rhinomelon Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 Rhino, isn't there a part of Isaiah which talks about the Lord God not seeing any other gods? Used in the context that he does not acknowledge them? Can this be used in any way to support the oneness of Jesus with God in the trinity?There are a number of such passages in Isaiah, mostly in the 40s chapters. Such passages, in addition to dozens of others in the OT and NT, provide a solid scriptural basis for monotheism. Now, with that monotheistic foundation established, the NT speaks of Christ and the Holy Spirit as God, in addition to the Father. What to make of this paradox (I wouldn't call it a contradiction)? That is a impetus for the doctrine of the Trinity, which means...I ain't got style, but I'll pick up some slack....Is the scriptural basis of the Trinity basically the balancing of the two concepts you first mentioned? 1. One God 2. Father, Son, Holy Ghost all GodIs the Trinity a concerted effort to maintain monotheism? Or are there some other scriptures that point to Trinitarian ideas from a different perspective?... JDave is absolutely correct. And good scriptural contribution to the discussion, as well, nathan! Now, on to other matters:Conclusion: He ascended and descended to His disciples many times after His resurrection.Zerinus, can you provide any official backing for this interpretation of yours? I'll even take LDS sources here. Maybe an Ensign article or paragraph from the LDS church website. I had figured that you are the type of person that would find the suggestion of a pagan origin for deification in Christian theology an attractive one. It sits well with your way of thinking. Therefore be it known unto you that I donâ??t. I believe that deification in Christian theology has a divine origin, and part and parcel of the original Christian revelation. It did not originate from paganism, Greek mythology, or Egyptian demonology!I don't believe it because it's "attractive", I believe it because that's what the facts undeniably say. If deification did not exist until the Christians developed it, why do we have dozens, if not hundreds, of quotes on the subject from pre-Christian philosophers and poets? For instance, Plato himself wrote that the ultimate goal of the philosopher is to be "as like God as possible". Also, if it supposedly an entirely Christian invention, why do early church fathers quote pre-Christian ancient philosophers and poets in support of the doctrine? Even LDS scholars acknowledge that the idea of human deification existed long before Christianity did. Heck, even Clement of Alexandria, you're favorite quote-mine, quoted pre-Christian philosophers in support of deification. For instance, from the Stromata 3:1--His is beauty, true beauty, for it is God, and that man becomes god, since God wills it. So Heraclitus was right when he said, "Men are gods, and gods are men. Who is Heraclitus, and when did he write? The â??actual doctrine of the Trinityâ? is â??three Gods in one God!â? like it says in the Athanasian Creed. You canâ??t just change the goal posts after centuries of debate and discussion and expect to just get away with it.Actually, the Athanasian Creed, which you helpfully posted, says the exact, precise opposite. To quote: 3. And the catholic faith is this: That we worship one God in Trinity, and Trinity in Unity;4. Neither confounding the persons nor dividing the substance.5. For there is one person of the Father, another of the Son, and another of the Holy Spirit.6. But the Godhead of the Father, of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit is all one, the glory equal, the majesty coeternal.I haven't changed the goalposts. "One God in three persons" is not a phrase of recent invention; it actually predates the formulation of the Trinity! Tertullian, writing in the 3rd century, wrote "Tres persona, una substantia" as a Trinitarian formulation. "Three persons, one nature". That predates the Nicene creed by about a century or so. "One God in three persons" is a rather common framework seen in the councils and writings about the Trinity. I'm fine with using it, and doing so leaves the goalposts where they've been for almost 1800 years. I prefer that to not knowing where the goalposts are in the first place, as in your case. More in a bit. Take care, everyone
rhinomelon Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 Like I said, it is not your doctrine of the Trinity. It has been around for centuries, and the definition of it is well-known and fixed by centuries of history and debate.You're correct, it is not "my" doctrine. But I believe it, I understand it, and that makes me more qualified to define it than someone who does not believe it, does not understand it, and dismisses it as "absurd", "contradictory" and "false". And you're also correct that the definition has been fixed for centuries. This is why I'm confused by the fact that you seem unaware of the definition, and all the debate and discussion that has gone into that definition. The only definition you've proposed was of your own making, based on an erroneous reading of a few snippets of one non-ecumenical creed. Such a definition easily meets the standard of the strawman logical fallacy.The â??actual doctrine of the Trinityâ? is â??three Gods in one God!â? like it says in the Athanasian Creed. You canâ??t just change the goal posts after centuries of debate and discussion and expect to just get away with it.The Athanasian creed, as already posted by myself and you, says precisely the opposite. Where in the Athanasian Creed is the phrase "Three Gods in one God" listed as an affirmative belief? Nowhere. Rather, it is listed as a false belief, and a misunderstanding of the Trinity. Perhaps you should read things in their entirety before posting them. That kind of a discussion is no longer productive, and everyone can realize that.Actually, I think you are the only one who thinks this conversation is unproductive. I'm enjoying it! I look forward to continuing it with other people who are not interested in shoving words into my mouth and running after strawmen of their own making. After a point is becomes obvious that you no longer have anything positive to contribute to the discussion, except just repeating the same arguments over and over which have been trounced several times over, and just engaging in a semantic debate.You don't think semantics is important? Anyway, I have loads of positive contribution, just waiting in the wings here. I had to deal with your tangents first, though. I'm happy with my arguments, and I am comfortable in letting others (besides you) judge them for themselves.Take care, everyone
nathansoz Posted February 4, 2009 Author Posted February 4, 2009 The Athanasian creed, as already posted by myself and you, says precisely the opposite. Where in the Athanasian Creed is the phrase "Three Gods in one God" listed as an affirmative belief? Nowhere. Rather, it is listed as a false belief, and a misunderstanding of the Trinity. Perhaps you should read things in their entirety before posting them. What is the Athanasian creed? Is it something that happened at Niacia?
