wenglund Posted November 22, 2011 Posted November 22, 2011 ...In my view, there is every reason to believe [that in the 1835 Abr. Mss.] these characters correspond to their English translations and there is every reason to believe the characters came first and were written in sequence from the Sensen text...In another thread you reiterate:"The argument is not that we have everything Joseph Smith possessed. The argument is that we have strong reasons to believe the source for the Book of Abraham is among the extant papyri. Hi Kevin,I realize you don't like me to ask you scrutinizing questions about your stated opinions, so please forgive me for inquiring, in addition to my previous question, how what you state above not only relate to the EA/GAEL, but also how it comports with your on-going contention that the BoA was derived, in large part, from the Book of Genesis?Thanks, -Wade Englund-
Loran Blood Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 (edited) JMS, a better question is why are YOU in this thread?Odd, I was just about to ask you the same question.Your comments are absurdNever mind, the cat has my toungue at the moment.and don't address anything I've presented. Your dismissal of the KEP based on the fact that the Church hasn't canonized them reveals the fact that you have no idea what the KEP are to begin with.The really fascinating thing about this assertion is that, whatever theory any apologist may take as a better fit to the existing evidence than another, Kevin Graham has no idea what the KEP are either. Neither does Metcalf, Smith, or anyone else. Neither do I. Nor does Will claim to "know" what they are. He has a detailed conjectural theoretical framework that seeks to move us closer to the truth, but he has not, to the best of my knowedge, beat his breast in fits of intellectual arrogance and claimed that he "knows" the meaning and purpose of the KEP. Kevin, as I've been pointing out for years, doesn't seem to understand the difference between knowledge, theory, hypothosis, and pure, unbridled speculation. He frequently conflates all of them with the others in attempting to make his points, and the water always emerges much the muddier for his efforts.We have portions of the original Book of Mormon manuscript. The Church hasn't canonized that either, but that doesn't mean it isn't the original manuscript.Yes, but we know what they are. We don't know what the KEP are or why they were produced. Check one more tautological argument in which Kevin seeks, yet again, to assume as settled and known what he has yet to demonstrate.Yes, I suppose it is "possible" that the scribes conspired to show the Prophet a thing or two about how real translations are supposed to take place. I suppose it is also "possible" that they all forgot which papyrus pertained to Abraham. I also suppose it is possible that the moon if made of cheese, but it probably isn't and there is no good reason to believe it is. It isn't enough to say something is possible. You have to give a good reason to believe a proposed possibility is in fact, reality. "Possibility" doesn't mean much in a world of truth-seeking creatures based in reality. We want to know what's true. What's real. If we can't find that out with absolute certainty, then we want the next best thing, which is to induce what is most probably true. Just because something is possible doesn't make it plausible or probableI thought you were going to argue your ideas here, Kevin, and stay away from polemics and personal attacks? The above is not an attempt at cogent, evidentially conncted argument, but just a traditional Kevin Graham ad hominem potboiler. It sounds like a cross between Madalyn Murray 'O Hair and Bill Maher.I don't think you're up to this, Kevin, I just don't think you're up to it.Back to back insults, you are thread banned. Edited November 23, 2011 by Minos
wenglund Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 I don't think you're up to this, Kevin, I just don't think you're up to it.I am willing to give him more of a chance, charitably and forgivingly understanding that some habits die hard. He has made a pretty good go of it so far in the "Missing Scroll Theory" thread.Thanks, -Wade Englund-
Cobalt-70 Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 What is the line of evidence to get me to those claims? What principles and premises do I need to accept to accept those claims?Maybe I don't understand your question, but here's my best shot: Smith certainly believed he was getting the words from God through some mystical process. I don't think he ever claimed that the translation was via pure intellect, although I don't think we know for sure that Smith was using his seer stone for the translation. Some contemporary said he was, but by that point he wasn't using the stone for his run-of-the-mill D&C revelations. Whatever process it was, it was magical, rather than academic.
