Jump to content
Seriously No Politics ×

A Note on the name "Aha".


Olavarria

Recommended Posts

Posted

conan-barabarian-1-set-2.jpg

The Book of Mormon is a book which is derived from an ancient record written, on gold plates, in a modified Egyptian script(Mormon 9:32). The book also makes passing mention of two warriors: Aha the Nephite and Ahah the Jaredite.

Alma 16: 5, 7

5)Therefore, he that had been appointed chief captain over the armies of the Nephites, (and his name was Zoram, and he had two sons, Lehi and Aha)â??now Zoram and his two sons, knowing that Alma was high priest over the church, and having heard that he had the spirit of prophecy, therefore they went unto him and desired of him to know whither the Lord would that they should go into the wilderness in search of their brethren, who had been taken captive by the Lamanites.

7)And it came to pass that Zoram and his sons crossed over the river Sidon, with their armies, and marched away beyond the borders of Manti into the south wilderness, which was on the east side of the river Sidon.

Ether 11:10

10)And it came to pass that Ahah, his son, did obtain the kingdom; and he did reign over the people all his days. And he did do all manner of iniquity in his days, by which he did cause the shedding of much blood; and few were his days.

In ancient Egyptian, Aha means "fighter" and was the name of one of Egypt's ancient kings.

Posted

I brought this name up in my presentation on evidences for the Book of Mormon at the stake priests/laurels conference over the weekend.

This is a dead on bull's-eye for the Book of Mormon, and all the critics can really say is that it is a coincidence.

But if it is a coincidence, it would seem unusual for Joseph Smith to give as a name for somebody in the Book of Mormon a three letter word that is usually associated in English with a sudden inspiration.

All the Best!

--Consiglieri

Posted

I meet a LOT of "coincidnces" and "shot down proofs" and LDs scolars "blinded by their faith" in my internet life... :P

The most unpopular beeing Jeff Lindsay and Back Yard Professor only a hint, that way so am I stupid aso... So one more coincidetnt in my book. Good to know thanks Her Amun

Posted

Aha!!!! :P

Posted
I brought this name up in my presentation on evidences for the Book of Mormon at the stake priests/laurels conference over the weekend.

This is a dead on bull's-eye for the Book of Mormon, and all the critics can really say is that it is a coincidence.

But if it is a coincidence, it would seem unusual for Joseph Smith to give as a name for somebody in the Book of Mormon a three letter word that is usually associated in English with a sudden inspiration.

All the Best!

--Consiglieri

How did that conference work out?

Calling something a co-incidence doesn't explain why the two things coincided. Ron and Nichole's blood in OJ's Bronco is a co-incidence but why was it in there? We shouldn't be surprised though, such reactions are millenia old.

See Helaman 16:14-23

Posted
I brought this name up in my presentation on evidences for the Book of Mormon at the stake priests/laurels conference over the weekend.

This is a dead on bull's-eye for the Book of Mormon, and all the critics can really say is that it is a coincidence.

But if it is a coincidence, it would seem unusual for Joseph Smith to give as a name for somebody in the Book of Mormon a three letter word that is usually associated in English with a sudden inspiration.

All the Best!

--Consiglieri

Hi Consiglieri,

The methodology used in these kinds of word list comparisons is very flawed. Here is a thread I started on this topic some time ago.

"Similarities between BOM personal and place names and ancient Near Eastern (NE) personal and place names are commonly used as evidence supporting BOM historicity. I find such attempts problematic or at least how the parallels are being used problematic. A major problem with apologetic (and critical) approaches is not controlling for multiple testing.

http://slack.ser.man.ac.uk/theory/hyp_multi.html

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_comparisons

(This is called the multiple testing or multiple comparison problem in statistics)

When multiple testing is not properly accounted for in an analysis this can lead to misleading results. For example suppose the probability of drawing a black marble from a sack of marbles is very low say .01. So for any given trial when I draw a marble from the sack there is only one chance in one hundred the marble will be black. Now suppose I draw 500 marbles from the sack with replacement ( i.e. I return the marble to the sack after I record its color). I would expect to see purely by random chance at least 5 black marbles. So although the individual probability of seeing a black marble is low if I look long enough the probability of observing a black marble at some point is very high. If I were to assign some significance to seeing a black marble I would be mistaken.

