Jump to content
Seriously No Politics ×

Notatbm

Members
  • Posts

    570
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

Notatbm's Achievements

Proficient

Proficient (10/14)

  • Posting Machine Rare
  • Very Popular Rare
  • One Year In
  • Conversation Starter
  • Reacting Well Rare

Recent Badges

56

Reputation

  1. Leonardo DiCaprio comes to mind. He is 51 and routinely dates early twenties girls. He just got roasted at some Hollywood event about it… yea it isn’t cool and is def creepy Agreed. I bet not a single one of them WANTED to make public statements about their sex life with the prophet.
  2. The fact is she was sealed to Joseph as a wife. Another fact is she wasn’t permitted to go to dances, date etc??? Hmmm wonder why that is? Prob because she was married AND had to hide that fact ( lie?) . In any case if she is married to the guy who is now a known lying liar who had sex with other plural wives and prob to some who were married to other men… well neither one of them have any credibility anyway. The whole thing was/is a twisted web of lies and going behind Emma’s back. Why do all that if you are not at least having sex with your plural wife?? anyway we can agree to disagree… I think the only reason this is so heavily fought against by TBMs is because she was fourteen. No problem admitting he had sex with some of the other ones even though that was flat out adultery because none of these marriages except to Emma were even legal in the first place. So much for the 12th article of faith. The church still can’t follow that one if the sec scandal is any indicator.
  3. Again- this isnt the women going around bragging about sex with Joseph. They were "dragged" in to testify to that fact.
  4. Well the church certainly didnt feel it looked all that great judging by this comment in the GTE re polygamy: "The youngest was Helen Mar Kimball, daughter of Joseph’s close friends Heber C. and Vilate Murray Kimball, who was sealed to Joseph several months before her 15th birthday."
  5. Yea I am not retracting my claim. The evidence you cited is an inference. Maybe they should have written her name down in the record instead of being cryptic about it?? I dunno. You are probably right, but the record doesnt say the word "Emma." As for the rest of this discussion, please continue on without me. Over the past year I have seen your posts and your "courtroom" duels with others that extend page after page focusing on even the tiniest of details. I went against my best judgement in even responding to you as I was like yea this is gonna devolve in a repeat of the "argument of the definition of what "is" is."...and it is starting to look that way. Thats fine, but I have better things to do and more interesting hobbies than to spend endless hours here responding to endless challenges. Anyway- im not interested in conversing with you anymore as it seems as if you always require a court battle and fight down to the very last word over EVERYTHING. I prefer more base discussions so I apologize for even responding to you- trust me it will not happen again. I'm not about to get caught up in the circus acts you have dragged others into and have this run on for days on end. You won... As for the CFRs...do what you will with them. Make your final last legalistic point and have a mod go after me and ban me from the thread or whatever. You apparently have the energy to spend all day here like the time is billable hours or something so do whatever.
  6. Being dragged into court as you described it doesn’t sound much like anyone was on a brag about having sex with js. Sounds more like the govt compelled them to give testimony and were under threat of perjury if they lied. as for Helen not testifying… I’m pretty sure the church didn’t want her up there stating she had sex with js as a 14 year old. If one considers that maybe if they did and waited till she was older she would have been 15 at the most since js was killed a year later. That would not have been the flex the church wanted. Even back then this marriage was sick.
  7. Am I required to by forum rules? Then no I see you are pretty invested as well judging by the massive walls of text you create for every response. Ok...you go with the evidence then. I know you want to treat everything as a criminal trial and trot out huge volumes of data, references and whatever else you can find, but many (to include myself) are satisfied with Occam's Razor. Do what you do and I'll do what I do. it isnt a complicated issue. Marriage = Sex. "inflammatory and offensive things to Latter-day Saints, who revere Joseph as a prophet." OK so what? Im a member of the church as well. I am entitled to an opinion. People can choose whether they want to be offended or not. I think some prophet somewhere described that behavior as a weakness or some such thing. I dont need to take orders from some random stranger on the internet. If you dont enjoy discussions with me then dont respond...its easy.
  8. "That the sealing was between Joseph and Emma is a reasoned inference." Is her name written there somewhere? I also responded to this same question you asked. We know that until he was married to 22 women other than Emma, JS and Emma were not sealed together. After...like you say, there is a reasoned inference, but again, she isnt named from what I understand. Sooo for about half of the time he was practicing polygamy, he chose to not be sealed to Emma and she was apparently unaware of the whole thing...apparently
  9. I am certainly willing to consider historical evidence of a sexual relationship, but I am not aware of any. Can you help in this regard? They were married as husband and wife. Totally justified in having sex and also, who would go around bragging about it or making statements. He was hiding all his marriages from Emma. That right there is not only scandalous but indicative of horrible behavior. If it was so honorable to have a bunch of wives (even little girls) why not be open about it??? Probably because it was not only illegal, but he was having sex with them which is.... Adultery on his part and probably on the part of some of the women if they were married to other men at the time. In her reminiscences, autobiography, poetry, and later defenses of plural marriage, she never described sexual relations with Smith. Do you dispute this? If so, please lay out your reasoning and evidence. What do you write in your journal about your sex life? Probably nothing and if you did you wouldnt share it here would you. Of course there is no evidence. The only "Evidence" anyone needs is a marriage. It is an expectation in marriage. I dont know why some are so hell bent on proving Joseph didnt have sex with some of his wives and not others. The dosctine is lieterally about sex among other things... raising up seed. If he