jskains Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 JMS, a better question is why are YOU in this thread? Your comments are absurd and don't address anything I've presented. Your dismissal of the KEP based on the fact that the Church hasn't canonized them reveals the fact that you have no idea what the KEP are to begin with.Oh, I am sorry, I didn't know you were the expert in KEP and that you get to decide who does and who does not have a right to an opinion on the subject. I also am fascinated every time a person like you decides to use the "if you don't come to my conclusion, you must be ignorant" style of logical fallacy, which tells me that you expect everyone to listen to your ideas and nod obediently in agreement.We have portions of the original Book of Mormon manuscript. The Church hasn't canonized that either, but that doesn't mean it isn't the original manuscript.KEP isn't the manuscript. It is the notes. There is a big difference.Yes, I suppose it is "possible" that the scribes conspired to show the Prophet a thing or two about how real translations are supposed to take place. I suppose it is also "possible" that they all forgot which papyrus pertained to Abraham. I also suppose it is possible that the moon if made of cheese, but it probably isn't and there is no good reason to believe it is. It isn't enough to say something is possible. You have to give a good reason to believe a proposed possibility is in fact, reality. "Possibility" doesn't mean much in a world of truth-seeking creatures based in reality. We want to know what's true. What's real. If we can't find that out with absolute certainty, then we want the next best thing, which is to induce what is most probably true. Just because something is possible doesn't make it plausible or probable.Translation, only your possibilities are valid. All else is just ignorance?The evidence weighs heavily against Joseph Smith as a translator. If you want to strap on a bullet-proof testimony that makes you impervious to the influence of "worldly" evidence; if you want to take comfort in an endless vortex of imaginative "possibilities," all for the sake of maintaining faith, then more power to you. I'm not interested in destroying testimonies. But for me, I need a good reason to believe Joseph Smith could translate ancient documents as he claimed, especially since all the evidence is riding against him. The question about his status as a true prophet doesn't pertain to this thread, so please take that elsewhere.Again, people like you want to stick the entire thing in a vacuum. So while YOU might want to ignore it, I don't. I think it is ignorant to take supernatural events and try to isolate them into a scientific or academic only perspective.JMS 1
jskains Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 Sorry to ask, but is it well known that Xander is Kevin Graham or did I misunderstand the implication? Sorry, I have a lot of irons in the fire, so I don't catch everything.JMS
LeSellers Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 Sorry to ask, but is it well known that Xander is Kevin Graham or did I misunderstand the implication? Sorry, I have a lot of irons in the fire, so I don't catch everything.His sig was, some months ago, "Yes, I am Kevin Graham. Boo!", as I recall. Some sort of self-congratulatory slam at us igrunt marmunz, I s'pose.Lehi
Xander Posted November 23, 2011 Author Posted November 23, 2011 (edited) Thanks for not taking the bait, Xander. Thank you for recognizing it as bait.These threads have taken on a new life of their own and I wish I had the time to respond to everyone, but I don't.It will most likely be a weekend thing for me, with an occasional quip from my phone.And for those wondering, yes I am Kevin Graham. I put my real name in my profile, didn't I?The only reason I'm going by my son's name is because "Kevin Graham" was already taken by some loud-mouth who got banned awhile back. Edited November 23, 2011 by Xander
LeSellers Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 And for those wondering, yes I am Kevin Graham. I put my real name in my profile, didn't I?Perhaps, we can't know because the "real name" doesn't show up in profiles.Lehi
floatingboy Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 It would be so nice to see a thread where things stay on topic and don't degenerate into name-calling and blame-placing. Thanks, Wade, for doing your best to keep it on track.If I may take a stab at your questions to Kevin since he hasn't answered them... I'm pretty sure he's not saying that the actual source for the BofA is the extant portions of the papyri, but rather only that JS and associates believed they were the source for it, or at very least that the portions of the papyri that they referenced as being the very Book of Abraham are in fact largely, if not entirely, the parts that are still extant today. I would wager that when Kevin says that Genesis is the source of the BofA, he means that it is the true source. Hope I didn't misunderstand your question and merely state the obvious. You also state:"...even were the characters derived in sequence from the Sensen papyrus, and were written first before the English text, then I would think that one may just as easily assume a correlation of enciphered translation than deciphered translation, that is if one assumes a translation correlation at all."In light of the fact that, in an enciphering