Jump to content

CA Steve

Members
  • Content Count

    1,886
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

1,349 Excellent

About CA Steve

  • Rank
    Separates Water & Dry Land

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Male

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. I like what Armand Mauss has to say in his 'Mormon Scholars Testify" about certainty of belief. Armand L. Mauss in Mormon Scholars Testify.
  2. If you do a Google search for "Mother Teresa controversy" I think you will find that her critics were much more widespread than just Hitchens. Critics range from the Washing Post, to the BBC and even the prestigious medical Journal Lancet published an article critical of her. See here for Wiki article on criticisms on Mother Teresa. Sometimes it's hard to accept that our heroes were/are human.
  3. As long as you don't count native Americans or Brigham Young's extermination order of them. Battle at Fort Utah
  4. Thanks Calm. Clearly if the OP had started out with a misquote (or even an accurate partial quote) of Elder Corbridge's similar type statement, it would not have reached 10 likes before someone thought to ask for a reference. Bill's name is a hot button issue here and many seem eager to jump on the criticism bandwagon anytime any sort of negative post about him is started. As a side note, I find it interesting that we openly approve of new converts expressing how they know the church is true only after a few months, or even weeks, of having read only the Book of Mormon and yet someone who claims to know the church is false after spending years investigating it is dismissed as being "emotional, fundamentalist, exaggerated, hyperbolic, or simplistic.
  5. A couple of observations. If this sort of criticism were being made of anyone within the church the OP would be required to substantiate the OP as something Bill had actually said with a reference that could be verified. Given the incredible amount of material there is covering Mormonism, it is not possible, in my opinion to "read and study every problematic issue in Mormonism" any more than I think it is possible to claim, as Elder Corbridge did recently in reference to material antagonistic to Mormonism, that "There may not be anything out there of that nature that I haven't read." Link to Elder Corbridge Talk.
  6. Exactly. By this same "reasoning" we can also conclude that the reversal revelation on baptizing the children of gay people is actually what God wanted since President Nelson is still alive.
  7. I am pretty sure this was just a policy statement, that had he lived a few years longer would have been reversed.
  8. This doesn't really answer your question but given that there are at least 400 different expressions of the church that Joseph started, I suppose there is only a 1 in 400 chance that any of us who trace our belief back to him, belong to the one expression that has not been allowed to descend into apostasy.
  9. I can just imagine the well-to-do people occupying the top floors enjoying the view and pointing out the sights and people below to each other. At 28 stories and with nearly 500,000 square feet and a stunning design, it really is a great looking and spacious office building.
  10. Well if you're uncomfortable with how the church uses the word 'historian', just wait until you see what we do with 'translation'.πŸ˜‹
  11. There are a lot of good historians in the field of Mormonism who are not professionally trained historians. I think we should judge historians by the quality of their work, not the letters after their names. I agree the church made a huge mistake by preventing Arrington from continuing his work, a mistake that it is still paying for as we could see from the Swedish rescue, but I believe they have really turned that around with what they have been producing in the last ten years or more. The JSPP is simply outstanding work. I am fine with an administrator at the head of the department as long as they continue to produce the same quality of work they have been producing recently. As a side note. I do not think it is feasible anymore to expect any one individual to keep fully informed in the field of Mormon history. It is a rapidly expanding field and the production is simply enormous. For example see this list of forthcoming books. Forthcoming Books on Mormonism. There is over 40 book on that list alone. Add to that the publication of half a dozen quarterly journals, and innumerable independent articles and other books, it is simple not possible to be current in all aspects of the field. So I would prefer they keep an able openminded administrator in the position even if he isn't actually a professionally trained historian.
  12. Sure. Nearly everyone agrees that leadership is capable of making mistakes, but seeing leadership acknowledge they have made a mistake is almost unheard of. Additionally, publicly pointing out that you think leadership has made mistakes can get you excommunicated. If we openly acknowledge fallibility we should also be able to openly discuss when that has happened or is happening. While we preach fallibility we practice infallibility. I think this is especially applicable when it comes to the living prophet and Joseph Smith.
  13. Our orthodoxy may not claim infallibility, but I think our orthopraxy does, especially when it comes to living leadership,
  14. I remember my parents efforts to collect and store a year's supply of food for our large family. We had 55 gallon drums of dry milk, hundreds of large cans of beans, oatmeal, dried vegetables, home canned fruits, and the wheat. Oh did we have wheat! Back then, we bought it in square 5 gallon metal containers that were stored out in the garage. We literally had a ton of wheat in the garage. My mom was constantly grinding it for flour and making the most fantastic homemade wheat bread, and if we were lucky, homemade scones. The smell of fresh baked bread still brings back memories of that house. Fast forward over a half century, my parents have moved four times since then, once back and forth across the country, lugging those cans with them each time they moved. Mom has since passed away and dad is getting up in years and my siblings and I are discussing what do we do with all this wheat? I plan using President Nelson's latest talk to convince my more conservative siblings of the blessings they will receive if they start hauling it around. πŸ˜‰
×
×
  • Create New...