Rob Bowman Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 Hannah Rebekah,You asked:Rob,Are you apart of or affiliated in anyway, directly or indirectly with the New Apostolic Movement?No. I am actually critical of the NAM.
Log Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 Rob,How shall we know you are personally authorized of God to make disciples?You are certainly free to ignore my questions, as you have heretofore done, but it is quite telling when you so do.
Hannah Rebekah Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 Hannah Rebekah,You asked:No. I am actually critical of the NAM.I understand that they also let others retain their previous sect as they fly under the radar. Are you following their beliefs in anyway as they are now assuming authority as well.
Vance Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 (edited) Vance,You wrote:That little rhetorical game of yours is really getting tiresome.As is your little game of avoiding the hard issues. You wrote:If you need me to answer that question, obviously you do not understand my position at all. So you have just contradicted yourself.Nah, it is you that doesn't understand your own position, at least not the weak and fallacious parts.How do you know your presumed interpretation is correct?The truth is, you don't. You can only presume it. And then, with that presumption you claim inclusion for yourself where it is NOT warranted.Now, show me, IF YOU CAN, how/why you are not presuming inclusion. Edited October 25, 2011 by Vance
Rob Bowman Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 Hannah Rebekah,You wrote:I understand that they also let others retain their previous sect as they fly under the radar. Are you following their beliefs in anyway as they are now assuming authority as well.No. I just told you, I am critical of the NAM. And you don't seem to have grasped what I mean by "authority." What I mean by authority is not an office or ecclesiastical rank. There are such offices (though not people holding the offices of apostle or prophet today), but all true Christians (persons adopted as God's children, believers in and followers of Jesus Christ, indwelled by the Holy Spirit) have "authority" in the sense that they are all "anointed" by and with the Holy Spirit (1 John 2:20, 27) and are God's people, described metaphorically in the words of Exodus 19:5-6 as a kingdom of priests (Rev. 1:6; 5:10), a royal priesthood (1 Peter 2:9). Thus all true believers--Jews and Gentiles, men and women (Gal. 3:28)--who have been baptized as disciples of Jesus Christ are God's adopted children through their faith in Christ (Gal. 3:27-4:7) and have "authority" to testify to Jesus Christ, to preach the true gospel, to study God's word in Scripture, to learn and grow and share with and teach others, to make disciples of all nations and teach those new disciples (Matt. 28:18-20).
Zakuska Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 Rob,How shall we know you are personally authorized of God to make disciples?You are certainly free to ignore my questions, as you have heretofore done, but it is quite telling when you so do.I beleive the biblical way was to asks for signs and tokens.
Rob Bowman Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 Vance,That's some audacity, criticizing me for supposedly avoiding hard issues (as if people like you and shalamabobbi are asking all the hard questions while most of the other LDS here are pitching softballs), while you have refused to answer a CFR issued by a fellow LDS about your false accusations against me.
DJBrown Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 DJ,You wrote:Could you comment on the following statement, please?"But if we are to live forever with our families in Heavenly Father’s presence, we must do all that the Savior commands us to do. This includes being baptized and confirmed and receiving the ordinances of the temple."--Gospel Principles (2009), 233.Rob,I think you missed my reply.The bolded portion of your quotation indicates that the book is outlining what is required for exaltation. But only those in the highest degree of the Celestial Kingdom are exalted. The temple ordinances are not required for the other degrees of the Celestial Kingdom. And all those who live in the Celestial Kingdom will live in the presence of the Father.So it is not necessary to receive the temple ordinances to enter the Celestial Kingdom. They are required to be exalted in that Kingdom.Thanks.
shalamabobbi Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 God's people, described metaphorically in the words of Exodus 19:5-6 as a kingdom of priests (Rev. 1:6; 5:10), a royal priesthood (1 Peter 2:9).Ah metaphorical..To be used like salt, too much and everything is spoiled, too little and you can't tweek the Bible to back up your position..
Rob Bowman Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 Log,You wrote:You are certainly free to ignore my questions, as you have heretofore done, but it is quite telling when you so do. Oh joy, another smartaleck who thinks his questions are so much harder than those of most of the other Mormons here. I don't even recall seeing your name before today, although I see you have posted a lot. You know, your previous post appeared less than two hours ago. Aren't you declaring your intellectual triumph over me a little hastily?You wrote:Do you possess the spirit of prophecy?As you define it, probably not, but it would help if you tell me what you think it means to possess the spirit of prophecy. I do have the Holy Spirit, who is the Spirit of prophecy, dwelling in me. In that sense, yes, I possess that Spirit; he dwells in me. Am I a prophet in the sense of holding a specific office of prophet in the church? No.What is the qualitative difference between your inspired words and the inspired writings of the apostles? In other words, why can't you write scripture, if indeed you are authorized by Jesus Christ to speak for Him, and to make disciples for Him? What accounts for the huge discrepancy between the powers of the apostles and yours?This is getting really old. I never claimed to speak inspired words, except when I quote Scripture. Why can't most of you ask me what I believe and pay attention to the answers I give before you jump to such off-the-wall conclusions?You asked:How do you know you have authority from Christ to make disciples for him? How can we know that you have such authority?Already answered.