scenario, so much meaning is being assigned to each character, thereby making the characters useless for enciphering other text, why do you believe it's just as easy to assume that they were attempting to encipher rather than decipher?Just to be clear about what I mean: If I am attempting to create either a cipher or invent a written language (or recover the "pure" language, for that matter), would it make sense for me to take a large chunk of text such as:"Hello. My name is Floatingboy. I was born in the western U.S., but at an early age I moved to the midwest and lived there until I graduated from high school. After that I went to Brigham Young University for two years until it came time to serve a proselyting mission for my church in South America. Upon returning from my mission two years later, I finished my college degree in another 2 years. That finished my formal education for the time being, until I made a decision years later to get a masters degree on the east coast."And then assign it a character such as Œ.How flexible would such a language be? Every time I use Œ, it has to represent that paragraph. Or, if I'm being generous, it has to represent a generic outline of a brief sketch of a person's formative years, which would then ostensibly be made specific to that person by the use of other subsequent characters. Even if we make Œ only represent "Hello. My name is Floatingboy", you still have yourself a very clunky and non-generative writing system that allows for very little to no creativity and originality. So, am I misunderstanding you completely? Do you envision it as working some other way?Thanks.
floatingboy Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 Ok, looks like I've beaten a dead horse. I hadn't seen the further discussion of this point in the other thread. But if there's anything you'd like to add to the thoughts expressed there, I welcome it.
wenglund Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 It would be so nice to see a thread where things stay on topic and don't degenerate into name-calling and blame-placing. Thanks, Wade, for doing your best to keep it on track.That was very nice of you to say. You are to be complemented as well. [thumbs up]actual source for the BofA is the extant portions of the papyri, but rather only that JS and associates believed they were the source for it, or at very least that the portions of the papyri that they referenced as being the very Book of Abraham are in fact largely, if not entirely, the parts that are still extant today.I understand that is his position (to which I have disagreed). However, I am not sure how this answers either of my questions. I am trying to find out whether, or how, Kevin's stated beliefs (about the correspondence between characters and explanations in the 1835 Abr. Mss., and coming first and taken sequentially from the Sensen papyrus) fit within a broader theory about how the BoA was produced, and what meaning he sees it all has to the verity of therestored gospel and the BoA as scripture. In particular, I am first trying to pin down why he evidently assumes that the text in the 1835 Abr. Mss was a deciphered translation, rather than an enciphered translation, of the Sensen characters, and how he believes that deciphering took place.I would wager that when Kevin says that Genesis is the source of the BofA, he means that it is the true source. Right. However, as mentioned above, I am trying to figure out how his belief about Genesis fits together with his other beliefs about the Abr. Mss. and the EA/GAEL, etc., in terms of an over-arching theory for how the BoA was produced.In short, I am trying to determine if Kevin may inadvertently be arguing inconsistently or against himself.Thanks, -Wade Englund-
wenglund Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 You also state:"...even were the characters derived in sequence from the Sensen papyrus, and were written first before the English text, then I would think that one may just as easily assume a correlation of enciphered translation than deciphered translation, that is if one assumes a translation correlation at all."In light of the fact that, in an enciphering scenario, so much meaning is being assigned to each character, thereby making the characters useless for enciphering other text, why do you believe it's just as easy to assume that they were attempting to encipher rather than decipher?As explained to Cobalt-70 in another thread, the supposed uselessness of the extent of meaning assigned to each character is just as applicable to deciphering as it is to enciphering. Either way, a single character is assigned a large amount of text. So, the existence of such supposed useless relationship between character and text, isn't necessarily evidence one way or the other in favor of or against deciphering or enciphering.As such, determining the direction of translation (decipher or encipher) must needs be determined in some other way. And, given the layers and layers of arguments I present in the other thread against the EA/GAEL as a deciphering device for the BoA, which arguments extent to the 1835 Abr. Mss., I tend to believe the Abr. Mss., like the EA/GAEL, to be an enciphering translation.Just to be clear about what I mean: If I am attempting to create either a cipher or invent a written language (or recover the "pure" language, for that matter), would it make sense for me to take a large chunk of text such