rhinomelon Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 What is the Athanasian creed? Is it something that happened at Niacia?Good question. The Athanasian Creed actually came after Nicea, and unlike the Nicene Creed or the Chalcedonian Creed, it did not come out of a council, but from a single individual. Athanasius was one of the main defenders of the Trinity at the council of Nicea, but the issue at that council was the relationship between the Father and the Son. The Holy Spirit was barely mentioned or discussed! In fact, if you look at the original Nicene Creed (before it was amended at the council of Constantinople to include more about the Holy Spirit), the Holy Spirit only has one line at the end, "We believe in the Holy Spirit."After the issue of Father/Son was settled, they turned their attention to the Holy Spirit, and Athanasius wrote a creed that summed up what he considered to be the orthodox position on the matter. Turns out, he was right, and this particular creed is still used today. It's not seen as an "ecumenical" creed, however, since it was never officially accepted by an ecumenical council. Nevertheless, the creeds that came after it basically agreed with it all the way. Hope that helps. Take care, everyone P.S. Zerinus, have you read Jules Gross' book on deification? Did you notice that the first 75 pages or so specifically talks about deification before Christianity, in ancient Greek philosophers and Jewish writings? Deification was certainly around long before Christianity, although Christianity developed something different from that foundation. Some small quotes from the book itself:Since the idea of deification has served as a link between Hellenism and Christianity, it was essential to start out by following the analogous movements which have become clear in the Greek world.Assuredly this doctrine [of deification] thrusts its vital roots into the inspired Books. But it also contains so many elements of Hellenic origin that several critics have wanted to see here the most manifest evidence of a hellenization of Christianity. . . . efore starting out on the exposition of the patristic doctrine, it is essential to point out similar currents of thought which appear in the Hellenic world, even if they would only be indirect analogs, in order to make known the environment in which the biblical seed was going to develop.Are you sure there was no concept deification before Christianity? I would like to see some actual references for that, please. I've provided some of my own, now it's your turn. Take care
nathansoz Posted February 4, 2009 Author Posted February 4, 2009 Hope that helps. Take care, everyoneThank you very much. Now I won't be (as) lost.
zerinus Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 I don't believe it because it's "attractive", I believe it because that's what the facts undeniably say. If deification did not exist until the Christians developed it, why do we have dozens, if not hundreds, of quotes on the subject from pre-Christian philosophers and poets? For instance, Plato himself wrote that the ultimate goal of the philosopher is to be "as like God as possible". Also, if it supposedly an entirely Christian invention, why do early church fathers quote pre-Christian ancient philosophers and poets in support of the doctrine? Even LDS scholars acknowledge that the idea of human deification existed long before Christianity did.I never said that deification did not exist before Christianity. I said that the Christian doctrine of deification was not derived from it. Christianity is a revealed religion (believe it or not), and its doctrines (true doctrines) are revealed, not derived. The same is true of LDS doctrine. We too believe in deification; but it came to us by revelation, not derivation. We donâ??t believe it because the pagans believed it. We donâ??t even believe it because the early Christians believed it. We believe it because God has revealed it (anew) to us. We think that the early Christians also believed it because God had revealed it to them. It was part of the original Christian revelation, not of pagan derivation.zerinus
rhinomelon Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 Thank you very much. Now I won't be (as) lost.No problem, anytime. And I'll be trying to send you some pdfs later, if I can figure it out. I'm working on an application at the moment, however. Anyway, feel free to ask questions of me anytime! I don't know all the answers, but I should be able to at least point you in a direction where you can find some.I never said that deification did not exist before Christianity.Ah, fair enough. I misunderstood. My bad.I said that the Christian doctrine of deification was not derived from it. Christianity is a revealed religion (believe it or not), and its doctrines (true doctrines) are revealed, not derived.I believe Christianity is a revealed religion as well, but I also acknowledge that the early Christians made use of the hellenistic culture and philosophies available, in formulating and expressing their doctrine. I also believe that deification as taught in early Christianity is something unique, and owes its uniqueness to its integration of divine revelation as found in the Christian scriptures. But the early church fathers used plenty of hellenistic vocabulary and concepts in their thinking on deification, which means one cannot really separate the two completely. Heck, the early church fathers wouldn't want to separate them much at all! As I noted before, early Christian thinkers used concepts and even direct quotes from pre-Christian philosophers in their writings, especially Clement of Alexandria. The apostle Paul himself does the same thing several times in his writings as well. Much to LDS chagrin, Christianity from the very beginning was interacting with and using element of the Greek worldview that surrounded it. Take care, everyone
