mfbukowski Posted February 1, 2014 Posted February 1, 2014 Interesting stuff and some new findings about the Noah story. I suppose some sort of bulls eye if one wants to see it that way! I am not a literalist but I also discount nothing. This is a very complex world in which all sorts of things can happen. The Jaredites crossed the sea to the New World in eight "barges" in 344 days, driven by currents and winds. Their route is unknown. Perhaps coincidentally, the North Pacific current takes about the same time to cross from Japan to Mexico (Sorenson, p. 111). The question of ancient long-distance sea travel has been much debated, but extensive indications have been found of pre-Columbian transoceanic voyaging (Sorenson and Raish). The Bering land bridge "is no longer recognized as the only scientifically acceptable theory to explain the means and timing of human entry into the New World" (Dixon, p. 27).The design of the Jaredite barges is unclear. They were built according to instructions given by God. Ether described them as being "light upon the water" like a fowl (Ether 2:16). They were "tight like unto a dish; and the ends thereof were peaked." To allow light and air inside they had some sort of a "hole in the top, and also in the bottom" (Ether 2:17, 20). Ether also compared the barges with Noah's ark (Ether 6:7). Thus it may be relevant that Utnapishtim, the Sumerian Noah in the Epic of Gilgamesh, similarly is said to have built his boat with a ceiling and water plugs, and to have waterproofed the entire inside with bitumen. Utnapishtim's story also recounts the raging winds that slammed water into the mountains and people, vividly paralleling the Jaredites' experience of being driven by a furious wind (Ether 6:6). http://eom.byu.edu/index.php/Jaredites A recently deciphered 4,000-year-old clay tablet from ancient Mesopotamia is putting a new spin on the biblical tale of the flood and Noah's Ark — and that's causing consternation among some Christian fundamentalists.The Book of Genesis includes detailed specifications for the giant boat on which all kinds of animals were placed, two by two, to shelter from 40 days and 40 nights of rain. The wooden ark was to measure about 450 feet long, 75 feet wide and 30 feet high (300 by 50 by 30 cubits, or 137 by 23 by 13 meters).All well and good: But the specifications listed on the Babylonian "Ark Tablet," which is now on display at the British Museum, are totally different. The Babylonian boat was supposed to be made of braided rope, stiffened by wooden spars and sealed with bitumen. And it was supposed to have a round base, measuring 230 feet wide (70 meters wide)."It was really a heart-stopping moment — the discovery that the boat was to be a round boat," Irving Finkel, a curator at the museum, told The Associated Press. "That was a real surprise."A circular ark is in keeping with the look of a coracle, a type of river taxi that was widely used during ancient times in the region now known as Iraq. But the layout doesn't mesh with Genesis, which is taken as the word-for-word literal truth in fundamentalist Christian circles.Which came first?Finkel said the account of the flood and the ark was probably passed along to the Jews during their Babylonian exile in the 6th century B.C. and served as the basis for the Genesis story. Biblical Archaeology Review's Noah Wiener said the cuneiform tablet was created "a full millennium before the Genesis narrative was written down."http://www.nbcnews.com/science/babylonian-tale-round-ark-draws-wrath-some-christian-circles-2D12035655 1
mfbukowski Posted February 1, 2014 Author Posted February 1, 2014 Didn't notice the other thread(s). Mods delete if you think appropriate.
Robert F. Smith Posted February 2, 2014 Posted February 2, 2014 Interesting stuff and some new findings about the Noah story. I suppose some sort of bulls eye if one wants to see it that way! I am not a literalist but I also discount nothing. This is a very complex world in which all sorts of things can happen. http://eom.byu.edu/index.php/Jaredites http://www.nbcnews.com/science/babylonian-tale-round-ark-draws-wrath-some-christian-circles-2D12035655Yes, and the newly discovered version also has animals entering the ark two-by-two.There is nothing new about Mesopotamian (Sumero-Akkadian) flood stories which are clearly related to the biblical story of Noah. Other aspects of the Primeval History in Genesis are also known from cuneiform documents. As Hugh Nibley has said many times, this is precisely what we should expect. After all, the Hebrews came from upper Mesopotamia and likely brought their own version of those stories with them. LDS Scripture has different versions of the Creation story from the Bible, Book of Moses, and Book of Abraham, just as we have different versions of the life of Christ in four separate Gospels. 1
Recommended Posts