as:"Hello. My name is Floatingboy. I was born in the western U.S., but at an early age I moved to the midwest and lived there until I graduated from high school. After that I went to Brigham Young University for two years until it came time to serve a proselyting mission for my church in South America. Upon returning from my mission two years later, I finished my college degree in another 2 years. That finished my formal education for the time being, until I made a decision years later to get a masters degree on the east coast."And then assign it a character such as Œ.It would make as much sense as to decipher the character "CE" as conveying all the information you presented above.How flexible would such a language be? Every time I use Œ, it has to represent that paragraph. Or, if I'm being generous, it has to represent a generic outline of a brief sketch of a person's formative years, which would then ostensibly be made specific to that person by the use of other subsequent characters. Even if we make Œ only represent "Hello. My name is Floatingboy", you still have yourself a very clunky and non-generative writing system that allows for very little to no creativity and originality.It wouldn't be flexible at all, whether used to encipher or to decipher.However, those who were involved in creating the "language" or whatever may have been less interested in flexibility, and more interested in efficient use of space, or perhaps even unbreakability of the "code."Thanks, -Wade Englund-
Jaybear Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 I am trying to find out whether, or how, Kevin's stated beliefs (about the correspondence between characters and explanations in the 1835 Abr. Mss., and coming first and taken sequentially from the Sensen papyrus) fit within a broader theory about how the BoA was produced, and what meaning he sees it all has to the verity of therestored gospel and the BoA as scripture. In particular, I am first trying to pin down why he evidently assumes that the text in the 1835 Abr. Mss was a deciphered translation, rather than an enciphered translation, of the Sensen characters, and how he believes that deciphering took place.Huh? One of your common retort is that "you don't understand my point" or "you don't get it."I think that is fair observation, because ... and I say with with all the kindness I can muster ... your explanation is incoherent.Surely you must know that LDS critics, Kevin included, do not consider Smith to be a prophet of God, or capable of translating Egyptian into English. He would therefore not as you suggest "assume that the text in the 1835 Abr. Mss was a deciphered translation". Further, I don't see how it is relevant whether Kevin personally believes that Smith deluded himself into believing he was translating from the Sensen papyrus , or was merely purporting to translate from the papyrus.So, really, what is it you are asking, and why?
wenglund Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 (edited) Huh? One of your common retort is that "you don't understand my point" or "you don't get it."I think that is fair observation, because ... and I say with with all the kindness I can muster ... your explanation is incoherent.I understand your confusion. Bless your heart, try as you might, you still somehow managed to confuse a question to Kevin as a comment by me. That kind of confusion is of your own making, and not something I can control for.Surely you must know that LDS critics, Kevin included, do not consider Smith to be a prophet of God, or capable of translating Egyptian into English. He would therefore not as you suggest "assume that the text in the 1835 Abr. Mss was a deciphered translation".To the contrary. While the critics may not believe Joseph to have been a prophet or to have literally translated the Egyptian papyrus, not a few them over the last 40 or so years, including Kevin (see HERE), have explicitly consider the 1835 Abr. Mss. to be a translation document, and implicitly considered the direction of translation to be that of deciphering. Granted, many of the critics may believe that the translation was "made up" or imagined in some way, or in part the product of an inspired EA/GAEL, but they still speak of it as translation nevertheless. Perhaps you weren't aware of this, which again may explain your confusion--which confusion is of your own making, and not something I can control for.Further, I don't see how it is relevant whether Kevin personally believes that Smith deluded himself into believing he was translating from the Sensen papyrus , or was merely purporting to translate from the papyrus.Since I didn't mention anything about "deluded," nor did my question presuppose, implicitly or otherwise, what Kevin may or may not believe about the nature of the translation, your confusion is again understandable. This can happen when you misread things into my statements that are not there nor were they intended to be. Again, this kind of confusion is of your own making, and not something I can control for.So, really, what is it you are asking, and why?Now that I have disabused you of several false and confusing perceptions of your own making, hopefully now you will be able to understand my fairly clear and straightforward questions. If not, please let me know about what exactly you may still be confused, and I will try again to unravel your confusion.Thanks, -Wade Englund- Edited November 23, 2011 by wenglund
