notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 From Beyond the Rhine River...OR...From Beyond the Sea?Let's peel back the veneer from Roman history to see a key clue the Romans may have glossed over.When Julius Caesar encountered peoples in northern Europe, an entire new mythology* emerged.He claimed that the Rhine River was something of a demarcation separating Celts/Gauls and Germans. That Gaul(France) was historically Celtic territory. And everything east of the Rhine River was historically Germanic territory.Modern translations say that any peoples in Gaul who were the exception to that rule crossed over from beyond the Rhine.But how much has been lost to translation and assumption here?Tacitus and other Roman historians adopted and built upon Caesar's assumptions...assumptions which were believed almost without question until about two generations ago, when linguists and ethnologists started examining the evidence more critically. Their evidence for a Nordwest Block is intriguing. It merits a closer look at Caesar's and Tacitus' own words. Some of the best ancient candidates for Nephite immigrants were said by Caesar and/or Tacitus to have come from "trans Rehnum." Which is translated into "beyond the Rhine."However, here's the problem. per Peter Ellis, the Celtic word for the Rhine means "the sea".So something crucial may have been swept under the carpet here.If the Latin evidence derives from Celtic testimony, our core understanding of ancient European history may be inside up and upside down.When ancient accounts claimed that certain people came from "trans Rhenum", it may derive from Celtic testimony which equally means they came from beyond the Sea.So which is it?since the Latin "trans Rhenum" likely derives from a translation of Celtic testimony, the Celtic source itself also meant "beyond the sea." But Romans could only conceive of translation possibilities which aligned with their pre-existing framework. For according to ancient thought, there was nothing across the sea. So cognitive dissonance required them to dismiss the implications of Celtic testimony.If this correction isn't valid, why the were Belgae, who were said to be "trans Rhenum" found in ancient England?Now of course in isolation, this correction doesn't require that "beyond the sea" means anything beyond the North Sea or beyond the British Isles. But it should be weighed in the context of origin accounts which describe nautical features (currents, Sargasso Sea) far beyond the scope of the British Isles.But we'll return to some of that a bit later when we examine some of the earliest maps of the Atlantic Ocean.* By mythology, I mean a framework which people choose to believe. Not all mythologies are false. On the contrary, many contain valuable truths, and many are based on an important kernel of truth.
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 I mentioned nothing about shutting down the thread.Agreed. I didn't get that impression from your post either.My...comments were to suggest that notHagoth7 simply take sometime to look objectively at his evidence...I'm listening.Specifically which evidence do you feel isn't being treated fairly? (And why?)(The whole issue of objectivity is a separate matter...there have been entire threads on that here..)...and hypothesis chain.You guys are making things too complex.Either the Nephites were there. Or they weren't. It doesn't get any more complicated than that.1) If one deems they were, it explains and reconciles hundreds of European cultural anomalies (language, origin accounts, cultural traditions, artifacts, etc.)2) If one deems they weren't, one would chalk all those correlations up to coincidence and/or wishful thinking. The tradeoff being that one might have no historically-attested explanation for the anomalies themselves. They would just be hanging there. Lonely. Sad. Dejected. The elf in me votes for door #1.
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 A comparison of a few Egyptian and Mi'kmaq characters:I found this in my old files. I don't recall where it came from and can't locate its source online anywhere.Does this look familiar to anyone? I'd love to match it back up with the report that went along with the image.
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 Comparison between Nephite characters in the Anthon Manuscript and Mi'kmaqAt the very least, this provides a writing system1) used by Native Americans2) that aligns reasonably well with the Anthon manuscript, 3) and with Egyptian.And Stout's argument for the Anthon characters was somehow the most robust? The most reasonable? The most likely?Or is that no longer the case?Again, if anyone knows where the images came from, please holler out loud.(This is another file I've found in my archive. It likely came from the same report as the other.But I can't find any trace of it online. Has anyone seen either of these two comparisons before?Can anyone tell us where they came from, or how to get our hands on the study that went with them?)Also, for you Egyptian gurus, are the Egyptian characters in this analysis heiroglyphic or something else?
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 Is it now just a matter of waiting for the theory to emerge......that an uncle's former business associate discovered a Mi'kmaq document in 1826?
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 The only mention of an LDS Mi'kmaq advocate I've found so far is Ed Ashment.He apparently discussed something about it in this article:Edward H. Ashment, "The Book of Mormon--A Literal Translation?"Sunstone 5 (March-April 1980): 10-14.Does anyone have access to that? And could you tell us whether images like these are in that article?Also, apparently Barry Fell did a very similar comparison with four of the five same Egyptian characters.Here's an article about Barry Fell's comparisons which concludes:[The priest who documented the Mi'kmaq symbols] "died 61 years before Champollion first published his decipherment of Egyptian hieroglyphics. It is unreasonable, therefore, to believe that Maillard could have invented Micmac writing with its Egyptian affinities. Either the affinities are the product of chance or Precolumbian contacts occurred between the Micmac and Egyptian voyagers."
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 Now I'm not insisting that a small sample of characters overlapping with Egyptian proves that Mi'kmaq derives from Egyptian.But the parallels are considerably more significant than Stout's analysis - since it's not just a matter of the symbols resembling one another, but also a matter of the visual matches having overlapping meanings. That's quite significant.Furthermore, we have the matter of Mi'kmaq corresponding to characters in the Anthon Manuscript, which are said to be reformed Egyptian. In such a context, what of Stout's theory?Are Joseph's assertions now at least as plausible?And this statement:"And now, behold, we have written this record according to our knowledge, in the characters which are called among us the reformed Egyptian, being handed down and altered by us, according to our manner of speech."Does that statement now sound more like that of a credible ancient historian?Is the premise of Nephites being historical, flesh-and-blood people becoming reasonable?