Consider Vern Holley’s work demonstrating similarities between Solomon Spaldings writings and the BOM.

http://solomonspalding.com/docs2/vernP3.htm#pg54

To help support his thesis Vern compared place names in and around the Great Lakes with BOM place names and produced a list of hits.

http://www.uwec.edu/geOGrApHY/Ivogeler/w18...place-names.htm

Now some of these similarities can be explained because they both occur in the bible. Like Jerusalem or Boaz. But other names are not so easy to explain like the valley of Alma or Angola place names in the BOM which exactly match place names near the Great Lakes. It would be tempting to use such seemingly impressive similarities between place names as evidence of dependence. Examples of Joseph Smith (JS) using place names from his immediate environment to populate his fictional work.

However such a conclusion is unwarranted due to the problem of multiple testing outlined above. If the BOM is authentic ancient history the probability of a place name randomly exactly matching place names near the prophet who is going to translate the text would probably be very low. But there are hundreds of place names in the BOM and hundreds of place names near JS therefore the probability of a handful of place names from the BOM randomly exactly matching names near JS may be very high. Based on the argument from marbles outlined above if I have 500 authentically ancient names the probability that any one name randomly matches names near JS may be very low say .01. But this still means I would expect to observe 5 matches purely by random chance. Hence a match between BOM place names and place names near JS is very weak evidence for dependence. In order to be convincing Vern would have to control for multiple testing in his methodology.

The problem of course is that similarities between BOM place and personal names and Ancient Near East (ANE) place and personal names suffer from exactly the same methodology flaw. Suppose the probability of a made up word showing some connection to a word from an (ANE) language purely by random chance is very low say .01. So for any given made up word there is only one chance in 100 that the word would show a connection with the ANE. Now suppose I collect together 500 made up words I would expect at least five to show some connection to the ANE purely by random chance. Hence finding a word that shows a connection with the ANE is in and of itself very weak evidence for dependence (similar to Verns list of similarities). There are hundreds of candidate words in the BOM even if it is very unlikely for a given made up word to show a connection by random chance. Given there are many words being compared the probability of finding one or several words randomly matching ANE words may be very high. In order to be convincing apologists would have to control for multiple testing in their methodology."

http://www.mormonapologetics.org/index.php...c=37178&hl=

To paraphrase your post above "Angola" exactly matching a place name near JS is a dead on bulls-eye for the modern authorship model of the BOM and all the apologists can really say is that it is a coincidence. :P

Additionally Vern's list of modern place names near the Great Lakes region roughly matches the geography described in the BOM. What are the chances this would occur by random chance? All the apologists can say is this amazing connection occurs by random chance.

If you can't tell I am trying to get across the point that simply pointing at a parallel and exclaiming how complex it is and how it can't occur by random chance is not at all convincing. Whether practiced by critics like Vern Holly or supporters like you and Her Amun. To build a stronger case more rigor needs to be exercised than simply "piling up" similarities pointing at them and exclaiming how complex they are and how only the dumb or hell-bound could possibly not be convinced ;).

All the Best,

Uncertain

Posted
How did that conference work out?

Calling something a co-incidence doesn't explain why the two things coincided. Ron and Nichole's blood in OJ's Bronco is a co-incidence but why was it in there?

Hi Amun,

How so? If something is a coincidence that may very well be all it is. Sometimes things look connected purely by random chance do you disagree? Are there no coincidences?

Here is a good link that briefly discusses coincidence.

http://www.davidmyers.org/Brix?pageID=91

We shouldn't be surprised though, such reactions are millenia old.