Jaybear Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 (edited) I understand your confusion. Bless your heart, try as you might, you still somehow managed to confuse a question to Kevin as a comment by me. That kind of confusion is of your own making, and not something I can control for.The "confusion" is driven by the fact that your question was premised an a questionable assumption, which you presented as fact. To the contrary. There is no contrary position. Critics do not believe that Smith could translate Egyptian into English. Period.They do not literally believe that, ... and I will use your words here .... "that the text in the 1835 Abr. Mss was a deciphered translation"Note that words you used now when blaming me for my confusion, are not the same words you used then. Now you say, critics "consider the 1835 Abr. Mss. to be a translation document"On that I agree, and was aware that critics believe that the 1835 Abr. Mss was or purported to be a "translation document."One can believe that it was intended to be a "translation document" but that it was not, in fact, a "deciphered translation."Since I didn't mention anything about "deluded," nor did my question presuppose, implicitly or otherwise, what Kevin may or may not believe about the nature of the translation, your confusion is again understandable. This can happen when you misread things into my statements that are not there nor were they intended to be. Again, this kind of confusion is of your own making, and not something I can control for.I didn't say you did. My point was that I don't see how Kevin's personal beliefs are germane to the issue.Regardless of what he believes, either it was or was not intended to be a cipher (or an exercise in "pure language").What then is the point of your question?If you really think you have identified an incongruity between Kevin's argument and his belief, don't hint, state the incongruity.Now that I have disabused you of several false and confusing perceptions of your own making, hopefully now you will be able to understand my fairly clear and straightforward questions. If not, please let me know about what exactly you may still be confused, and I will try again to unravel your confusion.I was not trying to pick a fight. I was trying to understand your question and your point. But your condescension is patently offensive. Edited November 23, 2011 by Jaybear
wenglund Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 The "confusion" is driven by the fact that your question was premised an a questionable assumption, which you presented as fact.There is no contrary position. Critics do not believe that Smith could translate Egyptian into English. Period. They do not literally believe that, ... and I will use your words here .... "that the text in the 1835 Abr. Mss was a deciphered translation"Note that words you used now when blaming me for my confusion, are not the same words you used then. Now you say, critics "consider the 1835 Abr. Mss. to be a translation document"On that I agree, and was aware that critics believe that the 1835 Abr. Mss was or purported to be a "translation document."One can believe that it was intended to be a "translation document" but that it was not, in fact, a "deciphered translation."I didn't say you did. My point was that I don't see how Kevin's personal beliefs are germane to the issue. Regardless of what he believes, either it was or was not intended to be a cipher (or an exercise in "pure language").What then is the point of your question?If you really think you have identified an incongruity between Kevin's argument and his belief, don't hint, state the incongruity.I was not trying to pick a fight. I was trying to understand your question and your point. But your condescension is patently offensive.I appreciate you sharing your point of view.As I see it, I attempted to clarify what I, as the author of the questions, understood to be the reasons behind your lack of comprehension. However, it appears now that you are unwilling to accept what I suggested, and are intent instead on holding firm to your prior uncomprehending position. So, I can't see that I will be able to do anything for you, and will leave things as they are, hoping that maybe since you alone seem to be having a terrible time grasping what I asked, that perhaps other participants may be of help to you where I could not.In closing my end of the exchange between us, I find it interesting, though, that while you appear to have no problem accusing me of incoherence (I certainly had no problem with it), you think is patently offensive condescension for me to suggest that the confusion is yours. Oh well...Thanks, -Wade Englund-
floatingboy Posted November 23, 2011 Posted November 23, 2011 In Jaybear's defense, Wade, I too was confused a bit by your questions. I just thought that there was something I was missing. As for your point about considering it the same problem to conclude deciphering or enciphering, I have to disagree. It's one thing to think that JS and associates believed that one character could represent multiple lines of English text (even if it doesn't seem reasonable), but it's another to think that anyone would reasonably believe that they could create some sort of meaningful and useful system for encoding other documents from English using this very inflexible alphabet. I don't think both ways of looking at it are on equal footing.