zerinus Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 I believe Christianity is a revealed religion as well, but I also acknowledge that the early Christians made use of the hellenistic culture and philosophies available, in formulating and expressing their doctrine. I also believe that deification as taught in early Christianity is something unique, and owes its uniqueness to its integration of divine revelation as found in the Christian scriptures. But the early church fathers used plenty of hellenistic vocabulary and concepts in their thinking on deification, which means one cannot really separate the two completely. Heck, the early church fathers wouldn't want to separate them much at all! As I noted before, early Christian thinkers used concepts and even direct quotes from pre-Christian philosophers in their writings, especially Clement of Alexandria. The apostle Paul himself does the same thing several times in his writings as well. Much to LDS chagrin, Christianity from the very beginning was interacting with and using element of the Greek worldview that surrounded it.I know they did; but there was a reason for that. The reason for it was in order to justify, defend, or simply explain their Christian belief to their pagan neighbors (who were often critical of or hostile to it). That is why they did it. They were trying to make their Christian beliefs more palatable (or understandable) to them. And many modern â??scholarsâ? have falsely concluded from this that that is where they had gotten their doctrines from! As you mentioned, even Paul does that, for the same reasons. One particular example that comes to mind is the following:Acts 17:28 For in him we live, and move, and have our being; as certain also of your own poets have said, For we are also his offspring.So from this some idiot scholar or historian should conclude that the belief in us being the children of God is derived from pagan philosophy! Well of course that is not the case. Paul was merely trying to teach his audience an important principle, but using materials available to him with which they were familiar. It does not mean that that is where he had got that idea from. The early Christian writers and apologists used the same tactics to teach, defend, or explain their Christian beliefs to their hostile pagan neighbors in their various books and apologetic writings.zerinus
nathansoz Posted February 4, 2009 Author Posted February 4, 2009 We think that the early Christians also believed it because God had revealed it to them. It was part of the original Christian revelation, not of pagan derivation.How do you think God revealed it to them? In all the books of prophecy and law of the Old Testament, wasn't it said in the text that the Lord had said that? But the books of the new testament, especially Paul's letters seem to be more in a lecture form. Is there anywhere that says 'Thus says the Lord' or equivalent in the New Testament?
zerinus Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 How do you think God revealed it to them?We know that God had revealed it to them because we know that God has revealed it to us. Therefore we know that it is true doctrine. Having determined that it is true doctrine, and originated from God; and when we discover that the early Christians believed in the same thing; then we conclude that the early Christians must also have obtained it from the same source, because it is impossible for them to have obrained it in any other way.zerinus
JDave Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 I am not sure if the deification tangent is fizzling out. It started from mentioning Christ "acquiring" divinity, and I would like to return there but skip the tangent.Rhino, I notice that you state there is a necessary distinction when discussing Christ's time on earth. I am wondering if you could clarify some more general points along this line. The questions may display an inherent LDS mindset, but as the good Dr. Steuss I am trying to overcome that handicap. Feel free to correct any faulty assumptions that might be hiding within any of the questions.If the Trinity is three in one with no dividing of the substance, how does Christ come to earth in a mortal body that is ontologically inferior to God, without any dividing of substance?If Christ worshipped God while on the earth, because He was not fully God, how was He able to perform Godly acts like forgiving sins as in Luke 5:24?Does Christ still have a human, physical, body? If so, how is this again avoiding any dividing of substance or ontological differentiation?
nathansoz Posted February 4, 2009 Author Posted February 4, 2009 If Christ worshipped God while on the earth, because He was not fully God, how was He able to perform Godly acts like forgiving sins as in Luke 5:24?Was he not still fully God while on earth? But the disciples of Christ also performed miracles did they not? For the question's sake I offer this, Christ was imbued with the holy spirit because he was one with the holy spirit. That follows along trinitarian thinking.Does Christ still have a human, physical, body? If so, how is this again avoiding any dividing of substance or ontological differentiation?Hmmm interesting question. Not on this earth he doesn't. He ascended into heaven. I'm not quite sure how to answer this.