See Helaman 16:14-23

Yes and sometimes a connection really is a coincidence. To all you apologists who say Vern Hollys list of place names are simply coincidence I give you Helaman 16:14-23 you apologists are simply repeating reactions that are millenia old :P.

All the Best,

Uncertain

Posted

You make good points Uncertain. You are good :P I would agree with almost everything you said IF we were talking about proof, and not merely evidence. I see things like "land of Jerusalem", the spacial relationship between NHM and Dhofar, "if..and"conditionals and linguistic "coincidences"(Nephi,Aha, Pahor(an),Paanchi, deseret) and the rise,developement,decline and fall of the jaredites and how it coincides with the rise,developement,decline and fall of the Olmec in both space(both straddle an isthmus) and time as evidence for the BoM's antiquity but not proof.

Here is an example: Suppose the 1st presdidency sends a message to all the Bishops of Hawaii and says something to the effect:"Flee to the mainland or die fiery deaths". One month later, Kim Jong Il nukes Hawaii, dropping a bomb on Laie. Is that a coincidence?

Maybe God told him, maybe Kim did. How would we know?Suppose the same bomb is dropped, withoput the 1st presidency letter, does that count as evidence for a lack of prophetic status?The same goes for things like "Aha", NHM etc. If a book claiming to be written in Egyptian doesn't have anything resembling an Egyptian word in its translation, would that count as evidence against it's "Egypticity"? If a lack of Egyptian words doesnt count against it, should Egyptian homophones that appear to share the same meanings count for it?If a lack of Egyptian words does count against it,should Egyptian homophones that appear to share the same meanings count for it?

Surely, numerical flukes of chance do happen. But does that explain the many "coincidences" in the BoM?

Uncertain, it is that the names are used in a proper context. How do you explain that away?
That is the real issue here. We are going past mere homophones here.
Posted
Uncertain, it is that the names are used in a proper context. How do you explain that away?

Hi volgadon,

Vern Holly's place names were also used to some extent in a "proper context" how do you explain that away?

What is the probability that an ancient place names will randomly perfectly match with place names near the prophet who is going to translate the record? In addition what is the probability these ancient place names near JS will roughly match the BOM geography? How do you explain all that away :P?

I also think you may misunderstand the argument somewhat. It may be very unlikely that a given made up word will be used correctly. However that does not mean it won't happen. There are hundreds of words in the BOM and tens of thousands of words in various ancient languages to compare them to (i.e. Arabic, Egyptian, Hebrew etc. ). Even if it is very unlikely that a given word will randomly match in proper context a word in Arabic etc. If you do enough comparisons even very unlikely things happen all the time. This was the point of my marbles example. I recommend you read the linked article our intuition about unlikely events is not very accurate.

http://www.davidmyers.org/Brix?pageID=91

All the Best,

Uncertain

Posted
Vern Holly's place names were also used to some extent in a "proper context" how do you example that away?

What is the probability that an ancient place names will randomly perfectly match with place names near the prophet who is going to translate the record? In addition what is the probability these ancient place names near JS will roughly match the BOM geography? How do you example all that away :P?

Actually, the probability is pretty good. After all, both Nephites and New Englanders were heavily influenced by "the Bible". So both civilizations having cities with biblical names or name-elements isn't so shocking.

I also think you may misunderstand the argument somewhat. It may be very unlikely that a given made up word will be used correctly.
Exactly my point.
However that does not mean it won't happen. There are hundreds of words in the BOM and tens of thousands of words in various ancient languages to compare them to (i.e. Arabic, Egyptian, Hebrew etc. ).

But were not talking about Arabic here. We are taking about Egyptian.

BoM

Aha

fighter

Egypt

Aha

fighter

It is a small connection to ancient Egypt,but a connection nonetheless.