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 Does the Nephite record merit a closer reading?
Gary@rics Posted December 6, 2009 Posted December 6, 2009 Now I'm not insisting that a small sample of characters overlapping with Egyptian proves that Mi'kmaq derives from Egyptian.But the parallels are considerably more significant than Stout's analysis - since it's not just a matter of the symbols resembling one another, but also a matter of the visual matches having overlapping meanings. That's quite significant.Furthermore, we have the matter of Mi'kmaq corresponding to characters in the Anthon Manuscript, which are said to be reformed Egyptian. In such a context, what of Stout's theory?Are Joseph's assertions now at least as plausible?And this statement:"And now, behold, we have written this record according to our knowledge, in the characters which are called among us the reformed Egyptian, being handed down and altered by us, according to our manner of speech."Does that statement now sound more like that of a credible ancient historian?Is the premise of Nephites being flesh-and-blood, historical people becoming reasonable?Wow, I've been busy for a day and look how much has gone forward! Please forgive me for being selective about what specific topics I respond to. I'll start with this latest.You ask if "the premise of the Nephites being flesh-and-blood historical people" sounds reasonable. I don't think that is what this thread is about. It was not the topic when I last visited! Rather, this thread is about an alternative to Stout's claim that similarities between the Detroit Manuscript and the Anthon characters are evidence that Joseph Smith was involved in a fraud. The alternative hypothesis, put forward in this thread by notHagoth7, relies on the prospect of Nephites crossing the Atlantic at least once from the Americas to northeastern Europe and at least once back to the same place in the Americas, and via that exchange bringing the Nephite writing shorthand to Europe. While there are many fascinating sidenotes and spinoffs from this premise, that is the core of notHagoth7's challenge to Stout. If his postulate were substantiated, then it would account for the similarity between the characters provided by Joseph Smith to Professor Anthon and a manuscript found and publicized in the region a few years before. It would eliminate the stain on Joseph Smith's character and erase an indictment against the Book of Mormon itself.The earlier link to the Mi'kmaq (and all the other ways that name is spelled!) is worth scanning again. I found that particular article diffuse and at times just plain confusing. As best I could tell, the characters used to encode Mi'kmaq language were provided by Europeans who utilized Tironian script to phonetically encode their speech. Only the spoken language--not the form of writing--were original to the Mi'kmaq. If I'm correct in how I read the article, this rare text of Mi'kmaq language offers no evidence of such characters being used by Native Americans.In your statement above, you conclude that "the parallels are considerably more significant than Stout's analysis - since it's not just a matter of the symbols resembling one another, but also a matter of the visual matches having overlapping meanings." I disagree. Much of Stout's analysis is specifically about the meanings of the Anthon characters, the ones copied from the golden plates and carried by Martin Harris to Professor Anthon. The Detroit Manuscript has not been found and is presumed to have been lost in the fire of the professor who last had possession. According to Stout, we do have multiple descriptions of the manuscript, which created a stir in New York in 1823. These scholarly and newspaper descriptions together provide an indication of at least some of its contents. Of the hundreds of pages, some were specifically determined to be an explanation for an aspect of the Catholic eucharist. Thus, the manuscript--with its described mix of Tironian characters and Latin marginal notes--was expected to hold many religious terms. Stout found that the characters in the Anthon manuscript seemed to abound with religious meaning. The described mix of Latin and Trionian character also explained why the Anthon paper had at least one figure that appeared to be Latin in origin: an 'et' (and). One suspects that an uneducated person copying facsimilies of the Detroit Manuscript, aware that its script was initially considered mysterious and unreadable, might not realize that it also contained a much less mysterious character, the Latin equivalent of our English ampersand: "&". Stout did indeed review both the visual matches and overlapping meanings of the Anthon characters.Stout's theory, it seems to me, is only further corroborated by the Mi'kmaq text, which you cite. It was, after all, "a 19th century Catholic prayer and service book, handwritten in the Mi'kmaq-R
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 Wow, I've been busy for a day and look how much has gone forward! Please forgive me for being selective about what specific topics I respond to.Welcome back. Understood completely. Respond to whatever seems appropriate, and feel free to let the rest slide.You ask if "the premise of the Nephites being flesh-and-blood historical people" sounds reasonable. I don't think that is what this thread is about.It's simple bridge building. If I recall correctly, someone in the thread said they'd have to come to terms with Nephites being real before being able to contemplate the idea of Nephites being in Europe. Wasn't that you?Either way, the Mi'kmaq discussion offers a bridge to help get to that first step, should one wish to choose it.Rather, this thread is about an alternative to Stout's claim that similarities between the Detroit Manuscript and the Anthon characters are evidence that Joseph Smith was involved in a fraud. The alternative hypothesis, put forward in this thread by notHagoth7, relies on the prospect of Nephites crossing the Atlantic at least once from the Americas to...EuropeYes.but that is the core of notHagoth7's challenge to Stout.I have expanded the challenge, and now extend it to encompass Mi'kmaq's apparent correlation with Egyptian.As best I could tell, the characters used to encode Mi'kmaq language were provided by Europeans who utilized Tironian script to phonetically encode their speech.Apologies for the confusing link. The article didn't assert any association between Tironian and