Flyonthewall Posted January 15, 2012 Posted January 15, 2012 In 1961 Israeli soldiers unearthed a cave that had inscriptions and drawings including the oldest known Hebrew writing of the word “Jerusalem” dated to approximately 600 B.C. by Dr. Frank Cross Moore, Jr. of Harvard University.“I am Jehovah thy Lord. I will accept the cities of Judah and I will redeem Jerusalem”“Absolve us oh merciful God. Absolve us oh Jehovah”The drawings depicted men who appeared to be fleeing and two ships.While investigating the cave, Dr. Joseph Ginat of The University of Haifa met a Bedouin who told him about the remains of an ancient oak tree about 1/4 of a mile away where, according to Bedouin legends and tradition, a prophet named Lehi blessed and judged the people of both Ishmael and Judah. The Bedouin told Dr. Ginat that Lehi had lived many years before Muhammad and that Arab people had built a wall of large rocks around the remains of the tree to protect it as a sacred spot, long known by arab inhabitants as “Beit Lehi”, meaning “Home of Lehi.”http://beitlehifoundation.org/history/
Flyonthewall Posted January 15, 2012 Author Posted January 15, 2012 doesn't say. This is new to me, and there isn't much info so I thought I would throw it out there to those that are far superior in studies than I to see if this has been addressed before
volgadon Posted January 15, 2012 Posted January 15, 2012 Clutching at straws. For starters, try Beit Loya rather than Lehi.
Sevenbak Posted January 15, 2012 Posted January 15, 2012 According to wiki, both are correct, as is a third interpretation.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khirbet_Beit_LeiKhirbet Beit Lei, Khirbet Beit Lehi or Beth Loya is an archaeological tell in the Judean lowlands, of Israel. It is located about 5.5 km southeast of Beth Guvrin on a hill 400 m above sea level.
TAO Posted January 15, 2012 Posted January 15, 2012 (edited) Huh... that is interesting...The drawings depicted three human figures, two ships, and two other figures that may be an encampment and a tent. The ships lead scholars to believe that the chambers were reused by Israelite refugees fleeing the Chaldaean armies in the sixth century BCE, probably Levites. Ships are a common motif in ancient Near Eastern burial chambers.Not that it has anyting to do with it, but it sure is intresting.In any case, Jeffrey Chadwick doesn't think it has anything to do with it: https://ojs.lib.byu.edu/spc/index.php/RelEd/article/viewFile/2355/2192 Edited January 15, 2012 by TAO
volgadon Posted January 16, 2012 Posted January 16, 2012 According to wiki, both are correct, as is a third interpretation.http://en.wikipedia....hirbet_Beit_LeiKhirbet Beit Lei, Khirbet Beit Lehi or Beth Loya is an archaeological tell in the Judean lowlands, of Israel. It is located about 5.5 km southeast of Beth Guvrin on a hill 400 m above sea level.Beit Lehi as a variation is highly disputed.
Ron Beron Posted January 16, 2012 Posted January 16, 2012 (edited) Again from Wiki the following gives a bit info on the inscriptions...Seven inscriptions in Biblical Hebrew remained in various states of preservation, and there is some disagreement about how they should be read. It appears that the wordsYHWH (Yahweh) and YRSHLM (Jerusalem) feature in the inscriptions which Naveh dated to the late 6th century BCE.יהוה אלהי כל הארץ, הרי יהד לו לאלהי ירשלם, המוריה אתה חננת נוה יה יהוהI remember an Ensign article about this a number of years ago. I'll look for the cite.Here's a list or references offered by the Wiki article...^ New Light: The So-Called Lehi Cave^ Macalister, R.A.S. (1901). "On a Rock Cut Chapel at Beit Leyi". Palestine Exploration Fund Quarterly Statement (London: PEF) 33: 226–230. Retrieved 28 March 2011.^ a b Naveh, Joseph (1977). "כתובות עבריות במערת קברים מימי בית ראשון [Hebrew inscriptions from a burial cave of the first temple period]" (in Hebrew). ידיעות החברה לחקירת ארץ-ישראל ועתיקותיה (Israel Exploration Society) 27: 235–265.^ Yehuda Dagan (2006). Archaeological survey of Israel: Map of Amazya (109). The Northern Sector. Israel Antiquities Authority. pp. 101–104. ISBN 9789654061957.^ a b "Patrich, Joseph; Tsafrir, Yoram (1992). E.Stern. ed (in Hebrew). האנצקלופדיה החדשה לחפירות ארכיאולוגיות בארץ ישראל [The New Encyclopedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land]. I. pp. 181–186.^ עמוס כלונר; יגאל טפר (1987). מערכות־המסתור בשפלת יהודה [Hiding Refuges in the Judean Shephelah]. Israel Exploration Society. pp. 131–136.^ Yoram Tsafrir (1993). Ancient churches revealed. Israel Exploration Society. pp. 265–272. ISBN 9789652210166. Retrieved 5 April 2011.^ Magness, Jodi. The Archaeology of the Early Islamic Settlement in Palestine. Eisenbrauns. p. 109. ISBN 9781457500701. Retrieved 24 March 2011.^ Beit Lehi (Horbat Beit Loya)—The 2008 Excavation Seasons^ "דף שבועי מאת היחידה ללימודי יסוד ביהדות, מס' 186" (in Hebrew). Bar Ilan University. Retrieved March 29, 2011. Edited January 16, 2012 by Ron Beron