Posted
But other names are not so easy to explain like the valley of Alma or Angola place names in the BOM which exactly match place names near the Great Lakes. It would be tempting to use such seemingly impressive similarities between place names as evidence of dependence. Examples of Joseph Smith (JS) using place names from his immediate environment to populate his fictional work.

Alma and Angloa are coincidences. See here and here

Posted
You make good points Uncertain. You are good :P I would agree with almost everything you said IF we were talking about proof, and not merely evidence. I see things like "land of Jerusalem", the spacial relationship between NHM and Dhofar, "if..and"conditionals and linguistic "coincidences"(Nephi,Aha, Pahor(an),Paanchi, deseret) and the rise,developement,decline and fall of the jaredites and how it coincides with the rise,developement,decline and fall of the Olmec in both space(both straddle an isthmus) and time as evidence for the BoM's antiquity but not proof.

Here is an example: Suppose the 1st presdidency sends a message to all the Bishops of Hawaii and says something to the effect:"Flee to the mainland or die fiery deaths". One month later, Kim Jong Il nukes Hawaii, dropping a bomb on Laie. Is that a coincidence?

Maybe God told him, maybe Kim did. How would we know?Suppose the same bomb is dropped, withoput the 1st presidency letter, does that count as evidence for a lack of prophetic status?The same goes for things like "Aha", NHM etc. If a book claiming to be written in Egyptian doesn't have anything resembling an Egyptian word in its translation, would that count as evidence against it's "Egypticity"? If a lack of Egyptian words doesnt count against it, should Egyptian homophones that appear to share the same meanings count for it?If a lack of Egyptian words does count against it,should Egyptian homophones that appear to share the same meanings count for it?

Hi Her Amun,

Well there are well defined methodologies in statistic's and the sciences to determine how significant an event is. That is whether two observations are casually connected. I would suggest apologists make use of these techniques. For example controls are absolutely fundamental to the scientific method. Appropriate controls could be used to help determine if a given list of similarities between the BOM and the ancient world are meaningful.

Look I am not necessarily arguing that the given parallels between the BOM and antiquities are due to random chance and are coincidental. What I am arguing is the methodology employed is not rigorous enough to make a good case. Simply pointing out similarities en mass is a good way to convince the already convinced whether it be critics or apologists who are employing the method. But to really build a strong case better methodology needs to be employed than this.

Surely, numerical flukes of chance do happen. But does that explain the many "coincidences" in the BoM?

Maybe, maybe not who knows that is the problem. A critic could just as easily point out those "coincidences" (i.e. Vern Holly) that support his position and exclaim does random chance really explain his favored set of "coincidences"? The problem is fundamentally flawed methodology in which there is no attempt to estimate what would be expected by chance. Simply a piling up of similarities and asserting statistical significance based on an appeal to personal intuition which frankly is an absolutely terrible approach.

All the Best,

Uncertain

Posted
Alma and Angloa are coincidences. See here

Hi Her Amun,

Yes I know they are coincidences that is the entire point. It demonstrates that perfect matches can and do occur by random chance. Therefore when someone presents a "perfect" match between a BOM word and some word from a given ancient language I am less than impressed. Because I am well aware "perfect" matches can and have occurred by random chance. Angolia and the valley of Alma are perfect examples of this.

All the Best,

Uncertain

Posted

To anyone who might have these stats handy: How many named people are mentioned in the BoM, and, of those, how many are NOT associated with any kind of war, battle, army, fighting, etc?

Just curious.

Thanks!

Posted
Actually, the probability is pretty good. After all, both Nephites and New Englanders were heavily influenced by "the Bible". So both civilizations having cities with biblical names or name-elements isn't so shocking.

Hi Her Amun,

Yes I mentioned this in my opening post. Many of Vern Holly's list are found in the Bible so those are not all that interesting. However a number of "perfect" matches like Angola are not found in the Bible so cannot be due to influence from the Bible. In addition by proper context I was referring to the fact that many of the place names roughly (very roughly in some cases :P match the geography used in the BOM.

Exactly my point.