Mi'kmaq. It was simply a link to a page about various shorthand systems. Mi'kmaq and Tironian are both mentioned on that page, but not in the same historical context. (Unless I missed something.)Only the spoken language--not the form of writing--were original to the Mi'kmaq.That's not accurate. Mi'kmaq children were initially observed making the characters, which led to a priest beginning to collect them.If I'm correct in how I read the article, this rare text of Mi'kmaq language offers no evidence of such characters being used by Native Americans. The subsequent links I provided demonstrate that they were used by and collected from the Natives. In your statement above, you conclude that "the parallels are considerably more significant than Stout's analysis - since it's not just a matter of the symbols resembling one another, but also a matter of the visual matches having overlapping meanings." I disagree. Much of Stout's analysis is specifically about the meanings of the Anthon charactersI'm listening.Thus, the manuscript-was expected to hold many religious terms. Stout found that the characters in the Anthon manuscript seemed to abound with religious meaning. The described mix of Latin and Trionian character also explained why the Anthon paper had at least one figure that appeared to be Latin in origin: an 'et' (and)...Stout indeed reviewed both the visual matches and overlapping meanings of the Anthon characters.That actually rings a bell now. I stand corrected on that detail. (It has been years since I have read it.) Thank you for the response on that.Stout's theory, it seems to me, is only further corroborated by the Mi'kmaq text, which you cite.Interesting. I reached the exact opposite conclusion. Because of the Egyptian correlation.It was, after all, "a 19th century Catholic prayer and service book, handwritten in the Mi'kmaq-R
Gary@rics Posted December 6, 2009 Posted December 6, 2009 In a previous post I described a cognitive bias, the representativeness heuristic. I now regret the manner in which I presented it, since my point about the cognitive bias has been tossed aside while an arbitrary probability game took center stage. I'm going to try once more to describe the bias. For any claim X, its probability of being true must be equal to or greater than the probability of X and Y and Z all being true.By contrast, when we hear of concurrent additional conditions that fit our expectations, our confidence in those notions increases with each new claim. Thus, we tend to be more trusting of the statement, "It's Monday and the TV is on and Monday Night Football is underway and Dad has already cussed at the officials" than we are of the statement, "It's Monday."I mentioned the representativeness heuristic because I thought I observed it operation in notHagoth7's impressive theorizing about the role of Nephites in European history. There is some probability that his basic hypothesis is true: Nephites brought Tironian shorthand to Europe, thus explaining how Joseph Smith was innocent in providing to Professor Anthon characters that resembled Tironian script known to have existed and been publicized in New York in 1823.Whatever that probability is--high, low, or 50%--the cumulative probability must be even lower for the hypothesis that Nephites brought Tironian shorthand to Europe, and sailed on an eastern sea that Alma said was in the west, and traveled to a land northeast that Alma called the land north, and traveled back to America within a year, and successfully sailed back to Europe even though Alma wrote that they were presumed lost in the sea, and befuddled Julius Caesar's navy, and were the foundation of multiple northeast European legends, and provided the kernel of truth found in Beowulf, and had one of their members enslaved and taken to Rome to be the scribe of Cicero, and taught the Romans the shorthand previously known only to a select few Nephites, and created an influx and widespread adoption of non-IndoEuropean words related to bears and seafaring, and that were forefathers of all the Caucasian Mormons who are the embodiment of Book of Mormon prophecies, and are somehow connected to elves, orcs, and Tolkein's historically-informed novels.NotHagoth7 used the same mental tools on me and my favoring the Stout hypothesis. Yesterday he asked asked me to estimate the probability of a series of conditions, based on my own life. The crux of the questioning--as I took it--was this: how likely is it that a person would end up with objects obtained from deceased or now-absent associates of our relatives? Wow, at first I thought he was right. But then I remembered: I have two tie pins--one shaped like an F16 and the other like an F4--that I got from my dad who got them 20+ years ago from a buddy at work. Once I broke through the mental barrier, a flood of other "hits" came to mind, from multiple sources and kinds. I have multiple documents that came from associates of my Grandpa when he was a mission president, two copies of photos given to my uncle in World War II, and several pieces of sheet music originally given to my great-aunt by a former singing companion. I also have an extensive collection of copied documents that funneled to me because of my employment and a hobby. I have two photo albums and three file folders filled with cartoons about my area of employment. I have loaned them out to family and friends. People came to know that I had an interest in these sorts of comics and for years have been sending them my way. Or course, I add them to my collection. After my sample of one, notHagoth7, I would guess that the odds of such a thing are pretty high.I decided to do a convenience sampling technique. I met with a group of friends today, seven of us who made plans before we knew about the winter storm. While at lunch I asked them noHagoth7's original questions. The responses varied wildly, from 0% to 100%, partly because one person has virtually the same team of coworkers today that she had 10 years ago. So instead, I asked them about having any physical objects that they obtained from former associates of relatives. Each one of my friends answered yes. They all had at least one such object, including letters, articles, calipers, a gun, the expanding descendents of a hens-and-chicks plant, recipes, cartoons, and books. So back to your original questions, notHagoth7: I calculated the odds as you presented them, calculated the odds as I estimated them, and then sought empirical evidence to