-
Posts
1,037 -
Joined
-
Last visited
About Vanguard
- Birthday 11/28/1965
Profile Information
-
Gender
Male
-
Location
Utah
Recent Profile Visitors
4,018 profile views
Vanguard's Achievements
-
You have a point. Outside of a legal context, I too believe these men were guilty (morally) of rape. Part of the problem becomes when (and if) these men are found innocent in a court of law, will we (the royal we) accept the verdict or will we rail against the very legal system that found them innocent?
-
I believe my point still stands. Again, emoting and providing empathy is one thing. Wanting to emote and receive empathy (I totally get this) while throughout this thread other posters (and perhaps MustardSeed?) suggest a miscarriage of justice if these young men are not found guilty is something else. We cannot walk and chew gum in this case.
-
I'm not sure If I'm understanding you or if you're not understanding me? I'm not talking about rape. I'm talking about people using the "I need to safe space to emote" as a pretense to accuse others of actions the people themselves don't know were committed. Again, true empathy toward someone does not require character aspersions against someone else. The minute an individual transitions from simply emoting to conclusory comments about the guilt of someone else, the conversation must turn to a more dispassionate exchange of ideas about the allegations to see if they stand up on their own. The position "Hey, I just need to safely express my feelings" is legitimate but it cannot walk hand in hand with "Hey, therefore the accused party is as guilty as sin and you are at best an enabler for not agreeing with me".
-
I disagree. When allowing for 'emotion in these conversations' to dip too far into largely unsubstantiated accusations (and criminal at that!) against another party, it is no longer simply about sharing one's feelings. And it certainly is not empathy. I remind my men's' groups continually that empathy does not mean agreement (though some times it does) with the details about what got the person to such an emotional state. I can emotionally connect with another's pain without the need to cast aspersions on another for contributing to said pain. As you've indicated regards to Nehor, I too can appreciate another's emotions around any given topic that I agree with, that is, until at some point in the future said emotion is aimed against me.
-
I haven't yet heard a good enough argument for why men should not be categorically viewed in the ways we have been discussing. I agree all women should show some degree of being 'consciously cautious' when around men for 2 reasons - 1) generally speaking, men are physically stronger than women are; and 2) an unacceptably high number of men demonstrate a proclivity for using that strength to their own advantage and to the great detriment of women's' well-being. I can't imagine I would be any different if I were in a woman's shoes. I do, however, believe it is better viewed that 'women should always be aware and vigilant of their surroundings when around the opposite sex' rather than 'women should view all men as potential rapists'. The latter phraseology seems overwrought and not helpful in the way intended. The vast majority of women are also murdered at the hands of men though I don't think anyone is advocating women should therefore view all men as potential murderers?
-
Ha! Finally I found this. Was just now for the first time reading the thread and the first thing that popped into my head was Mfb!! : ) He too has played with my head a bit. I wish I could find him to continue the exchange about the notion that ALL of these things do not have to be as we have conceptualized over time.
-
For me it's a really big deal and perhaps bigger than it should be. My wife and I have commented on this dynamic over the past almost 30 yrs. There runs something really deep about family members who have left the church and who now drink. I remember my youngest brother (I have 2 younger brothers who have left the faith) was polite enough to ask when both couples were out to dinner if we'd mind his purchasing a beer for dinner. Of course we said yes (what else would we say?!) but I found it hard. I have commented with my wife that I'd have an easier time with former member siblings and/or adult children having sexual relations outside of wedlock over them becoming drinkers the rationale being the sexual desire is more innate but the desire to drink not so much. And why would that be such a big deal? Who knows... I have seen Facebook photos of former active friends holding a drink and it brings me down. If my active member wife were to express a desire to start drinking I don't know that I could handle it over the long haul. I suspect your wife may struggle with something of the same thing. We decided to let our 24 yros have hard liquor in his bedroom (in our house) for when he needed to 'take the edge off'. It feels like a deal with the devil though. : ( I don't think I could bring myself to purchasing it for our children when out on the town. I salute you both. Talk to your wife. Process the experience with her. Concede where you should and challenge her if appropriate. Recognize these things may carry import beyond what you might have imagined. God bless you both. : )
-
I believe there will be some teachers (more likely in youth SS) who will simply wing it. 5-10 mins to get started will leave scarcely enough time and some teachers will decide it's not worth it.
-
Agreed. And perhaps part of that transformation is a shift in perspective re: what constitutes a 'blessing from heaven'? Sure there are countless folks who enjoy good health and the like but who don't pay any form of tithing. I wonder how many attribute this good health to their God (if they even have such a God)? Recognizing all of our good fortune coming from an all-loving God probably begets the transformation you speak of. I'm not saying there are no material and/or spiritual benefits to paying my tithing. I however do not want to spend my time trying to figure out what those particular blessings are (hence the transactional nature of such an endeavor). I thank my God for everything I have and will continue to pay tithing regardless.
