have not bothered to get up to speed on by reading reeks of arrogance. Edited December 4, 2011 by WalkerW 1
Log Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 In the interest of brevity, I shall dispense with the rest of your post. For the record, issuing preachments condemning my not reading the entire thread (something I acknowledged at the forefront--thus why I only provided links and not opinions in my first post), while feeling free to self-righteously opine on articles you have not bothered to get up to speed on by reading reeks of arrogance.Where did I opine on any articles save Card's? You may retract at your leisure.
WalkerW Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 As in "attempt" to circumvent the counsel to refrain from r - rated movies.In other words, the articles I provided were nothing but attempts to circumvent prophetic counsel. When you publicly rationalize and attempt to justify disobeying counsel, is that obedience?In other words, the articles I provided do nothing, but rationalize and attempt to justify disobedience.When you publicly counsel others to jettison the counsel of the duly authorized and recognized servants of God, you are diminishing their authority in the eyes of others, and harming those who otherwise might, but for your bad example before them, begin to trust in the counsel of the prophets. I guess giving strict heed to the counsel and teachings of the messengers of the Father is out of vogue around here.In other words, the articles I provided counsel others to jettison prophetic counsel and diminish their authority.When you were saying all of this, did you anywhere clarify that you were specifically referring to Card alone? I provided four articles. Without providing any reason to think otherwise, you offered up the above in response to them all. The only time you mentioned Card by name in response to me was when you called his article a "self-justifying screed."If no one else sees this as opining on the articles you did not read, then I'll retract.
Log Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 (edited) In other words, the articles I provided were nothing but attempts to circumvent prophetic counsel.I merely pointed out you were using them to do so.In other words, the articles I provided do nothing, but rationalize and attempt to justify disobedience.I merely pointed out you were using them to do so.In other words, the articles I provided counsel others to jettison prophetic counsel and diminish their authority.I merely pointed out you were using them to do so.When you were saying all of this, did you anywhere clarify that you were specifically referring to Card alone?So sorry; I was talking to you.I provided four articles. Without providing any reason to think otherwise, you offered up the above in response to them all. The only time you mentioned Card by name in response to me was when you called his article a "self-justifying screed."That is, in fact, the sole time that I referred to the content of any of the articles.If no one else sees this as opining on the articles you did not read, then I'll retract.Well, whatever will make you feel better.So, Walker, do you feel justifying and encouraging others in not paying strict heed to the counsel and teachings of the messengers of the Father augments, or do you feel it diminishes, their authority? Edited December 5, 2011 by Minos Log has left the building.
WalkerW Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 I merely pointed out you were using them to do so.I see. I did misunderstand. Your remark was not directed at the authors, but at me for linking to the authors. It was a personal jab at my supposed disobedience. That's much better. Not only did you not read the articles I provided, you decided to assume what they said and therefore make a quick analysis of my personal obedience and character. Classy. Consider this the retraction you requested.So, Walker, do you feel justifying and encouraging others in not paying strict heed to the counsel and teachings of the messengers of the Father is augmenting, or is it diminishing, their authority?I don't believe I said anything of the sort. I simply linked to what I considered thought-provoking articles and gave brief responses to your multiple comments. Justifying and encouraging others to not pay "strict heed to the counsel and teachings of the messengers of the Father" in principle is certainly not spiritually healthy or respectful of their authority. However, I also think engaging the counsel, reflecting on it, seeking personal revelation for it, and discussing it is absolutely essential and spiritually more beneficial than the kind of "when the prophet speaks, the thinking is done" approach that is fairly common.
Log Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 (edited) I see. I did misunderstand. Your remark was not directed at the authors, but at me for linking to the authors. It was a personal jab at my supposed disobedience. You misunderstand again, apparently. I don't know, nor do I care, whether you, nor any other person on this planet, watches R rated movies or not.It's literally none of my business.I don't believe I said anything of the sort. I simply linked to what I considered thought-provoking articles and gave brief responses to your multiple comments.If I were to, in a thread entitled "Drinking Wine," throw up articles with titles such as "Wine's Health Benefits," and the like, what inference may justly be drawn immediately?Justifying and encouraging others to not pay "strict heed to the counsel and teachings of the messengers of the Father" in principle is certainly not spiritually healthy or respectful of their authority. However, I also think engaging the counsel, reflecting on it, seeking personal revelation for it, and discussing it is absolutely essential and spiritually more beneficial than the kind of "when the prophet speaks, the thinking is done" approach that is fairly common.As nobody here has said any such thing as this false dichotomy you depict, why bring it up?Incidentally, which is spiritually healthier: to engage in a conversation about whether to keep the counsel given, or how to keep the counsel given? Edited December 4, 2011 by Log
Senator Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 You misunderstand again, apparently. I don't know, nor do I care, whether you, nor any other person on this planet, watches R rated movies or not.It's literally none of my business. You apparently care enough to offer up your judgements and indictments on those that hold a different view than you. If I were to, in a thread entitled "Drinking Wine," throw up articles with titles such as "Wine's Health Benefits," and the like, what inference may justly be drawn immediately?I don't know, but not thinking presumptuously might be a good start. Incidentally, which is spiritually healthier: to engage in a conversation about whether to keep the counsel given, or how to keep the counsel given?Neither, I think they are not mutually exclusive. 1
Log Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 (edited) You apparently care enough to offer up your judgements and indictments on those that hold a different view than you.Not at all. I couldn't really care less what views anyone holds on this subject. That hasn't been my point.In fact, reading through the thread, see if you can spot where I state my view on R-rated movies. Edited December 4, 2011 by Log
Nominee Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 the kind of "when the prophet speaks, the thinking is done" approach that is fairly common.CFR that the "when the prophet speaks, the thinking is done" approach is fairly common.