JDave Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 Was he not still fully God while on earth?If he was fully God, then why did He worship the Father? If Christ was fully human and fully divine, did He simply choose which role He would play based on the situation? Or are they not mutually exclusive? Maybe that is my confusion. Is there no mutual exclusivity to Christ acting and deciding both as human and as God?
zerinus Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 If the Trinity is three in one with no dividing of the substance, how does Christ come to earth in a mortal body that is ontologically inferior to God, without any dividing of substance?I don't fully comprehend your question. It sounds like a Trinitarian question to me. I am not a Trinitarian, so I wouldn't be qualified to answer that question, assuming that I understood it. You need to clarify.If Christ worshipped God while on the earth, because He was not fully God, how was He able to perform Godly acts like forgiving sins as in Luke 5:24?Again, I do not understand your question. You are attributing assumptions to me that I don't recall I have made. I am a Mormon after all, don't forget!Does Christ still have a human, physical, body?That question I understand! Yes, but a resurrected one, which is different from a mortal one. If so, how is this again avoiding any dividing of substance or ontological differentiation?Again, I fail to understand the meaning or relevance of your question. I am sure the fault is mine. Please clarify.zerinus
nathansoz Posted February 4, 2009 Author Posted February 4, 2009 If he was fully God, then why did He worship the Father? If Christ was fully human and fully divine, did He simply choose which role He would play based on the situation? Or are they not mutually exclusive? Maybe that is my confusion. Is there no mutual exclusivity to Christ acting and deciding both as human and as God?He could have worshiped the Father to set an example for us? I don't think there is exclusivity. He came as a human, so he could relate to us, and bear our sins as one of us. But he was still God.
JDave Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 I don't fully comprehend your question. It sounds like a Trinitarian question to me. I am not a Trinitarian, so I wouldn't be qualified to answer that questionSorry about that, zerinus. I meant to address rhinomelon. I will remember that last bit, however, in case it becomes necessary to remind you.
rhinomelon Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 Hey JDave, good questions. I have a church activity tonight, but I'll try to get an answer out later. Take care
cksalmon Posted February 5, 2009 Posted February 5, 2009 John 20.17 and Luke 24.51 record two separate accounts of His ascention. The first one reads:John 20:17 Jesus saith unto her, Touch me not; for I am not yet ascended to my Father: but go to my brethren, and say unto them, I ascend unto my Father, and your Father; and to my God, and your God.That tells me that He intended to ascend to the Father before He did anything else. Next He appeared to them and allowed them to touch Him:Luke 24:39 Behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself: handle me, and see; for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me have.That tells me that in the intervening period between His appearance to Mary and to the disciples He must have ascended to the Father, and then returned to continue the remainder of His ministry to his Disciples. That means that John 20.17 and Luke 24.51 relate to two separate accounts of His ascension into heaven. Furthermore, in the book of Acts we read that Jesus continues to minister to His disciples from time to time for forty days after His resurrection before His final ascension to heaven:Acts 1:3 To whom also he shewed himself alive after his passion by many infallible proofs, being seen of them forty days, and speaking of the things pertaining to the kingdom of God.He was not with them all the time during that period; but appeared to them periodically to give them instruction. So what was He doing in the intervening periods during those forty days when He was with His disciples? Was He wondering aimlessly in the desert debating what to do next? No doubt He would return to His new home which was in heaven, and perhaps perform other functions such as visiting the lost sheep of the house of Israel elsewhere. Even after His final ascension he continued to appear to His disciples occasionally to minister to them, such as when He appeared to Paul and to Ananias for example.Conclusion: He ascended and descended to His disciples many times after His resurrection.zerinusHi zerinusâ??A few comments.Probably a better translation of the Gr. ἃπτου (haptou) in John 20 is "Stop clinging to me" (so NAS), or "Do not cling to me" (so ESV). I agree that we must connect haptou meaningfully with the next sentence, introduced by Gr. γὰρ (gar, "for"): "for I have not yet ascended to the Father."Here's how I personally don't read the verse (paraphrased): "You are not allowed to touch me because I have not yet ascended to the Father."I read the verse more like this (paraphrased): "Don't cling to this body [as if my resurrection to the living is the final statement]; the final consummation of my work hasn't yet occurred" [i.e., when Christ ascends to heaven and sits down at the right hand of God, his work having been completed].In other words, I take Jesus' statement to Mary here to be theological in nature. She was already "touching" him, clinging to him; he says to her, "Stop clinging to me."When Jesus appears to Thomas (John 20.24-29), having already appeared to the other disciples, he invites Thomas to tactilely examine his wounds. The focus here is evidential. The text does not tell us whether or not Thomas availed himself of the invitation. I do not believe Jesus' statements to Thomas to "put your finger here," etc. are indicative of a reversal of his statement to Mary. In other words, Jesus was not communicating to Mary, "You are not yet allowed to touch me because I have not yet ascended to the Father," and subsequently to Thomas, "You are now allowed to touch me because I have already ascended to the Father." I don't think such a reading is in view for the author. But you connect his very next appearance (after having appeared to Mary)--prior to his appearance involving Thomas (John 20.24-29)--with the pericope in Luke 24.36-49, which strikes me as sensible. I would suggest that that pericope should be interpreted in a similar manner to his invitation to Thomas: i.e., it is evidential in nature. An invitation physically to confirm their doubts as to the reality of his resurrection. "They still disbelieved for joyâ?