Jump to content
Seriously No Politics ×

Maligning the Brethren


Recommended Posts

Posted
6 minutes ago, ALarson said:

Care to elaborate?  I'd love to hear the reason.

 

6 minutes ago, Johnnie Cake said:

Which was?

This is not the forum for this discussion.

Posted (edited)
2 minutes ago, busybee said:

This is not the forum for this discussion.

Thought you might say that :)

Maybe we should start another thread where you can elaborate?

 

Edited by ALarson
Posted
1 minute ago, ALarson said:

You wrote that in response to Happy's example of blacks being prohibited from voting (you quoted him and then responded).  If that was in error, I understand.

Are you seriously comparing someone being baptized into the church and receiving the gift of the Holy Ghost to the dangers of teenagers drinking alcohol or smoking tobacco?  

(And, yes we are off topic, and maybe this should be a separate thread.)

 

I don't recall mentioning Black people voting at all. I responded to a post about the priesthood ban being similar. It wasn't, but anyway... Yes way off topic.

Posted
2 minutes ago, busybee said:

I don't recall mentioning Black people voting at all. I responded to a post about the priesthood ban being similar. It wasn't, but anyway... Yes way off topic.

You probably quoted him in error and responded.  His quote included info regarding the prohibition of blacks to vote.  

The quoting feature seems difficult to work with now (at least it is for me at times).

Posted
5 minutes ago, ALarson said:

Thought you might say that :)

Maybe we should start another thread where you can elaborate?

 

It would be shut down in the blink of an eye on this forum.

Posted
38 minutes ago, busybee said:

1) I don't believe that they are suppressing criticism. If they are, it's obviously not working. I believe that it is unhealthy for the members of any organization to criticize the leaders publicly and I feel that is what Elder Oaks meant.(yes, I know, assuming etc etc., but surely we each use our insight in interpreting the things we hear.) I don't feel that the work of the church is helped at all when members openly criticize the leaders. There are correct channels to follow for those who have a problem with what the brethren are doing. Are those channels always completely free from the debris of human failing? Of course not. But I firmly believe that the church is in the Lord's hands and He leads the men who He has called to administer the affairs of His church.

2) I feel when the Lord wants His servants to apologize, it will happen. There are no examples of prophets apologizing in the scripture (to my admittedly limited knowledge). If you know of some please share.

I don't believe anyone should have to apologise for something that they personally did not do. For example, I grew up in Apartheid South Africa. Do you believe I should apologise for what was done in the name of apartheid? Why should today's leaders apologise for previous leaders perceived mistakes? I also don't think it would be good for a religious organization to be offering apologies because where does one then draw the line. Will we soon be apologising for everything that someone doesn't agree with or perceives to be offensive. We might as well say 'Let's call the whole thing off' if that is going to be the case.

Thanks for your detailed response.

Even if we don't agree, I have to hand it to you for answering questions straight-up.

As to South Africa, I do not think it would be amiss for leaders of the government there to apologize for Apartheid, though it would of course make little sense for ordinary citizens to do so.

Posted
28 minutes ago, ALarson said:

Thought you might say that :)

Maybe we should start another thread where you can elaborate?

 

 My recent comment  (on page 7) in the thread on the Priesthood ban might give you some idea of why I feel it was necessary.

Posted
3 minutes ago, busybee said:

 My recent comment  (on page 7) in the thread on the Priesthood ban might give you some idea of why I feel it was necessary.

I'll read it.  Thanks!

Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, Doctor Steuss said:

Thus far in my life, "I'm sincerely flattered, but I'm not gay, sorry," has worked quite well.  Haven't had to punch anyone yet (and, when you have a lot of gay friends, like show tunes, and aren't affraid to get on the dance floor, people tend to assume you're gay... a lot).

I would assume that for the vast majority of sexual interest in our culture (both the secular and the religious) this is enough, in all forms of sexual interaction (male/male, female/female, female/male).  But there are still sexual assaults out there occurring enough that self defense classes are given, etc.  And it should be noted in terms of missionary companionship, what companion wouldn't know that his companion would most likely not appreciate such attention, even if he was homosexual given that missionaries (all but senior couples) have committed to put aside that part of their lives for at least those two years.  So it seems likely to me that if the companion did make unwanted advances, it was likely past the point of normal interaction where 'I am not interested' works.

It makes me wonder and wish for a study on sexual activity in missionaries and if this is skewed towards overt, more aggressive behaviour (for hetero and homosexual behaviour) when it does occur because for those who would normally act at the acceptable level that you suggest above, the rules of missionary life and self-control would be enough to remove that level, thus leaving the more aggressive types as the 'common sexual encounter for a missionary' instead of rarer variety they usually are.