settle the matter. Did the sequence of conditions--those required by Stout's hypothesis--render improbable his claim that Joseph Smith obtained copies of the Detroit Manuscript characters from his mother's brother? Yes, the initial calculating yielded extreme improbability estimates. But those initial estimates were off by a factor of more than 1,000 when compared to data from an informal sample. Rather than seeming unlikely, it appears that the odds are surprisingly high. How about you? Do you have objects--letters, articles, books, or memorabilia--that came from former associates of relatives? If so, it just helps add to the plausibility of Stout's hypothesized chain of possession.The extras of notHagoth7's research and speculating--all the scintillating possibilities and potential iterations--add to the thrill and scope of it all. But they do not add to the likelihood that it is true. I might be the lone voice on this point, but for me, the extras only serve to exceed my capacity to believe. NotHagoth7 does have a core hypothesis. There are predictions that would come of that hypothesis. So far I haven't seen evidence that strengthens that core hypothesis.I don't know about the other skeptics here. But I don't expect devout LDS people to abandon their convictions because of one challenge to the authenticity of the Book of Mormon. People adhere to Mormonism or any religion because of many valid reasons: it informs their lives, guides, gives meaning, comforts, and offers promise. There is also the not irrelevant matter that they sincerely believe it to be true. I struggle with the belief part, even though I was raised LDS and still sometimes long for the former benefits of trying and pretending to believe. Even from my skeptical stance, there was such comfort and good in the hope that maybe...Yesterday I asked three direct questions. Only one person answered, in each case shying away from the actual questions and finally reaching a draw: neither Stout nor notHagoth7 won, by his vote. No one else even responded. They were good question, too, I thought.What I want to request is a candid acknowledgement that Stout's article--if verified by subsequent research--is a bruising indictment about at least some of the story surrounding the translation and publication of the Book of Mormon. If the best counter-argument available so far invokes elves and Frodo and western seas that lie to the east, making us gulp and choose our words carefully before answering simple questions, it might be time to concede that the alternative hypothesis itself is insufficient. Drawing from an ever widening range of strained connections, obfuscating with innuendo and indirect questions, and an engaging and pleasant social style does not alter the conclusion that I suspect most of the readers have already reached: Nephites in Europe is not a compelling argument.That brings me to a rather edgy follow-up question. What would it say about a system of belief if it caused people to defend ideas that they don't actually believe?Unless I'm a horrible judge of people, I don't think most readers of this thread buy the hypothesis that Nephites carried Latin shorthand to Europe. On the other hand, most readers of this thread also don't believe that Joseph Smith lied. That claim probably flies so directly in the face of what is trusted and held dear that anything--however fanciful--is accepted. I would suggest that a better approach is to attack the first hypothesis and acknowledge that a better answer isn't available. Yet.Gary@rics.
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 In a previous post I described a cognitive bias, the representativeness heuristic. I now regret the manner in which I presented it, since my point about the cognitive bias has been tossed aside while an arbitrary probability game took center stage. I'm going to try once more to describe the bias. For any claim X, its probability of being true must be equal to or greater than the probability of X and Y and Z all being true.There's also the issue of confirmation bias. The argument could be made that the mounting evidence in this thread traces to my own confirmation bias.On the other hand, one could also conclude that it can be traced to my brother opening my mind to an idea, which allowed me to begin seeing realities I hadn't even considered before.One's own confirmation bias might determine which of those two paths one chooses.Unless, of course, one genuinely desires to overcome one's own confirmation bias...to see what's behind the mirror.It can be a worthwhile exercise sometimes.By contrast, when we hear of concurrent additional conditions that fit our expectations, our confidence in those notions increases with each new claim. Thus, we tend to be more trusting of the statement, "It's Monday and the TV is on and Monday Night Football is underway and Dad has already cussed at the officials" than we are of the statement, "It's Monday."Except in such a scenario, I would have to believe we're in an alternate reality. Because I've never heard my dad cuss. Nor can I ever remember him spending time watching a sports event that one of his kids weren't playing in.There is some probability that his basic hypothesis is true: Nephites brought Tironian shorthand to Europe, thus explaining how Joseph Smith was innocent in providing to Professor Anthon characters that resembled Tironian script known to have existed and been publicized in New York in 1823.While agreeing with the general statement, moving forward, I might opt for some word other than "probability" - since such a term is generally used for assessing the likelihood of some future outcome. Either something happened or it didn't. Math doesn't change that.Whatever that probability is--high, low, or 50%--the cumulative probability must be even lower for the hypothesis that Nephites brought Tironian shorthand to Europe, and sailed on an eastern sea that Alma said was in the west, and traveled to a land northeast that Alma called the land north, and traveled back to America within a year, and successfully sailed back to Europe even though Alma wrote that they were presumed lost in the sea, and befuddled Julius Caesar's navy, and were the foundation of multiple northeast European legends, and provided the kernel of truth found in Beowulf, and had one of their members enslaved and taken to Rome to be the scribe of Cicero, and taught the Romans the shorthand previously known only to a select few Nephites, and created