wenglund Posted November 24, 2011 Posted November 24, 2011 In Jaybear's defense, Wade, I too was confused a bit by your questions. I just thought that there was something I was missing.I appreciate you letting me know. However, I think Jaybear was more than a bit confused, and this because he was missing more than a little something--though he seems to think otherwise. Whatever the case, hopefully you have a better understanding now about what I was asking. If not, feel free to ask for clarification.As for your point about considering it the same problem to conclude deciphering or enciphering, I have to disagree. It's one thing to think that JS and associates believed that one character could represent multiple lines of English text (even if it doesn't seem reasonable), but it's another to think that anyone would reasonably believe that they could create some sort of meaningful and useful system for encoding other documents from English using this very inflexible alphabet. I don't think both ways of looking at it are on equal footing.Could you please explain what you believe is the inequality? In each case there is a single character that represents multiple lines of texts. Right? And, to believe that one character may be deciphered into multiple lines of English text, is to implicitly believe that it was previously enciphered the same. And, to believe that one character may be enciphered into multiple lines of English text, is to implicitly believe it may in the future be deciphered the same. To be honest, I am not seeing the difference except in direction of translation.Thanks, -Wade Englund-
floatingboy Posted November 24, 2011 Posted November 24, 2011 yes, of course that character would be enciphered and then deciphered the same way. but to claim that it could be part of an alphabet that could in turn be used for other different english text stretches credibility. it would be useful only for expressing the exact same set of english text.
wenglund Posted November 24, 2011 Posted November 24, 2011 yes, of course that character would be enciphered and then deciphered the same way. but to claim that it could be part of an alphabet that could in turn be used for other different english text stretches credibility. it would be useful only for expressing the exact same set of english textAgain, as I see it, your view applies equally whether the alphabet is intended to decipher or encipher. Either way, it would be useful only for expressing the same exact set of English text. So, I am still not understanding where you see the inequality?Thanks, -Wade Englund-
Pahoran Posted November 24, 2011 Posted November 24, 2011 The text of the Book of Abraham didn't come from the papyrus itself. So it did come from a mystical process. But Smith believed that the text corresponded to the Egyptian characters listed on the left of the translation manuscripts. So he and his scribes thought he was translating Egyptian characters from Papyrus XI. Whether the characters or the "translation" was written first or last doesn't change that fact. Whatever the order, it was a purported (and mistaken) translation of actual Egyptian characters (as best he and his scribes could transcribe them) via a mystical process.Call for references, please that "Smith believed that the text corresponded to the Egyptian characters listed on the left of the [so-called] translation manuscripts." Where and when does Joseph say that he "believed" any such thing?Incidentally, calling the Abraham manuscripts in the KEP's "translation manuscripts" is a deliberate attempt to beg the question. Just so you know.Regards,Pahoran
Pahoran Posted November 25, 2011 Posted November 25, 2011 The insinuation was a popular one back then. William liked to float this meme about how the critics were deceiving people with manipulated photos. Suffice it to say - and you can check the link - Don and Chris were turned off by Will and Pahoran's attitude about this subject.I note the gratuitous flame-bait.Regards,Pahoran
Xander Posted November 25, 2011 Author Posted November 25, 2011 I note the gratuitous flame-bait.Regards,PahoranAs opposed to ... a regular bait?All I did was allude to the original context of the exchange, which involved you. No baiting intended.
Xander Posted November 25, 2011 Author Posted November 25, 2011 (edited) Incidentally, calling the Abraham manuscripts in the KEP's "translation manuscripts" is a deliberate attempt to beg the question. Just so you know.Just so you know, the only reason to beg this question is apologetic, for the documents themselves clearly indicate they are translation manuscripts. There is every indication of them being translation manuscripts. That's why the first page of MS 1 states at the top, "translation of the Book of Abraham." Mormon scholar James R. Clarke also agrees.Imagine, allowing the document to speak for itself. What craziness. Edited November 25, 2011 by Xander
Recommended Posts