-
Posts
323 -
Joined
Recent Profile Visitors
The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.
Eschaton's Achievements
-
Sadducees' Trap used the Book of Tobit in Matthew 22
Eschaton replied to Pyreaux's topic in General Discussions
He won't find any mainstream scholars arguing that Jesus thought marriage would continue in the eschaton. -
Sadducees' Trap used the Book of Tobit in Matthew 22
Eschaton replied to Pyreaux's topic in General Discussions
You misunderstand. I'm not arguing that Jesus was an ascetic who required strict celibacy. I'm giving you the framework showing that Jesus did not value family relationships over celibacy, that his view was an immanent apocalypse, and that he understood as marriage as not continuing on beyond this life. All three of those are standards of New Testament scholarship. The "like the angels in heaven" is your clue that Jesus did not think marriage would continue past this life. Other important passages include his praise for those who abandon wives and children to live Jesus' lifestyle. -
Sadducees' Trap used the Book of Tobit in Matthew 22
Eschaton replied to Pyreaux's topic in General Discussions
- “I suggest that Jesus—anticipating the final tribulation, general resurrection, the incoming of the exiles, a last judgment, even his own end-time role—did not expect there to be a next generation. He thought of himself as inaugurating the new age, when people would be like the angels, when marriage and childbirth would be no longer needed. To advocate a celibate lifestyle for everyone is no simple social program; it signals the end of the age. Thus it is the apocalyptic setting that substantially drives his so-called ‘moral’ program.” Kloppenborg, John S., and John W. Marshall. 2005. Apocalypticism, Anti-Semitism and the Historical Jesus: Subtexts in Criticism. Vol. 275. Journal for the Study of the New Testament Supplement Series. London; New York: T&T Clark International. - The correctness of this interpretation is assured by the fact that it is difficult to conceive of an act of “being counted worthy” as occurring at any time subsequent to physical death. This logion, then, reflects the view that humanity is currently divided into two classes, the “sons of this age.” who marry, and “those who are counted worthy to attain that age and the resurrection from the dead,” i.e., “sons of God” or “sons of the resurrection,” who do not marry. That is, celibacy is regarded as a prerequisite for resurrection. (p. 121) Aune, David E., “Luke 20:34-36: A ‘Gnosticized’ Logion of Jesus?”, Jesus, Gospel Tradition and Paul in the Context of Jewish and Greco-Roman Antiquity: Collected Essays II (WUNT.1 303), 2013. And of course in Jewish apocalyptic literature, only the wicked, fallen angels have relations with women. 1 Enoch 15:6-7 1 And He answered and said to me, and I heard His voice: 'Fear not, Enoch, thou righteous 2 man and scribe of righteousness: approach hither and hear my voice. And go, say to the Watchers of heaven, who have sent thee to intercede for them: "You should intercede" for men, and not men 3 for you: Wherefore have ye left the high, holy, and eternal heaven, and lain with women, and defiled yourselves with the daughters of men and taken to yourselves wives, and done like the children 4 of earth, and begotten giants (as your) sons And though ye were holy, spiritual, living the eternal life, you have defiled yourselves with the blood of women, and have begotten (children) with the blood of flesh, and, as the children of men, have lusted after flesh and blood as those also do who die 5 and perish**. Therefore have I given them wives also that they might impregnate them, and beget 6 children by them, that thus nothing might be wanting to them on earth. But you were formerly 7 spiritual, living the eternal life, and immortal for all generations of the world. And therefore I have not appointed wives for you; for as for the spiritual ones of the heaven, in heaven is their dwelling.** -
Sadducees' Trap used the Book of Tobit in Matthew 22
Eschaton replied to Pyreaux's topic in General Discussions
Jesus says they're "like the angels in heaven." So yes, sexless. Jesus never makes any such distinction. There is no reason to read contemporary LDS doctrine into an ancient first century text. Your argument is sophistry. Biblical scholars read Jesus' statements on marriage the same way I do. The only reason you're trying to lawyer in an exception is because of your commitment to contemporary LDS dogmas. No, it's not an assumption, this is all coming from historical scholarship of the Bible. Jesus praises the sexless and never praises family relationships. Jesus forbids divorce and remarriage, not divorce per se. Timothy, a second century forgery, is the prime example of Roman family values creeping into Christianity, as I mentioned in my previous post. Some early Christian ascetism was based on philosophy, but in Paul and Jesus' case, it was likely just due to their belief in the impending eschaton. There is no use in getting married and starting families when the end of history is coming any day now. Paul and Jesus didn't forbid marriage, but they treated celibacy as a higher way of living. -