an influx and widespread adoption of non-IndoEuropean words related to bears and seafaring, and that were forefathers of all the Caucasian Mormons who are the embodiment of Book of Mormon prophecies, and are somehow connected to elves, orcs, and Tolkein's historically-informed novels.Interesting. You interpret the mounting evidence as somehow decreasing the likelihood of Joseph conveying the truth? Doesn't that seem odd to you?That the Book would and did go forth to Nephites, Jacobites, and Josephites....See, here's the deal. This framework is not as fragile or brittle of an approach as you're making out here. One, two, three, or a half dozen correlations (of the 100+ correlations explored) tracing to some other explanation wouldn't reduce the viability of the overall premise. It would still be robust. Every piece of evidence explored doesn't have be due to Nephite influence, in order for European Nephites to be the cause of the rest of the correlations. Truths can be independent of one another. So your assertion that exploring additional evidence somehow reduces the likelihood of the overall premise being true is flawed logic.The evidence simply serves to demonstrate the viability of 1) the Book of Mormon being a true record. 2) and the book's claim to helping us learn our heritage also being true. 3) And the D&C's 1828 prophecy that the book would go to Nephite/Jacobite/Josephite descendants being true. If one or a dozen correlations end up being due to another explanation - no sweat. That wouldn't negate or reduce the truth of the three items above.There is still sufficient ability for the remaining evidence to open the door. And then some.As to the eastern sea being the western sea, you perhaps haven't assessed the evidence fully. If you examine the map I linked to earlier in the thread, you might see that it demonstrates how the Gulf of Mexico was, to the perspective of some in Mesoamerica, their west sea. And the Pacific was due south of them - their south sea. We need to take a walk in their moccasins and view the world as they would likely have viewed it, rather than impose our perspective on their culture. (Again, I'm not arguing for a Mesoamerican Zarahemla - since I'm still Zarahemla-agnostic. That was just an exercise in seeing whether the premise can align with each of the best-known LGT models without doing violence to the text. If it couldn't have fit the Mesoamerican LGT, I would have had to simply posit that the European premise was not compatible with that LGT theory.) [cont'd]
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 NotHagoth7 used the same mental tools on me and my favoring the Stout hypothesis. Yesterday he asked asked me to estimate the probability of a series of conditions, based on my own life. The crux of the questioning--as I took it--was this: how likely is it that a person would end up with objects obtained from deceased or now-absent associates of our relatives? Wow, at first I thought he was right. But then I remembered: I have two tie pins--one shaped like an F16 and the other like an F4--that I got from my dad who got them 20+ years ago from a buddy at work. Once I broke through the mental barrier, a flood of other "hits" came to mind, from multiple sources and kinds. I have multiple documents that came from associates of my Grandpa when he was a mission president, two copies of photos given to my uncle in World War II, and several pieces of sheet music originally given to my great-aunt by a former singing companion.I can't argue against your experience. I can only argue from my own. Which don't align with what you're saying. So to push this beyond the anecdotal, and more properly weigh things in the model you would prefer to use, it would be more scientific to launch a poll, to assess which of our two realities is the aberration, and which is the norm.After my sample of one, notHagoth7, I would guess that the odds of such a thing are pretty high.Again, while I'm not one for believing odds have a whole lot to do with the past, I'd like to see your math behind your assertion above. Perhaps a poll that queries for each of the data contingencies I presented (links between A, B, C, D, and E). To get a better idea of the bell chart for each contingency. Or, one could read the Book of Mormon. Ponder it. And ask God if it is true.I decided to do a convenience sampling technique. I met with a group of friends today, seven of us who made plans before we knew about the winter storm. While at lunch I asked them noHagoth7's original questions. The responses varied wildly, from 0% to 100%, partly because one person has virtually the same team of coworkers today that she had 10 years ago. So instead, I asked them about having any physical objects that they obtained from former associates of relatives.Each one of my friends answered yes. They all had at least one such object, including letters, articles, calipers, a gun, the expanding descendents of a hens-and-chicks plant, recipes, cartoons, and books.That's surprising. Are you sure the question they answered is the same one that you asked.You're saying that their letters, articles, calipers, gun, plant, recipes, cartoons, and books they got from their relatives were all once owned by their relatives' former associates? That's beyond surprising.So back to your original questions, notHagoth7: I calculated the odds as you presented them, calculated the odds as I estimated them, and then sought empirical evidence to settle the matter. Did the sequence of conditions--those required by Stout's hypothesis--render improbable his claim that Joseph Smith obtained copies of the Detroit Manuscript characters from his mother's brother? Yes, the initial calculating yielded extreme improbability estimates.OK But those initial estimates were off by a factor of more than 1,000 when compared to data from an informal sample. Rather than seeming unlikely, it appears that the odds are surprisingly high.What was your outcome? And what were the underlying numbers for that outcome.How about you? Do you have objects--letters, articles, books, or memorabilia--that came from former associates of relatives?Not a stitch.If so, it just helps add to the plausibility of Stout's hypothesized chain of possession.And since I don't....?Again, while I genuinely appreciate this discussion, and am more than willing to continue discussing it, the core problem in this whole exercise is this: probability isn't a very effective tool for fathoming the past.