Log Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 (edited) Log,You wrote:Oh joy, another smartaleck who thinks his questions are so much harder than those of most of the other Mormons here. I don't even recall seeing your name before today, although I see you have posted a lot. You know, your previous post appeared less than two hours ago. Aren't you declaring your intellectual triumph over me a little hastily?Sigh, another preacher come to lead us astray with his philosophy mingled with scripture. I asked a straightforward question. You bypassed my questions in favor of others posted after mine. The questions I have aren't hard, usually requiring yeses or noes for answers.As you define it, probably not, but it would help if you tell me what you think it means to possess the spirit of prophecy. I do have the Holy Spirit, who is the Spirit of prophecy, dwelling in me. In that sense, yes, I possess that Spirit; he dwells in me. Am I a prophet in the sense of holding a specific office of prophet in the church? No.Then you can prophesy, correct?This is getting really old. I never claimed to speak inspired words, except when I quote Scripture. Why can't most of you ask me what I believe and pay attention to the answers I give before you jump to such off-the-wall conclusions?Either you have the spirit of prophecy, or you do not; if you do have it, you can speak inspired words by the spirit; if you do not, you cannot. Which is it: can you or can't you?Already answered.Please post a link to whichever post you show how we can know YOU have been PERSONALLY authorized by God to make disciples for Him. I have missed it. I also missed the one where you explain exactly how you know you have such authority. Edited October 25, 2011 by Log
Rob Bowman Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 DJ,You wrote:I think you missed my reply.No, just hadn't gotten around to responding yet.The bolded portion of your quotation indicates that the book is outlining what is required for exaltation. But only those in the highest degree of the Celestial Kingdom are exalted. The temple ordinances are not required for the other degrees of the Celestial Kingdom. And all those who live in the Celestial Kingdom will live in the presence of the Father.So it is not necessary to receive the temple ordinances to enter the Celestial Kingdom. They are required to be exalted in that Kingdom.I understand what you are saying. However, earlier you had written:To enter that Kingdom, the basic requirements are to have faith in Jesus Christ, repent of one's sins, be baptized, received the Holy Ghost and endure to the end. All who do those things will enter the Celestial Kingdom.Since the vast majority of people who have ever lived will not be baptized in the LDS Church, that vast majority will need to have the temple ceremony of proxy baptism performed on their behalf to enter the Celestial Kingdom, won't they?Also, according to LDS doctrine, people who have accepted the LDS gospel, been baptized, etc., but are not "valiant," will go to the terrestrial kingdom, not the celestial kingdom (D&C 76:73-79; Gospel Principles, 272). I would guess that being temple worthy and participating in its rituals would be an indication that one was valiant, but perhaps that is an incorrect guess.
Calm Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 That has to be one of the screwiest criticisms I have seen in a while, and that's saying something. Anyone who acted on Christ's instructions (believing in Christ and submitting to his authority as Lord, getting baptized as a disciple of Christ, and committing to obey all that Christ commanded) would surely no longer be a non-Christian, "logically speaking"!!That would depend on which instructions they chose to follow, including what they believe in Christ, right? Otherwise LDS who most definitely believe in Christ, submit to his authority as Lord, get baptized as a disciple and commit to obeying all Christ commanded would be recognized as Christians by those of your own association.....and yet we are not.Of course we've been claiming we were qualified as Christians and have a Christian faith based on our obedience to this and other commandments of the Lord for years. I am glad you agree with us. Please spread the word, I expect to see the anti cult sites removing LDS from their target list shortly.
Calm Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 Something I can finally agree with..I'm on my way out the door. I just read the US constitution and am about to take action in the name of the USA..Great. I expect a tax refund of several thousand dollars at least to show up in my mailbox shortly.
Zakuska Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 That would depend on which instructions they chose to follow, including what they believe in Christ, right? Otherwise LDS who most definitely believe in Christ, submit to his authority as Lord, get baptized as a disciple and commit to obeying all Christ commanded would be recognized as Christians by those of your own association.....and yet we are not.Of course we've been claiming we were qualified as Christians and have a Christian faith based on our obedience to this and other commandments of the Lord for years. I am glad you agree with us. Please spread the word, I expect to see the anti cult sites removing LDS from their target list shortly.Dontcha get it Cal. It's the wrong Lord. The Lord who we obey is the Anti-Christ (Or so I've been told).
diglot Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 Hi Diglot,Why do you say that?Regards,joBecause I approach the biblical text from the realm of higher criticism, and it is a well established view that the Gospel of John isn't exactly the most reliable text when it comes to authentic sayings of Jesus.