Sadducees' Trap used the Book of Tobit in Matthew 22
Eschaton replied to Pyreaux's topic in General Discussions
24 Jesus said to them, “Is not this the reason you are wrong, that you know neither the scriptures nor the power of God? 25 For when people rise from the dead, they neither marry nor are given in marriage but are like angels in heaven. The angels in heaven of course being sexless. It strikes me as a dishonest reading to parse out the words to suggest that Jesus was suggesting that existing marriages would be valid in the afterlife. Jesus wasn't pro-marriage to begin with - he asked his followers to abandon their families and praised those who lived as eunuchs. In fact both Jesus and Paul were in favor of celibacy and didn't celebrate family relationships. That narrative in Christianity only came later, as Roman cultural values started to creep in. -
oops, wrong thread
-
Latter-Day Saints, white Evangelical value empathy the least
Eschaton replied to Eschaton's topic in General Discussions
We do have different standards - you're going by the received Christian tradition and I'm going by the historical consensus. -
Latter-Day Saints, white Evangelical value empathy the least
Eschaton replied to Eschaton's topic in General Discussions
We don't have eye witness testimony to that effect. That comes from John, written last in the 90s CE, the least historical of the four gospels. We have no eye witness testimony in regards to any of the teachings of Jesus, but the self-exalting sayings in John are the least likely to be historical. Otherwise one has to explain why that kind of language doesn't appear in our earliest gospels. If the authors of Mark/Matthew/Luke knew that Jesus was saying those kinds of things, why didn't they report it? And why do the sayings in John match the writing style of the author of John's gospel? By historical standards only a small percentage of the reported sayings of Jesus are likely to have been something Jesus actually said in life. Those historically likely sayings include some of the memorable aphorisms and parables, and other sayings that align with historical criteria. -
Latter-Day Saints, white Evangelical value empathy the least
Eschaton replied to Eschaton's topic in General Discussions
That's a Christian theological view. From a historical perspective Jesus was a law-observant apocalyptic Jewish wisdom teacher who, like many other Jewish thinkers, had his own interpretation of Torah. -
Latter-Day Saints, white Evangelical value empathy the least
Eschaton replied to Eschaton's topic in General Discussions
Indeed! Jesus himself was not in any sense a Christian, but Christian empathy derives from his Jewish teachings, which did not emerge in a vacuum. -
Latter-Day Saints, white Evangelical value empathy the least
Eschaton replied to Eschaton's topic in General Discussions
Yup, exactly. Regarding the most conservative religious groups, it's definitely white evangelicals and LDS: https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2024/04/09/party-identification-among-religious-groups-and-religiously-unaffiliated-voters/ -
Latter-Day Saints, white Evangelical value empathy the least
Eschaton replied to Eschaton's topic in General Discussions
While it's not comprehensive, it's enough to show a trend away from empathy as a value amongst the two most conservative American religious groups. Empathy gets in the way of the aims of the wicked, so they propaganize their adherents to harden their hearts against human kindness. Propagandists are eager to have their abuses tolerated by the American public, hence the anti-empathy campaign. -
Latter-Day Saints, white Evangelical value empathy the least
Eschaton replied to Eschaton's topic in General Discussions
I envy you not having heard of it, but it's real: https://www.npr.org/2025/03/22/nx-s1-5321299/how-empathy-came-to-be-seen-as-a-weakness-in-conservative-circles -
Latter-Day Saints, white Evangelical value empathy the least
Eschaton replied to Eschaton's topic in General Discussions
Yes I believe that's right -
Latter-Day Saints, white Evangelical value empathy the least
Eschaton replied to Eschaton's topic in General Discussions
I value empathy. The opponents of Christ and traditional Christianity do not. Do you value empathy Kenngo?