frankenstein Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 Those opposed to R movies do you watch the sanitized versions of such movies? Have you ever paid for services that sanitize movies?
volgadon Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 The problem with this claim is that MPAA ratings were not always available to others in other countries and still might not be for those who don't have Internet access.Nor does every country use a similar system (and some that do have similar labels have different standards.). http://en.wikipedia....e_rating_systemNor is the application always consistent, at least not in Israel, Russia and Ukraine.
volgadon Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 A Russian-Jewish mouse! (if you're referencing what I think you're referencing)Unfortunately for him, there were cats in America.I am, and I think that it is what Cinepro's link was referencing.The first movie though had some dark moments.
volgadon Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 CFR that the "when the prophet speaks, the thinking is done" approach is fairly common.Seeing as you are CFRing a subjective experience of one of my friends, I can state that I have seen this often, especially when serving a mission with elders from the USA and also later moving to Utah. 1
volgadon Posted December 4, 2011 Posted December 4, 2011 I see. I did misunderstand. Your remark was not directed at the authors, but at me for linking to the authors. It was a personal jab at my supposed disobedience. That's much better.Of course it is, you flithy libertarian. One had only to glance at your avatar to tell that you are subverting the 11th commandment- Thou shalt watch no R rated movie- in attempting to drag everyone else down to the fiery pit of destruction. I could tell you the exact time at which to expect a Danite raid upon your personal DVD collection, but that is pointless, since nobody expects the Danites and their newly upholstered chairs... 1
Nominee Posted December 5, 2011 Posted December 5, 2011 Seeing as you are CFRing a subjective experience of one of my friends, I can state that I have seen this often, especially when serving a mission with elders from the USA and also later moving to Utah.Thank you for sharing what you have seen. Living in Oregon and having previously lived in Utah for a short time, I have not had the same experience. Your friend is lucky to have you. I hope my CFR was not in anyway considered a personal attack on the character of your friend. It was not intended that way. When he stated that the "when the prophet speaks, the thinking is done" approach is fairly common it just sounded like a fact more than an opinion. I am aware of the approach but I certainly would not consider it common. Yet be assured, that is just my opinion.
altersteve Posted December 5, 2011 Author Posted December 5, 2011 Thank you for sharing what you have seen. Living in Oregon and having previously lived in Utah for a short time, I have not had the same experience. Your friend is lucky to have you. I hope my CFR was not in anyway considered a personal attack on the character of your friend. It was not intended that way. When he stated that the "when the prophet speaks, the thinking is done" approach is fairly common it just sounded like a fact more than an opinion. I am aware of the approach but I certainly would not consider it common. Yet be assured, that is just my opinion.In Utah at least, the "when the prophet speaks, the thinking is done" approach is common. And some people kind of annoy me when they think like that, especially since Church leaders have consistently emphasized the importance of thinking for ourselves and using our own reasoning coupled with the guidance of the Spirit when it comes to choosing how to live our lives. Obeying or believing whatever the prophet says just because the prophet says it is something I strongly disagree with.
Nominee Posted December 5, 2011 Posted December 5, 2011 In Utah at least, the "when the prophet speaks, the thinking is done" approach is common. And some people kind of annoy me when they think like that, especially since Church leaders have consistently emphasized the importance of thinking for ourselves and using our own reasoning coupled with the guidance of the Spirit when it comes to choosing how to live our lives. Obeying or believing whatever the prophet says just because the prophet says it is something I strongly disagree with.I don't know if you are familiar with the area but I'm in Portland and I am surrounded by independent thinkers! I would say it is common here to be "obsessively opposed to the typical" ~so lucky me. To have it said though, I do agree with you here. We each need to think and seek confirmation for ourselves and the church leaders have always been very clear about this. My eyes have been opened. I genuinely did not realize there were so many blind followers.
Calm Posted December 5, 2011 Posted December 5, 2011 I don't think it is so much that there are "blind followers" but rather there are so many "busy followers". It takes time and sometimes great effort to study and ponder all that we have been commanded, instructed and counseled to do in our own lives and to help others and therefore we all make choices of what things we will concentrate on and what things we will rely on others mostly or even completely. For example, there are any who have chosen to simply go to doctors when they are feeling off and then follow whatever the doctor instructs them to do without questioning or finding out more information for themselves. For many this is more than sufficient and they can lead healthy lives by doing so. There are some for whom this choice ends up being detrimental, perhaps because the doctor does not have enough knowledge, the individual needs to learn what issues are the most important so they can keep the doctor and themselves focused on the main problem and not on distracting side issues, or because it takes personal insight and knowledge to even begin to describe their disorder sufficiently well for the doctor to understand the issue, iow in these cases the patient needs to expand their ability to use the language that will communicate the correct concepts. In terms of spirituality, I know many members who taken at face value might be called "blind followers" but many have chosen that path because they have proved those who they follow already and they see it as an efficient way to make the many decisions of what to focus on that are demanded of those trying to do good in the world with limited time and resources. Others have chosen the path as a way to consciously set themselves apart from the world. There are, in my experience, many other spiritually mature reasons for using what may, if done wisely, amount to a spiritual shortcut. One can run into problems from what I've seen if one doesn't take the time before investing someone with such confidence and authority to explore the reasons why one is doing so, for oneself and for the other because if one doesn't take care, one sets the situation up for disappointment when conflicts ultimately arises, the other is not actually worthy of such trust even in most cases, or one locks oneself into inflexibility preventing one from taking full advantage of opportunities of growth and expansion when they appear.I think it is important to refrain from judging so called blind followers at least until one knows the motivation behind such a choice, whether it is trust based on wisdom and experience, fear or an avoidance of personal responsibility or something else.
Recommended Posts