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 The extras of notHagoth7's research and speculating--all the scintillating possibilities and potential iterations--add to the thrill and scope of it all.Good. I'm glad you're enjoying the journey.But they do not add to the likelihood that it is true. I might be the lone voice on this point, but for me, the extras only serve to exceed my capacity to believe.Interesting. Why? Does it seem too good to be true?NotHagoth7 does have a core hypothesis. There are predictions that would come of that hypothesis. So far I haven't seen evidence that strengthens that core hypothesis.Huh.I struggle with the belief part, even though I was raised LDS and still sometimes long for the former benefits of trying and pretending to believe.Belief is not something that happens to us. Or a mere feeling. Belief is part of an actual conscious choice - a path we choose to walk.Even from my skeptical stance, there was such comfort and good in the hope that maybe...Good. At some point, as you're certainly aware, the idea is to move beyond a maybe, and make a decision.At the River Jordan, Joshua told the people to make a choice. "Choose ye this day..."In this matter, you also get to choose when that day of decision arrives.But I'd encourage you to make one. Sooner than later.Your forefathers made that choice.The Book of Mormon attests to that.neither Stout nor notHagoth7 won What I want to request is a candid acknowledgement that Stout's article--if verified by subsequent research--is a bruising indictment about at least some of the story surrounding the translation and publication of the Book of Mormon.Opposition in all things. It is a counterpoint. I have no qualms acknowledging that. If the best counter-argument available so far invokes elves and Frodo and western seas that lie to the east, making us gulp and choose our words carefully before answering simple questions, it might be time to concede that the alternative hypothesis itself is insufficient.Problem being:1) Elves existed. (Not the pointy-eared mythical variety.) They were a real people who inhabited, for example, the Elbe River region. They sailed real seas. Walked through real woods. That likely includes Angles and Saxons in the Elbe region. Some of them migrated elsewhere - to England, and the Americas...etc. So feel free to make light of your own forefathers. But why would you want to?2) If we accept the Scandinavian manuscript evidence, Frodo actually existed. (Just not Tolkien's fictional spin on that name.)3) And the Gulf of Mexico IS west of the Yucatan. One doesn't have to gulp to acknowledge that.Paul drew from local cultural icons to help illustrate various points of the gospel. Are you suggesting such an approach is somehow inappropriate?...Nephites in Europe is not a compelling argument.So be it. March on.That brings me to a rather edgy follow-up question. What would it say about a system of belief if it caused people to defend ideas that they don't actually believe?I don't follow. Are you suggesting that I don't believe the things I've written here?Or that I don't believe in the Book of Mormon?Or Joseph's mantle as a prophet?Or in God?I do believe. Deeply. Unless I'm a horrible judge of people, I don't think most readers of this thread buy the hypothesis that Nephites carried Latin shorthand to Europe.You're implying that Tironian was Latin. Others have compared it favorably to demotic (Egyptian).If so, that would mean the system was simply ported over to Latin, and later expanded to include abbreviations for Latin words.Based on the evidence within Roman culture and within Cicero's letters, Tiro was something other than Roman. Things rarely happen in a vacuum. They're usually development/improvements from some other idea or culture. Cultural diffusion. It happens every day.On the other hand, most readers of this thread also don't believe that Joseph Smith lied. That claim probably flies so directly in the face of what is trusted and held dear that anything--however fanciful--is accepted.What precisely is fanciful?I would suggest that a better approach is to attack the first hypothesis and acknowledge that a better answer isn't available.Not my preferred tack. Nature hates a vacuum.And I'm less interested in attacking what others choose to believe as I am in sharing what I believe.If I am going to suggest that people discard something, I want to offer them something of equal or greater value in exchange. Plus, I firmly believe Nephites were in Europe. It reconciles my heritage, and helps me love it more. So why would I even want to discard it?
USU78 Posted December 6, 2009 Posted December 6, 2009 An interesting construct, notHagoth. Are you thinking about gathering these things together and maybe selling copies in Desydoesbooks?
erichard Posted December 6, 2009 Posted December 6, 2009 Comparison between Nephite characters in the Anthon Manuscript and Mi'kmaq...At the very least, this provides a writing system1) used by Native Americans2) that aligns reasonably well with the Anthon manuscript, 3) and with Egyptian....Hi not,I have not yet read all of this thread, but do find it interesting. Here is the idea my friend Bob has told me:Since no other native Americans have a written language (that I know of), and since the Mi'kmaq language has similarities with the Egyptian and the Anthon transcript, it is possible that Moroni, after he buried the plates for Joseph to find, traveled on and eventually lived with the Mi'kmaq and taught them the written language he had. And they used it for generations until the Europeans came.As a servant of the Lord, I can believe the Lord would provide a place for Moroni to spend his last days around others instead of being completely alone. You may have already said this in this thread. I am sure others have also thought of this.Richard
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 Are you thinking about gathering these things togetherDone already.and maybe selling copies in Desydoesbooks?Short answer: That's not my plan.** Long Answer to A Question You Might Now Wish You had Never Asked:1) I intend to keep the digital text available on my website. This thread will be a helpful corollary to that.2) Or, if people want, for their own personal use, they can print it out and put in a three-ring notebook on the shelf.3) If there was ever sufficient interest in a professionally-bound version, it's something I'd be willing to do. One of the advantages of avoiding publishers is that you can get it professionally bound, and still keep a digital version available. 4) I am working on an initial DVD, which will likely go into replication later this month...we've become more of a visual culture than a reading culture, so I'm hoping that approach will make the message more accessible to people and families...rather than a footnote-intensive book that few people read.5) As a corollary, Elves in History, which I've only dipped into here, is nearing completion, and that's a book I intend to publish. 6) Also, I'm working nearing completion on the Elves in History DVD. (Not the pointy-eared variety.) Remains to be seen which of the two DVD's goes to replication first.7) There are a handful of other items (most of them related in some way) in various stages of completion in the pipeline. About half of them are book-type items. Most of the others are screenplays.**Basically, in the digital age, I'm not a fan of dealing with distributors and bookstores. I've been there, done that - and it was WAY more hassle than it needed to be. It also puts a big distance between you and those reading your stuff. I'd rather deal directly with a reading audience. It's a MUCH better way to get feedback on things that might help improve the next edition etc.It allows you to be more nimble and keep your print runs smaller so you CAN improve the next edition, rather than be stuck with a few hundred books or DVD's that you wish you could ship with the two newest chapters or the new map into. Etc. And as a researcher/writer, the old-school brick-and-mortar publishing route is WAY more anti-climatical than most people might imagine.My wife and I were actually discussing the logistics of all this a few days ago, but I intend on creating an option on my site later this week to allow people to preorder the DVD content if they'd like, to help us gauge how many we'll replicate in the first run.Are you sorry you asked?