wasnt trying to procreate with each of these wives he was disobeying the lord apparently. My understanding is that she characterized the sealing as “for eternity alone” and focused on its dynastic/spiritual purpose (linking the Kimball and Smith families and securing eternal blessings for her father’s household). After the sealing she continued living with her parents and attending school; she wrote about social restrictions (missing parties) rather than any intimate relationship. She was later married “for time” to Horace Whitney after Smith’s death. They do? Could you explain why and how laws existing in 2026 "apply" to Joseph Smith in the early 1840s? Yea I they place Joseph Smith in the modern era why not apply the modern era laws? Oh... yea because he would be in preison and looked at no differently than warren Jeffs who still has many of his brides dfending him just like Joseph did. Possibly, yes. Again, I would be interested in what evidence you believe exists of a sexual relationship. They were married- that is all the proof needed. What proof is there of your fellow ward members having sex?? Esp the ones who have not had children yet? Answer: None unless they are going around talking about it, but everyone knows there is like a 99.99% chance they are. Not sure what you mean here. Look at the crap the AZ Gov candidate lamb is involved in. It isnt polygamy but do you think for a minute running for president (which Joseph did apparently) and everyone knew he had a pile of wives, was detroying printing presses etc he would survive in the current political climate?? He didnt even survive it in his day both figuratively and literally. I think this is incorrect. See here. Per Richard L. Bushman, Joseph and Emma were sealed on May 28, 1843. Bushman is a pretty solid historian, so I assume he has documentation. Do you have contrary evidence? That Joseph and Emma were never sealed? I have not ever seen any proof with her name on anything resembling a sealing. There might be something out there, but my understanding is it isnt settled science so to speak. Not sure open mockery is helpful to the discussion. JS is worthy of being mocked. Thats what you get when you marry women behind your wife's back. Thanks, -Smac
  10. I dont have any. They were sealed as husband and wife. According to LDS doctrine it wouldf have been ok to have sex right?? It def was permissible so why does everyone fall all over themselves trying to prove he didnt? He is supposed to...
  11. i dont know if you have children or not, but is there any proof anywhere you and your spouse had sex? Proof that I can look up? Did you testify of it, write an article, tell all your friends? Etc... There isnt any proof laying around I had sex before having children but i had a few episodes and that was before I was even married. Just because there is no "evidence" or statement that doesn't mean a thing. No one runs around esp back then making a brag about having sex with their secret husband who is married to ten other women. The very purpose of polygamy is to have children so sex is going to be involved ..whether they had kids or not.
  12. Does the doc say her name at all? From what I understand is she was not sealed to Joseph....For sure not before 22 other women were we do know that is pretty much settled. After the 22 initial wives... possibly.
  13. Yea she is a "Victim." I know you dont have a problem with prophets having sex with teenage girls, but hey anything to defend Joseph. The poem below written by Hellen Mar Kimball doesnt portray someone who is happy nor really had a choice in the whole matter. I mean what 14 year old girl is going to want to marry some 38 year man? Answer: None "I thought through this life my time will be my own The step I now am taking’s for eternity alone, No one need be the wiser, through time I shall be free, And as the past hath been the future still will be. To my guileless heart all free from worldly care And full of blissful hopes and youthful visions rare The world seamed bright the thret’ning clouds were kept From sight and all looked fair... ...but pitying angels wept. They saw my youthful friends grow shy and cold. And poisonous darts from sland’rous tongues were hurled, Untutor’d heart in thy gen’rous sacrafise, Thou dids’t not weigh the cost nor know the bitter price; Thy happy dreams all o’er thou’st doom’d also to be Bar’d out from social scenes by this thy destiny, And o’er thy sad’nd mem’ries of sweet departed joys Thy sicken’d heart will brood and imagine future woes, And like a fetter’d bird with wild and longing heart, Thou’lt dayly pine for freedom and murmor at thy lot; But could’st thou see the future & view that glorious crown, Awaiting you in Heaven you would not weep nor mourn. Pure and exalted was thy father’s aim, he saw A glory in obeying this high celestial law, For to thousands who’ve died without the light I will bring eternal joy & make thy crown more bright. I’d been taught to reveire the Prophet of God And receive every word as the word of the Lord, But had this not come through my dear father’s mouth, I should ne’r have received it as God’s sacred truth." Then why did Joseph keep his marriages secret from Emma? I'll tell ytiou why...because he was havng sex with them. The whole doctrine is for polygamy to be used as a method to rais up seed which means to have sex with his wives. Just because none of the wives had any children doesnt mean he wasnt having sex with them. Was Helen MAr Kimball sealed to Joseph as a wife or daughter? A: She was sealed as a wife...so sex it is of course 1. Helen’s Explicit Use of the Word "Wife" In her later journals, public defenses of polygamy, and autobiographical letters, Helen directly referred to herself as a plural wife. For example, in an 1881 autobiographical letter detailing the arrangement, she signed her name as "Whitney Smith" to acknowledge both her earthly husband (Horace Whitney) and her sealed husband (Joseph Smith). [1, 2, 3]
  14. Oh my bad. I forgot that no one ever lied back then… especially Joseph smith. for the record he wasn’t sealed to Emma until AFTER he married 22 other women all the while lying about it and breaking the law. So until he got those 22 marriages out of the way… Emma wasn’t sealed to him. Praise to the man. What a guy! Joseph smith would be sharing a cell with Warren jeffs today.
  15. Yea keep believing he didn’t have sex with her. Why not, she was his wife. You also placed this scenario in today’s political landscape so today’s laws apply as well. He would be in prison for not only marrying a 14year old and having sex with her, he would be in prison for marrying other men’s wives. Politically, he would not survive with all the shenanigans he was up to. Heck he didn’t even bother to get sealed to Emma. Praise to the man!
×
×
  • Create New...