-----

Back in the 70s, my experience was that I saw a lot more gay bashing (mostly verbal, but occasionally heard reports of physical...I did live by San Francisco, had friends and employers who were gay) outside the Church.  Among the young men of my ward, who were all jock types save the social leader who was a musician/geek, there was an occasional derogatory remark, but never any report of physical aggression.  I guess my biggest problem with condemnation of this talk is that everywhere I've lived during that decade (Illinois, Utah, California...some visits to Ohio) examples of verbal abuse, bullying and violence towards gays were heavily present in the surrounding culture while what was taught at Church from what I could tell (not being in priesthood lessons, but in SM & SS with these young men) was to have self-control and to treat others with respect and love.  

While Elder Packer's talk might have been more helpful if it had been written to detail the hows and when (which seems to me is usually left to the manuals, talks don't generally go into particulars, but may throw out a detail here and there to encourage thinking about specifics for ourselves imo), the overall climate of what was being taught at church most definitely was not encouraging physical responses unless physically attacked and I saw instruction that one was to resist verbal provocation, leave the environment when possible and to use violence as a last resort, not the first.  If young men were hearing it this way, I would be shocked if this was their first exposure to the idea of violence against gays and they were not already deeply influenced by what was going on outside of church, rather than getting this attitude from within.  If this talk was the only exposure young men had ever received in regards to homosexuality and physical responses/self-protection, I would be more concerned about what was not said, but that just isn't the reality as far as I can tell.  It would be the very rare young man who would have heard that talk and never receive instruction of self-control, pursue nonviolent options first, etc. from church leaders both before and after the talk.

 My husband was a missionary when the talk was given and he didn't hear it then and never encountered it and he was born in Utah County and has lived there most of his life, his family was the archetype Mormon family (his mom and dad were models for an illustration for an Ensign article on Celestial Marriage...I found that so appropriate :) ) and he has been active in all of his student wards, was called to be a counselor in a student ward when we were married and always been either EQ president or a ward clerk and his best friends were YM leaders, bishopric members, HPQLs.  Not bragging here, just explaining how he would be exposed in pretty much all his wards to the core ideas and personality of those wards, whether in Utah, California, Kansas, Canada, Hawaii or Russia (and then his time as a missionary in South America).   He was never given the pamphlet and apparently none of his friends ever talked to him about the talk as today is the first time he has heard of it (it may have been referred to in passing but never in enough detail to identify what was going on...that it said anything about defending yourself against gays or homosexual advances with whatever violence one wanted or the more mild (and in my view more contextually accurate) interpretations.  I will have to ask my son if he ever heard of it growing up.  I may be the only one who encountered it at Church and that is because I was the librarian and was going through the old stacks looking to see what could be thrown out.  Nor have I ever heard any discussion of this at church, just on the message boards or from one or two gay LDS friends.

Thus any claim that this was a major influence in nonhomosexuals' lives and was the major reason they might justify in their minds violence towards gays is just unrealistic, imo.  There was tons more ways young men at the time were being exposed to the idea that gay bashing was seen as acceptable by part of society (not LDS society in my experience, though we unfortunately probably have some that ignore church teachings about treating others with respect and love, not with violence save in the rare case of necessary self-protection.

I have no doubt that a young man who felt homosexual attractions would be impacted by that talk in significant ways even if much less attention in the short and the long run was going to be paid by the typical LDS teen.  Just as a talk mentions in part of the talk a selfish trend among married couples to not have children is going to have a much greater impact on childless couples even if they are doing everything they can to have children.  Given the advances of science and the change in the language in discussing homosexual attractions and behaviour in the Church and because of the desire of those who want to use it as a battering ram against the Church (not saying all who criticize it use it in that fashion, just that some do), I hope that they will remove the talk from lds.org one of these days (but then we will run the risk of trying to cover things up so perhaps they will choose to keep it up and assume that those intent on learning the Church's approach will actually look at what is happening now and not what happened 40 years ago where in the US the world was a much different place for homosexuals or even just discussion gender issues, even in places like San Francisco :) ) and rely on the better, more current approaches (such as mormonandgays website) or even come up with a new one that incorporates much of the current discussion.

Edited by Calm
Posted
1 hour ago, ALarson said:

Yes they have.  Children under 18 who live in the home of a SSM parent are prohibited from being baptized.  Once they turn 18, they can be baptized under certain circumstances and stipulations.  But until then, yes, their baptism is prohibited.

Prohibit definition:  Formally forbid (something) by law, rule, or other authority;  prevent (something); make impossible.

Then stop leaving out the until 18 years old part. It's not just you , or not even you but every critical article and post leaves out the "until 18 years old". They want you to think it'd be forever. It's a lie of omission. You can't vote until you're 18, you can get a driver's license until you're 16, you can't get married without your parents permission until you're 18, There are many things you can't do until you are 18. When I was growing up I wanted to race motorcycles for a living, the answer was NO, but you can do what you want when you're 18. Anything that is a long term project that is worth doing is worth spending 10 years to get ready to do it. I spent 10 years getting my boat, getting it ready to cruise and saving money to cruise on. Baptism is forever. All of our baptisms are under certain circumstances and stipulations. 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...