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 As a servant of the Lord, I can believe the Lord would provide a place for Moroni to spend his last days around others instead of being completely alone.I agree with that thought completely.And Bob's Mi'kmaq corollary is really interesting.You may have already said this in this thread.I've said something similar in the book (about the Lord providing a place for Moroni).I don't yet have a framework for what to do with Mi'kmaq, since I haven't adopted a geographic framework for Zarahemla. But I certainly like Bob's suggestion. Especially as an explanation for how the script got there. I appreciate you sharing it here. Please thank him.Either way, an Egyptian-resembling script in the northeast corner of North America does suggest that Joseph's claim to having ancient plates from such a culture, as testified to by over a dozen eyewitnesses, has interesting corroboration.My book does briefly explore the idea that Moroni may have found a way to reunite with Nephites in Europe.Both that and Bob's general suggestion could be true.He could have dwelt among the Mi'kmaq while enlisting their help building a boat.And taught them worthwhile skills (like writing) in exchange for their time and labor.Some of you may be aware of the event in England, with Heber C. Kimball, where he experienced such an overwhelming outpouring of the Spirit that he wept and wept. Later, he asked Joseph what it meant.First, here's his account from his journal:"These towns seemed to be affected from one end to the other; parents called their children together, spoke to them of the subjects upon which I had preached, and warned them against swearing and all other evil practices, and instructed them in their duty, etc. Such a scene I presume was never witnessed in this place before ; the hearts of the people appeared to be broken, and the next morning they were all in tears, thinking they should sec my face no more. When I left them my feel- ings were such as I cannot describe. As I walked down the street, followed by numbers, the doors were crowded by the inmates of the houses, waiting to bid us a last farewell, who could only give vent to their grief in sobs and broken accents. While contemplating this scene we were induced to take off our hats, for we felt as if the place was holy ground. The Spirit of the Lord rested down upon us and [i was] constrained to bless that whole region of country. We were followed a considerable distance from the villages by a great number, who could hardly separate themselves from us. My heart was like unto theirs, and I almost thought my head was a fountain of tears, for I wept for several miles after I bid them adieu." When Heber later asked Joseph what it meant, who here remembers Joseph's reply?An answer here.
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 Christmas ChecklistOK, so far, we've covered:TannenbaumElvesWise MenWe Three KingsLeaving out Milk and CookiesA naughty and nice injunction from one of the other thread elvesA memorable ride to a land northwardBeing gathered with our familyAnd finally, the necessity of Christ's atonement, and his visit to our fathers, as he promisedHave we left any important part of the narrative out?
notHagoth7 Posted December 6, 2009 Author Posted December 6, 2009 Gary,The more I think about the math, the more I need to say this.It simply doesn't matter what the probability adds up to. It could be 1%. What matters is what actually happened.Here's another take on that.In any business setting, people will run a cost/benefit analysis. A risk/reward calculation.To see if the benefit outweighs the cost - to determine whether the potential reward outweighs the risk.If it does in spades, it's an investment, not a gamble.But your calculations focus heavily on the cost/risk. I'd suggest focusing on the benefit. On the reward.Likewise what does the cost of something matter if the payoff is considerable? In such a calculation, isn't there a point where such a cost becomes irrelevant?You say it's an exciting thought.Question: how does that compare to the test for a good seed, as explained by Alma?Would it be meaningful if Nephites helped shape Western Civilization - and the freedoms we enjoy today?Would it bring a smile to your face to descend from elves?Would it be even more meaningful if there was something that told of their origins? Your own family history?Why not test it from that vantage point.And see if it bears good fruit.Seriously. Remember the feeling of being a kid on Christmas morning?The left-side of the brain is important.But so is the right side.Please don't suffocate the kid inside with so much math that it drowns out the joy.Math isn't the safest route to certainty.For the things that matter, the path is more along the lines of something like Hope. Belief. Faith. Charity. Knowledge.
erichard Posted December 6, 2009 Posted December 6, 2009 ...I don't yet have a framework for what to do with Mi'kmaq, since I haven't adopted a geographic framework for Zarahemla. ...My book does briefly explore the idea that Moroni may have found a way to reunite with Nephites in Europe....When Heber later asked Joseph what it meant, who here remembers Joseph's reply?Like many, I believe that the Book of Mormon Cumorah was not the hill in upstate New York where Joseph got the plates. So I believe Moroni traveled alone after the final battle, and finally deposited the plates in New York.The idea of Nephites going to Europe sounds strange. But truth is often stranger than fiction. Have you read any about the Welch coming to America in 1170? http://www.madoc1170.com This could tie into your ideas.I do not remember Joseph's reply, or even this account, actually. Please tell us!Richard
notHagoth7 Posted December 7, 2009 Author Posted December 7, 2009 The idea of Nephites going to Europe sounds strange. But truth is often stranger than fiction. Have you read any about the Welch coming to America in 1170? http://www.madoc1170.com This could tie into your ideas.True. There are similar Irish accounts too.I do not remember Joseph's reply, or even this account, actually. Please tell us!Speaking of Heber's experience in England, Joseph explained: "some of the old Prophets traveled and dedicated that land, and their blessing fell upon you." (Church History in the Fulness of Times, p. 176).Old prophets. Who traveled. And dedicated land or lands. Does that ring a bell for anyone?In earlier LDS teaching, that was said to be one of Moroni's roles.So the 1828 prophecy about the record going to the Nephites.And Joseph's statement about prophets in ancient England.And another statement he made about the "old countries" of northern Europe and the gathering of Israel.Despite everything Joseph shared, it would appear that Joseph was holding several aces close to his chest.There's apparently much that he chose not to tell - for very specific reasons.But the glimpses of his meaning poke through.
thews Posted December 7, 2009 Posted December 7, 2009 Like many, I believe that the Book of Mormon Cumorah was not the hill in upstate New York where Joseph got the plates. So I believe Moroni traveled alone after the final battle, and finally deposited the plates in New York.Which final battle? The one Zelph fought in? What actual data are you using to make this assumption?