Cold Steel Posted January 18, 2012 Posted January 18, 2012 (edited) Yes, this is something that W. Cleon Skousen first wrote about.And like the Quetzalcoatl question, some LDS scholars are too quick, in my view, to declare it too good to be true. There were too many Lehis back then, they say. Anyone could have written those inscriptions and drawn those ships.True, but on the other hand, the untold story goes like this: Dr. Ginet was in Utah to do research on the Mormon people. He wasn't very interested in the theology, but more sociology. At some point, Skousen gave Ginet a copy of the Book of Mormon and urged him to read it. Ginet promised to and eventually found himself thumbing his way through it. He was largely unimpressed until he came to the part about the cave where Nephi and his brothers hid after fleeing Laban and his men.He told Skousen that he was stunned. He knew about the cave discovery in Israel, that it was dated around 600 B.C., and that it seemed to prophesy of the eventual redemption of Jerusalem and that those who made the inscriptions may have been planning to escape Jerusalem's destruction by way of ships. On his return trip to Utah, he brought the film (produced in Israel by non-LDS scholars) and gave it to Skousen. Ginat subsequently became a believer in the Book of Mormon, but was not, to my knowledge, baptized. He and Skousen became close friends and both visited the cave and photographed the inscriptions.I don't know whether it's the cave or not, but Ginat believes it was. According to the Arabs in the region, it was on the property of a prophet named Lehi. As I said, it was dated to 600 B.C. Lehi was wealthy and had a lot of land. He would sit under a tree and prophesy. If the brothers fled Laban, I'd think they would flee to someplace they were familiar with. I've read that it was also a burial site, but I can't document that.Also, Lehi may have been a common name, but how many of them were prophets? That's pretty much all I know. Based on that, I tend to think there's a real possibility that this was the cave. The church has a prohibition on baptizing Israelis, so I don't think Dr. Ginat was ever baptized. I do know, however, that he's a believer. See here for more information.And from Skousen's Treasures of The Book of Mormon:Did the Sons of Lehi Hide in the Cave of Beit Lehi?Although it was unknown to Latter-day Saints until 1970, there is a site approximately 20 miles southwest of Jerusalem which has been known locally for centuries as Beit Lehi or the "House of Lehi." Adjacent to this site is a cave in which someone hid out around 600 B.C., and made a number of datable inscriptions on the wall of this cave.During 1970-71, Dr. Joseph Ginat, an administrative assistant to the minister of Arab affairs of Israel, came to Utah to do some specialized studies and during this visit he saw a copy of the Book of Mormon for the first time. As a professionally trained archaeologist, he became fascinated with the possibility that the opening chapters of the Book of Mormon provided an explanation for the "Lehi story" which archaeologist in Israel have known about for many years.Dr. Ginat pointed out that not only could the ruins of the ancient community of Lehi have been the residence of the prophet Lehi but the nearby cave very well could have been the hideout for Nephi, Laman, Lemuel, Sam, and Zoram. Dr. Ginat feels that after the death of Laban the sons of Lehi would have felt compelled to go into hiding until the state of alarm had subsided. They would therefore have chosen some extremely obscure place with which they were familiar and where they knew they could obtain food and water. Dr. Ginat states that the cave of Beit Lehi fits all of these requirements in every respect.He further emphasizes that the Book of Mormon says these men were gone so long that their own mother gave up hope of their ever returning and went into mourning, thinking they were dead. This circumstance confirms the idea that they were in hiding for a long time and could have written the inscriptions on the wall of the Beit Lehi cave indicating that eventually Jerusalem would be redeemed.In June, 1974, Dr. Ginat returned to Utah with a film of the Beit Lehi cave and the surrounding terrain. He also brought with him a full-scale cast of the inscriptions on the wall of the cave.The narration on the Israeli film is very interesting since it gives a rather complete historical background on the Beit Lehi site, the nearby cave, and the Arab tradition concerning the ancient prophet Lehi who once lived there. Edited January 18, 2012 by Cold Steel
volgadon Posted January 18, 2012 Posted January 18, 2012 Do you know how far away it is from Jerusalem?
Ron Beron Posted January 19, 2012 Posted January 19, 2012 Do you know how far away it is from Jerusalem?Sounds like a setup of joke so..."How far is it?"
nosmelone Posted January 19, 2012 Posted January 19, 2012 Do you know how far away it is from Jerusalem?I think it is 22 miles southwest of Jerusalem. If I recall this is one reason that some scholars say it was not related to Lehi, because the "western" direction wouldn't have been the direction he traveled he would have traveled southeastern. Either way it is interesting and the judgement is still out I suppose.
pkb95632 Posted September 25, 2012 Posted September 25, 2012 As has already been noted, the archeologist Jeffery Chadwick studied this topic and concluded that Beit Lehi was not the home of the Book of Mormon Lehi. One of his main conclusions was that the name of the site was Beit Lei, not Lehi, which was Arabic for 'twisted' or 'bent' and not Hebrew for 'jaw' or 'cheekbone'. But, Hugh Nibley in his book Lehi in the Desert on page 44 quotes a source dating from 1881 that lists place names in western Palestine which includes Beit Lehi. Thus, the name predates the current discovery and discussion. Perhaps Chadwick is wrong about the name. If so, this weakens his objections but doesn't altogther dismiss his conclusions.