¦."The verb used in this instance is Gr. ψηλαφήσατέ (pselaphesate): "Touch me" [in context, for the purpose of alleviating your doubts]."This is not parallel in my opinion to Jesus' command to Mary to stop clinging to him. I don't find the two situations isomorphic, as it were. One point that can be viewed as arguing in favor of your position are the ascension pericopae recorded in Luke 24.50-53 and Acts 1.6-11. They are contradictory and cannot easily be read, if taken at face value, as separate recordings of the same event (the timing and locales are different). We know beyond reasonable doubt that Luke and Acts share a common author and that the literary "diptych" was circulated early in its history as a unified document: Luke-Acts. It does seem odd that the author (say, "Luke") would have recorded the same event in a contradictory manner in such a short span of text.A minority of the UBS committee believed that Luke 24.50-53 was not original to the Lukan autograph, but was rather added later when the Gospel of Luke began to circulate separately from Acts. That scenario would fit better with my preconceptions, but there is much to commend the view that the passage is original. (I won't go into details, unless you're particularly interested, but one might consult Metzger's A Textual Commentary on the Greek NT, 2nd ed.: 162-166).Nevertheless, I don't believe that the texts you've adduced necessitate the position that Jesus "ascended and descended many times after his resurrection." That strikes me as an unwarranted conclusion, whatever the textual problems with the "single-event" scenario might be. Best.cks
rhinomelon Posted February 5, 2009 Posted February 5, 2009 I know they did; but there was a reason for that. The reason for it was in order to justify, defend, or simply explain their Christian belief to their pagan neighbors (who were often critical of or hostile to it). That is why they did it. They were trying to make their Christian beliefs more palatable (or understandable) to them.The apologetic use of Greek philosophy was certainly a large part of the rationale for using it. But I have to add that it went much deeper than that. Many early church fathers saw the Greek philosophies as God-inspired, though to a lesser degree than scripture. They didn't use it simply to reach out to the outside world; they used it in their own thinking, in their own discussions within the church. Some of the early church fathers (such as Clement of Alexandria) actually taught philosophy and rhetoric, which explains why his writings are chock full of references to pre-Christian thinkers. And Clement's writings were addressed to other Christians, not to pagans outside the church. It varied from church father to church father, but almost all of them thought of philosophy as a tool to be used alongside theology proper. Interestingly, I think a strong case could be made that the early church fathers who spoke most strongly of deification also delved deeply into Greek philosophy. The vocabulary they used in speaking of deification was already around; they just gave specifically Christian meanings to them. That was a pretty common practice, actually, even as early as the New Testament. "Ekklesia", for example, is now translated "church", but before Christ it was a common term for various local organizations, from burial societies to professional guilds.I am not sure if the deification tangent is fizzling out. It started from mentioning Christ "acquiring" divinity, and I would like to return there but skip the tangent.Sounds good!If the Trinity is three in one with no dividing of the substance, how does Christ come to earth in a mortal body that is ontologically inferior to God, without any dividing of substance?Good question! The answer here is found in the Christological formulations of later creeds. The divine nature of the Son took on human nature, but without changing or mixing either nature. We see this in the New Testament, with Christ being fully divine ("In Christ all the fulness of the deity lives in bodily form", Col. 1, for example), as well as fully human, just like us ("He became like his brothers in every way", Hebrews 2, maybe? In there somewhere). And yet the natures weren't mixed, which would have made Christ's humanity not like ours at all ("He was tempted in every way we are tempted, yet was without sin"). Nor are the natures the same, as LDS theology might suggest, because the Bible makes clear distinctions between God's nature and human nature. As far as the substance issue, the divine "substance" was attached to the human "substance" in Christ, with each retaining the coherence and characteristics of their respective natures. Neither nature was changed or mixed into some kind of third substance, because that would make Christ neither God nor man, and besides contradicting scripture, what's the point in that? There is an important principle that played a large role in figuring this all out, which was summed up by Athanasius, although others had the same idea before him. He put it this way: "What was not assumed, was not saved." What this means is that Christ came to take on the complete human nature and redeem it completely, being the second Adam as Paul says. Christ did not have a human body, but divinity in place of a spirit, for example. He took on every part of the human nature, body, soul, spirit. If he had been just a body with a divine mind, then how could Christ be said to experience everything we do, and struggle with temptation like we do? To put it more colorfully, if Christ had to use divinity as a cheat to perfect humanity, what hope do we have?So Christ was both completely divine and completely human. As the Chalcedonian Definition puts it, Christ was of one substance with God with regard to his divinity, and one