diglot Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 Whoa whoa whoa there cowboy!How do you know that the author,1) Doesn't have a personal relationship with Jesus Christ?Completely irrelevant as to whether the site represents mainstream Christianity.2) That Jesus is NOT his Lord and Savior?3) Doesn't have the Holy Spirit dwelling in his heart, the same Spirit who inspired the Scriptures, the very Spirit whom Jesus sent as another Paraclete to be with all of his disciples following Jesus' ascension.4) That The Father is NOT his Father by His gracious adoption of him as His child through his faith in Jesus Christ?5) Jesus Christ has NOT called him to be His disciple?6) His (Jesus') instructions to all of His disciples, does NOT includes him, as found in the Scriptures, which are His word?7) As a child of God the Father, a follower of Jesus Christ, indwelled by the Holy Spirit, his participation in the life and mission of the church of Jesus Christ is NOT a part of his personal relationship with the true and living God?And the same sentiment applies to the rest of your points.
diglot Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 diglot,Are you part of or affiliated in anyway, directly or indirectly with the New Apostolic Movement?http://en.wikipedia....lic_ReformationAnd I doubt by a long shot that you even read the website that you proclaimed as not mainstream Christianity and swatted off like a mosquito. http://www.atruechur...lordisaman.htmlNo, I am not affiliated with the NAM.Did I read the whole website? No. I did read quite a few pages of it though, including the statement of beliefs.If you want this website to represent mainstream Christianity, fine. It doesn't really matter either way to me.Would you have a problem if I said the FLDS is representative of mainstream Mormonism?
Calm Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 Why can't most of you ask me what I believe and pay attention to the answers I give before you jump to such off-the-wall conclusions? .Sometimes I really, really get a kick out of this board. Can someone get this engraved in stone for me?
Rob Bowman Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 calmoriah,Sarcasm and moving the target do not make a very compelling argument.That would depend on which instructions they chose to follow, including what they believe in Christ, right? Otherwise LDS who most definitely believe in Christ, submit to his authority as Lord, get baptized as a disciple and commit to obeying all Christ commanded would be recognized as Christians by those of your own association.....and yet we are not.Of course we've been claiming we were qualified as Christians and have a Christian faith based on our obedience to this and other commandments of the Lord for years. I am glad you agree with us. Please spread the word, I expect to see the anti cult sites removing LDS from their target list shortly.
diglot Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 (edited) You are not reading enough into what Christ said and John should not be taken lightly. After all his book is considered scripture.How do you like that rebuttal?You have essentially just stated that "I don't like that interpretation".The reason I don't like your interpretation is because you are reading too much into that verse.It's as bad as Catholics reading their dogmas about the papacy into Matthew 16:18 Edited October 25, 2011 by diglot
Calm Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 (edited) Dontcha get it Cal. It's the wrong Lord. The Lord who we obey is the Anti-Christ (Or so I've been told).I say it is the Lord of the Bible, Christ. I have read His Word many times. The Spirit has filled me when I have done so. This is my sincere and actual experience.Thus according to the standard set out by Mr. Bowman I am authorized to do so because I have accepted, believed, been baptized and committed to following his commandments. This is what he said and I am accepting him at his word. Since I am authorized by the Lord, anyone who rejects me, rejects the Lord. Edited October 25, 2011 by calmoriah
Rob Bowman Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 diglot,You wrote:Because I approach the biblical text from the realm of higher criticism, and it is a well established view that the Gospel of John isn't exactly the most reliable text when it comes to authentic sayings of Jesus.Not so much. I highly recommend that you read Richard Bauckham's discussion of John in his book Jesus and the Eyewitnesses and also study Craig Blomberg's book The Historical Reliability of John's Gospel.
Calm Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 (edited) calmoriah,Sarcasm and moving the target do not make a very compelling argument.Target is right where it always has been. Perhaps it's you've who moved? That can make the target look different, especially if one lacks accurate/stable 'landmarks' or context by which to sight by....The only thing sarcastic in my comments was about the anti cult movement recognizing us as fellow Christians and I wholeheartedly wish that was plain truth and not sarcasm. Edited October 25, 2011 by calmoriah
diglot Posted October 25, 2011 Posted October 25, 2011 (edited) diglot,You wrote:Not so much. I highly recommend that you read Richard Bauckham's discussion of John in his book Jesus and the Eyewitnesses and also study Craig Blomberg's book The Historical Reliability of John's Gospel.I have read the one by Bauckham. While interesting, it doesn't seem to have altered the scholarly community in any significant way regarding the issue. Few scholars, as far as I am aware, who are engaged in early Christian studies consider John to be historically reliable and useful concerning the historical Jesus. Edited October 25, 2011 by diglot
Recommended Posts