MormonMason Posted September 25, 2012 Posted September 25, 2012 (edited) 22 miles would seem at first glance a bit far to be "at Jerusalem." It is clear, however, from the Book of Mormon that Lehi actually did not live in Jerusalem. Wherever it was, it was "down" from Jerusalem and one had to "go up" to get from the place to the walls of Jerusalem.Another thing that may or may not be of relevance is that wherever it was, it had to be in a place where people would not necessarily have noticed that Lehi and family had been gone for an extended period of time. Had there been a sizable population surrounding his home, it is likely that it would have been ransacked and no riches available for the attempted purchase of the plates of brass. Then again, this could be nothing because they may have buried much of it to hide it.Additionally, if a fleeing group of people wanted to keep the direction of their initial encampment from being discovered, they might flee a different direction and hide in a cave that is not too near the ancient ways that could have led any pursuers back to their encampment. Edited September 25, 2012 by MormonMason 1
nealr Posted September 25, 2012 Posted September 25, 2012 Jeffrey R. Chadwick, "Khirbet Beit Lei and the Book of Mormon: An Archaeologist's Evaluation," Religious Educator 10/3 (2009): 17-48 is the best and most thorough treatment to date. He puts any association of the site with the Book of Mormon completely to rest, and he has far more more damning reasons than the simple fact that the Arabic lei (loya in Hebrew) is not the name Lehi.http://rsc.byu.edu/archived/Volume%2010%20Number%203%2C%202009/khirbet-beit-lei-and-book-mormon-archaeologist%E2%80%99s-evaluation 1
nealr Posted September 25, 2012 Posted September 25, 2012 According to wiki, both are correct, as is a third interpretation.http://en.wikipedia....hirbet_Beit_LeiKhirbet Beit Lei, Khirbet Beit Lehi or Beth Loya is an archaeological tell in the Judean lowlands, of Israel. It is located about 5.5 km southeast of Beth Guvrin on a hill 400 m above sea level.I think Wikipedia is simply acknowledging that the site has been called Khirbet Beit Lehi, not that it is a proper translation of the actual name. I see nothing from that Wiki entry that provides any defense for the translation as "Lehi".
volgadon Posted September 25, 2012 Posted September 25, 2012 As has already been noted, the archeologist Jeffery Chadwick studied this topic and concluded that Beit Lehi was not the home of the Book of Mormon Lehi. One of his main conclusions was that the name of the site was Beit Lei, not Lehi, which was Arabic for 'twisted' or 'bent' and not Hebrew for 'jaw' or 'cheekbone'. But, Hugh Nibley in his book Lehi in the Desert on page 44 quotes a source dating from 1881 that lists place names in western Palestine which includes Beit Lehi. Thus, the name predates the current discovery and discussion. Perhaps Chadwick is wrong about the name. If so, this weakens his objections but doesn't altogther dismiss his conclusions.Beit Lahi.
Flyonthewall Posted September 25, 2012 Author Posted September 25, 2012 I went to a presentation on this at UVU some months ago, and they had a disclaimer that this was in no way proof of anything in the Book of Mormon, but simply a dig site that needs support. There were some students from UVU that went and did some 3D mapping of the site.There was an Israeli archeologist that did the presentation and he kept pronouncing "Lehi" as "Le-hee".
nealr Posted September 26, 2012 Posted September 26, 2012 I went to a presentation on this at UVU some months ago, and they had a disclaimer that this was in no way proof of anything in the Book of Mormon, but simply a dig site that needs support. There were some students from UVU that went and did some 3D mapping of the site.There was an Israeli archeologist that did the presentation and he kept pronouncing "Lehi" as "Le-hee".Chadwick talks about that archaeologist in the article I linked to. He is a good archaeologist, but Chadwick suspects he is simply pandering to the people who are funding him in pronouncing it that way. Multiple scholars both inside and outside the Church have stressed that the word is not "Lehi" or "le-hee" (the correct pronunciation of Lehi). If you are interested in this topic, you really should read the Chadwick article.
Maidservant Posted September 26, 2012 Posted September 26, 2012 I went to a presentation on this at UVU some months ago, and they had a disclaimer that this was in no way proof of anything in the Book of Mormon, but simply a dig site that needs support. There were some students from UVU that went and did some 3D mapping of the site.There was an Israeli archeologist that did the presentation and he kept pronouncing "Lehi" as "Le-hee".There is an article about Beit Lehi in the most recent UVU alumni magazine.
Recommended Posts