substance with us with respect to his humanity. As far as how this actually worked in practice, I must confess that I haven't figured it out yet. I don't see a logical contradiction, but visualizing it in some way has eluded me thus far. I know that it is scriptural, but I don't understand all the nuts and bolts. I've put a lot more effort into understanding and thinking about the Trinity; Christology has always been on of my least favorite theological topics.But to preempt a possible objection here, just because it's difficult to understand or visualize does not make it an automatic absurdity or logical contradiction. I find string theory difficult to understand, and it's virtually impossible to visualize how vibrating cosmic strings produces all the matter I see and touch, and yet that is precisely what many scientists believe and defend.If Christ worshipped God while on the earth, because He was not fully God, how was He able to perform Godly acts like forgiving sins as in Luke 5:24?Christ was fully God, but he was also a perfect man, and as a perfect man he demonstrated the proper, perfect relationship of a human being with his God. But as he was also fully God, he was able to do things only God could do, such as forgiving sins and taking on the sins of the world on the cross. Both natures were at work, and we see them both acting in Christ in different ways. It is also important to keep in mind that Christ gave up certain aspects of his divinity in order to become human, according to Philippians 2; this doesn't mean that he gave up his nature, but he gave up certain abilities or powers in humbling himself. Omniscience and omnipresence, for example. He voluntarily placed limits on himself in order to fully take on the complete human nature. Does Christ still have a human, physical, body? If so, how is this again avoiding any dividing of substance or ontological differentiation?Christ does indeed have his body, and he'll be coming back in that body someday! As far as the substance issue, the two natures remain ontologically separate. He is one with the Father and Spirit in his divine nature, and one with us in his human nature, and the two natures are separate; they don't mix. This might be one of those areas harder for someone from an LDS background to understand, because of the materialistic bent to LDS theology. We don't know of non-physical substances in our human experience, only physical ones, and when they get put together, they mix and change. But as mainstream Christianity believes the divine nature to be immaterial, it presents no contradiction here. The divine nature and the human nature can coexist in Christ without changing each other or mixing to produce something different from either part. Christ's divinity "infuses" his humanity, with the result of one person having two natures. That might be a better way to describe it. Like I said, this topic gets into some subtleties here that baffle me sometimes. I'll take the Trinity any day!Enough for tonight. Nothing like talking Christology right before bedtime! Take care, everyone
JDave Posted February 5, 2009 Posted February 5, 2009 Rhino,I really appreciate all the time that you have put into this discussion with your well thought out responses. I read through the Trinity, Trinity, Trinity thread (wow ), and together with your responses hear I think I have my head wrapped around the theological construct of the Trinity. I appreciate its ability to conserve monotheism and see that as its main appeal (personally). I understand (and even have some agreement with) the majority of what you wrote, so I will ask for clarification on the rest.As far as the substance issue, the divine "substance" was attached to the human "substance" in Christ, with each retaining the coherence and characteristics of their respective natures. Neither nature was changed or mixed into some kind of third substance, because that would make Christ neither God nor man, and besides contradicting scripture, what's the point in that?And since the divine substance is spirit and immaterial and omnipresent, there is no separation of Christ from the Father? This makes some sense, but what about the intercessory prayer where Christ asks God why He has forsaken him? That sounds like there was a separation, even if momentary.But to preempt a possible objection here, just because it's difficult to understand or visualize does not make it an automatic absurdity or logical contradiction.I personally find such objections to be absurd in themselves. I really enjoyed 3DOP's thread recently about the 'Successful Error'. If millions of people agree on something, how can it be patently absurd? Some objections just can't be preempted though. It should be coming....Christ was fully God, but he was also a perfect man, and as a perfect man he demonstrated the proper, perfect relationship of a human being with his God. But as he was also fully God, he was able to do things only God could do, such as forgiving sins and taking on the sins of the world on the cross. Both natures were at work, and we see them both acting in Christ in different ways.I can grasp that. But if Christ had full divine nature and full human nature as you stated earlier, and he was capable of acting upon both, that would require some balancing act of not only will but also consciousness. I will expound on the problem I see here if it doesn't make sense.Christ does indeed have his body, and he'll be coming back in that body someday! As far as the substance issue, the two natures remain ontologically separate. He is one with the Father and Spirit in his divine nature, and one with us in his human nature, and the two natures are separate; they don't mix.I think I grasp the Hypostatic Union (if I correctly used the term). I don't quite grasp how the Trinity remained unchanging through this. I understand that Christ's human nature is not essential to His divinity, but it seems that the altogether 'other' nature of the Trinity changed to something altogether 'more other' with Christ retaining his physical body and human nature.I can see why you prefer pondering the Trinity -- it seems that my confusion at the moment rests squarely on Christology. Didn't even know there was a separate area for it... Thanks again!!
