Here's my response. (Apparently, it's too long. In any event, it wouldn't post to Reddit.) I'm sure this poster would appreciate constructive feedback. And if you can let me know why Reddit doesn't like me, that'd be good, too!
It wouldn't allow me to post this directly to Reddit, but I posted my Reddit response here, then posted a link to the response that I posted here successfully on Reddit. (If that makes any sense!)