Gary@rics Posted December 7, 2009 Posted December 7, 2009 Welcome back. Understood completely. Respond to whatever seems appropriate, and feel free to let the rest slide.It's simple bridge building. If I recall correctly, someone in the thread said they'd have to come to terms with Nephites being real before being able to contemplate the idea of Nephites being in Europe. Wasn't that you?No, but with your prompt, I recall the question and I now see why you mentioned it.I have expanded the challenge, and now extend it to encompass Mi'kmaq's apparent correlation with Egyptian.Apologies for the confusing link. The article didn't assert any association between Tironian and Mi'kmaq. It was simply a link to a page about various shorthand systems. Mi'kmaq and Tironian are both mentioned on that page, but not in the same historical context. (Unless I missed something.)Thanks for clarifying. There were sections of the article that I found confusing. I thought the author's emphasis on the various shorthands was relevant to the Mi'kmaq script.That's not accurate. Mi'kmaq children were initially observed making the characters, which led to a priest beginning to collect them.The subsequent links I provided demonstrate that they were used by and collected from the Natives. I must have missed the subsequent links. The first link provided a lot of information, including some tentative indication of a type of shorthand being invented and practiced by the Greeks, long before Hagoth or Tiro. That would argue against the Hagoth hypothesis. One of the things you speculated earlier was that most Nephites were not familiar with the written shorthand used in the Book of Mormon, explaining why that form of writing died out in the Americas. If we now have evidence of children playfully using the script, then that part of your hypothesis should be replaced. For children to use it, the script must have been relatively easy to use and that much more likely to continue in use among remaining peoples in America. That would be only a secondary challenge to the core of your hypothesis, I believe.To my eyes, the Mi'kmaq script supports your hypothesis. I know you don't need my approval, but I find this to be the most meaningfully supportive evidence that you have presented. According to the accounts, did the script used by children actually encode phonetic features of the language with sufficient completeness that it actually constituted a form of writing? If so, this evidence is definitely in your favor.I know you dismiss the matters of probability, but they are important. Adding extra ncesssary conditions to a hypothesis reduces the likelihood that it will eventually prove out. There is an opposite effect, however, that results when we make a prospective list of the evidence called for by the hypothesis. I twice offered some ideas about that. That was neither cheeky nor dismissive, but a genuine gesture of how to either confirm or discredit your idea about Nephites in Europe. When a hypothesis predicts a finding, which only later is obtained, our confidence in the hypothesis increases. Maybe it would help to replace my use of "probability" with "confidence in the hypothesis." Sure, once a fact is determined, its probability becomes either 100% or 0%. Unavailable certainty is useless in guiding us on uncertain paths. When making life decisions--whom to marry, whether it is safe to travel on a snowy day, or which Internet sites to read--involves formal or informal determinations of probability. It matters.I have a favor to ask, being a newcomer here: how do I quickly navigate to a specific page in this thread? I want to go back and read those other links about the Mi'kmaq.I don't follow your assertion here. Where are you finding the assertion that Mi'kmaq is a form of Tironian? (Not that I object to that assertion - but I'm interested in the precise statement and its source.)That was how I interpreted the first article. Although I want to repeat: some of it was confusing to me. In the opening paragraphs it jumped wildly: the Mi'kmaq script found (Aha! I thought), then attributed to a Catholic priest (Scratch that! I corrected myself), followed by an admission that the author was initially wrong (Say what? I concluded). At times I could not tell what the author was trying to say. What of Mi'kmaq being a form of Egyptian? Coincidence? Or evidence of contact with seafarers who used Egyptian characters?I want to go back and read that. There have been mentions--not by you, but in some of the older documents considered here--that mistook Tironian for Egyptian and Phoencian, so I want to read those sources myself. I personally find it unlikely, so it would take fairly compelling evidence to convince me. Since it fits your expectations well, the evidence would not have to be so rigorous for you. That's fair. If the Mi'kmaq script proved to have evolved from Egyptian, I would see that as evidence favoring your hypothesis. How about you? If the Mi'kmaq script were found to be unrelated to Egyptian, would you consider it evidence against your hypothesis?Oh, you mentioned another cognitive bias: confirmation bias. I agree that it, too, is relevant here. For the record: it affects my thinking and judgment just as much as it does yours. According to the research on confirmation bias, the more effective way to reduce it is to define and then look for evidence that one's pet idea is wrong. My pet idea here is that Joseph Smith, Jr., was involved in some variety of fraud and that the Anthon characters are footprints from that misdeed. At this point I believe that Nephites did not visit Europe, did not introduce shorthand to the Old World, and did not lay a foundation for legends about elves or seafaring peoples from the west. The only way I am likely to find out if I'm wrong, however, is--well, that's why I'm here! This is my antidote to confirmation bias. I'm curious: what sort of evidence would, in your mind, discredit your hypothesis? What is your method for avoiding confirmation bias?By the way, I don't doubt your testimony. I don't think I even hinted at that and I apologize if I came across as attacking the sincerity of your religious convictions. What I suspected--apparently in error--was that even you found the Nephites-in-Europe notion to be a long shot. If you are convinced that it probably happened, I'm confident that you rank it well below your conviction about LDS theology, the Book of Mormon, and the existence of God. The way you write, those deeper forms of belief seem to be very close to the center of your being.Gary@rics
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.