zerinus Posted February 5, 2009 Posted February 5, 2009 The apologetic use of Greek philosophy was certainly a large part of the rationale for using it. But I have to add that it went much deeper than that. Many early church fathers saw the Greek philosophies as God-inspired, though to a lesser degree than scripture. They didn't use it simply to reach out to the outside world; they used it in their own thinking, in their own discussions within the church.Agreed, they did! Believe it or not, LDS also believe that past religious leaders of other nations, as well as many ancient Greek philosophers and â??wise menâ? of the ancient past, were indeed inspired of God, but to a lesser degree than the prophets of scriptures. Here is a quote:However, we claim that Godâ??s inspiration is not limited to the Latter-day Saints. The First Presidency has stated: â??The great religious leaders of the world such as Mohammed, Confucius, and the Reformers, as well as philosophers including Socrates, Plato, and others, received a portion of Godâ??s light. Moral truths were given to them by God to enlighten whole nations and to bring a higher level of understanding to individuals. â?¦ We believe that God has given and will give to all peoples sufficient knowledge to help them on their way to eternal salvationâ? (â??Statement of the First Presidency regarding Godâ??s Love for All Mankind,â? 15 Feb. 1978). [From the First Presidency Message: Communion with the Holy Spirit, By President James E. Faust. Ensign, March 2002.]The earliest Christians did primarily draw upon Greek philosophers in their writings as an apologetic exercise in order to make Christian doctrine more acceptable or understandable to the pagans. But as time passed, they got carried away with that idea, and began to make use of those writings more as a primary source to develop their thinking on Christian doctrine. As a result of the Apostasy, the Church was no longer led by inspired prophetic leaders who could check that drift away from revealed doctrine, which is how many errors in Christian doctrine arose. But initially that was not the case. My original argument that the doctrine of deification in early Christianity was revealed rather than borrowed from pagan sources still remains valid.zerinus
zerinus Posted February 5, 2009 Posted February 5, 2009 Hi zerinusâ??A few comments.Probably a better translation of the Gr. ἃπτου (haptou) in John 20 is "Stop clinging to me" (so NAS), or "Do not cling to me" (so ESV). I agree that we must connect haptou meaningfully with the next sentence, introduced by Gr. γὰρ (gar, "for"): "for I have not yet ascended to the Father."Here's how I personally don't read the verse (paraphrased): "You are not allowed to touch me because I have not yet ascended to the Father."I read the verse more like this (paraphrased): "Don't cling to this body [as if my resurrection to the living is the final statement]; the final consummation of my work hasn't yet occurred" [i.e., when Christ ascends to heaven and sits down at the right hand of God, his work having been completed].In other words, I take Jesus' statement to Mary here to be theological in nature. She was already "touching" him, clinging to him; he says to her, "Stop clinging to me."When Jesus appears to Thomas (John 20.24-29), having already appeared to the other disciples, he invites Thomas to tactilely examine his wounds. The focus here is evidential. The text does not tell us whether or not Thomas availed himself of the invitation. I do not believe Jesus' statements to Thomas to "put your finger here," etc. are indicative of a reversal of his statement to Mary. In other words, Jesus was not communicating to Mary, "You are not yet allowed to touch me because I have not yet ascended to the Father," and subsequently to Thomas, "You are now allowed to touch me because I have already ascended to the Father." I don't think such a reading is in view for the author. But you connect his very next appearance (after having appeared to Mary)--prior to his appearance involving Thomas (John 20.24-29)--with the pericope in Luke 24.36-49, which strikes me as sensible. I would suggest that that pericope should be interpreted in a similar manner to his invitation to Thomas: i.e., it is evidential in nature. An invitation physically to confirm their doubts as to the reality of his resurrection. "They still disbelieved for joyâ?¦."The verb used in this instance is Gr. ψηλαφήσατέ (pselaphesate): "Touch me" [in context, for the purpose of alleviating your doubts]."This is not parallel in my opinion to Jesus' command to Mary to stop clinging to him. I don't find the two situations isomorphic, as it were. One point that can be viewed as arguing in favor of your position are the ascension pericopae recorded in Luke 24.50-53 and Acts 1.6-11. They are contradictory and cannot easily be read, if taken at face value, as separate recordings of the same event (the timing and locales are different). We know beyond reasonable doubt that Luke and Acts share a common author and that the literary "diptych" was circulated early in its history as a unified document: Luke-Acts. It does seem odd that the author (say, "Luke") would have recorded the same event in a contradictory manner in such a short span of text.A minority of the UBS committee believed that Luke 24.50-53 was not original to the Lukan autograph, but was rather added later when the Gospel of Luke began to circulate separately from Acts. That scenario would fit better with my preconceptions, but there is much to commend the view that the passage is original. (I won't go into details, unless you're particularly interested, but one might consult Metzger's A Textual Commentary on the Greek NT, 2nd ed.: 162-166).Nevertheless, I don't believe that the texts you've adduced necessitate the position that Jesus "ascended and descended many times after his resurrection." That strikes me as an unwarranted conclusion, whatever the textual problems with the "single-event" scenario might be. Best.cksYou are stretching that an awful lot to make it say what you want it to say. I don't believe it for on moment. But you have comnpletely ignored one thing: ". . . say unto them, I ascend unto my Father, . . ." So He was kidding when He said He was ascending to His Father?zerinus