But were not talking about Arabic here. We are taking about Egyptian.

BoM

Aha

fighter

Egypt

Aha

fighter

It is a small connection to ancient Egypt,but a connection nonetheless.

I am not disputing the fact there is a connection. I am disputing the fact that the mere fact there is a connection is sufficient grounds to postulate a causal connection. That is the connection with Egypt is anything other than coincidence. Simply pointing out a connection does not establish that connection is meaningful.

All the Best,

Uncertain

Posted
Simply pointing out a connection does not establish that connection is meaningful.

Exactly!! Just like the use of Angola being too late in history, right?

Posted
Hi volgadon,

Vern Holly's place names were also used to some extent in a "proper context" how do you example that away?

What is the probability that an ancient place names will randomly perfectly match with place names near the prophet who is going to translate the record? In addition what is the probability these ancient place names near JS will roughly match the BOM geography? How do you example all that away :P?

All the Best,

Uncertain

I'm talking about names that were unknown to Joseph and contemporaries.

Posted
Exactly!! Just like the use of Angola being too late in history, right?

Yep, now just apply this reasoning to BOM apologetics. The place name Angola perfectly matched by random chance a place name in the BOM. In addition Vern Holly's list of place names taken as a whole also are used to some extent in the "right context" that is they roughly match the geography in the BOM. Therefore we can conclude perfect matches in correct context can and do occur by random chance. Therefore using matches between BOM names and ANE names is weak evidence at best of a causal connection. Unless further work is done demonstrating these matches are casually connected (i.e. the BOM was written by ancient Hebrews).

All the Best,

Uncertain

Posted
I'm talking about names that were unknown to Joseph and contemporaries.

Hi volgadon,

Yes I understand see my latest post to Her Amun. Such matches can and do occur by random chance. Therefore the mere fact such matches exist is weak evidence at best. Whether a critic is using the methodology or and apologist is.

All the Best,

Uncertain

Posted

Really? The b/m pattern and other Aramaic influences in the right combination for Lehi's time and place, names like Zarahemla which make perfect sense in both parts, word games like Sebus and Jershon, Egyptian names which are used properly, in short too many coincidences.

Posted
Yep, now just apply this reasoning to BOM apologetics. The place name Angola perfectly matched by random chance a place name in the BOM. In addition Vern Holly's list of place names taken as a whole also are used to some extent in the "right context" that is they roughly match the geography in the BOM. Therefore we can conclude perfect matches in correct context can and do occur by random chance. Therefore using matches between BOM names and ANE names is weak evidence at best of a causal connection. Unless further work is done demonstrating these matches are casually connected (i.e. the BOM was written by ancient Hebrews).

All the Best,

Uncertain

Its Moroni 10:4-5 all over again :P

Posted
Really? The b/m pattern and other Aramaic influences in the right combination for Lehi's time and place, names like Zarahemla which make perfect sense in both parts, word games like Sebus and Jershon, Egyptian names which are used properly, in short too many coincidences.

Hi volgadon,

Again this is simply asserting a connection on the basis of complexity and personal intuition. Look it may be all this is to complex to occur by random chance. But this core point must be demonstrated using solid methodology not simply asserted on the basis of perceived complexity. Anybody can list a set of parallels and claim in perplexity how the "other side" is just ignoring how powerful it all is. But this is not science neither is it convincing. If indeed all these connections are to complex to occur by random chance. Then it should be easy to demonstrate this using rigorous methodology including reasonable controls. Simply asserting over and over again that all these connections with the ANE must be meaningful is not a convincing approach. It is no different than a LDS critic listing all the set of parallels with the nineteenth century and exclaiming only the poor deluded Mormons would find it unconvincing while all "right thinking" individuals would be convinced. Apparently you have no problems seeing why Vern's methodology is fundamentally flawed but you don't see you are using the exact same approach. It is great if you want to convince the already convinced but not if you want to build a solid case.

All the Best,

Uncertain

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...