cksalmon Posted February 5, 2009 Posted February 5, 2009 You are stretching that an awful lot to make it say what you want it to say. I don't believe it for on moment. But you have comnpletely ignored one thing: ". . . say unto them, I ascend unto my Father, . . ." So He was kidding when He said He was ascending to His Father?zerinusHi zerinus--Just giving you my take on the passage (mostly following Calvin here, if memory serves). If you don't find it compelling, feel free to ignore it. I get the idea from reading your interactions with others (and with myself now) that when others disagree with you they are definitionally incorrect. With regard to αναβαινω (anabainō), "I ascend" or "I am ascending," the text certainly presents us with Jesus' intention. On the other hand, we can be sure that Jesus did not mean "I am ascending at this very moment," since John does not record Mary witnessing his ascension. So, again, this passage just does not record "the" or "an" ascension. If you can show me from the text that John records the ascension event in chapter 20, I'll reconsider my position. Again, I believe there is a lot going on theologically in this encounter. Your view might be correct, but I'm certainly not convinced on the basis of this passage in John 20. cks
zerinus Posted February 5, 2009 Posted February 5, 2009 Hi zerinus--Just giving you my take on the passage (mostly following Calvin here, if memory serves). If you don't find it compelling, feel free to ignore it. I get the idea from reading your interactions with others (and with myself now) that when others disagree with you they are definitionally incorrect. With regard to αναβαινω (anabainō), "I ascend" or "I am ascending," the text certainly presents us with Jesus' intention. On the other hand, we can be sure that Jesus did not mean "I am ascending at this very moment," since John does not record Mary witnessing his ascension. So, again, this passage just does not record "the" or "an" ascension. If you can show me from the text that John records the ascension event in chapter 20, I'll reconsider my position.I go by the context of the passage; that context suggests to me He should ascend to the Father shortly after His encounter with Mary before continuing His ministry to His disciples at a later date. There are several other circumstantial evidence (mentioned earlier) that supports that interpretaion. You are free to disagree. I cannot "prove" to you that my understianding of the case is the right one. Neither can you "prove" to me that your point of view is the right one. So what do you want me to do about it that you disagree with me?zerinus
cksalmon Posted February 6, 2009 Posted February 6, 2009 I go by the context of the passage; that context suggests to me He should ascend to the Father shortly after His encounter with Mary before continuing His ministry to His disciples at a later date. There are several other circumstantial evidence (mentioned earlier) that supports that interpretaion. You are free to disagree. I cannot "prove" to you that my understianding of the case is the right one. Neither can you "prove" to me that your point of view is the right one. So what do you want me to do about it that you disagree with me?zerinusHi zerinus--I would agree that context is crucial if we hope to interpret correctly. I'm left wondering, then, why you seemingly haven't taken John 20.19 (two verses after your proof text) into account. I have no doubt that you believe you've found circumstantial and contextual indicators supportive of your interpretation. The text itself, however, lets us know that your suggestion (Jesus "[continued] His ministry to His disciples at a later date") is incorrectâ??and, in fact, impossible, if we take the text at face value. John 20.1 tells us that Mary "came to the tomb early, while it was still dark." Let's assume that "while it was still dark" indicates that the time was around 5:00 a.m. or so. You suggest that John 20.17 indicates that Jesus ascended to the Father shortly after his encounter with Mary (just after daybreak, perhaps?) and returned at a later date to continue his ministry to His disciples. John 20.19, however, tells us that Jesus appeared to the disciples "on the evening of that day" (τή ἡμέρα ἐκείνῃ, tē hēmera ekeinē). "Evening" here is Gr. οψιας (opsias), indicating a time after 3:00 p.m. Thus, Jesus appeared to the disciples approximately 10 to, say, 15 hours after his appearance to Mary.Jesus can't have "[continued] His ministry to His disciples at a later date" if he continued his ministry to his disciples only hours after his appearance to Mary in the early morning--unless, by "a later date" you mean "several hours later on the same day." I can't imagine that that's what you intended, though. If you take John 20.19 into account, I'd imagine that you'd need to change your interpretation to something like: "[Jesus continued] his Ministry to His disciples [later that day]."You are free to disagree. I cannot "prove" to you that my understianding of the case is the right one. Neither can you "prove" to me that your point of view is the right one. So what do you want me to do about it that you disagree with me?I think it has been shown that your interpretation supra cannot stand in light of the text. I was just attempting to have a dialog, zerinus. I take it that you're not interested in that. Best.cks
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.